My wife and I are in town for a small vacation and this was a must as I love lobster rolls. We both got the lobster roll flight - though I wish there were more than 3 options for the flight they were nothing short of amazing. We sat at the bar immediately and received great service and drinks while we waited. The manager was awesome and gave great conversation. If we are ever in the area again this will be a must go. read more

The food was fast, fresh and delicious. The lobster role flight let you taste them all. Our server Sunshine was the cherry on top.

Second time here and we love it! Atmosphere and food are fantastic and Sunshine was an amazing server. Feels like you're eating on the coast!! read more

This spot has been on my list. When u found out they were replacing The Stonehouse in Lewiston, I knew I had to finally check it out. We got to eat out on the patio by the street which my son loved people watching and seeing all the cars go by. Our server Leah was fantastic and so nice. Incredible service and no wait for a table. We ordered a couple of lobster rolls and got my son a kids chicken finger meal. The lobster roll was amazing. I'm going back for another one so soon. The lobster was delicious and the roll itself was so soft and buttery. It also came with Old Bay seasoned chips which were fantastic. Needless to say, we loved our lunch here and we will definitely be back for more. With all the concerts in Artpark, this might be our new stop beforehand. read more

See all

4 of us went as first timers Wednesday night. The food gets a 9 out of 10. The service through was struggling. After seeing the hostess, she said it would be a little wait or she could give us a table up near the sidewalk. We didn't care. We took the sidewalk table. Our waitress was training someone new. Then our waitress disappeared. I think every interaction we had with someone was with a different employee. I think because we were the furthest table in the sidewalk area that we were forgotten about. One one of us had silverware and a napkin. We never were asked about drink refills. We didn't see anyone during our meal to check in and see how it was or for us to ask for refills or napkins. When the food was delivered, our loaded lobster tots were missing. We let the employee know. 10 or so minutes later, someone else brought them out, set them on the table next to us, and even though those people said they weren't those, and we said they were ours, the employee insisted that table could have them for free. It was easily another 15 minutes before we got ours, and by then our other food was gone and we were ready to go home. When we were able to let another server know we needed silverware, a different employee appeared down the sidewalk with silverware, and then turned around and never brought it down to us. We were at the restaurant for two hours which seems excessive for lobster rolls and tots.... But the food.... The food was elite. Best lobster I've ever had. Our group had a few lobster roll flights, a few lobster BLTs, street corn, pineapple slaw, and the loaded lobster tots. I really cannot say enough about how delicious everything was. We all loved the lobster rolls. They all were equally delicious. The lobster was so fresh. They were full of meat. They left nothing to be desired, except another one. The lobster BLT was equally great. Plenty of lobster on it and the whole sandwich was fresh, great toast, other great ingredients. The pineapple slaw was delicious coleslaw in general, but I couldn't really taste the pineapple. We all loved the street corn. The lobster tots didn't get an entirely fair review from us because they came out so late after our meal, but the tots were cooked to perfection. We actually all voted that even though the cheese was delicious, there was a bit too much, and the lobster was so lost under the cheese. We thought it would have been better with the lobster on top. Even though we had some service issues, the food was top notch. The location is great. The main street in Lewiston is a must. And we will definitely be back. It was a great night to sit outside and enjoy the company of good friends and great food, and the vibe at this new location delivered. read more

See all

We've been to the original, but I wanted to try this location when I was in Lewiston for a concert. Same great menu and service. Larger location with plenty of seating and a bar. I love the California roll, but this time I tried the lobster tots. Plenty of lobster. Wish there was a bit less cheese sauce and aioli. It tastes good. It's just a bit too rich for my preference. The tots were still crispy. If there's ever an unseasonably cool day, I'd love to try the grilled cheese and lobster bisque. Definitely worth a visit if you're in the area. I prefer the view in Olcott, especially since you can walk closer to the water to enjoy your food, but there's something to be said for shade and a bar. read more

Olcott Lobster - Lobster tots - Seafood Near Me - Lewiston, New York

See all

Lobster roll flight was delicious! Tons of lobster, not skimpy at all. Service was fast and friendly! Outdoor seating area was nice and clean. Will definitely be back!! read more

Olcott Lobster - Outside - Seafood Near Me - Lewiston, New York

See all

Went for the second time last night. I love the set up of the restaurant with the open air atmosphere. On a warm breezy night it's perfect. Food has been good every time, portions are a little small but lobster is expensive and they don't skimp on how much they pack in the roll. They have a few choices of what kind of lobster roll you want so there is variety. Our waitress was Racheal and she was one of the best waitresses ever. Very friendly and personable and made it even a more pleasant experience. read more

See all

Love that this location is an actual restaurant with indoor and outdoor door seating. The place is airy and well lit, which gives the overall appeal of a coastal restaurant. The staff were extremely nice and helpful. I ordered the Lobster Roll flight, which came with 3 different rolls. All were delicious!! The Olcott Fire was a bit spicy for me (as it should have been), but still amazing. I will definitely return! read more

Olcott Lobster - Lobster Roll Flight - Seafood Near Me - Lewiston, New York

The restaurant is rather costly but the food is worth the experience. I suggest you treat yourself to some wonderful lobster rolls

We were greeted quickly and were brought to our table shortly afterwards. Our server, Savannah, was very friendly and accommodating- even turned down the music when requested! Our food came out promptly and was delicious! We went early so crowds were not an issue. Highly recommend! read more

Olcott Lobster - Lobster Flight - Seafood Near Me - Lewiston, New York

See all

I met a group of women friends at Olcott Lobster (Lewiston) for lunch on September 3rd and was delighted with the experience. The lobster rolls are fresh, generously proportioned, and delicious. Great Margaritas. Especially worth mentioning was the staff's attentiveness to our party of five. Thanks Michelle and Matt! My only regret is that Olcott is a seasonal restaurant--it will close at the end of October until the Spring. I need to hurry back! read more

Olcott Lobster - Olcott Lobster Company, Lewiston, NY - Seafood Near Me - Lewiston, New York

This will always be a favorite of mine. The lobster rolls and the lobster grilled cheese are fabulous. Lots of lobster. We had wonderful service from our waitress, Sunshine, was fabulous. Friendly. Efficient. Nice open air atmosphere. Big screen TVs. read more

Our first time at Olcott Lobster and we loved it! We waited until the crowd died down to stop by, around 7:30 pm. The hostess said it would still be about a 40 minute wait but we were able to snag bar seats right away. Both bartenders very friendly and attentive! I ordered the lobster roll flight and subbed out the spicy one for the surf and turf for a small up-charge, so it then consisted of Connecticut style with warm butter, Maine style with lemon aioli and surf and turf which was Connecticut style with filet on top. We also got the lobster tots! Having been to Maine many times and the opportunity to try truly authentic and incredible lobster rolls.... Olcott is holding their own! The rolls were delicious. Packed with lobster meat, but I think the most impressive part was the perfectly toasted and buttered roll, which truly makes all the difference. I could have done without the surf and turf, (just too much going on) but the other two are very solid classics. Overall a great casual place to get a very authentic and delicious lobster roll and not have to drive several states over to find it! We will be back for sure! read more

Olcott Lobster - Lobster tots - Seafood Near Me - Lewiston, New York

See all

I went to the Olcott store last year, and liked it. Family was visiting, I decided to try the new Lewiston location. The wait for a table was 40 minutes but there were empty tables. We grabbed the bar seats while we were waiting and were able to order drinks and food. By the time we finished, our name was called for the table. We got 2 flights, 2 drinks, buttered corn and pineapple slaw. All were tasty. The lobster rolls had good amounts of lobster meat. If you look at the price they may seem expensive, but those are solid lobster meat. They have indoor and outdoor seatings, sitting at the bar was fun. Parking can be street side or in the plaza parking lot next door. read more

See all

Quick service and off the chain food. The lobster tots and Surf and Turf was amazing! And our waitress Leah was amazing and sweet. read more

Olcott Lobster - Surf and Turf Roll and LOBSTAH Tots - Seafood Near Me - Lewiston, New York

The ultimate compliment? Better than "LOBSTA" rolls in New England! The lobster rolls at Olcott Lobster's Lewiston location are high quality, generously portioned, and priced fairly. Absolutely delicious. A very casual lunch experience mid-week which also included potato tots and very good clam chowder. Our server, Amy, was impressive. She sealed the deal making this visit likely one of many more to come in the future. Very nice open surroundings. I'm guessing this place is mobbed on weekends and rightfully so. Well worth the 45 minute drive. Congratulations to owner Michelle in recognizing her dream after years of hard work and dedication in other businesses. We wish you much success! read more

Went there on Saturday night got there about 630. there was about a 20 minute to a half hour wait. The weight was worth it though lobster rolls were amazing and will definitely go back. The flight gives you three different lobster rolls so it's a way to try a different variety. Service is warm and friendly. read more

Olcott Lobster - Lobster roll flight - Seafood Near Me - Lewiston, New York

We had a great lunch here! My husband said it was the best thing he's eaten in a while. I got the Connecticut roll with a side of potato salad. The roll was just the standard lobster roll with butter. The rolls came with homemade chips. The food was delicious! Everything tasted very fresh. Our waitress Michelle was amazing. She was so sweet with our 4 month old son and kept talking to him. We love going out and sitting on a patio, and this was a nice one. We will definitely be back to get more rolls! read more

Olcott Lobster - Connecticut Roll and potato salad - Seafood Near Me - Lewiston, New York

See all

Well now I don't have to drive all the way to Olcott to get the best lobster roll in our area. They serve lobster rolls,sandwiches,soups,clams,oysters and lobster Mac and cheese. Everything is bought in the New England area. The new location at the Old Stone house Restaurant. There are seats at the bar and table seating. The lobster rolls are to die for. The new restaurant probably has triple seating over the Olcott location, I hope they don't run out of lobster because with the quality of the food and prices they'll be killing it! read more

The Lobster rolls were great! They were average sized and they did not skimp on the lobster. I think they were priced fairly as well (about $24-$25). We also ordered the loaded tater tots and they were pretty tasty. Service was great. It was nice sitting outside, and we were happy to get a table out of the sun (some were in the sun). read more

See all

My wife and I have been twice now and we love it! I've gotten the lobster roll flight and the fire roll and both were excellent! The service is friendly and the entire restaurant is a patio. It's a fantastic and fun space! read more

Fun place, great atmosphere! Food was awful Had the Lobster roll. Was tasteless and portion was small. No side with $26 lobster roll read more

The ambiance of this restaurant is very, waterside, boardwalk vibe. Staff is super friendly, and the nautical vibe is comfortable and welcoming. Kid friendly and adult drinks are available for purchase. The food was absolutely amazing! The Olcott Lobster Company desevers a 100/10! Would come back again! read more

Sunshine was amazing service food excellent , love Maine lobster , potato salad amazing and everything else !!

Felt overall everything very average. Atmosphere generally good, service was poor. They hire youngins who can't even tell you if place takes reservations. Lobster Bisque was too thick lacked lobster and flavor. Both sandwiches were ok at best. read more

See all

Sunshine was the best and the west coast lobster roll was amazing. Also ambiance at the bar was great.

Definitely a cool place to grab food. Covered outdoor patio with open air seating. Get the tots! read more

Olcott Lobster - Olcott Fire Roll and the loaded lobster tots - Seafood Near Me - Lewiston, New York

Wife and I stopped by for lunch and the food was great. You get a fair share of lobster with each order. Highly recommend coming back.

Sunshine was an outstanding server, very friendly kind and helpful. The Lobster Rolls are the best outside of New England I highly recommend you stopping in for one read more

Loved every minute of the DJ that was here on Wed 7/29 (The People's DJ)! He's fabulous and it was a fun treat to have a fun 'club like' experience come to Lewiston! read more

Overcrowded. Overpriced. Beautiful view of a parking lot that you can't park in. Lol. If they don't get good bands they won't last a year.

Wish we took pictures!!!! It was way over regular food portions! Very fast and friendly service! The flight and loaded tots were more than enough for two adults and absolutely delicious!! read more

sunshine was the best waitress. Such a delight! Food fantastic! Sunshine even better!

Our 1st time here. We took the Discovery Shuttle up from Niagra Falls and knew we wanted to have lunch here! We were not disappointed! Lobster rolls were amazing and so wa the staff! We will definitely be back!! read more

Sunshine was the best waitress ever! Fast, kind, friendly, and knowledgeable about the menu. It was our first time at this location (love the original!) and it was just as wonderful! Fresh lobster. Delicious chowder. Wish we had left room for dessert. We will be back. read more

Beautiful place , friendly staff, food was not good at all . The chicken tenders were dry and tator tots overcooked . The lobster rolls were basically 3 little half rolls none of them were seasoned right ,not worth the crazy amount they charge and not to mention no real flatware. The street corn blah . Wouldn't recommend this place except for a cocktail lunch with Beautiful scenery !!! read more

It was very expensive for the miniscule amount of lobster that I received. I thought it was almost comical at first with the plastic silverware and $45 for a couple ounces of lobster and exactly 2 small chunks of steak in 3 pieces of bread. We were charged over $100 for a chicken sandwich with no condiments and a burger with potato chips. We tipped our waiter well and when he asked If we would return, none of us answered.... read more

Great spot. Accommodating staff. Simple good food. Bonus points for gluten free beer on tap.

Found this place through a great review on TikTok. It was not that We got unlucky with our server she was the worst she was all over the place. She took forever to come over, couldnt get her system to work had to have another server show her how to about 3 times so it took us 45 minutes to even get our food ordered. My lobster roll was really good but my husband who doesnt eat seafood got a chicken sandwich and it came out with cheese we called the server over to let her know he couldnt eat it with cheese and she told us we could SCRAPE IT OFF. Then when i said could he just get a new one she told us they would have to charge us for both sandwiche. INSANE. I wont be back :) read more