Best ice cream I've ever eaten in my life! My favorite flavor is rocky road and I enjoyed the raspberry rocky road option. Many different choices and options for dietary needs. I'll post a photo of the menu from the day we went. My teens got a flight and loved it. The employee was nice and the front of the shop was clean. Issue: The bathroom was downright filthy. Like gas station at a truck stop in the middle of nowhere dirty. It needs to be power washed and/or gutted. It always concerns me when a food establishment has a dirty bathroom because it makes you question the cleanliness of the food prep area you can't see. read more

See all

Honestly, I was pretty disappointed. The ice cream was extremely underwhelming, and for me, even Dairy Queen tastes wayyyyy better. Maybe I just wasn't prepared for how unusual some of the flavors were--but I suppose that's fitting for a place called Oddfellows. I tried a sample of the cookie flavor, and it was easily the worst cookie ice cream I've ever had. The texture of the Raspberry Rocky Road was also off putting, and even the sprinkles were weird. One thing I will say is that I didn't look inside the bathroom, so I can't speak to its cleanliness. But honestly, if I had gone in and found it to be filthy, I probably wouldn't have gotten the ice cream at all. Cleanliness matters to me, and if a business isn't keeping its customer areas sanitary, it naturally makes me question how seriously cleanliness is taken behind the scenes with food preparation. Again, I didn't actually see anything in the food-prep area, so I'm not making that claim--just explaining how I personally would feel. The staff was super friendly, though, so credit where it's due--the customer service was great. Unfortunately, the ice cream itself was a major miss for me. I really don't know how this place has managed to stay in business in Hyde Park. In an area with so many options, the product has to deliver, and this just didn't. For me, it's a one-and-done. I won't be back. read more

They REALLY hit the spot on a VERY HOT DAY. Located in the lovely Hyde Park Village, it's nice to stop in after having had some of my favorite Sprinkles cupcakes to compliment and cool off with. I love how they let me take Muffin in with me so she could enjoy the ambiance and cool air too, lol. Oddfellows has a huge selection of ice cream flavors, some of the classics, and some more unique. I rarely do classics (unless it's really REALLY good and no one does it better) so I went with their Banoffee flavor which is something like banana with toffee. Very satisfying and sweet with a unique twist from the banana adding the slightly smoky bite of toffee. And I'm not even much a banana person, but this would be a nice go-to whenever I stop by. Service is pretty prompt to greet and attend to as well, so I always feel pretty welcomed. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Banoffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

Still some great flavors here, but quality has noticeably been going down since they opened. Their products are not as reliable and service not as friendly. There's a noticeable decline in the entire experience and maybe others feel the same bc the place is almost always empty even on the weekends. I'm there often bc it's the only ice cream shop and that's what my kid always asks for. Each time I left with an unpleasant experience - my waffle cone had holes so the soft serve was leaking out the sides, the staff member wasn't friendly, the soft serve another time was barely a full serving and consistency was off, odd smell in the store, etc. I'm sad to the decline of this great ice cream concept and the fun, friendly scoop shop it once was. read more

The passion fruit sorbet was bright, tart, and tangy--refreshingly bold in flavor. The salted caramel honeycomb added the perfect balance of sweet crunch, making each bite a delicious contrast of textures and tastes. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Exotic fruits sorbet and the salted caramel honeycomb. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

What a whimsical ice cream spot in Hyde park Tampa. Lots of selections of hard scoop ice cream. They also were very friendly service. They even have ice cream flights to try many options. It smells so wonderful Inside with freshly made waffle cones and bowls! read more

Reese and Natalie, Thank you for your kindness and serving us so last minute!! The ice cream was divine and I will absolutely come back to try more flavors. The mixes are so creative and out-of-the-box. I really loved the miso peanut butter ice cream I got. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - miso peanut butter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

This gourmet ice cream palace is special! Like Jenni's they have phenomenal flavors that are next level. Not cheap, but truly a special experience. The shop is in lovely Hyde Park. An area of Tampa that's lovely for shopping, a stroll, and lots of eateries! Free parking!!! It offers a wonderful variety of exotic flavors. Soft serve. Floats. Pints. They were very accommodating about petting me try some of their terrific flavors. The Green Hills of Pandan is a Sonic the Hedgehog flavor coconut and pandan flavored ice cream with candy and chocolate in it. They also have miso peanut butter brownie, an Aval raspberry ciderrosé infused flavor,. The matcha latte coconut based matcha green tea is GREAT! They have a vegan grasshopper chocolate mint cashew based ice cream with chocolate cookies that has cashwes and wheat in it.. They also have several vegan coconut based ice creams. They have a passionfruit apricot pistachio,. They do a peabut butter s'mores, a key lime pie with marshmallow swirls and graham soil, two GREAT coffee flavors : coffee crunch with swirls of coffee soil and one with St. Pierre's waffles. Cones are about $7, a double scoop for $10. They also do floats, flights ($12) ice cream sandwich, soft serve and pints for 11ish. I love their coconut vegan flavors and their cashew based one. The tropical fruits sorbet, a mix of mango, banana, passionfruit and guava, is delicious. Definitely a splurge for extraordinary ice cream including two Sonic the Hedge Hog themed flavors!!! What's not to love? read more

See all

Solid flavor choices and staff were cool allowing you to try different flavors. The miso was very unique but ended up getting strawberry matcha. Flavor was good but the quality wasn't there... it felt very heavy. A bit too creamy. The price seemed a bit too high for what it is. Wasn't able to finish it but do give credit to the flavor profile. Willing to try again next time read more

Really good ice cream, good and unique flavors. Service was good, it was clean. I recommend checking it out. read more

An Instagram reel brought me here. I got the ice cream flight with my friend. I've gotten ice cream flights elsewhere that had bigger portions, so I thought I wouldn't be able to eat one alone, this one had smaller scoops so I probably could have. I liked that there were a variety of flavors, some I liked better than others. Flavors: Vegan Matcha Latte: 3/5 Raspberry Rose Cider: 5/5 Key Lime Pie: 5/5 Passion Fruit, Apricot Pistachio: 3/5 Miso Peanut Butter Brownie: 3/5 The last one was a long name I can't remember. All in all, it was ok. The Rose one is probably the only one ai would get again because it was unique but none of the other were ones I would get a pint of, maybe because I'm comparing it to other ice cream flights I've gotten, this one didn't seem as memorable. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Delicious ice cream. It's pretty steep for two half scoops You could literally go to publix and buy two whole containers for the price I paid for one cone. I guess they justify prices like that by location. Hyde park is chez chez, but I'd go back if I was in the neighborhood and wanted an expensive treat read more

Stopped here after having a brunch. Place is nice inside, has some chairs to seat down but not many. It's absolutely freezing inside. You basically enter a freezer. We barely could finish ice cream before we got so cold that couldn't seat there anymore. Service is nice and pleasant, just as regular ice cream place. They have lots of unique flavors, selection is pretty large, especially if you like to try some interesting flavors. Taste wise is not so good, definitely had better ice cream before. It wasn't creamy, I could taste ice pieces. I think ice cream from the grocery store is better, obviously not every, but Whole Foods has a pretty good selection of ice cream that tastes better. So, I think me, and our party of 4 were pretty disappointed in a quality. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Inside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Oddfellows has I screaming, you screaming all of us screaming for ice cream! First off, it is located in the heart of Hyde Park Village, one of Tampa's best hangout spots. The location instantly gives extra points as there is so much to do in Hyde Park and what better way to end the night then with ice cream.   Upon walking in, I was warmly (ironic) greeted and offered to sample some literal cold treats. The flavors had fun, unique names that my kids enjoyed while I enjoyed the taste. I found the ice cream to not be overbearingly sweet, in fact, I personally could have went for it being a little sweeter. The prices were a tad bit higher than some of my other local favorites but not so much to knock off points. I sampled a variety of flavors before finally deciding on a two scoop but being honest, you really cannot go wrong with any flavor you choose. All are unique enough where you're sure to leave satisfied while not feeling weighed down by the typical richness you would find in these flavor combinations.   After you enjoy one of the many spectacular restaurants in the village or if you're just hanging out in the area, be sure to stop here to scream for some ice cream! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

VERY SATISFIED! Tastes good and the workers are nice and chill! :) The inside is very clean and air conditioned! read more

Really solid place to go for ice cream in the Hyde Park neighborhood. So many unique ice cream flavors available. The people working here are really friendly and allow you to sample and find the flavor of ice cream you are looking for. Love the ambiance and vibe of the store in general as well. I got the Peanut Butter Marshmallow Ice Cream and it was well balanced between sweet and the savory notes from the peanut butter. I only wish the shop had more group sitting options, but on a nice day, sitting outdoors is perfect as well :) read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Peanut Butter Marshmallow Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Nice little ice cream spot in the trendy Hyde Park area surrounded by shops. After trying a few samples, we settled on a waffle cone with a scoop of cookies and cream and a cup of a coffee flavored ice cream which I don't remember the name. Both of us liked our selections. The shop was clean and the manager was fast and helpful. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

OddFellows has a nice set up with limited seating. They offer a variety of flavors, including vegan options. The staff were not that attentive to serving customers. We were looked over several times, which impacted our experience. The ice cream was okay. I liked that they had flavors you may not normally get. I had the mango sticky rice. It was pretty good. read more

I had a fantastic experience here. The service was wonderful! The guy at the counter during lunch time on 2/15/2022 was so patient and professional. I wish I remembered his name. He greeted us and answered all of our questions. He provided samples as well. This has been on my list of places to go to when in Hyde Park Village. It borders the park area and it's near Sorrento Sweets. Anyway, the OddFellows ice cream shop first opened in Williamsburg, Brooklyn back in 2013. It has been super popular ever since. They have some wonderfully unique flavors that apparently all started from pregnancy cravings. Just read about it when looking up interviews with Mohan Kumar (one of the owners). I also think there is a story behind the toy monkey with the cymbals. That's their mascot named Clyde. Creepy monkey aside, the carnival theme is what makes them stand out. It's a whimsical atmosphere. I really do love the creativity in the décor and their product. I was set on trying their Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio ice cream. No one was going to change my mind on that. Although I thought about trying the Kitchen Sink flavor. The ice cream was amazing! It had the most natural passion fruit and apricot flavor. It didn't taste artificial whatsoever. The pistachio was there but it was finely chopped and just provided a little texture here and there. It was great! I'd totally get it again. I'm looking forward to trying more flavors. They bring out new ones each month. I hope they bring out the Thai Tea flavor again. That would be awesome. read more

See all

Delightfully surprised with my passion fruit apricot pistachio ice cream with Oreo cookie crumbs. I've been stuck on my love for Chill Bros. And with that, I haven't found an ice cream I loved much. This time, I tried a few flavors at Oddfellows and they were pretty good. They tasted bright and flavorful and like the flavor they say they are. I really enjoyed my ice cream. It didn't taste all weird and it did taste like every single flavor it was without tasting off or fake. I'm happy I tried it. I would definitely recommend them. I do wish they gave a sliver of cone on the side like other ice cream places. I also had no issues with the guy who assisted me with my order. He was very friendly with giving me samples, & getting my order. The inside is nice and bright and fun. They have a handful of booths and tables, but it would also be nice to eat it outside in the center area since it's at Hyde Park Village!! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

It's was super hot outside so an ice cream sounded right. Looking at the options I see they have a wide range of different flavors. They have flavors with infused alcohol! I also liked how on the menu it says whether an ice cream is vegan, gluten free, contains dairy. They have something for everyone depending on their dietary restrictions. I got the Vegan Chocolate and Peanut Butter ice cream with Pistachio. If I wasn't told this was vegan I would have never found out because I can't even tell the difference. I really enjoyed the ice cream and we'll worth it especially with the heat this summer. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Vegan Chocolate and Peanut Butter ice cream and Pistachio - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Came in at 9:30, party of 7 to Order ice cream and three of our kids needed to use their restroom. They said "the bathrooms are closed" we asked why you don't close for 30 minutes??? They said "we already cleaned them" I am assuming the owner/manager has no idea this happens!!! If you want ice cream, and need to use the bathroom at this place, Please come before 9 PM.!! Absolutely unacceptable and ridiculous that they do this. They lost a fairly large chunk of cash on us!! If you're gonna hire high school students to work here.... Hire some to clean bathrooms after you close! Hope the health department doesn't show up tonight!! Going to Dairy Queen.... I run a fairly large food service company and would fire my staff for pulling what these knuckle heads do.... Won't be back!! read more

First time here. I ordered a vanilla bean ice cream with graham cracker solids. The ice cream was delicious. The single serve is a really small cup. They should make it slightly bigger, especially since the topping didn't even fit. I also think they are a bit overpriced. Again, the ice cream was tasty. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Vanilla Bean Ice Cream with Graham Crackers Solids - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

OddFellows is a cute spot right next to the fountain in the middle of Hyde Park Village. There are a lot of interesting flavors of ice cream to try. The ice cream is decent but I wish it was a bit smoother. I would be curious about trying their soft serve. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - PB S'mores - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

The ice cream was amazing and the service was superb. Dimitri was so helpful. The Italian cake ice cream in a home made cone was delicious.

We were walking around Hyde Park and wanted to get some ice cream, so we decided to give OddFellows a try. The layout was confusing. We weren't sure where to order. Most ice cream places you go, you can actually see the ice cream in the display case but here you just ordered off the menu. I prefer seeing the ice cream before ordering. My fiancé tried their chocolate ice cream and said it was ok, not as creamy or rich as we were hoping for. I tried their chocolate soft serve ice cream which I thoroughly enjoyed. It's definitely pricey for ice cream, but the quality wasn't worth what you paid for. Chills Bros is still our favorite place for ice cream in Tampa. Chills Bros has similar prices but you get a huge serving and better ice cream! @living.with.reg read more

Rude workers and not great ice cream. They claim they close at 10pm on their door but at 9:45pm they were already closing up. They were definitely in a rush to clock out and made that clear. I asked for a sample of one of their flavors and the girl behind the counter rolled her eyes and seemed like I was being annoying. I felt guilty so I ordered the vegan chocolate ice cream even though I wasn't impressed with the sample. The taste was very average, not creamy or fresh. For $6 for one kiddie scoop of ice cream, it was a huge disappointment. I ended up tossing it out halfway through. It just wasn't good. It was very mediocre and boring and not worth the calories or sugar. Won't be back. read more

See all

I'm rewriting this review because I tried this place again and it seems as though they have hired new friendly faces which is such a breath of fresh air from our 1st visit. We were promptly greeted by the staff and even though they were out of cookies and cream again, the young man working there suggested we call ahead to see if they have it and also recommended his fav flavors. Tried regular vanilla and my bf had the cinnamon bun like ice cream. Both were delicious! :) So happy the new staff matches the ambience of this ice cream shop because it really is a cool trendy place with tasty ice cream! Enjoyed it way better this time and it's nice to see a business actually care about their customer experience! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Yummy vanilla !! With homemade waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Ice cream is great!!! The monkey pictures, not so much.... Those pictures are scary. Service was great. They have very unique items on the menu. It is in a very nice location. Again with the pictures though. I'm gonna have nightmares about those. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Oddfellows ice cream co. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

This ice cream joint is always busy at night. We stopped in during the day, and it was empty. They have a lot of ice cream options, and they are clearly labeled vegan, gluten-free, etc. for those with allergies. As for me, I was told there was an element of cross contamination even if they got the ice cream from the back, so I opted out Hubs had the coffee ice cream, and he liked it a lot. It's a nice little spot to get something cold and refreshing. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Delicious and great service ! Definitely a unique but classic ice cream spot . Definitely a must in Tampa !

This is a new location for this ice cream shop. It fits nicely in Hyde Park Village. The business started in Williamsburg, Brooklyn by a married couple having a baby, and their friend, an award winning chef. They have several locations between Tampa and Brooklyn. Many of the flavors are unique such as cheddar apple pie, peanut butter banana, key lime pie, and poppycock just to name a few. The key lime was excellent. They also serve vegan ice cream and sorbet. You can try a small spoonful before deciding The store is modern with clean lines. There is a seating area inside. Parking is difficult in this area, but there is a free parking garage a few blocks away. read more

See all

Oddfellows is a new ice cream shop in Old Hyde Park. The owner of the store is super nice and the staff is working very hard this afternoon for soft opening. Today, one free scoop of ice cream. I got the Coquito ice cream which has rum in it. I tasted the rum right away. The ice cream is creamy and refreshing on this afternoon. I believe there is at least 30 flavors. I will be back soon. read more

See all

Absolutely Fantastic Experience! I had the best time at Odd Fellows recently, and I just have to share how wonderful it was! The shop itself is clean, welcoming, and full of delicious options--but what really made my visit memorable was the amazing service I received. From the moment I walked in, staff greeted me with a genuine smile and friendly attitude. Then patiently walked me through all the flavors, offered generous samples, and even made some great recommendations that I ended up loving -- it's life-changing! It's rare these days to see someone who clearly enjoys what they do and makes every customer feel valued. Jon went above and beyond, and it turned a simple ice cream stop into the highlight of my day. Highly recommend this place--not just for the amazing ice cream, but for the kind of service that leaves you smiling long after you've finished your scoop. Can't wait to come back. read more

Such a cute and decorative shop, it felt very welcoming along with the staff, they were great, helpful, and kind. I was amazed at all of the crazy flavors, I have never tried ice cream with wasabi in it which I have to say was surprisingly good if you like wasabi. My fiancé had the cookies and cream and I had the chocolate chunk, both good and was the right touch on such a hot day. Thank you OddFellows for this unique experience! read more

See all

Odd fellows has a great location just inside of Hyde park village. We stopped in on a standard blazing Wednesday evening after a walk. We tried the vegan chocolate chunk and the vanilla soft serve with sprinkles. The staff was friendly and it was nice to cool off in the air conditioning. They have a fun upbeat decor, perfect ice cream shop vibes. I love that they offer vegan options so even the dairy free members of our party could partake in the goodness. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Vegan chocolate chunk and vanilla soft serve with sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

This place has some very interesting flavors of ice cream. I tried the aval raspberry rose flavor on a waffle cone and it was a nice blend of ice cream with raspberry swirl. The waffle cone was made to order, sweet with a hint of peanut butter flavor. Interested in coming back to try some more. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Aval Raspberry Rose - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

The prices were very expensive for skimpy portions. I paid $9 for a dollop of soft serve. The employees were also very rude and ignored me and the people i was with. read more

Cute but quirky ice cream shop with fun flavors! Reasonably priced. Nice staff. Tables to hang and chat. If you're in the area, stop by. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Stopped by at Odd Fellows before tacos at BarTaco (don't judge!) but my Husband and I decided to have a little snack beforehand. I chose Cookies and Cream (played it safe for a first time!) and he chose Mint Chocolate Chip (my least favorite). The ice cream was creamy and delicious! Surprisingly, I even enjoyed the mint chocolate chip as it wasn't an overwhelming amount of mint flavor. The two young ladies working behind the counter were very sweet and helpful, even when a big group of customers came in all at one time. I'd love to come back and try some of their other flavors! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Double scoop ice cream - Cookies and Cream and Mint Chocolate Chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tampa, Florida