I have been going here almost once per week for the last 5 months. We usually get subs or Stromboli and they are always, hot, fresh, and awesome. The meatballs are tasty as well. Today, I was hesitant but decided to try one of their cheesesteaks. I am usually afraid because there are so many horrible versions out there. Well, I wished ai would have tried one sooner because their cheesesteak was awesome. i ordered the Nikoli's cheesesteak with steak, pepperoni, sausage, provolone and sauce and the actual steak was the star of the show. Not a "normal" cheesesteak but this was awesome and i will order the whole version next time. This place always has awesome food, awesome customer service, and fair prices. If you are in the area, don't hesitate to try them!! read more

Everything I ordered here so far is absolutely good The service was quick and done to satisfaction Clean organized just a nice atmosphere . I can't wait to try something else. read more

This is a great place to go if you are looking for a place that is not too crowded and has quick service. I ordered a medium vegetable stromboli and a side of fries and I had leftovers for days! Even though the stromboli had a lot of green peppers, the tastes blended together very well. I would say though, they had a pretty violent movie playing on the television for the majority of the time that my husband and I were there, so if you're looking for a family dinner with kids, maybe just get takeout at this place read more

My check in posted way before I was done with my review. We called our order in for pickup. We were told 30 minutes and when we arrived within the 30 minutes, our order was ready. Pipin' hot fresh out of the oven. 2 pizzas! Garlic cheesy bread. Meatballs. We order the specialty pizza, Nikoli's Famous Italian Style! XL. But I asked for the meats to be on one side only. And my pizza was perfect. Lettuce, tomato, onion, garlic, cheese. Yummy. Perfect! We also got a cheese pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms. Very good too. In fact, everything was great. And I couldn't get the pictures taken before slices were MISSING. read more

See all

17.00 sub Chicken Parm. hardly any cheese nor sauce. very dry and frozen chicken patties. Roll slightly burnt as well Plus a surcharge added for using a credit card. read more

This place is my hidden gem man if your looking from delicious food at a fair price this is it I got an Italian sub and an order of fries I'm sort of a snob when it comes to subs and I have no complaints about this sub well made dough generous portions of meat and cheese not to heavy on the Mayo and just very well put together thanks for the awesome meal guys read more

Great little pizza joint in the middle of no where PA. They make a good slice. Friendly people. If you're traveling to the area and need a quick bite go there. If you live in the area it's one of the few non chain places around. Support small businesses. read more

Terrible. They messed up our delivery order eight months ago, failed to make an active effort to correct the problem, and then unbeknownst to us, placed us on a no delivery blacklist. Horrible customer service. Never again. Check out Peppino's instead. read more

Started to swing by this place for afternoon lunch..sliced pizza wasn't for me, but I figured ,eh, it was a slice .. Recently had small subs. I was impressed. Great sub. Roll great, and stuffed with meat..pricing competitive.. Workers/owner also make the place. I appreciate friendly service.. 4.5 would be my score.. read more

Awfully awful. Picture dominos pizza in the 80s. No thanks. Bland sauce complimented by a cardboard crust Was a disaster. read more

Pizza is great. They follow state guidelines from the state( sorta). Currently no inside dining. They have a sign saying you must wear a mask. Sadly staff are not wearing masks correctly. Noses exposed. Sometimes even the mouth is exposed. read more

Ordered almost 40 Dollars worth of stuff. Got large. Boil with two tiny sauces. Asked for More sauce and told 50 cents more? WTH! Already overpaid for book. Not going back! read more

Super friendly guys working! Went for a late lunch today. Lots of takeout and deliveries going out the door as we were eating. The bread! The bread, though! Amazing! I had a delicious cheesesteak and my friend had a turkey sub. Definitely will return! read more

Nikoli's Pizza and Catering - California cheesesteak and turkey sub! - Pizza Near Me - Camp Hill, Pennsylvania

This place is disgusting. The pizza tastes like cardboard and is soggy. Soggy pizza? Yeah.. tell me about it. Tastes like they pour sugar in the sauce. Dominoes is better. Please save your money and don't go here. read more

This little joint is not your normal pizza place....but the service is not that great...its a local joint...and I was not a local. I did takeout...and got bumped by two other customers as we were all standing in line to place our order....just because the guy behind the counter recognized them and called them by name....then he even went outside to show him his car before taking my order....the service is the main reason for my low rating....I thought the pizza was pretty good and would of at least given it a 3 or 4 star rating...... read more

Nikoli's Pizza and Catering - Italian Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Camp Hill, Pennsylvania

Tried them for takeout this evening, and the food was okay. White pizza had okay flavor, but without a stronger garlic pop I like. Also, the crust on the gluten free pizza we got was a bit soggy, but could have been because of the time it took to get it home. Glad I did takeout, too. Few families with kids running around the back room added a bit of noise, read more

Awesome owner. It really has a big part in the community. Really good food. Everything always tastes great and fresh.

Been there for lunch several times, both take out and eat in. Food is good, inexpensive and well made. if you order delivery for the office they are nice enough to write each person's name on the sandwich which is awesome. This is a regular stop for me when in Camp Hill. read more

Rick and his crew never fail to meet or exceed expectations. They are always willing to fix anything I order the way I want it.

A go-to when we are in the area! We are very critical of pizza and don't like most, but Nikolai's does it right. The sauce is amazing and is the main reason for this pizza being in the top 5 of best pizza I've had anywhere. We haven't been disappointed with anything else on the menu, from wings to calzone. Definitely recommended! read more

Nice local pizza place, delivery is great. We pick up a lot but have eaten in as well but it's nothing fancy as far as dining but I don't have an issue with eating there. We live very close so no need to deliver for us. Great subs and some of the best french fries I've ever had and the prices are very reasonable and I like that they seem to be active with the community. I'm personally not a fan of their pizza but it's not bad, and their hours are bit limited for a pizza place I've called more then a half hour before closing and they already had the grill off. But other that we really enjoy their food. read more

My 2 slices of cheese came out warm but not hot. I prefer a more crispier thin crust than their softer crust. Overall, a pretty good pizza, reminiscent of mall pizza. read more

WARNING: Fennel Spice Alert!! For people who do not like fennel, their pizza has it. I am guessing the sausage has it also as another user said the sausage is 'bad'. For people who hate fennel, its presence in sausage or sauce makes the best food 'bad'.. Yuck. Their marinara served on the side is really good and has no fennel but I had one bite of pizza and made my fiance eat the pizza because it has fennel seasoning which I despise. So I will not be ordering pizza here again. We are new in town and I think Zeiderellis has better pizza if you do not want FENNEL.. Their bread is DELICIOUS. This makes up for the fennel in the pizza. The garlic sticks and marinara are supremely delicious! We are ordering the lasagna tonight with ceasar salad, and the cheeseburger sub (also excellent because like I said, their homemade bread is EXCELLENT and soft and warm. The excellent bread is why i'm giving this place 4 stars, and the fennel is why i'm not giving it 5. For people who love that particular spice fennel, they probably will give it 5 stars. read more

Pizza really was VERY bad. the crust was so limp, it was as if it was microwaved. i ordered my sub with mayo, oil and vinegar, and there was NONE on it. the bread was not fresh either. oh, and the guy that worked the counter made me feel like he was doing ME a favor selling me food....was put on hold TWICE when calling in my order...place was old and dirty. not sure how they are still in business..... read more

Not a fan. Bad sausage, Pizza dough cooked like a frozen pizza though the crust was good. Old and dirty inside,

Nikoli's has not only delicious food, but also excellent service and pricing, and the owners are great and friendly people. They are always involved in charitable events, even hosting a 5k run through Nikoli's, which is a fun time for everybody! The restaurant has a decent amount of seating inside, and has a TV for entertaining all you sports fans. The items on their menu is always fresh, each and every time. The restaurant also has catering which is perfect for parties and/or events. Obviously, they must make tasty food, right? So, why not choose this place? read more

Let me start by saying I have ordered from this place in the past, both pickup and delivery, without issue. However, today has turned me off for good. My co-workers and I decided to order lunch from Nikoli's. I called it in, and said we'd be paying on 2 cards, and one in cash. At no point did the girl tell me that we would EACH be charged a delivery fee ($1.50) even though they were coming to the same place. When I asked my cash paying co-worker how much tip to give, since he gave me a $10 and his bill was $8.91, and he was flummoxed. He said, "My salad was $6.49, why is it so high?" which began the investigation into this sad and ugly tale. I called and the girl on the phone said it was the delivery fee, and when asked, admitted yes...we were all three charged. I asked why we weren't advised this up front and she had no answer. I hung up, and the food arrived. I felt bad for the driver, and gave him a tip anyway. I called the restaurant and asked for the owner and right off, he had an attitude. He said that he would have told us up front, and the computer just populates it that way. I said, "Why not lower the delivery charge (gas is no longer close to $5, let's be honest)?", and he said he can't do that, and something about it being $0.50 per person (for everyone? for deliveries? I don't know). "Maybe your staff should be trained to explain that clearly, that it just didn't seem right to not disclose that", and he kept interrupting me, telling me I needed to "just relax" and "calm down" and then said I was "crying over $3." Well, at that last comment, flames shot from my eyes and if I hadn't been irked before, I sure was now. They also inadvertently charged my other credit card using co-worker for the ENTIRE order. He said he was going to back that off her card and make it right, as if he was doing us a FAVOR, and I said, "No, that was a mistake on your end." He again told me to "just relax" and that he was going to waive everything. I said I didn't care about it being free, because he wasn't being very customer friendly and I wasn't interested in the least. When I inquired about the cash paying customer, after he insisted on refunding the entire order, he said, and I quote, "I'll bring the Goddamn $9, and leave it on the counter and whoever paid for it can come get it." Which he did, and he wasn't as sassy when he gave me the cash and credited receipts back. Bottom line, YES...he refunded everyone (we didn't ask for that, would have been fine with delivery charge removed from 2 of the bills), and the food was good. But when you are going to pick arguments and belittle/condescend to your customers, that's when things are over. I handled Executive Complaints at Verizon Wireless for years. I know how to deal with irate customers, being professional, apologetic but also explaining the situation (and making it right when possible) as non-confrontationally as possible, which is key. The owner did none of those things, except waive the charges for the lunch. I won't order from there again, because I'd rather give my money to an owner who values their customers. read more

We order from here quite often at the office. They have a lot of good specialty pizzas. Their sandwiches are good as well.

The pizza is good and I like the meatball subs. They offer boneless wings which is nice. My only negative is the delivery is really inconsistent. One time we will order and it arrives in half an hour and another time it's an hour and a half. read more

Very good pizza, nice soft fluffy crust. Docking a star because they did slightly mess up my order but it was still very good food.

Good delivery service. Food was ok. Hot wings were HOT- which was what I asked for, I'll prob ask for medium hot next time. No celery or dressing with wings. $25 for a large cheese and a dozen wings..I think that's a little high. Wasn't the best but I'll try it again. read more

Not a fan of the pizza. And they only have pepsi. The only good thing is they deliver, which is rare for the area unless you want Papa John's. I will not be getting food from here again read more

Nikoli's is the perfect choice for delicious catered Italian food! I called them in a bind when I was hosting a party, and their meatballs and ziti were a huge hit. I recommend Nikoli's for anyone hosting or throwing any kind of party! read more

We tried Nikoli's years ago because it was conveniently located between work and our daughter's daycare. We would swing by on the way to picking her up in the evening. While it's been 8 years since Nikoli's was on our way home, we still make the extra trip when we can because we LOVE their pizza. Our girls ask whenever we bring a pizza home, "Is it Nikoli's?" and if it isn't, BIG disappointment! It's the only shop that offers an extra large which really is perfect for our family of four. We've had their subs, salads, and stromboli all of which are good. The extra bonus are their offering of cannoli's. But it's the pizza that gets us there even though we have numerous other shops closer to our home. Nikoli's is like getting Philly or NYC pizza in Central PA and you can't get better than that! read more

Excellent pizza! Since it was our first time in we tried the Italian style pizza along with a Greek salad. Both were very good and we were impressed by the ingredients which all seemed to be fresh and good quality. We both also considered the crust to be among the best we have ever had. Thank you for the excellent lunch! read more

I ordered a ham & turkey sub - there was no ham at all on the sub; I also ordered a California cheese steak which should have had lettuce & tomato but there was only cheese & onion on it. read more

We love their white pizza with broccoli. It's awesome having a great pizza place so close to our house when an evening just gets too busy to cook! read more

I absolutely LOVE this place!! Delicious food, great service and quick delivery! Food arrives piping hot. Has become our go to pizza place!!

We have used nic's for catering twice and eat in frequently. They have the best meatballs I've ever had and all my guests were blown away by the taste. read more

Hello, my name is Randall and I frequently go to Nikolis. Late in the week, me and my co-worker were waiting for our food and as we were waiting we could hear screaming and arguments in the shop. I can say the words we're extremely vulgar. I know I heard at least 6 times that he said f*** you to her, called her a dumbass, told her he can say and do whatever he wants to her, and to shut her f****** mouth. And that's just what I heard while I was in the actual shop. I must say, that poor girl. And if you're reading this just know that God loves you. I'm giving three stars just for her customer service and because the food was and is always phenomenal read more