Pizza on one side restaurant on the other We were in the restaurant and it was delightful! Best Eggplant Rollatini I have had in years. Gusts enjoyed the salmon, homemade ravioli. Marsala. Calzone, and stuffed breads were fantastic. The Italian bread is made in house and so good! We also enjoyed a wonderful Caymus Cabernet. Smooth rich and a great nose. Service was friendly old world Italian and the dining room was warm and inviting. Definitly a return trip with friends -!! read more

We ordered two different stuffed breads. Picked them up with disappointment: they were so thin, like two flatbreads sandwiched. Not worth the $38 for two. Called to let them know and they weren't very receptive to the criticism, like our feedback didn't matter. They also messed up a pizza order couple weeks ago, so we're done with them... too bad, because I want businesses to succeed, and they used to be so good. read more

Fratelli's Pizzaria Restaurant - Pepperoni stuffed bread, thinnest ever. - Italian Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

Pizza was awesome! Service was great, they were attentive and food came quickly, will definitely go back.

I've been here probably 12 times in the past four years and every single time it is fantastic. I haven't left a review before but tonight I had take out and ordered the halibut special. I literally called them to tell them how delicious it was! Can't wait to go back! read more

Fratelli's Pizzaria Restaurant - Halibut mashed potatoes, sun-dried tomatoes, and spinach! Absolutely delicious! - Italian Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

Pizza was really good. Service wasn't. Two guys from somewhere that really didn't care if you had a good experience or not. Three stars only because the pizza was really good. read more

My grandparents have been going here for years- presentation was much better than I remembered. Portions are very generous for the price, though the eggplant and chicken parm etc dont seem to have pasta included (though $20 for bread, salad. and large portions still seems to be a good deal). Home made fried mozzarella is always goor. wait staff was friendly and quick. not very full on a friday night but area seems clean and set up nicely. read more

See all

Always great food here. We mostly like the pizza, but we have been branching out to try the rest of the menu. I had the grilled honey salmon VERY good! And my DH got the baby spinach salad with chicken. You can tell by the picture that there was so much chicken I almost couldn't see the salad!! My son had his favorite cheese pizza. This place never disappoints! read more

Fratelli's Pizzaria Restaurant - Baby spinach salad with chicken - Italian Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

See all

Food was great. Seems like legit Italians. Nice dining area in back. We will be back.

We were visiting the Wallingford area and found this restaurant on Yelp. The Staff were very attentive. Salad or soup came with meal as well as homemade bread. The only odd thing about my meal is eggplant parmigiana did not come with pasta despite being listed under pasta on the menu. The chicken parmigiana dinner was served over pasta. read more

I haven't been to Fratelli's in about 20 years and have fond memories from back then... however I heard they are under new ownership and wanted to give them a try... and was not disappointed. The quality of the dishes are way up, my cutlet and my eggplant were perfect and super crispy. Sauce was great, the mandolin potatoes au gratin were a very nice touch. For some reason, finding great Italian in the Wallingford area has been tough for while, but not anymore! I just found my regular weekly Italian spot to get a solid meal. 100% will be back as a regular. read more

Fratelli's Pizzaria Restaurant - Chicken Genovese - Italian Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

More than just a Pizza joint! People here are gracious and nice. Ordered the rigatoni - perfectly cooked, sauce was great. Even the table olive oil was exceptional. No misgivings here, glad to have found this gem. Please support this place - good people, good food, great atmosphere. What more do you need? Cheers read more

So so good and huge portions. If you love Italian food, then this is the place to be. The service was great. Our waitress was very attentive to our every need. Overall great experience. read more

Love the homemade bread, cozy atmosphere in a booth with dim lighting. Excellent comfort food. Very friendly servers and attentive service.

Average pie at best. Not bad. but nothing we are rushing back for. we had a red pie with meat. read more

We've been going to Fratellis for a few months now. The food is delicious! We've had pizza appetizers entrées, and everything was excellent. We look forward to going each week because the owners and servers are so accommodating and just want to please you. Looking forward to seeing you this week! read more

I ordered the Chicken Parmagian and to my dismay there was no pasta included. At $22.95 to get only two pieces of chicken parm is not a good deal. There are better options at other area restaurants where pasta is included. Staff is very attentive. However I thought that was below what I expected. So I dropped to 3 stars from 5. read more

I recently went to a party that was catered by Fratilli's. I had their chicken marsala, and chicken francaise. Both entrées were delicious. The chicken francaise was one of the best I ever had. They also included their homemade bread that was outstanding. Can't wait to dine in now that we found great Italian food in Wallingford. read more

AlwaYs loved this place Great pizza service and people Thirty charctors needed to complete this read more

Great atmosphere. Great food. And a very friendly Staff. Tony is the man!!! Will definitely stop by again when traveling through. read more

It's been a while since we been here due to Covid and I was pregnant,l. During that time their menu changed and so did the food (not sure if they have a new chef?). I ordered chicken saltimbocca which I've had numerous times here before and it was not at all the same. It wasn't good. Considering it was my birthday and I had requested to get food from here I was highly disappointed. My husband said his food was still good/the same (he orders the same thing every time- zuppa de pesce white) however we specifically asked for the olive oil to go with the loaf of bread we ordered and we didn't get it. Updating to 3 stars because my meal was terrible and they left out the olive oil. Im hoping it's a fluke but I certainly won't be ordering my meal ever again. read more

Spent an evening here with some good friends - overall our experience was good. When first walking in, I was super confused because I was immediately greeted by a small room and a counter. Definitely not what I expected when walking into a restaurant - but then I remembered "Ah! This is also a pizzeria"! The actual Fratelli's restaurant (not the pizzeria) is in the door immediately to our right. My party of 4 came on a slow Wednesday evening so we were attended to almost immediately. Well actually, we were never brought to our tables... we just picked our own table because there was no hostess or waiter in the immediate room after the pizzeria section. We seated ourselves in the adjacent room that was finely decorated and felt pretty fancy. All of the tables were super duper clean and the table settings were pretty neat. Our waiter was friendly and attentive to our orders. The only thing he missed was allowing us to sample our wine before accepting the entire bottle for the table. No big deal in the end because the wine is perfect. Bread and oil were offered and we graciously accepted them. Their oil was fantastic by the way. Our pizzas came about 30 minutes later. We had our drinks readily filled when they were nearing their end and were quick to give us take home boxes when asked. Overall our experience was pleasant and I do anticipate coming back again. read more

See all

The owner is very nice and keeps his restaurant very clean. The service was amazing and within 10 minutes of ordering my chicken cutlet came steaming in! I definitely recommend anyone visiting Wallingford to come to Fratelli's Pizzaria restaurant! read more

This is the last time we will order from Fratelli's. We have patronized this restaurant for 22 years and never had a single complaint. The food has always been incredible and the service great. The last time we ordered a large pan of lasagna and it didn't taste very good. We quickly realized they didn't even bother to use real noodles (they used to)! They used the awful, cardboard tasting and flat quick-cook noodles and the meat was really gristly. Pretty frustrating to spend $50 on a pan of lasagna, just to have them skimp on the products. I could have made it myself for half that. Thought we would save some time though and have some to freeze for later. Tonight I called and ordered two cheese pizzas with extra sauce and some fried mozz. The fried mozz used to be triangles and delicious! Now they taste like fast food cheese sticks and have no flavor- also had a 1/4" long wooden splinter in one. Thank goodness I noticed it before I ate it! The pizzas were the worst we've ever had! Not only was there no extra sauce, there was hardly any at all. The majority of the pizza was just terrible, flavorless, congealed cheese and dough. Out of two large pizzas, my family of five with three teen/tween boys only ate 1/2 of one pizza. Unbelievable! My kids were throwing the pizza in the trash because it was inedible. I guess this was our last time ordering from Fratelli's. So disappointing. It used to be our favorite restaurant. So sad. My two stars were extremely generous. read more

Love Fratellis Good Italian food and the bread is second to none. The deserts are made with Italian in mind. The pizza is good, not great. Other dishes are presented well. Good prices and service is good. Will go back again. read more

Went here for the first time last night and the bartender and the service was great! Drinks were great and the food was very good! We will definitely be returning! read more

It didn't have to come this 1* rating but I absolutely loathe liars and poor customer service. I ordered a very simple dish. I looked at their website that had alot to choose from. I finally by the description of their meal ordered my entree. They told me it would take about an hour to deliver so I picked it up instead. I'm copying and pasting this off of their website. "Chicken Piccata prosciutto, caper berries, lemon sauce $15.50" Right off of their page. Got my meal, brought it home, opened it up. I got chicken, caper berrys and ziti. I called up and said I got chicken but where's the prosciutto? He said oh let me see? I spoke to the owner it doesn't come with prosciutto u need to order the sorrento if you want that. I said I'm looking at your website I'm reading u the description and also u charged me $18 when it says $15.50 he said oh those are old prices. Well wtf. Old description, old peices, tastless food. I said this food was not good. He said that's our most popular dish. Well if that's their most popular dish. Chicken ziti 4 caper berries and a mocoussy sauce I don't want to find out what the rest of their food and prices end up being. I originally was going to have this delivered so I have my c.c. info over the phone. So when I got there she said its all taken care of. No receipt, no anything. Just handed me my food and I was on my way. If they had admitted like oh crap we messed up the order and agreed to fix it, they would have gotten a 3 star maybe. But because they lied about the ingredients and lied about the price. Their ego and bland ass chicken and caper berrys just gained them a poor review. I recommend not lying to your customers especially when they've given you the opportunity to fix their order. I recommend Michaels Trattoria for 2 bucks more get yourself a real meal. read more

Fratelli's Pizzaria Restaurant - Don't order the piccata - Italian Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

The food is incredible and the staff is top notch. We come with friends both local and from out of States. We can't wait to return.

Sorry, we cannot provide any photos, but this restaurant has always been fantastic for value and flavor. The new owners are very hospitable and have done a beautiful job renovating the restaurant. Do you need to come here or it's good food. The house wine was good too! read more

I'm not on yelp to nitpick and that is why I am giving this place 5 stars across the board. Giving any negatives for one or two things that aren't perfect are the people that are just out to try to make a name for themselves, so they can feel a sense of worth and I'm not here for that. We went for an after funeral buffet and everyone was blown away by the food, and service. Usually there is someone out of the bunch that doesn't like something, but not one had any gripes. Were there a few minor things... maybe, but they would be so miniscule that it would not be worth bringing up, because they had quite a few people to attend to. Please try this restaurant, because we all were more than pleased with everything. My wife and I can't wait to go back for a private meal, and we will be soon. When you get fantastic food in a buffet, I can't imagine what a private sitting will be like. The widower and family couldn't have asked for a better farewell for their loved one. Thank you all for everything! 10 Stars all around! read more

Leila is so great! Better than Tony. Such a lovely busser. Always checks on customers, makes sure everyone is okay. She has a great sense of humor !! Food is great , atmosphere is perfect . Leila will make you feel at home !!!!! read more

Great food, great atmosphere, great service!! Food is always wonderful ! Feels like a family

So it was date night, Italian was the choice and where to go what the big question, soooooo I yelped it and Fratelli's won the coin flip I had and let me tell you it was destiny lol, The NY strip was AMAZING! Honestly we haven't stopped talking about going back. I got fettuccine Alfredo on my mind... see y'all soon lol read more

Fratelli's Pizzaria Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

I ordered two pizzas from here last night. The customer service was awesome, but the pizza was not worth $60! That's including tip and delivery. Seriously disappointed. read more

Same name, different owners. Have been eating at Fratelli's for years, they certainly hit a rough spot. Changed owners recently and the new owner / chef really gets it. Food is amazing, the staff makes you feel like part of the family. The chicken Genovese is outstanding, as are so many of the other dishes. Good wine selection. read more

My wife took us there last night for a quick bite - she'd been there once before.... It looked like any other Italian neighborhood restaurant - until we sat down. Our friendly waiter greeted us immediately, was polite and not pushy. My wife asked about their grinder rolls - the waiter was also the BAKER! Long story short, he was Kosavan, the owner, his wife, and several customers were all from the Balkan countries on the Adriatic Sea. We had a wonderful visit with the whole staff along with great grinders. Hers was Chicken Parm, mine was Meatballs. They were as good as any I've had around. As it turns out the owner's cousins also came to this country for opportunity and opened restaurants in the area. I'll visit and review the others as well. And I'll try the real parts of the menu here too! read more

Recommend the broccoli rabe and sausage, any chicken dish or steak au poivre. We like sitting at the bar and get excellent service and drinks. Very clean and good atmosphere! read more

Brought my family here who were visiting out of town. We all throughly enjoyed our pasta and steak dishes. Desserts were amazing too and homemade! They are already saying they want to come Back the next time they visit read more

What a surprise. Service was great and the food was too. They greeted us like old friends and took care of everything we needed. Oh and the bread made in house was ample and amazing. Seasoned oil on every table and reasonably priced. We will be back. read more

Fratelli's Pizzaria Restaurant - Garlic roasted shrimp - Italian Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

I got the recommendation of Fratelli's from a friend. I was a little weary as it was 6:30 and it wasn't very busy. I happened to ask some others on their way out and they said it was amazing. They also had lots of Togo boxes in their hand as that is usually a sign that their portions are large. The bread that they gave was very good Italian bread. I asked for oil and vinegar but for some reason I was given red wine vinegar instead of balsamic. I got mozz sticks for an appetizer. They were good but very small portion. I got the chicken saltimbocca. This is chicken with prosciutto, spinach over kind of a gravy sauce. There were also some potatoes in there. It was good although the chicken was a little rubbery. You should never have to struggle to cut chicken. It came with a side of marinara penne pasta and a house salad. A lot of food for the price. My mom had eggplant parm which she said was great and the pizza looked good. I'd go back. read more

Fratelli's Pizzaria Restaurant - Chicken saltimbocca - Italian Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

Always a good meal at Fratelli's! I mostly go with the prociutto pizza; an excellent choice. It's got a nice blend of flavors and saltiness. I came here once for lunch and the grinder was massive; I took half of it home. It was on a loaf of Italian bread. Impressive! Service is usually good; prompt and friendly. We've sat in the bar and the dining area. We usually opt for a table in the bar. Good selection of beverages. Nice spot for Italian in wallingford. read more