Stopped in for 6 bagels and veggie cream cheese. Total was $18.61. New owners recently took over, so good for them. It looks like similar friendly staff. The service was quick since I was getting everything to go. The wait for breakfast sandwiches seemed longer on a busy Sunday morning. The place looks great, new booths and refreshed decor. read more

See all

Best bagels in Swedesboro. Very NY style, still consistently good. They are always friendly and quick with service. Has a very nice charming small town feel. read more

The smiles, warm friendly staff are really attentive to help you select your bagels which are made on site at 5am before opening at 6 am-2pm. Fresh-squeezed OJ is really good. The ambiance is hometown vibes. A must-visit in Swedesboro, NJ! read more

See all

Service was good, but we ordered two everything bagels with cream cheese and they were so salty we could not eat them. I did let them know and they apologized, but it was wasted money, beware! read more

First time trying Old Town and a little disappointed. Ordered a sesame bagel toasted with 2 fried eggs, sausage/ salt and pepper. The sesame bagel wasn't toasted and they added ketchup. I HATE ketchup Also ordered an everything bagel extra toasted with cream cheese, I got an EGG bagel, not toasted. for $18, I'd expect to get what I ordered. lol I understand people made mistakes and I'm sure they would have fixed it, but unfortunately I was headed to NC and checked the bag when I was already 30 mins out. BUT with that said, my daughter said the egg bagel was delicious! read more

I dropped my wallet outside of their store in the parking lot and one of their employees drove it to the police station who in turn, contacted me. This is an amazing experience and gave me more hope in humanity. Please give them your business. read more

Old Town Bagel came highly recommended so of course I had to try it. Located in a strip mall, the interior decor is wonderful displaying old photos of the area. On a Sunday morning they had a great selection of many flavors of bagels. The service was perfect. My only suggestion is toasting the bagel a little longer, mine missed that slight crunch I expected. Maybe next time I'll toast at home. read more

Just another bagel place... very inconsistent with the way things are made. One day pork roll is thin and two pieces, some days it's thick and one. Price is not a deal by any means. It's a shame because it has the potential for greatness but can't compete with a real bagel spot. Bagels are ok.. very comparable to the ShopRite down the road. Again not bad if you want a one step above Wawa and are very easy to please. read more

Went here for the first time searching for a good bagel spot and this place made my day. Got an everything bagel with egg and cheese! It was so delicious comparable to the amazing bagel places I've had up north. The bagel was warm, soft, and the egg was cooked with perfection. Will definitely be coming back! read more

A local spot for good bagels! I was welcomed warmly when I walked in. The smell of bagels was heavenly :) I ordered a bacon, egg and cheese on a garlic bagel. The bagel war toasted and warm. Fluffy on the inside and crunchy on the outside. The sandwich was great! Just wish I had alittle more bagel. If I'm in the area again I would def. Stop by and get more bagels :) read more

Old Town Bagel - Yummm - Bagels Near Me - Swedesboro, New Jersey

See all

This place is just awesome--best bagels in South Jersey! We've been coming here for 5+ years now (so this review is clearly long overdue). Their breakfast sandwiches are incredible! My go-to is the Pork Roll, Egg Whites, & Pepper Jack Cheese on a Toasted & Scooped Egg Bagel with Black Pepper & Ketchup (complicated, but they manage to get it right...deliciously right!). They have a wide array of bagels, deli meats, muffins (Double Chocolate muffin here is amazing!), fresh squeezed orange juice (as in they make it when you order it), coffee, and all the likes. Reasonably priced phenomenal bagel sandwiches...YUM! read more

See all

Bagels are great! I placed a order for delivery but they never got it. It was for the guests of a presentation that was visiting our buisness. Old Town Bagel came thru for me and delivered it their selves. THANK YOU THANK YOU!! Michele read more

My dad absolutely loves the bagels here. I've been coming now and love the train station sandwich. My fiance tried the muffin today and said it was great, had filling too. They even offered to toast/butter it. Gonna try that next time. Service is great, and friendly. Nice chill spot. read more

I came in here after a long run because I needed carbsss and these bagels totally did the trick! I ordered a "half dozen," which is 7 here. The woman sliced each one and threw in a few extra! Sometimes, it's the small things :) The bagels themselves are very fluffy and fresh - I had a pumpernickel one when I got home and it was good! I would definitely come here again. Aside from the food, the staff was very friendly and made the trip worth it! Next time, I will definitely be trying the freshly squeezed orange juice... read more

Old Town Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Swedesboro, New Jersey

See all

Best bagels in south Jersey. I ship bagels to fla, cause my family can't find a bagel as good as Old town bagels in FLA

Overall, it's really good! My only real critique is the stock is unpredictable. Sometimes they're almost sold out by 10am others they're open their full shift. I know that they only have so much control as it depends on how busy they are, but it is unfortunate to go in during hours and there be little to no options. With that being said... the bagel are great quality and delicious. The breakfast sandwiches are huge and filling. The vegetable cream cheese is delicious! I wish there was more though lol read more

Only place to get NY style boiled bagels. The best!!! From NY so know what a perfect bagel tastes like ;). Their bec needs some work though....eggs need to be less fried. Once you try their bagels you will not want to go anywhere else! read more

Great bagel shop with really friendly employees! They have a nice selections of high quality bagels, and it was the first thought a friend and I had for giving friends who are from the South their first real bagels. I don't think either I nor they could have been more impressed! The bagels are quick to come out and are toasted to perfection. They aren't too pricey, and the lines haven't been too long when we went either. DELICIOUS pork bun! The restaurant as suggested to us the first time around, and I can totally see why it was! Would definitely recommend if you're looking for a good bagel (and I'm not even really into bagels)! read more

Old Town Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Swedesboro, New Jersey

Fresh OJ is delicious. Bagel sandwiches were yummy..definitely recommend. Staff was friendly

This place is a joke they are literally out of bagels by 9 o'clock in the morning, what a horrible business plan, and horrible business. Needs new ownership or management someone needs to tell them that breakfast and bagels should not be gone by 9 AM, don't think it's because you're selling so good, it's because you don't make enough. read more

I do love the bagels and especially the scallion cream cheese. But I have to say I am extremely dissatisfied with the service. Their menu says they serve breakfast and lunch all day. It also says they close at 2PM. The last two days they were out of bagels and closed around 10AM. Today they were closed, lights out and employees gone before 10AM. is not uncommon as I have gone other days and they close before lunch time because they are out of bagels. I have difficulty understanding after many years in business why they have not yet decided to make sufficient supply to deliver on their commitment to customers to stay open till 2PM and to serve lunch. I guess this aligns with the fact that no one has claimed this business here on yelp and therefore management does not care to receive nor react to reviews that could make them aware of their shortfalls. Another perspective is they are satisfied with the income they are making and are not interested in making more or keeping their employees working till 2PM to earn wages in these trying times. read more

Old Town Bagel - breakfast and lunch served all day - Bagels Near Me - Swedesboro, New Jersey

Great bagels. They do sell out quickly, but are wonderful about taking phone orders. They had my selected bagels sliced, bagged and waiting for me to pick up! read more

Bagels very good. Friendly staff. When you're the only show in town it's easy to be average but this place is consistently good. Definitely go early on weekends as they sell out. read more

Best damn bagels of all time, it would just be nice if they weren't always sold out, it's a bagel store. How can you be out of bagels? Like literally every single day, you know you're bound to sell out just up production a little bit and, it sucks when I'm like oh the bagel store closes at two and I roll up at 10:30 and you guys are out of bagels and you have a come back tomorrow sign it's pretty depressing and like at the very least just make more of the big sellers a special place is great, but it closes like three hours early every day read more

Best bagel shop in South Jersey. My only complaint is that they run out of everything bagels quickly on weekend mornings if you don't go early enough. Pork roll egg and cheese on an everything bagel has become a favorite. read more

I'm not really sure what's happened to old town but service has fallen off. All things considered with covid, the last 3-4 times we have been there our order is ALWAYS wrong. Last time our entire bagel order was wrong and they forgot my wees sandwich and this time it was not just a little wrong, the entire order was wrong. This last trip was our last one. We ordered a dozen bagels, 2 bagel sandwiches and 2 cream cheeses. Typically when they are out of something they'll tell us when you call in and one of the sandwiches we ordered they said the type of bagel and cream cheese was out, so we changed to a different type. The other sandwich was a bacon egg and cheese on an egg bagel, can't screw that up right? I get the order and immediately check because they've been missing stuff consistently. Missing the second sandwich that was just a toasted bagel and cream cheese. I go back and tell them I'm missing it, customer service person looks at the receipt and shows its not listed (but I sat next to my wife and listened to her order it), as they tell me we didnt order it. I get home and my wife points out the entire bagel order is wrong and we were shorted 2 bagels (again, last time they only gave us 10 as well). I opened my basic bacon egg and cheese on an egg bagel, and it was pork roll with a different cheese and bagel. Best of all, the toasted bagel with cream cheese I had to reorder was wrong. They didn't toast it. I stood right in front of them and ordered it, they wrote it down and still got it wrong. It's a shame because the bagels are excellent and the food is great but after several trips and incorrect orders, it's become a job to have to check every order and return (sometimes) when my order is wrong because now it's a given. I understand with covid the take out volume has increased but this service issue started prior to covid and has progressively got worse. I'll give it another try later this year and hopefully it's improved read more

I stopped in here to grab a quick bite on the way to the beach and what a great choice! Very tasty!

Old Time Bagel is one of my favorite bagel places! Friendly staff! Great place to call ahead early in the morning and get a fresh bagel with egg and any meat as a topping! read more

Best bagels I've had since leaving New York. The cream cheese is amazing you just need to get there early before they sell out. You must try the veggie cream cheese. They're not cheap but it's worth it. Buy a bunch and freeze them. read more

Ok it's 6:38AM... I was going to waIt to review this place when I got hOmE from work but I couldn't wait. I pass this place all the time on my way to jobs and never stopped. Today i was early and said let me grab a bagel for me and my co-worker. Best decision I have made in a while. These bagels were literally the BEST I have had in Philadelphia/ South Jersey. Growing up in NYC/ North Jersey bagels I am hard to please and these were unreal. I swear if you sold these in Staten Island people wouldn't kNow they were made in south jersey.. the vegetable cream cheese was so good and freSh it tasted like they just made it tO order. The bagels were perfectly seasoned, crispy on the outside and soft when you bit it. The ladies at the front desk were really nice and friendly too. You could tell they love what they do and we're just happy that early in the morning. I will definitely be back... probably tomorrow . A must have. read more

Old Town Bagel - Everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Swedesboro, New Jersey

See all

So convenient to have bagels delivered! My order came faster than expected (less than 30 minutes!) and everything turned out great! I did expect the bagels to be warmed/toasted, but not a huge deal. They were still delicious! We tried the chocolate chip bagel and the plain bagels with plain cream cheese, and I can't wait to try a different kind next time! read more

It's a good bagel as long as you call them place an order and then continually call and remind them about the order otherwise all they say to you is I'm sorry. Go find another bagel place it'll be worth your time. They have changed what a shame. Never again. read more

Gotta say I really wish a solid bagel shop was easier to find. Last two times I went in around 9/9:30 they had only 3 varieties, both times I left. Never in my life would I have thought I'd go to Dunkin to get a half dozen bagels, it was a sad day needless to say. And today this was the condition of the bagels we got. I've seen less mutated things come out of a nuclear plant. Honestly painful that a half decent bagel/shop is hard to find. read more

Old Town Bagel - three bagels on a cutting board - Bagels Near Me - Swedesboro, New Jersey

I had the bagel and lox sandwich. The smoked salmon was good. the cream cheese was decent with fresh vegetables and capers. read more

I am from NY and these are the first bagel that tastes anything like a real bagel since I moved out to Philadelphia area. Awesome bagels!!

good spot for bagels, breakfast is good, service also solid. Veggie cream cheese is a must if you pick up. Lunch sandwiches are not bad as well read more

I can't believe we lived right down the street and haven't stopped in until now. I guess from the outside, it doesn't look like more than a little bakery. Inside there are lots of seats, it's clean and nicely decorated. The bagels are great, but what is awesome about this place is the quality of everything they make. The egg on the sandwiches are made to order, not pre made like most places. Lunch is great too! They use good quality lunch meat and have an excellent variety. Staff is friendly, helpful and fast. read more

Typically, I love this place. We've gotten breakfast sandwiches here a million times. Today I pulled plastic out of my 2yo's mouth while she was eating ham and cheese on an onion bagel. Plastic! And no, it's not a casing. It's plastic. Get it together Old Town Bagel! You are slipping. read more

Old Town Bagel - a broken bagel on a table - Bagels Near Me - Swedesboro, New Jersey

This is our favorite breakfast spot. The staff know us by name and we love the friendly atmosphere, bagel sandwiches, fresh squeezed OJ, chocolate cinnamon-y muffins, and selection of coffees. Even a standard toasted bagel with butter is delicious. Toasty warm in there on a freezing cold day, love this sunny spot! read more

Bagels are better than anywhere else around. Add breakfast sandwich stuff to one and your morning is complete. Great selection of bagel flavors, nice little shop. Only problem is the hours, i can never make it there in time. But when i do, its a treat. Really enjoy them. Nice service, and all around a nice place. read more