Hands down best New York style pizza place in town. I found it by accident, and have been taking people there for 2 years now. Have always had amazing pizza there. Oly downside is they won't deliver over 3 miles. read more

My husband and I love getting pizza as a special treat but we hate getting the same soggy mess from other chain pizza places. This is by far the best off the grid pizza place we have found in Tulsa. If we are not hanging out downtown, this is our go to spot. Also the cannoli's are bomb! read more

This restaurant has the best NYC pizza around! I have had the opportunity to enjoy pizza in NYC and the pizza at NYC Pizza does not disappoint. The food is fresh and hot, the employees are so friendly, location is great and the prices are fantastic! You definitely need to check this place out if you're craving a hot slice of NYC pizza! read more

Great food, authentic NY style. If you usually order a large, I'd recommend the extra large here. Be sure and grab an order of the garlic knots, reasonably priced and a delicious addition. read more

I got the white pizza. Hands down the best pizza I ever ate, and I'm an old broad.....I even worked at Ken's Pizza when in high school in the 60's, so I thought I knew good pizza. NYC pizza is Perfection. I got my order to go, and almost swooned at first bite when I got home. That ricotta and fresh basil makes it. My first time there, definitely not my last. I also got a salad and cannoli but filled up on pizza and not able to taste and assess them. Staff was friendly and accommodating. I highly recommend. read more

This place is OUTSTANDING. If you don't get garlic knots to go with your pizza, you will certainly be doing yourself a disservice! You will not be disappointed by anything you order at this place. They will put whatever toppings you want on the pizza and pop it in the oven. I wasn't sure how I felt about that at first, honestly. Oh my gosh though... holy amazing! I stuffed myself silly and wished I had room for more! Have you ever had a meal that you just wish wouldn't end? The service is also fantastic. I unfortunately can't remember the guy's name who served us, but he was a hoot. I really enjoyed him... he made jokes and was a genuinely pleasant guy who you could tell really enjoyed his job. I will be sure to add his name next time I go there.... because we will definitely be going back! read more

Probably the third or fourth best neopolitan pizza in Tulsa. Their Sicilian pizza is somewhat authentic and is one of the best in Tulsa. It is also one of the few pizzerias that cook the peppers and onions properly for the specialty rolls . Too many places leave them undercooked and hard which ruins the overall eating experience. The cannolis have been both good and not so good. The shell is sometines a little stale and not as crispy as it should be but the filling is usually very good. The only real negative is that upper management is sometimes rude and shows very poor customer consideration at times. Fortunately the employees are much friendlier and more courteous. Definitely worth a try if you like pizza, especially Sicilian. read more

The pizza was great. The personnel making the pizzas hygiene was horrible. How do you take cash or credit cards from everybody that walks in and not wash your hands before handling dough and toppings?!!!! Straight from the register to the pizza work station! Dirty money, bloody money, nasty money...oh well, the customers will accept total disrespect and return for more?! No! Every customer who sees this nasty habit should verbally correct the cooks and if repeated, contact the Tulsa health Department. read more

Never been to NYC but I love this place. Reasonably-priced and very good. First time I just had a slice and it was pretty tasty. So the next time I got whole pie made to order and now I'm addicted. Won't go anywhere else, and you gotta try the garlic knots and canoli YUM! read more

Have been eating their pizza for years. It's always great We order it at least twice a month. read more

Outstanding, can't believe I haven't been here before. Authentic NY crust, thin but holds toppings well, baked to perfection. The sauce is obviously made from scratch and truly the best pizza sauce I've ever had. Yes, ever. read more

Cheese, and mushrooms were good inside of the calzone. The dough was not cook well and it tasted like the cook washed his hands in the toilet!!!! I will not comeback!!! I believe that is what happened because I was sick after eating there same day... instantly! and still cleaning my gut due to this horrible cook!!! Ugh!! I had to get some medicine to get well. I do not recommend this place. Unless you want to be sick... go ahead!!! read more

What a difference a couple of weeks makes. Mediocre pizza is being kind... just barely a step above CiCis. Staff indifferent. Not going to repeat this one. read more

I have ate there a few times and doesn't seem to be very consistent, one time it maybe really good the next time the crust was soggy not crispy as usual. The people that work there are not very greeting. So I have mixed review. The canolis are good and have been each time I got them. I just live down the street from nyc so I keep going back . read more

First time was great. Second time was very disappointing. The second time we ordered our pizza was soggy and just mush. This happened with brothers pizza on sheridan. I'll probably give them another chance and update this review then. read more

Very good!!! From a boy who grew up in Philly... it was very nice to have something that reminded me of all of those great mom and pop places back in Philly. The crust and even the smell of the pizza was excellent. And I would HIGHLY recommend the garlic knots!! read more

Best pizza in town. Love the garlic knots!! Highly recommend! Family owned business. It's nice to say hello to the guys when I come in. New York style cheesecake and cannolis are fantastic as well. Nothing bad to say about this eatery. Go and see them for some good pizza and New York atmosphere. read more

Wow, This place is amazing. Try the pizza rollups and grab a canolli. I almost cried it was so good. Now stop reading and just go already.

Our first visit was today for an late lunch/early dinner. My husband and I absolutely loved their thin crust supreme pizza, their marinara sauce and the pepperoni knots! We will be going there again for sure! Only reason for 4 instead of 5 stars was no option for a beer. read more

I thought it was ok for Oklahoma, but wife found a hair in pizza and now she will never go there again. Place was kind of dirty.

The pizza is a true New York style pizza and I know this because I am from the East Coast and just moved to Tulsa. I haven't found a good piece of pizza place yet besides this place. The cannolis either the regular chocolate are normally fabulous as well. Prices are fair and the people are nice service is normally very quick. read more

Wont deliver and i'm only 5 miles away; Holiday Inn Express by the Aquarium. The man said they do not go out that far, that i'm up past the river. That's okay though, my money will be spent elsewhere. I guess NYC pizza doesn't need the business; good for them. read more

They have the crust down perfect, where they miss is the way they top everything. I was craving Sicilian slices but I found every slice from this place to be dried out, lacking some olive oil and a touch of sugar in the sauce. But what it sits on is perfected! I went back on Thursday, NO Sicilian AGAIN, WTF? So I got 2 sausage slices, this time they were done just right! I guess that's the way it is with all these places, depends on the baker doing the prep that day? Most likely. Contrary to what you may have heard, the best pizza is found out on Long Island, not in Manhattan. read more

Great food however service is not Southern friendly by any means and sometimes are not open with no warning but when you can cook like these boys who gives a damn!!! Best cannoli in Tulsa hands down!!! read more

Found out about NYC Pizza about a month ago. Been there 3 times since, got there around 1115, they open at 11, doors have been closed and locked each time. But right down the road is Mario's Pizza. Their pizza and service is great. Go to Mario's not NYC Pizza read more

Possibly the best pizza in the city. I've had a few different NYC pizza joints (John's of Bleeker, Joe's in the West Village). I think this place holds its own, if not beating those establishments. It would be recommended to not order too many toppings, or just get a regular pie. read more

have eaten here twice now over the last couple of weeks. 1st visit was an order placed to go and the 2nd was dine in. Both times the sicilian which I order was fabulous! simple cheese square pizza with a nice tasty crust. Small size runs around the $14 dollar mark, was 6 decent size portions. The ends are the best. Both times the pizza had to be made to order. The staff are straight forward, however they are friendly. Both times the pizza was hot out of the oven, tasty fresh and was worth about the 20 minute wait. Why only 4 out of 5 stars? Can use a little cleaning up. I would not call the place filthy, however I would not call it immaculate either, they can be a little slow to get the tables bused. All in all a tasty place for some great NYC pizza, better then the wanna be's in BA that say they have NYC pizza. read more

I have eaten a lot of NY style pizza from Midtown, Times Square and Uptown and this has been, by far the best pizza outside of NYC I've found read more

It is the best cheap slice in Tulsa. Way better than pie hole and way more affordable than S TG's and other specialty pizza shops. The thin crust is great, but the Sicilian slice is the best. If you're looking for a new lunch spot rotation try this one out. The only con is that the restaurant could be better kept. you truly feel like you are in New York sitting in that nasty dining room looking up at the ceiling tiles that are turning the color of their pepperoni. They could put more effort in the front of the house as well, but alas this is a greasy pizza shop and they play the part well. Can't replace Andolinis for me (best in Tulsa) but this is the spot for anyone looking for a quick tasty slice read more

Went here for lunch. Got two slices of pizza, one pepperoni, one sausage. Pretty good NYC style pizza. Better than chain pizza for sure. Pretty good prices, around $5.50 for the 2 slices and a water. The guy at the counter was helpful and nice. read more

Incredibly good NY style pizza, almost worthy of 5 stars. We randomly stopped here on a drive from Austin to St. Louis, and were amazed at our find. Check it out if you are in town. read more

The food was good but the place was disgusting. The guy preparing the dough was using his bare hands. Which is fine until he rang people up taking cash and credit cards and then going back to the preparing the dough without washing his hands. He would also use his bare hands to put your pizza on a plate. This is so gross. Not coming back!!! read more

This place is not in the same category as an Andolini's or even a Savastano's or Hideaway for me personally. It's pretty decent New York-style pizza at criminally low prices. I've been told their cannoli and other menu items are pretty solid as well, but I've always stuck to the slices of pizza when I've visited. You can order 2 pretty big slices and get out of there for less than $7. I'd give the quality/taste a B. read more

No words to express how good this is! The garlic knots side I could just make a meal out of that! Best kept secret for take out. Not a place I would stay and eat. I want to take this back to the ranch and eat while binge watching my favorite shows and escape reality tastefully! read more