Ordered a pizza turnover with pepperoni. On the outside, it looked great. If someone orders something with pepperoni, they probably would like to actually taste the pepperoni. Well there was 1 piece of pepperoni about every 15 bites. I guess next time I'll have to pay extra for extra pepperoni. This has also happened in the past with panzarottis from here. read more

Delicious,I've never had bad experience. Food great best blue cheese and hot sauce. Most importantly very clean.. owner friendly. Great experience read more

This is the worst pizza place I have ever been to. First of all the pizza is horrible. We ordered 2 pies and a coke. The sauce on the pie taste like it had ketchup for sauce. Then there was a fly cooked into the cheese of one of the pies. My brother almost ate it then he saw it and wanted to throw up. When I brought it back up I just explained to them the situation and just simply asked for my money back for that 1 pie. The girl at the counter gave us attitude and said "well we didn't bring it out like that". She then asked for the manager I guess to come up. And I explained to him the situation and he gave us the money back with no problem. The manager or whoever that was was great. Everything else about our visit wasn't. read more

Best Pizza in Sicklerville for sure! My husband LOVES Nick's Pizza and this location is always clean and the staff are always happy. My only complaint is the layout of the parking lot. There is a "one way" so I have to go around the whole parking lot because of the direction I turn in. Very frustrating, but the food is delicious. Pizza, Cheesesteaks, chicken fingers, crab chowder, you name it, its delicious. read more

Came in for some wings a few weeks ago around 9pm. After paying for my order I waited at the counter for my order to be ready. As they're boxing up my wings I hear a girl say "Man Down!" Followed by laughter! I asked the man who presented my food why that was said and he brought the girl out for her to explain. I asked if she dropped a wing and she tried to tell me she said it because she dropped her towel (which was tucked into her apron as she told me this)! I work in the food industry and there's just some things YOU DON'T SAY OUT LOUD FOR CUSTOMERS TO HEAR! Then as I walked out sipping my tea... The girl is babbling some sort of "are you fucking serious?" Nonsense as i walked out the door! There is no doubt in my mind that as they were boxing up my wings that one fell and of course they wouldn't admit that but c'mon! Never again will I give this place my business! Plus Nick's in Clayton is waaaay better! read more

Ordered takeout from here and 75% of the food we ordered was over cooked and/or burnt. Fries were so hard we couldn't even eat them. And the boneless wings were a little too crunchy for our liking. The rest of the food wasn't bad, mediocre at best, definitely nothing to be impressed with. Took about an hour for food to be delivered which is a little longer than normal delivery times. read more

Best Greek salad and rustica sandwiches around! Staff is friendly and they deliver in a timely manner. We always order from Nicks in Voorhees! read more

Bad customer service. Good food if they don't mess up your order!!!! I picked up my order and when I finally got home to eat it was incorrect. So I called them and had to drive back to correct my order and they did not care and charged me extra!!!! read more

This pizza place has gone downhill fast in the last several months. The service is horrible and the wait for food that was phoned was unacceptable. They said a 20 minute wait for phoned in order and got there about the 20 min mark and had to wait another 30 min. And I have heard their hiring practices of teenagers is under investigation by the Dept of Labor. Don't eat here. There is an all out boycott being recommended for this place. There are many other great Pizza places in the area. read more

We were excited when Nick's opened close to us a couple of years ago. We have had many pizzas from there. But lately the pizzas lack taste, have very little ingredients on them and they average of 10-20 longer than when they say the food is going to be ready. I hate having to stand there and watch people come and go with their pizzas when I was told 20 min and then had to wait 45 min for my pizza. The last time we bought a pizza from them there was very little green peppers and hardly any sauce. We ordered extra cheese and could tell no difference between it and regular cheese. It's time to find some good pizza in Sicklerville. Sorry, Nick's. We are done. read more

Awful owner! Our food was over an hour, we ordered a salad and a cheesesteak and I called several times and why the driver finally showed up he started yelling at me because he got a speeding ticket and was blaming me! I am a customer...well not anymore! He left with the food so now we are stuck eating cereal for dinner! When I called the owner to complain he hung up on me!!! Awful people do not order from here!!! read more

In a pinch to get lunch I stopped into Nicks pizza where I used to come frequently years ago when I lived in the area. When I stopped in, the girl from behind the front counter began chasing a little boy in the dining room.. only until the phone rang. She took the phone call, and proceeded to take two more phone calls before even looking my way. After 10 minutes she finally addressed me, but with an eyeroll. I simply asked if any slices were available, she glanced behind her and said "no." So I asked if she knew when a pie would be out (because it's lunchtime- 12:30 I assumed a pie for slices was firing up) and instead of asking or requesting a pie for slices she says to me "I honestly have no idea." .... so I left feeling very confused as to what I even bothered going there for. I mean forget the ignorant front desk girl... I literally asked for a slice and she told me no. Extremely frustrating when you only have 35 minutes for a lunch break. Definitely will not go back. If I knew her name I would list it, she was insanely rude. read more

Who screws up your order then asks for the other item back? Thanks for the fried egg hoagie with mayo, lettuce, and tomato instead of egg salad hoagie! I hadn't ordered in many months because of screwed up orders. The nail in the coffin is asking for the screwed up items back. I had to fish them out of the garbage can. Last straw. Bye, Nick's. I knew I should have ordered from Corrado's! read more

The food that I have ordered has always been very good the cheesesteaks are very good the cheese burger Hoagies are very good the anti-pasta salad is amazingly good so if anybody has anything bad to say I'm sorry but I order from them at least once a week but everybody's taste buds are different I like their food and it does take a minute for delivery that pleases me because it shows me it's freshly cooked read more

If you want a good pizza or sandwich, go to Nick's. The sandwiches were delicious. I couldn't say enough about them. We have tried other places in the area and this is hands down the best. read more

Only word I can use to describe this place is BAD!!! Food gets worse. Was forced to eat there tonite out of convenience. We visited a friend so we ordered local. Pizza has no taste and is like sponge. The rest of food not worth $78.00 read more

We usually order Nick's on a regular basis. Have been ordering from them since we moved to Erial 5 years ago. The last couple times the pizza just seems to be okay. I'm not sure if they changed something, but it doesn't seem to be as good as it used to be. On the hunt for a new go-to pizza shop. read more

Very good pizza loaded with yummy cheese. Good toppings especially the meatball. Neapolitan and Sicilian are equally good. We go there to dine in read more

The food is actually really good however the staff seems unprofessional. I went in to order and a woman in the back was literally screaming at another employee and said "I'm going to f-ing quit!" Not the friendliest environment. I'd go back for the food though read more

Very disappointed. Tonight I went here and the employees are not friendly. Most were sitting in booths eating. We felt very uncomfortable because God forbid we came in more than an hour before close. Food came quickly but I don't love smelling cleaning products while I eat beside our table. Out of the whole place, they start cleaning the trash can next to us while we eat. I don't appreciate being asked if the two pizza slices are really just for me and then when I went to eat the second slice I went up for a refill and they turned off the sofa machine at 9:10 when they close at 10. I will not be going back. read more

The food is not bad but the service, which was decent when they first opened, has really slipped. Third week in a row they got my order wrong, when I called and asked for the manager he was too busy to get on the phone. The girl I spoke to could have cared less about my complaint. I won't be going back. Anybody can make mistakes but I would expect a little concern after three weeks in a row. read more

Decent food. They cant get delivery orders right. Always takes 45 min to an hour for them to delivery (i live 2 miles from location). They forgot fries for my order. Took an addition hour to delivery fries. Rude phone on phone. A lot of competition in the area. I recommend looking elsewhere. I know I will. read more

this pizza place epitomizes everything that is wrong with the state of New Jersey. staff was lazy and inattentive, and did not even apologize after a 35 minute wait for slices of pizza. pizza was cheap and greasy just like the schmucks feebly attempting to make it. there was also a bucket of urine outside the door read more