Life is too short, sample everything! I love how they offer samples of all their honeys, oils, and…read morevinegars. They had a good number of different honeys, however, the number of different oils and vinegars was much more impressive. Yes, you can try them all (with or without bread). I landed on the caramelized onion balsamic ftw. HBU?

I loved this store. If you love olive oils and vinegars this is your spot. You can sample any of…read morethe oils and vinegars. I wish I remembered the ladies name who helped us. She was quite the character. Every combo we tried she tried also, lol. They even have a pamphlet to tell you which oil and vinegars go together. Funny coasters and bags and lots of other cute stuff to choose from.

I enjoy stopping in to check out local olive oil shops and this one was great…read more With so many bottles everywhere I didn't know where to begin, but Tommy a store associate was super helpful. He gave me and my sister the run down of each section. He went over the different types of olive oils and made sure we knew to sample those we wanted to try. I sampled several different flavors, but I made a purchase of the Harissa olive oil since I was completely out of the one I had from a different company. At the time of my visit there was only one other person browsing around. Then after my sister and I arrived, a few more people came it. It was quiet with low music playing in the background. It was a really great first experience thanks to Tommy.

I'm always on the hunt for the perfect VOO with lemon that doesn't leave a funky after taste. While…read moreon vacation we stumbled on this amazing store. The gentleman working was so nice and knowledgeable. So many great oils and balsamic vinegars. The lemon infused oil and Sicilian white balsamic are AMAZING!! Made pasta and added both. Just put in another order for a gift

Verde Valley Olive Oil Traders is the reason I make the drive from Phoenix to Cottonwood and…read morehonestly, it's worth every mile. This shop is one of those rare places where you walk in and immediately feel like you've stepped into a little world of flavor, warmth, and genuine hospitality. The moment you enter, you're greeted with that bright, fragrant mix of fresh olive oils and balsamic vinegars that makes you want to taste everything. The store is beautifully organized, spotless, and full of small-batch, high‑quality oils and vinegars, if I remember correctly locally sourced. What really makes this place special is the experience. The staff is always incredibly friendly, knowledgeable, and excited to guide you through tastings. They explain the layout, offer thoughtful suggestions, and help you discover combinations you never would've thought to try. It's educational without ever feeling pretentious, just fun, flavorful, and welcoming. Every visit, I end up finding a new favorite. Whether it's a bright citrus‑infused olive oil, a rich aged balsamic, or something seasonal and surprising, the quality is consistently top‑tier. Cottonwood has a gem here, and I'll keep coming back as long as they keep doing what they do best: offering incredible products with even better service.

I love olive oil stores, and it's great fun to sample the oils and the flavored vinegars, but this…read moreis the first store where we got to talk to a salesman who is also a chef. He was able to recommend different pairings, tell us where each oil was from, and talk to us about cooking with olive oil and vinegar. We had waited for the store to open in the morning before continuing our journey north, and I'm glad we did. We'll visit this one again and order from them online. They're delightful.

Free olive oil & basaltic vinegar tasting! They can ship it to your home, and the staff is very…read morehelpful. We learned so much at this store! I'd highly recommend stopping in if your waiting to eat at Haunted hamburger.

We stopped here on a day where it was threatening rain and we wanted to take a little break from…read morethe heat and humidity. We climbed several of the Jerome stairs to get to the upper town level where the shop is located. They have a wide variety of olive oils and balsamic vinegars with many unique flavors. We told Bob which ones we'd like to try and he gave us mini tastings of those. Then he put together some combinations for us to try. Everything was so good, it was hard to choose what we wanted to purchase. We ended up with Tuscan Herb Olive Oil and Neapolitan Herb Vinegar. The combination of those two will be so delicious as a marinade for meat, a salad dressing, or sprinkled over pasta or vegetables.

Rafter Eleven has a wonderful atmosphere, both inside and out. Good coffee and friendly staff. Have…read morebeen back several times and it's been consistently good.

A nice quiet place for lunch or just coffee. Their pastries according to my husband are fantastic…read more If they had a couple of gluten free sandwiches or gluten free bread substitute they'd get another star. I know many folks have asked if they had gluten free items besides a salad

This is not a restaurant but a store that sells olives, different kinds of olive oils and balsamic…read morevinegars that are aged 18 years. I bought the Tuscan herb olive oil and traditional balsamic vinegar. The taste is divine. Also, the lady was so helpful with introducing us to the pairing of olive oils and the balsamic vinegar. If it wasn't for her I probably wouldn't have bought anything. Great store overall. Definitely suggest this place!

Really amazing store! Wonderful assortment of olive oils and vinegars. They also carry olive based…read moreskin care items, pastas from Italy, sauces and condiments. We restocked our olive oil and vinegar bar, and picked up a couple cute gifts. Great customer service!

Food was good. Service was stale. The staff did not even smile at us until we left. I asked to…read moresample the pastrami prior to ordering a $22 sandwich-nope they don't do that. I asked for a side of BBQ sauce-that will be an extra $0.75. Really?! Ma'am I just spent $100 for 5 sandwiches a splash of sauce is not the big of an ask.

Housemade pastrami? Corned beef? Porchetta? Yes please! Proper Meats + Provisions seemed like the…read morebest place in town to eat a sandwich lunch between NPS site visits around Flagstaff. We popped in on a Monday morning hoping to score some great grub and we certainly found some! Cubano ($20.95) - Starting with the bread - it's really fluffy, not toasted or pressed as with usual cubanos. Unfortunately, it's probably a little too light for the sandwich because some parts get mushy from being soaked in all the dijonnaise. The dijonnaise is very sweet, creamy with a mustardy zing. I think they add a bit too much, making the sandwich more fatty and messy to eat than I like (not to mention what I stated before about it soaking into the bread). The meat is fantastic. Both porchetta and ham are griddled on the flat top, giving them a developed and concentrated edge. The ham is to the point of being like country ham, while the porchetta still has great seasoned porky flavor. I believe they griddle the swiss cheese alongside the meat. It melts and crisps up into a cheese skirt, adding a fantastic texture to the sandwich. There's a lot of crinkle cut pickles underneath the meat, but it's not enough acid to cut through all that fat. Sandwiches come with a side of house chips. They are fried until a darker golden brown color, but aren't burnt. This gives a great kettle chip-like crunch. Even with different sized chips, they are very evenly fried with all chips being the same texture. They are salted the perfect amount. (4/5) Aleppo Pepper Pastrami sub Tomato Soup ($22.75) - This place is famous for their pastrami, and I can tell the quality. It's cooked on the griddle until it develops crisp edges. It's fatty, but the fat is rendered so there are no chewy and leathery parts. The meat is extremely tender and thinly sliced. It's honestly almost like bacon in texture, but the taste is completely different, with the exterior spices and pepper making a huge impact along with the rich concentrated meatiness inside. The bread is a nice toasted sourdough, not strongly sour in flavor, but definitely noticeable. The bottom slice is slathered with plenty of nopales studded cream cheese. It's added in a large amount and is an extremely creamy and fatty substance yet somehow doesn't overwhelm the sandwich. It's warm but not melty. The nopales are clearly there but I didn't find it to contribute much. The pastrami is layered on top of that followed by a ton of sweet brown caramelized onions that are very tender. An entire green chile, roasted and super smoky, is above that. Finally, aleppo mustard is spread on the top slice of bread. Between the green chile and the aleppo, there's a slight warmth that tinges the sandwich. It's nothing too spicy. Instead of chips, we opted to sub the Tomato Soup (no fee). It's very homestyle, full of tomato richness in a thick blend. It has a strong tangy tomato essence. There's basil oil drizzled on top for a boost of freshness. The soup is unfortunately quite a bit too acidic for my tastes, but that's only by itself! While very acidic, the soup is actually great as a balance to the sandwich (along with the pickle of course) since there's so much richness and fat coming in between the bread. (5/5) Proper Meats + Provisions definitely serves some great sandwiches. We were considering visiting again for our 2 full days in Flagstaff, but weren't able to make it because they close so early at 6! Bathrooms - Two unisex rooms Note: Proper Meats charges a 3% credit card fee. This is labeled on the menu

Such a cute shop with a great variety of loose teas, jams, honey and chocolate. There's a bunch to…read morebrowse and I loved the iced tea sample-so refreshing. Also grabbed a Hammond dark chocolate to take home as a treat. Great friendly customer service!

I am out of state and my dad had purchased a jalapeño chocolate bar that he absolutely LOVED. I…read morewanted to get him some more for Christmas but the website did not have it available. I called the store and asked if they were seasonal and maybe thinking they were just out of stock but the INCREDIBLY kind young lady offered to look for them, not only did she find them, she offered to specially ship them to me! Incredible service, super kind and I had 0 expectation that this was even possible. She really went above and beyond and that kind of service is so rare! I really appreciate great service and I regret I did not grab her name but thank you!! It made for the most thoughtful Christmas gift and I am super excited to give it to my dad.

I was here a few days ago and had incredible service and amazing food!…read more Our server Henry really was the nicest sweetest guy ever, he was very friendly as a server should be. We got the Belgio Dolce Pizza as recommend and I really can see why it was a 3rd place winner. Super unique pizza and incredible service made for such a perfect date night, I will be coming back when i'm in flagstaff!

Came in for lunch...also this is famous for being on DDD with Guy Fieri…read more Decor - Very cool inside with seats at kitchen and a separate bar area. Food- Pepperoni Pizza with fennel sausage. $16 + $3 for the small amount of fennel sausage. It was great but not worth the xtra $3. - Pizza crust was amazing and the entire pizza was delicious. - Spaghetti & meatballs $14.50 with a small salad. Way too much sauce but the meatballs were good. Wouldn't get it again. - Overall good service and glad we finally made it here. I like how they have a section on the menu, "what Guy ate". They probably got tired of people asking. CON - The "Flagstaff Service Charge" of 4% is total bullsh*t!

Food was really good, only issue was how fast we got our food. Maybe just a bad night for kitchen…read morebut for us and other tables around us also were experiencing the same issue. Took about 45 minutes to get our main courses after ordering.

We have been to Nic's many times and this time really left a bad taste in our mouths. We were…read morecharged $18 for generic Long Islands (hold your judgement) and when we inquired why they were so much compared to last time ($11 and rung up as Long Island vs Special Drink) we were told they only have premium alcohol now no well and thats why it was so high in price and they have been that way for 2 1/2 years. BS we were here about 9 months ago and they were not this price. Inquire about any drink not listed as they seem to charge whatever. Business will shift somewhere else.