Not a bad spot at all. I will admit that my review is based solely on a to-go order, so I can't speak to the dine-in experience just yet. My wife and I ordered takeout for a date night at home and kept it simple with a tavern-style thin crust pizza and an order of mozzarella sticks. The mozzarella sticks were okay, although I suspect some of that comes with the territory of fried food spending time in a takeout container during the drive home. The pizza, however, was very good. It was exactly what we were looking for that evening: crispy, flavorful, and satisfying without trying to be anything it wasn't. Based on our experience, we would absolutely order again. In fact, next time we'd like to visit in person and see how the dine-in experience compares. read more

Big restaurant with light natural decor and plenty of seating in the bar area as well as in the dining area and enough tv that you won't miss the game but not overwhelming. The service is friendly, fast and welcoming. The menu has plenty of options form apps, salads, pizza and sandwiches so there is something for everyone. The boneless wings are juice and the sauces have plenty of flavor. The hand tossed pizza was hot and paced with flavor. This is a good place to grab a bit and catch a game. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Half and half pizza - Pizza Near Me - Goodyear, Arizona

See all

Went in for drinks before our movie down the road. Spacious, clean, welcoming. We had draft drinks & they were crisp & cold! Staff was helpful & patient with my special needs son. Will have to come back to try food. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Just inside bar area. - Pizza Near Me - Goodyear, Arizona

See all

We celebrated my son in laws birthday here last night. My daughter and son in law had eaten at Old Chicago (in Kansas) while vacationing. So glad we tried Old Chicago. The atmosphere, sports and family friendly. The food was amazing. We had 2 different pizzas, salad, buffalo chicken rolls (my favorite), pepperoni rolls, nachos, chicken wings, beers and wine. Our phenomenal server, Diana, was amazing. She offered to refrigerate our cake and was on top of everything before needed. She made sure our beverages were never empty. The food was so good. We left there fat and happy. Thank you Diana and Old Chicago. We will be back soon. read more

I ordered a 'Veggie 7' on Tavern Thin Crust and was pleasantly rewarded. Topping coverage was generous and the thin crust had a nice crunch. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Goodyear, Arizona

They have a nice bar set up, good craft beer and delicious pizza. Service has alway been good, they do get busy so get there early.

10/10 very good pizza reminds me of home. The ambience is nice too. It's perfect for dates or family dinners.

This place is consistently good. It's nothing mind blowing but it's good. We like sitting in the bar area, watching sports, eating pizza, and enjoying a drink. Who doesn't love that? My only feedback is that their margaritas are not good! Also, their beer prices are too high if you don't come during happy hour. They really should have at least one decent priced beer (under $6) available at all times of the day. It's not like this is some fancy place. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Happy hour menu - Pizza Near Me - Goodyear, Arizona

I'm ordered for pick up and was not happy with the order. The prices do not match the quantity or quality of the food. The boneless chicken wings looked more like chicken nuggets. I will not be ordering from here again. read more

My 3 boys, husband and I came here after a weekend of camping and tired- too tired to cook or clean more. Out to dinner we go! We had actually chosen the Haymaker because I wanted to appease everyone in our family. I'm also picky about pizza and wanted more options than what most pizza joints offer that are actually edible. We had several servers greet us and help us as they had a couple big groups of guys watching baseball on their many tv's. They even have Chive tv playing- we really get sucked in watching that channel. We are also a huge sports family and love pretty much all sports! Live, on tv and playing. I ordered the chicken walnut salad- delish- I asked for dressing on the side. We ordered the Chicken Bacon Ranch (cbr) Pizza and fried pickles, my boys got kids chic strips and a burger. They kept our drinks refilled- hubs had a Few beers, my boys had milk and strawberry lemonade and I had water. They accidentally made a different pizza- the pepperoni one- it was really good and It was slightly spicy! I had 1 slice after they offered to let us keep the mistake while they corrected our pizza order. When the CBR pizza came I had a slice of that as well and it was so good!! It was pretty comparable to a CBR pizza I used to get way back in the day up in WA state. So I was happy I found a new spot that makes a good one. :). We did regular hand tossed pizza- going to try thin crust next time. My husband really loves Chicago style pizza but I didn't want to wait that long for so many carbs lol. :) Everything was good- we had excellent service too!! I will definitely go back in there for a family dinner. I even liked the vibe in the bar area- to chill and have a brewski. lol very clean and all the sports on tv!! Thanks for a great service and good- We now have a new dinner spot for my family of boys and I! read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Goodyear, Arizona

Man! This place gave us a run for our food and money. I wish I could say I would go back! Only saving grace is it was fixed after the third attempt. Please when you visit if you order a deep dish style pizza to have them make sure they place the top over to it while it's in the over. If not, it's a charred pizza and they would try to say it's fine. When clearly. You can see it's not. Worse part of all, we took it up to the manager and he was still attempting to make us take this charred pizza. We hate to be those people at any restaurant but it was not edible. Unless you like burnt pizza which we didn't. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Goodyear, Arizona

First time here, and was excited to try it. Seemed nice and clean, came at a good time so it wasn't so busy. Food was okay, wings were the best, and the spinach dip was good. We came around happy hour so it was a great deal, I don't know how i feel about the pasta chips the spinach dip comes with (some were undercooked and stale?) The service was good until it wasn't. Our server was attentive until we got our food and once we did she would take FOREVER for refills and bringing back ranch. I was waiting to finish my meal with my ranch, waiting over 20 minutes and feeling hostage to leave. The only thing I could say they could improve is to be more attentive because people have plans, want to eat their food fresh with the right condiments, or maybe invest in those kiosk registers so people could leave when they want. read more

It's a nice place but we do not like the pizza. Other items were pretty good though. Service was good. read more

Would not recommend coming to this place. The food was very very average. VERY small portions if you want a side of ranch it's gonna be $1.50. Beer was flat had to be sent back twice. Really wish I didn't come here. Here on vacation and was looking for something solid. VERY DISAPPOINTED. Server was very nice. FOOD IS NOT GOOD AND GOOD PORTIONS. read more

If you're looking for a laid-back spot where your taste buds can throw a little party, Old Chicago in Goodyear is definitely worth the visit. From the moment I walked in, the vibe was welcoming and the staff was all smiles--seriously, I think they might be part-time comedians, because they had us chuckling between bites! IPA Beer Tour: Hoppy Days Are Here Again Instead of a standard flight, I went full IPA mode--and what a flavorful ride it was! From citrusy punches to piney finishes, each glass had a bold personality trying to out-hop the last. It was like speed-dating with beers, and I think I may have found The One. Or Three. Pro tip: samples are available before committing. Chicken Caprese Sandwich: Italy Meets Backyard BBQ This beauty showed up stacked with juicy grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, ripe tomato, and a drizzle of balsamic glaze that whispered sweet nothings. Throw in some basil and you've got my partner hooked. Fish and Chips: Golden & Glorious They nailed the classic. Flaky fish, lightly battered and fried to a perfect crunch, paired with fries that were just the right balance of salty and satisfying. I didn't expect much for fish at a pizza joint, but these satisfied my craving. A solid 4 out of 5. ‍‍ Service with a Smile (and Maybe a High-Five) The team there made the whole experience feel like hanging out with old friends--if your friends knew how to perfectly time refills and deliver piping hot meals with flair. Bottom line: Old Chicago Goodyear is the kind of place you go to try something new... and end up planning your next visit before you've even finished dessert. If good vibes, tasty bites, and a cold pint sound like your kind of night, this spot's got your name on it. read more

I wouldn't be surprised if this restaurant closes within the next year or two. I went yesterday with my family around 1pm on a Sunday, the place was about 25% full thinking we'd get our order and food within a reasonable timeframe ...but no, service was incredibly SLOW and the food was a nightmare. We ordered 3 orders of 9 piece chicken wings ordered EXTRA extra crispy....they were absolutely not fried correctly. Edible, but definitely not what we asked for. Also ordered a chicken ceaser salad and the manager came up to us and told us the chicken was burnt so it'll be a while before it comes out, it finally came out and the Romain lettuce was somehow FROZEN and soggy at the same time....i literally couldn't eat it and had the server just take it off the bill. Anddddd 2 large pizzas....which is really why we came here and were incredibly disappointed. The pizzas were SOGGY at the bottom....im not sure how long they were sitting out in the kitchen to be that soggy and NOt hot when we got them but it was bad. Overall the experience was bad and definitely wouldn't recommend this place to anyone. Like I would have preferred dominos pizza over this place. read more

These guys have gotten better with age! The pizza is as good as mentioned before, but this time I have something that I really liked that I wanted to share. This time, I decided to order some wings. They come with your option of different rubs and sauces. Well, I don't really need all the sweet sauce, so we ordered the jerk rub with the sauce on the side. Without the sauce, the wings were so delightfully crunchy and the jerk was really, really salty good with just slight heat. We kept going back to the bones, hoping to get a little extra bit of crunchy goodness. These were hands down, the best I've had! And add a pint from their well stocked bar to the pizza and wings, and what else could you ask for? Salad? Yes, it is really good as well! read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Spice Jerk Rub Dry! - Pizza Near Me - Goodyear, Arizona

See all

Such a better visit this go round. We were greeted and seated right away. We ordered a pizza, chicken tenders as well as an old Chicago chopped salad. As an appetizer we had some Nashville hot wings. Everything came out quicks and everything was delicious. Our server was great and friendly. Great stop today. Vibe was good and bar area clean and plenty of tvs to watch . read more

See all

There's variety beyond pizza here. Add in apps, salads, sandwiches, wings, pastas, and desserts and you've got something for everyone in your group. We ordered house salads for all and a small, cauliflower crust pizza. That was enough for a party of four adults. Service was very good. This place is part full service restaurant and part sports bar, though the sports bar noise didn't intrude into the restaurant. read more

Quick seating - inattentive staff recommended a pizza and a salad and then split the dinner for two of us to share read more

This place is always our go to place for happy hour food & drinks. Great happy hour prices on the food and it's always consistently good, always served hot and tastes great. Jasmine & her crews are always on point with the service, cleanliness and very friendly as well. If you've never tried this place I think you'll be pleasantly surprised. Go watch a game and have some drinks and you'll see what I mean. The cheeseburger is to die for as well as the farmers daughter pizza! read more

I hadn't been to an Old Chicago in many many years and wanted the Italian Nachos. I made the mistake of ordering them to-go as carryout. When I got back to my hotel, I realized the didn't give me any marinara sauce to go with them and they were weak on cheese. As I started to eat them, I realized all the cheese was melted/stuck to the wax paper in the bottom of the box. It was almost like the accidental flipped them upside down when putting them in the box...but there was some toppings on top...idk. Either way, it was not great. Probably should have eaten them there for a better experience. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Italian nachos - Pizza Near Me - Goodyear, Arizona

Service is always good, food is good. Pizza is not like home but will do for now lol. Ample parking they could update the seating as it looks well used. read more

See all

The seating was super uncomfortable and we were sat in a child unfriendly area. Service was slow and there was a "flippant" vibe. The servers were definitely tip gauging making the experience uncomfortable. The food took a really long time to receive. It was good but there was a spicy aftertaste. Not too busy for a Sunday afternoon read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Goodyear, Arizona

See all

I used to love this place. We ate here every couple of weeks. However, lately it's really changed. I usually get an individual pizza. The last two times there's barely been any toppings on it. I might as well be getting a plain pizza since it's mostly cheese. The price certainly hasn't changed though. Really disappointed. read more

Was very upset with the service I had here, we came in for a family dinner had it got completely ruined by our very disrespectful waitress. We felt very uncomfortable with the attitude the waitress was giving towards us so we decided to leave. Was looking forward to eating here but when you ask a question and the waitress gives you attitude it takes the whole vibe away. read more

Great ambiance and service. Really yummy eats, pizza and appetizers. Great for groups or casual date night.

Our food was seasoned well and came out fast, and hot which it honestly hard to get at many places. Our server was very attentive and a manager was walking around "touching tables" to check on guest. Overall a great experience and we will return. read more

Very surprised at how good this pizza really was, very good, not Great in my opinion. National franchise just recently came to the West valley next to Haymaker's. Good service, and good beer selection for those of you who enjoy that drink. The downfall is the surprising limited choices in my opinion and the very long time it takes to get your Pizza, Over 35 minutes on all 3 of ours, when it wasn't very busy. I would go here again, since I'm still looking for a really good pizza choice in the valley. Strangest thing to me with all the LA, Chicago, and NY transplants and hundreds of Pizza joints the Valley's pizza so far is mediocre at best. My opinion as always read more

See all

Happy Hour! You need to go for Happy Hour! The best time to try apps, pizzas and more. You will not regret the pizza roll ups, the chips and spinach dip, and the deal on beer. My family loves this place for their pizza as well. So good! read more

I don't really know why they use the word Taproom in their name? I wasn't thrilled with the food or beer the first time but thought it was just a bad night for them so I tried Old Chicago again. I asked the server what dark beers they had. She had to check with the bartender? She returned and said the darkest beers they had was Kiltlifter and Guinness. I said is that it and she said yes. I told her I could get those beers at Walmart. Asked for a manager and she said since it was summer they weren't carrying many dark beers. Basically same as the first time I came here which was not during summer. I ordered the lunch special personal pizza. Not many toppings on it. Just so so. Needless to say why would I go to a "Taproom" with such a limited variety of beers. I would much rather go to The Yard House where they always have a multitude of different beers and better food also. Now I know why the parking lot is never full at Old Chicago!! read more

So glad this location opened! All the appetizers are amazing and the pizza is fantastic! The happy hour specials are decent too. Service is always good regardless of how busy they are and it's great for game day with all the TVs. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Double deckeroni oc thick crust - Pizza Near Me - Goodyear, Arizona

We tried this on a Friday afternoon around 2 pm. Plenty of seating. Greeted right away. Got a booth just as we requested. Hostess very friendly. Several options on tap. Accommodating for my different taste of drinks. We got lucky and our server Dannie was amazing. I haven't had this attention to detail from a server since the pandemic started. Specifically since both the upscale and fAst food restaurants are in dyer need of staff. NOT NECESSARILY PRODUCTIVE STAFF. At this point businesses are taking whatever they can get. And I am very understanding of the situation everyone is in. Which is why Dannie is a gem in the hospitality industry!!! She should be training every employee that walks in the restaurant. In regards to the food: the wings were ok. Hubby liked the buffalo. The drinks were as expected and delicious. Recommended by Dannie. Pizza was great. TRY IT!!!!! Thanks for a great experience!!!!! By the way, the Manager on duty was great as well! Thanks!! read more

See all

Pizza was burnt. Manager MIKE said he checks every pizza going out. NOT TRUE! Wanted to argue with me about getting a new pizza. Not happy, as we waited an hour for delivery. Would give 0 stars if I could. After returning the pizza to the manager MIKE, he proceeded to look at the bottom of the pizza and state it wasn't burnt, even though the top of the pizza is burnt. Burnt cheese, burnt crust. He wanted to argue with my husband about the order. He stated he looks at every pizza going out, but only looks at the bottom! What?!? LOUSY MANAGER MIKE! read more

First and foremost, this place does not serve a typical Chicago style deep dish pizza. Don't let the name Chicago pizza fool. Nonetheless, this place has a great ambiance, it's modern looking with high top tables and a bar with big screen TVs. It's essentially a sports bar that serves great pizza and had a great staff that's been clearly trained on customer service. I don't understand the 3 start rating, Everyone was very polite and all had a smile on their face. Did I mention the food was excellent. We will clearly be back if we are in town again. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Goodyear, Arizona

See all

I you like lemon chicken pasta, I recommend the Tuscan chicken with spinach pizza. All the deliciousness of a lemon chicken pasta on a pizza. Leaving the spinach uncooked as a finishing touch added a bit of freshness. We ordered it on the ale crust. The combination worked well. Not being a red sauce, it was a bit oily, but not overly so. Veggie 7 was ordered on their deep dish crust. Old Chicago's deep dish is more like a BJ's Pizza crust than a Lou Malnati's crust. The crust is similar to Detroit style. (Old Chicago does offer a Detroit style crust as well.) Cheese then toppings sit on top of a fluffy crust. Buttery crust had a nice crispness to the bottom. Toppings include artichoke hearts, olives, onions, tomatoes, and peppers. Multiple crust options are available for the majority of their specialty pizzas. Pizzas are only a tip of the iceberg. There is a full menu of non pizza choices. Wings, salads, pastas, fish and chips, fried chicken, burgers and sandwiches help round out the options. There is a "gluten sensitive" section. A children's menu is also available. Service was okay. Our server checked on us before our food arrived, and once more right after it did. No drink refills were offered. By the time our check was brought to our table, three of the four of us were out of drinks. Decor is old meets new. Stonework has an old-world Italian feel. Seating and decor has more of a brewery feel. Indoor and outdoor seating is available. Prices are a bit on the high side. A rewards program includes a free appetizers after making one's first purchase. Points are earned depending on dollars spent. read more

See all

Stopped in to watch the NBA game. Plenty of tv's. Our server as good snd the Chicago 7 thin crust pizza is as delicious. I love as disappointed the bartender would squeeze lines for a skinny margarita and the fried pickles were salty. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Goodyear, Arizona

The food was good. However my burger had no tomato or cheese and yet they charged me 1.50 for a side of mayonnaise?

We go here every Friday night but we missed 10/31 due to Halloween. So we had to get those pepperoni pizza rolls to go! They are so addictive we can't ever get enough of them. The service for to go or dine in is always good and the prices are reasonable for the quality you get. Highly recommend this place! read more

We go to Old Chicago in Goodyear Bi-weekly, we ALWAYS have a great experience and food..Brandy is a great server, always attentive, very friendly and always makes sure everything is good. Jasmine the manager always walks around and talks to all the customers to ensure everything is as advertised. We will definitely be going again soon! read more