Not the best. The place looked very shady. The only person making the pizza was nice but I won't go back.

Staff is great the service was great the food was perfect little out dated but place ws clean read more

Oakdale Pizza - Awesome pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

Gf and I ordered from here tonight. Pizza and a tiramisu. The pizza came with all the topping having slid to one side and the the entire thing was absolutely oozing grease. It was disgusting. The crust was just as bad. It was brittle, tasteless, and without any rise. It made Domino's look like Pepe's. Then the Tiramisu. It was a tiny sliver for $5, which irked me, but then we noticed how dry it seemed (and tasted). We each took one bite and put it in the refrigerator bc it was too gross to eat after that greasy pizza. Later, I take it out to consider another bite and I see a big spot of MOLD on it. Absolutely abhorrent. I can't wrap my head around how disgusting this whole experience was. Do not go here. And if you work for the health department you may want to pop in. read more

Oakdale Pizza - Moldy tiramisu - Pizza Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

See all

Just got a grinder and salad from this place, as I was waiting for my grinder to be packaged up the female dropped the meatball & sauce ladle on the floor and wiped it with a dirty towel and put it back in the warmer & sauce .... Never again read more

i feel like this place has really fallen off. it used to be my favorite until it was taken over. for awhile it tasted the same and then something changed. now it's incredibly bland and i even found a piece of metal in the last pizza i got. luckily they refunded it for me but just overall so sad that this place isn't what it used to be. read more

I was visiting from out of state and a friend had told me this was a Greek family and had raved about their food and pizza. I ordered 2 pies to go and was disappointed overall. While there was nothing "wrong" with the pizza, it was greasy and average at best. The folks running the show weren't a Greek family, at least while I was there. With all of the amazing pizza that can be had around here, why bother with mediocre at best? Try Christos or Little Rendezvous for coal fired pizza that is truly 5 star. read more

Found my new favorite pizza joint in Wallingford Great pizza. Crust not too thick - not too thin. Sauce was superb. Toppings and cheese fresh. Baked to perfection. Meatball grinder was outstanding. Limited menu. Don't come in looking for the latest craze in "gourmet" cuisine. Don't come in for the decor. True Mom and Pop restaurant that has been there for decades Owners and staff are extremely friendly and will bend over backwards to insure you love your order. Don't even try to order online. Pretty sure they have never even seen any of these reviews Just a great Old School place to go for terrific food and service with a smile.. read more

Delivered hot ! Fresh toppings . Good Sausage Pizza was good. Greek Styled Pizza read more

Friendly. , delicious and hot! Too many pizzas arrive warm but theirs are hot abd davir ful No scrimping on the toppings Yup darn good pie read more

Small local mom & pop pizza shop close to the Oakdale. I prefer to patronize the locally owned small businesses in my travels. We ordered the clams Casino pizza . Huge specialty pie @ a great price. Local family charm. George, the owner was welcoming and attentive. Denise, our server, was really kind as well. Very nice woman. Thanks Denise kiss read more

Oakdale Pizza - a large pizza on a table - Pizza Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

Not impressed with our order at all! The food was terrible. Bread hard and dry, lunch meat on its way out. Slopped together to make the order. Best thing was the bottle of soda that came with the meal. Only enough pastrami to make one grinder. Salad is old. Not impressed at all. Will not be returning read more

Delicious pizza! Last weekend was the first time trying this place since moving to Wallingford! Great Sicilian pizza! Lots of toppings & great flavor! We ate half of the pizza before I could take a picture! Lol read more

Oakdale Pizza - Half mushroom, onion, and green peppers, other half bacon, sausage, pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

We have been getting our pizza from George for about 50 years. Best pizza. Loved their meatball grinders and combination grinders. Chef salad, good! Tonight our order of 1 meatball grinder, heated and 1 combination grinder heated came to $32.00!!!!!!! A month ago the total was about $20!!!! I know prices are going up but NOPE. We won't be going back. Person taking the order didn't know her job. Neither grinder was heated. Food was ok. We thought that maybe George has sold out. Man I spoke to said he was George's partner. Hmmmm. Facebook page has photo of menu..... from 2017. The price for a 12 inch grinder was a little over $7. Can understand increase in prices but..... wow. We will be making our own food. I gave it 2 stars because the food was good but not exactly how we ordered it. read more

After reading some raving reviews on Yelp, I decided to give Oakdake Pizza a try. Since then, my family and I have nearly solely bought from this family restaurant. (My parents swear by this place and refuses to buy from anywhere else.) Though I'm not entirely a fan of the pie, the service is incredibly friendly and warm. The pizza seems to be Greek styled: has a thick crust and adds a fair amount of cheese. I just wish it was a bit more saucy (but that's just the type of gal I am!) I definitely do not pass for a pizza connoisseur but I believe the restaurant is worth a try! Their sitting area feels kind of cramped and the interior in general is a little worn out but everything still feels homey. I would recommend for family nights! read more

Walked in to get my pizza front lady was in the phone taking an order, touching the phone, pen, notepad, menus. When she got off the phone she put it down turned around and continued to make the pizza with no gloves. I wouldn't come here if you like your pizza made with her dirty bare hands. read more

Nice to see how highly rated they are. This was my "go to" spot for pizza before going to the Oakdale theatre. And I think my memories of Oakdale pizza are better than Oakdale Theatre. LOL. The pizza is really good. Thin style, crispy and quite tasty. Staff were always great, food and service were quick and it was a great place to relax and have a good meal, particularly if you like pizza or Italian in general. read more

Oakdale Pizza is by far the best pizza restaurant in Wallingford! Always fresh, great prices and exceptional, friendly service. You can dine in (cozy mom and pop restaurant vibe) or take out, either way you'll get delicious pizza! read more

We love coming here- we call it "George's" instead of Oakdale Pizza because the owners are so friendly you feel like you're going to an old friends house. The decor is waaaay outdated but they've been here forever. We usually stop in for grinders or pizza so I'm not sure how the other food is. It's a nice relaxed atmosphere- George often buys big boxes of Wise chips and gives you a few bags free chips with your order, not 100% of the time but often enough to mention it. Certainly very generous of them. George sometimes sings while he's making your order- tells you that he still loves what he does after all these years! Customer service is huge for my family (even my 9 yo won't stand for terrible service!) and this is something they do consistently well. We love to support local businesses so we will definitely continue coming here! read more

Love this place, the food, the owner. Try the chicken, omg! And the pizza, grinders, salads. It's all amazing!

Great place the owner is friendly and helpful the pizza is pretty good. Less o ions if you order o ions on your pizza. Overall pretty darn good read more

I have been coming here for about 7 years. I strongly recommend for those of you who don't like the thin crispy brunt pizza that is prevalent in CT. This is a family owned business with warm service and great food. Give it a try!! read more

We love George. He feels like part of the family. Food is good at a responsible price. We order take out from Oakdale often.

My boyfriend and I came here on a snowy Saturday afternoon. We ordered a bacon and pepperoni pizza. It's absolutely delicious. Cooked perfectly and brought out by George. We just moved to the area, we'll definitely be back. read more

The owner and family are truly customer service experts! The food is always delicious, the portions are large, and the prices are fair. Oakdale is our go-to pizza place in town and they never disappoint. We highly recommend their pizza and boneless buffalo wings! read more

I love this place. The owner and family are so friendly. They deliver in a speedy manner and the food has never disappointed. I have had pizza, grinders, and pasta. Everything I have consumed has been fantastic. read more

The place was dirty. It took 40 minutes to get a pizza and there was no one else in the resturaunt. The owner was yelling at someone on the phone the entire time we were there. And after all that, the pizza was not very good. I would not go back there again. read more

My family has been ordering from Oakdale for years. The quality has remained consistently excellent. They produce some of the best pizza in a part of the country that I think produces the best pizza anywhere -- so that's saying something. read more

The best in town if you like deep dish styled pizza! The owner and his wife are the nicest people you'll ever meet.

Been in town forever...the crust is always nice and crispy...love that about their pizza. Nice people and good food!

Finally a pizza restaurant that has consistent product and service. Pizza, grinders and service are great. Joe, one of the delivery guys in particular is awesome as are the staff that I have dealt with to date. Keep up the good work and we'll keep calling read more

Best Greek pizza in Wallingford. I often order pizza and it is very consistent unlike other places. I also like the owner George who really appreciates your business. And yes you may get a free bag of chips ! read more

food is great good wings ,pizza & grinders ziti & meatball dinners are well worth it the most consistent restaurant in town & the owners are awesome Been going there many years never disappointed Keep up the good work read more

10/10 for experience. Within two seconds of grabbing our beers out of the fridge, they were opened for us. Decor was great- loved the plants. Bonus points for George yelling at his family/workers in Italian. Overall best feature of this establishment was the chip box. Would recommend. read more

I absolutely love Oakdale!!! Bea and George are amazing with customers and very very fast with orders!!! The pizza and the wings are delicious!!! If you're looking for a place to go for pizza, this is the place!!! read more

Everyone likes George and his family. Pizza is Greek style, and is relatively tasty. Have been eating there for many years before George and wife went back to Greece and then after they came back. I gave one star because of a recent occurrence that was so disgusting I couldn't believe it. I was three slices in to a pizza, when all of a sudden I bit down on something hard. Pulling it out I discovered that I actually had someone's fake fingernail in my mouth. This was easily one of the grossest restaurant experiences of my life, and there have been several. I called the restaurant and let them know I had their fingernail if they needed it back. No amount of free pizza or apologies can resolve this one. This is a big no no for me. Gross. I still have the nail in a bag. Lots of other pizza places in town that don't have these issues. read more

Oakdale has Greek styled pizza which is the best I've ever tried. The food here is great, I highly recommend the fried chicken pizza (with or without BBQ) the chicken parm grinders, the antipasto salad, the mozz sticks and many more great items here. They've been open for many years and they sure know how to run a great business. They also deliver too!! read more

George and his family are so kind and hospitable. They're food is great. Perfect neighborhood restaurant, especially if you're looking for a grinder! They're pizza is pan-style, as long as you like that you'll love the pizza! Extensive menu and they do it all really well. read more

A great spot for Pie in the Wallingford area. The owner George is the sweetest guy. Always super pleasant when we stop in.