The Buffalo Chicken pizza at Olivetto's is something to behold! I have been able to detect the use of duck sauce in the seasoning, and it kicks this whole flavor experience up 100 notches! It's definitely a knife-and-fork affair, though, as picking the slice up off the plate may cause you to lose some of the enormous amount of chicken that is provided. Unfortunately, I can't vouch for any other slice in this place because I only get the Buffalo here. It's THAT GOOD!! read more

Ordered 6 pies for a school party for 12:30 the pizzas didn't arrive til 1:05 totally ridiculous, and the pies were awful. Save yourself the stress and order from Cinellis, fast, reliable, and great fresh food! read more

Delicious. Great service by our waiter, Elvis. Lunch special! We all enjoyed! Others ordered spaghetti with clam sauce, Caesar salad and minestrone! read more

See all

I love Olivettos been there a few times now and everything I had was phenomenal. My absolute favorite is the pasta with the garlic and oil. It is the best garlic and oil I've ever had in 43 years. How they get that flavor is absolutely incredible. No matter how many times I tried at home you can't get that amazing flavor that this has. It's a must try next time you go read more

After an adventure on the LIRR, I decided to stop into Olivetto Pizza, and I'm so glad I did. I ordered the chicken, bacon, and ranch slice, and it hit the spot on a perfectly crispy, great flavor, and generous toppings without being too heavy. The quality of care was pleasantly nice. The staff was super friendly from the moment I walked in. Even though they were busy, they were patient, welcoming, and quick with the service. The place itself is also impressively clean, the tables, counters, even the floor looked well taken care of, which I really appreciate in a pizza spot. All in all, a great stop after an adventure. I'd definitely come back and would recommend Olivetto Pizza to anyone looking for a solid, satisfying slice. read more

Just bought a few slices to take home because it's tough parking at our go to King Umbertos. One of the most disgusting pieces of pizza I ever had. It didn't even look like it should have- maybe something they would make in Alabama or Mississippi. Never ever again, one star is too many. read more

One of the best regular slices and buffalo chicken I've had in a very long time. The crust is thin and crispy and not like any other pizzeria. They also have a party room can't wait to go back and try the rest of their Pizza highly recommended. read more

Olivetto Pizzeria - Regular slice of buffalo chicken with a delicious crust - Italian Near Me - Franklin Square, New York

My boyfriend and I love coming here when we're craving Italian food. The penne a la vodka is pretty good. The fried calamari is delicious. The chicken franchese is really good. The chicken parm is good. The shrimp scampi was amazing. But there was a pasta dish with mixed vegetable that was not so good. The customer service is either really good or terrible depending on the person you get as your waiter/waitress. The prices are fair though and the food is good. read more

See all

Olivetto's Pizza is delicious! Great Italian food and pizza, perfect for a family dinner. Cozy atmosphere and tasty dishes make it a local favorite. read more

I recently had their chicken marsala pizza. It was outstanding. I ordered the 12 inch pie and I couldn't finish it at one seating. If you like chicken marsala, I highly recommend this tasty treat. read more

I recently made Olivetto's my go to pizzeria ordering from them weekly and my wife and kids were eating there for pasta night while I worked. My most recent experience with them however was just frustrating and them hanging up the phone on me for their mistaken miscommunication was so aggravating, I'm going out of my way to write a review on Yelp. Long story short, I ordered on Slice at 9:16PM a $46 order. At 9:28PM I got a message saying order is delayed and they will update soon. At 9:31PM I got a message that the restaurant was closed and the order was canceled (My money was still gone, but that's not Olivetto's fault). I called at 9:40PM and they told me that my order has actually been sent out and that Slice was wrong. We even discussed the details of the order and I was told my order will be there soon. I said great, cause I was willing to go pick it up if not. Needless to say, 9:55PM rolls by, no delivery and I know they close at 10PM so I call again feeling bad about bothering them. First I get told that it is still on the way, then they hand me off to someone else who gets on the phone only to tell me that they had told Slice that my food wasn't coming, then say that they thought it was a part of 7 orders the driver left with but it wasn't. Confused, I simply asked "So then I'm just not getting any food?" and whoever it was, just shut the phone down. Flat out hung it up. I understand things get busy and I understand it was close to the end of the night, but the whole problem started with your (Olivetto's) miscommunication and how it was handled is deserving of a 1-star review across all platforms. This is a town of great pizzerias with great customer service and, to me, you are no longer one of them. read more

Olivetto Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Franklin Square, New York

1.5 for a delivery of 1 grandma pie, pizza was barely warm, asked for plates and cups and received nothing , never order from this place

Came here with a group of about 20 people for a price fixed 3 course lunch. I'm not sure how much it cost because someone else picked up the tab. The food was very good though. You had a choice of limited items. I started with a house salad that was flavorful but definitely on the small side. Then came the rigatoni marinara which was accompanied with garlic knots and focaccia bread that was excellent. The sauce was made right by someone who has probably been doing it for many years. Also ordered the chicken marsala as my main course and was very happy with it. I will say though, the waitress and staff made the dining experience very enjoyable. Everyone was very attentive and super pleasant. I certainly wouldn't mind going back to try a few other menu items. read more

Service and the food was great! The smaller room in Olivetto was so nice and comfortable! read more

Good food nice staff. Pleasant dining area. Good calamari & chicken parm. Would go again read more

Olivetto is always my go to. The lasagna, manicotti, ravioli, and fettuccini are delicious. The waiters are the kindest people you'll ever meet! The place is always clean and has a nice ambiance to it. 100% recommended. read more

I love going to this place with my family. Good drinks , good food, the service is great and the ambiance is just right. read more

I went for a dinner on a Tuesday evening hardly no one was in the restaurant. I ordered a Lasagna and my husband ordered Eggplant Parmesan. The eggplant was horrible and looked like it was just lying there ... dried out not appealing terrible. We should have complained but regretted not complaining when we got home. The waiter was nice enough but he should have not served us that ... i gave him 20%. Who should be responsible for this? I think the owner should give me a credit of $12 for the eggplant parm sandwich! You don't serve paying customers that crap! I still have it saved in my refrigerator that is the half we took home. You don't need ambiance when the food is that bad. Also the Lasagna wasn't that fresh either probably was frozen and reheated! The owner should rethink what he's serving to the customer before he forced to close down! Disgruntled customer! read more

Been going here for years. Never a problem. Tonight get 2 heroes to go, 1 a shrimp parm. Get home the shrimp parm literally had cleaning fluid mixed in. Probably spilt. The party eating it spits it out. I smell it can't smell. Take a bite and it's disgusting. Call up restaurant tell them at first I say just make another one. It's late she's hungry. While driving there she texts and said forget the other sandwich. I get to restaurant and tell them. Counter person very nice I think the manager comes over I tell him he smells it I said you have to take a bite. He says he will send to back to investigate further. I guess they have a lab. He says we can't refund on card. Never heard that before. Then he says credit for next time I said ok. He says 25 good I said absolutely not. You put poisin in the food. I drove back and forth twice He says that's double. Really I paid 34.68 for 2 sandwiches. He says what do you expect a hundred bucks . I said forget it and walked out. Sorry but never again. Move on folks. read more

Very disappointed. The last time I ordered for pickup, they forgot my chicken roll. I called and they said they would put a credit on my account. Yesterday, I called to place an order, and told them about this and the girl on the phone said there was nothing on my account so she could not do anything. Very poor customer service. read more

This is my second time ordering from this place .first time the item I ordered was great. However they forgot to bring the bread. I re-order the same item yesterday and had a terrible experience. It is the hot anti-pasta . It was very dry. No flavor at all. Plus they did not send the bread . This is not a cheap dish I am a senior only cost me $17. It seems the dish was prepared . And been sitting a long time waiting for delivery. Because when I opened the dish It was not what I expected. There was no sauce the sauce was stick together and they were no parsley usually they put fresh parsley over it. I just picked on it and the rest went to garbage. Bottom line senior just lost $17 I'm not going to order from this place any longer they have a lot of other places to do a good job plus they charge you a service fee deliver free and a fee if use the credit card a credit. card read more

We went thete for the 1st time. Everyone is very friendly and accomadating. The food was cooked perfect, and very tasteful. O had yhe eggplant rolliniti as my main dish. Brought home the left overs, my kids loved it as well. We will be back read more

It seems to be the best option if this is your local spot other than that, I think I failed to bring my mother a few towns over, I was expecting more but got satisfactory linguine plum sauce fried Koler cooked perfection was decent. My daughter likes the slice but she's also nine years old. What does she know? Take my review for what it is and always try and have a good experience when you're out to eat laugh a little, even if the food is bad in this case, it was not, just nothing to brag about I think they could do better read more

Was passing by and decided to stop in, as per the reviews. Tale of the tape: Garlic Knots When I first saw them, I was intrigued... The outer shell has a soft, almost flaky crisp, reminiscent of a crescent roll, with a decent garlic flavor. However under this cover is a heavy, doughy denseness that belies its outer shell. My disappointment was palpable as I consumed the outer part of the knots with gusto, leaving the inexplicably doughy insides. I will bake them up to see if they metamorphose into something resembling the outside's texture. If the inside had matched the outside, these knots would easily had been in my Garlic Knot Top Ten. Penne alla Vodka slice The ratio of sauce to pasta to cheese is just right, and the vodka sauce itself is good. It's not very good, or even great, but it does merit a good rating. The crust, however... the crust is where it shines. Thin and crispy with a lightness that stands in marked contrast to the innate heaviness of the pasta and sauce. One of the best crusts out there, no question! The combination of it all made for an enjoyable taste experience. Conclusion I would definitely go back to sample more of their fare if I'm in the neighborhood. read more

Olivetto Pizzeria - Garlic Knots - the outside is really good, but the inside... - Italian Near Me - Franklin Square, New York

See all

This is a great local pizzeria spot that I feel is highly underrated. They offer a wide array of pizza, and Italian dishes for very fair prices. I love their traditional pie. There is always a great cheese to sauce ratio, and the crust is cooked to perfection every time I have it. I also like the fact that the crust is not extremely thick like other places. I have only ordered take-out, but I do look forward to sitting in their restaurant section soon, one night for dinner. Customer service is always great, and my order is always completed quickly. I have not had any negative experiences thus far. They are located in the King Kullen shopping center where there is ample parking. Definitely check them out if in the area, they will not disappoint! read more

I order frequently and the food is good yet the level of service is not at par as we expect for a local family Italian pizzeria. The person taking order is outright rude ...makes you want to order somewhere else so you don't have the attitude that comes along. read more

Olivetti was our go to restaurant for years. Usually delivery service. Lately the pizza and entrees have been disappointing but today I gave it one last try. Unfortunately we were disappointed again penne pesto tastes like it came from a jar and was very oily. Rigatoni bolognese was watery no flavor and could hardly find the meat. Sadly we won't be ordering in the future. read more

This place is new to me, and so far, everything is delicious. The chicken Francese is hands down their best dish, but I keep coming back to their house salad with grilled chicken. The grilled chicken is very tasty, I must learn how they cook it. read more

Amazing food. Amazing pizza. Best vodka sauce and fresh moZz sticks. Also great chicken rollitini. Fantastic meal read more

So this Pizzaria is in a strip mall (Franklin Plaza). Which basically means that it doesn't have to be good because people will grab a quick bite to eat while shopping and running errands. It's also a place where your less-discerning locals - of which there are apparently many - will get pizza delivered from on the weekends. Their regular slices are okay at best (better than frozen pizza I guess). But their specialty slices are exceptionally bad. For example; their buffalo chicken slices are prepared with blue cheese dripped across the slices - weather you want blue cheese or not. Their "salad" slices are always soggy and stale-tasting. I ordered a specialty slice with spinach, onions and mushrooms. Sounds simple enough right? Not at Olivetto's. Instead of getting the onions chopped up, they were draped in big circles over the slice(s). And the mushrooms weren't the small squishy mushrooms that I've had on slices of pizza in New York since I started having specialty slices, but raw mushrooms you'd have in a salad. When I showed them the slices and told them what the problem was - they had zero idea what I was talking about and there was zero recognition of any problem. In short, go to Gallery Pizza just down the road, or Carmela's also in the area. Don't waste your money. read more

Olivetto Pizzeria - a slice of pizza with mushrooms and onions - Italian Near Me - Franklin Square, New York

See all

The workers at Olivetto are always kind and generous. My family and I always get the food in a reasonable amount of time. I love the food i get 99/100. The restaurant is clean and sanitary, an important part of the dining experience. Thank you read more

Olivetto Pizzeria - Spaghetti and meatballs - Italian Near Me - Franklin Square, New York

My family lived in the area for 60+ years and my 95 year old mother loved going there for lunch. As soon as she came in they knew her and what she wanted and always showed her respect and love. Mom passed away in Aug 2023 but we will always remember olivettos with fondness read more

I don't know how, but this Pizzeria/restaurant has become our go to spot. The pizza is solid, but the food is better than one might expect. Their Penne a la Vodka sauce is like no other. It's a more cream based sauce that's just absolutely addicting. We have ordered it for dinner and even catered events and everyone has loved it. They've expanded the restaurant side recently, so I assume many others have noticed their quality too. Definitely a place worth checking out. read more

Can't believe how expensive this place is and the food is not even good, flavorless, I was ripped off with a horrible check close to a thousand in what it was supposed to be a nice dinner night with my family and not happy with that they even messed up the checks and charged me for other table as well on my credit card. Never ever going place to this place. Be aware, you can go to any other place and pay less than half and eat at least good food. read more

First time here! I came for pick up! A narrow entry way leads to a nice size dining area. All the food looks great!! Place was busy ;) lots of diners and pick ups! My order was on time! Transaction was a breeze. Walked away with a cheese pie and a pepperoni pie. Both delicious! Sauce was nicely seasoned. Would try again! read more

See all

My family and I come here every couple of weeks. My favorite dishes are the shrimp oreganato, the eggplant rollatini and the hot antipasto for 2 (makes a great entree). it is. great go to place. nicest and extremely competent staff ever. read more

Nice variety. Good pricing. Good food. The new addition makes it so much easier to get a table.

Small Pizzeria & Casual Italian Restaurant that offers a nice Tuesday dinner special. A friend and I both enjoyed this. For about $17 you get a salad or side of pasta, a bread bowl for the table and a extensive choice of chicken entree and dessert plus coffee or tea. I went with "Chicken Matteo" (oddly the name of another wonderful Italian restaurant). Grilled chicken with grilled Eggplant, Grilled Zucchini a Little Cheese and Tomato Sauce. Tasty. The cheesecake was factory fresh but that's what I expected. Haven't tried the pizza here yet but I'll get around to it. read more

Olivetto Pizzeria - Chicken "Matteo" - Grilled seasoned breast, grilled zucchini and eggplant topped with some mozzarella and lightly sauced. - Italian Near Me - Franklin Square, New York

I've been coming here since they opened. They are the only place around here that has a really great chicken franchese slice, so it's my go to. It's also my families go to pizza place when we order in. Very friendly staff as well! read more

My Christmas Eve order was beyond the BEST ! Anthony calls the day after Christmas just to make sure I was happy with how everything came out . Who does that any more ??? Fast lunch with my husband on a Saturday and the calamari is cooked to perfection along with my baked clams ... fresh , just the way I like it ... Don't walk but run in and have a slice of the best pizza.... You will be back ... I promise ! read more