Service was mid. The waitress didn't seem to know the dishes well enough to answer our questions, and she took forever to check on us, refill our water glasses, and bring us the check. The decor is cute - very colorful and fun. Food was okay. I had chicken quesadillas since I wasn't that hungry, but I found it really salty. read more

What a find! I was invited to a tequila tasting and I wasn't sure what to expect. The owner, Omar, was amazing and had us try some fantastic tequilas. He gave us the history of each bottle and answered all of our questions. We had several appetizers and each was amazing! The best Mexican food I have had outside of my go to spot in Harlem. I will definitely be coming back with my family. I highly recommend this hidden gem. read more

Omar's Pueblo Viejo - Mexican Near Me - Carmel, New York

I love the ambiance feel when you walk in the restaurant. Colorful, energetic and friendly staff. HUGE selection of Tequila the owner Omar is passionate and knowledgeable tequilas. Came in on a Taco Tuesday got the special Tacos for my hubby and I got Shrimp tacos both with soft tortillas. Chips / Salsa and I added Guacamole spicy. Chips came in nice, warm, and thin crunch. Soo good! Tacos were fills up with meat, lettuce cheese and salsa on top. Nicely lay in the plate so its easy to grab. Its a really odd location but they have been establish for years. Locals come here for good food. Omar has the widest variety of Tequilas. Go at the bar and Omar will show you his best And Exceptional bottles. read more

See all

Walked in by chance, and so glad we did! Excellent food & drinks. Super friendly staff! Place was clean & authentic

Visited Easter weekend for a birthday get together. I did like it, just not absolutely loved it. The place is nice and the staff was both friendly and helpful. The meal was gopd but a bit overcooked. Not bad just not good enough for a forth star. Plenty of parking and the bathroom were clean. Overall i would come back. read more

Omar's Pueblo Viejo - Steak and lobster - Mexican Near Me - Carmel, New York

Welcome to Omar's paradise! Let's start with a tequila selection that I never knew I needed. Food is tasty and delicious. Great combination of a great host paired with good food and great drinks! read more

Omar's Pueblo Viejo - Mexican Near Me - Carmel, New York

See all

Omar is the ultimate host with the most impressive tequila selection I've ever laid eyes on. read more

Omar's Pueblo Viejo - Mexican Near Me - Carmel, New York

See all

The selection of tequilas is amazing, owner is super friendly and outgoing, have been there twice and had a great time on each occasion

My local goto spot, for a nice sit down dinner. The place has gotten better over the years. It's a very cool experience with dishes that they will prepare infront of you at the table side. Also fun place to bring someone on their birthday. The interior is very unique & colorful. The staff always has bright smiles & is very helpful. read more

Do not go here , total rip-off , they charged me $18 bucks for a lemonade and two " cappuccino" when i said something the manger or whoever he was got smart with me ! read more

Great Authentic Mexican food and Tequila! The service was exceptional. Omar is a great host.

We came for graduation party with 30+ guests and really enjoyed ourselves! The ambiance was festive, the music was good and it was a buffet style with chips/guac/salads at the tables. There was a spread of fruit, salad, rice and peas, refried beans, chicken and steak enchiladas and fajitas. The sangria and the margaritas were a hit! Another thing - They do have a changing table in the women's bathroom which is something I look for as a mother. read more

Omar's Pueblo Viejo - Mexican Near Me - Carmel, New York

See all

Is a nice very colorful restaurant people are nice ambiance is good service was good as well good presentation it was a Friday so they had a person play a guitar music was soothing food was delicious a place I try again read more

See all

Stopped by on a Friday night. Seemed pretty busy but no wait to sit down. Salsa was good, and they gave refried beans with the chips too. My coconut margarita was good. Entree portions were large and food was tasty. I liked the salsa sampler they gave me with my entree to add extra spice to the dish. Service was a little slow when trying to get a check. Prices were fair too. Nice spot for a quick bite. read more

I recently ate here with a friend for lunch. The food is AhMazing!! I had the Enchiladas de Mole. She had Quesadillas they were cut into little pieces. I honestly forget the name of her order but she loved it as well. The chips and salsa are so delicious too. Fresh and tasty! I will definitely be back! read more

Omar's Pueblo Viejo - Mexican Near Me - Carmel, New York

See all

Where do I even begin? I've been here a few times because it's close to home and I love Mexican food. The drinks are great. Haven't had a bad margarita from there yet, but the food ... ordered the salmon topped with shrimp both the salmon and the shrimp were overcooked. Ate at the bar and The manager there clearly had his favorite customers and treats them like royalty, but was not attentive at all to me and my guest. But the worst of it is that I had gotten takeout from there about a year ago and found an extremely long hair in my appetizer ! Threw the entire order out! Will never go back there. There are much better places in Mahopac. read more

First time at Pueblo Viejo in many years. It's under new ownership and the new food is delicious! We started with the Cadillac Margaritas and the table side guacamole. The tortilla chips were warm and crunchy, the guacamole was very good. Then we had the shrimp cerviche which was very good I just wish there was more shrimp I believe there was only 3 medium sized shrimp on the plate. There should be 6 that would give a couple Sharing it 3 shrimps each. Then we split the red snapper special. Wow! I am still thinking about it today, it was crunchy, flavorful and so fresh. The side of rice and beans and guacamole for the meal were so good too. Everything tasted fresh. The owner Omar was behind the bar serving drinks he was very nice and welcoming. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Update: I have diarrhea now Not busy at all yet the food took 30mins to come out. Asked for well done got medium rare. The food was not good. Ordered a meal that came with steak shrimp and chicken. The steak after being cooked was good and juicy. Everything else after that was not good at all. For it being so expensive it's a big waste of money. read more

We had such a great experience with this restaurant! We have been here a few times in the past and the food and service is always fantastic. The staff are always so kind and very attentive. I love their new tablet menus with pictures of all their delicious foods as well! My monster of a two year old ate EVERYTHING they made and the staff were very playful with him. Highly recommend for a great dinning experience read more

We got here at about 6:45 on a Wednesday evening. Live music playing (too loudly but nice music) and the place was pretty empty. Three tables and about 12 people total. It took about 8 minutes to get drinks. Should have been a warning. Chips and salsa were very good. We had two servings and could have had two more on the time we waited for our food. They took our order probably about 15 minutes after we were seated By 7:20, the place was getting busy but we still didn't get our food. I called the server over and they said it was coming out soon. I decided that I would wait 15 minutes and if we didn't get service, we would leave money for our drinks and salsa and leave. After 15 minutes, I attempted to make eye contact with the server and he ignored us. I got up, took my wallet out and took cash out and put it on the table and walked out. While walking out, the original server and two other staff members watched me but didn't say anything so we left. read more

We started out with well made Margaritas. The chips , salsa and refried beans were flavorful and a nice touch. The waiter took our food order and drink order together. The drinks came right away. The food took forever to arrive. Unfortunately the waiter didn't check in with us until he delivered the food . I had Chicken Fajita and my wife had Chili Relleno. I have had Fajita in numerous restaurants . It's one of those dishes that is hard to mess up. They figured out a way to undercook half the platter and turn the rest in to charcoal. They managed to undercook my wife's platter ( the cheese center of the chili was not melted) . The waiter adjusted our bill ( 2 drinks were not changed) when we complained. We would have preferred an edible meal. The only reason I gave it a 2 was the good drinks and pleasant atmosphere. Otherwise it would have been negative stars for poor service and inedible food. read more

Food Is Great guacamole is amazing as well a must have when you eat there service is good as well and the Sheryl temple

Never disappoints. Excellent food, especially the fajitas and homemade salsa. Fun ambiance.

Great food and great service. They really make you feel at home whenever you go there. Best restaurant in Carmel

Great food and amazing service! The owner is usually at the bar serving when we go and each time he makes the experience well worth it!

Came here for Taco Tuesday and was pleasantly surprised. The tacos were delish and authentic. The churros are amazing!! The atmosphere is authentic as well. read more

I've gone to this restaurant for over 15 years and have always enjoyed the food, and the ambiance is beautiful. However, since the ownership has changed, the food has gone downhill. Everything is extremely salty to the point where you can't taste the food. The prices have also risen tremendously. Now we go to Fiesta Mexicana on route 22 in Brewster, which is only about 10-15 minutes away. The food is outstanding, they have many more entrée choices to select from, and the price is a much lower. read more

OK...ate here 3 times. 1st time lunch menu: app; the shrimp "coctel" (NOT ceviche) was really good with lots of shrimp. Had coctel in another Mexican & both were about the same; served the same way, etc. OH, but Viejo ran out of cukes. Forget what I had for entrée; it was ok, nothing to write home about. 2nd time: for dinner order the coctel again. Hardly any shrimp (2 shrimp cut up) with mostly juice/liquid, $17.99. Only reason I went back to eat here was for the coctel. App; chicken mole; chicken breast was thicker than the shoe leather chicken at Las Mañanitas/Fiesta Mexicana (both owned by the same people). BUT chicken was overcooked; just more shoe leather. UGH Why do Mexicans or whoever cooks, overcook everything???? BTW, MY mole & salsa verde (made from scratch & my own tomatillos from my garden) is so much better!!!! 3rd time: Paella; freakin' horrible...!!! The mussels & clams were ok. The shrimp were HARD. NEVER had such hard shrimp before & they tasted like they were about to go bad. I should have spit them out in order NOT to get sick. The tiny 1/2 lobster tail was overcooked, dried out & hard. AND I found some kind wrapper in my rice...!!!! WTF...!!! $25.99 for sh*t...!!! Will not be returning. I do have to admit the staff are very nice. I do NOT like that Viejo charges a patron who uses one's credit card so Viejo is reimbursed by the patron for Viejo's charge by credit card companies. Damn, how cheap can one get...??? OH...FOUND THIS PIECE OF WRAPPER IN MY RICE...!!! WTF...!!!! Viejo should recognize it...I'm sure. My pics won't upload read more

My favorite Mexican restaurant in the area. Food is always great whether eating in or taking out. Service is also top notch.

I mean just drive the 15 minutes to las manitas or fiesta. Service: spilt the margarita on the whole table, forgot the appetizers, and bought us a wrong meal when we tried to tell them we ordered something else told us that was what we ordered when we didn't. (Mind you one of four people in the restaurant). Food: I found chunks of garlic in the chimichanga, the sauce tasted like marina, canned green beans in the rice To top it off it's not cheap seriously drive the extra 15 minutes you'll thank me. This place was filled with old people and that should tell you something read more

Absolutely a horrible experience!!!!!! 23.99 for shrimp fajitas (a total of three) Ridiculous.. And when I mentioned it to the waitress she tells me shrimp is expensive Are you kidding me!!!! read more

Absolutely horrible. We'll never go back. We decided to try this restaurant because we heard so many great things. I ordered shrimp fajitas $23.99. When I received my dish it was FULL of vegetables. Not peppers and onions the way it should be. Instead they added squash and carrots with some red sauce on top and THREE shrimp. We have been to plenty of Mexican Restaurants. I know what how shrimp fajitas are suppose to look and taste. This was not it. When I mentioned it to the waitress she responds by shrimp is expensive. Are you kidding me. Who wants to pay $23.99 for three shrimp. I don't even want to get started on my wife's meal. She ordered steak and shrimp fajitas. Two shrimps and one piece of steak. Her's was $26.99 And we paid the whole bill. What ever happened to the customer is right? EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED read more

Been coming here for a few years now.. they recently changed owner ship and it's nothing short of amazing. They have so much pride in their drinks and food. The cocktails are full of fresh flavor with an authentic taste.. the food is equally as delicious. The owners are amazing as well read more

Omar's Pueblo Viejo - a table full of mexican food - Mexican Near Me - Carmel, New York

Our go to spot for local Mexican. Staff are so nice and friendly. Food is a tasty and big portions.

Ordered the nachos azteca as an appetizer And unlike piling on the ingredients on a mountain of nachos they applied chorizo refried beans onions sour cream and cheese on 8 individual tostadas with a side of guacamole Very satisfying as everything tasted very fresh Had some shots with dos xx ( on tap) service was good and we will be back to try the dinner read more

Omar's Pueblo Viejo - Great ambiance - Mexican Near Me - Carmel, New York

This place is great! Always a good experience coming here and the food is fantastic. It starts off with the colorful atmosphere and great wall decorations. Made to look like a little village, you almost feel like you're on vacation here! You're immersed in the colors, sounds, and sights of Mexico. Not to mention the food is delicious! It's a very authentic feel when you walk in accompanied by a very authentic taste as well. The flavors and aromas all seasoned and blended tastefully for a hearty meal and experience. You won't be disappointed no matter what you order off the menu. Great place to go grab some dinner before you head to the movie theater next door. I highly recommend. read more

Omar's Pueblo Viejo - Mexican Near Me - Carmel, New York

See all

I ordered through Yelp/grubhub and the order was 30 minutes late. I called for a status update and was told the driver would be here at 7:10. I called back at 7:30, now an hour late and was told by grub hub the driver was on the way. For the inconvenience they gave me $10 back. Shortly after receiving then discount, the restaurant cancelled my order. It just seems petty over $10. We won't be going back here. read more

My daughter wanted Mexican food for her birthday and wanted to come here. We came for lunch and although the place was empty, it was definitely worth it. We ordered the Carlota which consisted of a chicken chimichanga and enchilada and the Rosita which was a beef chimichanga and a taco al pastor. First of all the chips and salsa were great! Chips were warm and the salsa was fresh. My beef chimi was the perfect size and the taco was soooooo flavorful. The rice and refried beans were great as well. I ate every bite and I can't wait to go back. The service was great as well. read more

See all

Food is so good and our waiter Martin is the best definitely recommend this place to go w friends or family

So I decided to go here after not wanting to eat Wendy's. We got there at 7:20pm on a Saturday. We order simple things aka 4 chicken tacos, quesadilla, and chimichanga to take home. We literally waited 45 mins without complaining. Every waiter and staff I had asked where is the food, they kept saying 10, 7, 15 mins etc... finally I told them I don't want the order and they even said another 10 mins. The crazy thing about it is that I observed people coming in to order and getting their foods way before us. When asked why it taking forever, the waiter said because, the cooks are too busy. If yah going to order call ahead and don't wait inside. What a joke!!!!! read more