I have been to this place several times in the past two years, and each time the food was…read moreexcellent! In fact, my sister came for a visit recently, and she requested the Old Ice House. That's the best compliment they could receive. The wait staff was great and it's been consistently great, along with the food and drinks. I think the atmosphere is just right; the fact that it was an actual ice house makes the place welcoming. I haven't been there during live music events but I'm guessing they're fun too.

We happen to be spending the night in Durant and came upon this restaurant on Yelp. It did not…read moredisappoint!! Food was excellent, the wine was great and inexpensive and the service was spot on! If your in Durant....Check the Old Ice House out....you won't be disappointed.

Love the cauliflower crust pizza with roasted tomatoes, black olives, red onions, sweet bell…read morepeppers, pineapple and feta cheese topped with mozzarella, oregano and Parmesan with olive oil. My own Mediterranean type creation. Clean restaurant and helpful atmosphere.

The Good 5* Italian Sandwich, best I've had since Little…read moreItaly in California 4 *Cheese and toast appetizer The Average 3* The pizza with pre-made crust run through a machine to cook. Like 5 Pie but not as good The Ugly 2* Dried out Buffalo Wings 1* The desserts; both tiramisu (premade and frozen solid) refunded without being able to taste 1* this peach thing on again one of their premade crust where they opened a can of peaches and scattered 1/4 of the can on the crust and added sugar to call it dessert 16 points divided by 6, being generous I give them 3

Just like any other firehouse. Didn't have a problem. The reason I'm posting is mainly cause the…read morereviews haven't updated and I figured I'd help. The staff is great, the food tastes like it usually does. And it was as clean as it could be for a lunch rush when I was there. Glad I didn't just listen to these old reviews and enjoyed my lunch. It was a bit pricey. But that's firehouse itself not just this particular one.

I've been here several times. Ordering in person and using the app. They always greet me and the…read moreorders are correct. I've tried several subs on the menu and never been disappointed. I'll continue coming here.

Great service. Great food. A legend in Durant. It's a " don't miss" when in Durant. I came here…read moreoften 10/12 years ago when I lived here. Now I'm back again. Happy to report it's still great

Food and service were great, and I very much like the total ambience of the restaurant.read more

absolutely love this place, the honey croissants are the BEST IVE EVER HAD!!!!! Also love all the…read moremenu options, their blended coffees are so good and their drive thru is so fast! Also their Pup cups ARE SOOOOOOOO CUTE, they go above and beyond and put a dog treat in them, my dog loves going with me

Coffee was great! I stopped in just to try something new and was pleasantly surprised. Prices were…read morefair and the drinks were on point. Can't wait to go back and try more

Very rude staff and terrible service at this Einstein Bagels location. The employees showed no…read morecourtesy and made the whole experience unpleasant.I

Best bagels in Durant but basically the only bagel shop in town. Directions indicate it is in the…read morecollege bookstore but it's not, just next door with their own entrance and drive thru. I was unable to get their app to recognize this location so I could order ahead. Don't know what was up with that but will try again

Best hamburgers anywhere! The meat is fresh daily, never frozen. It's a half-pound, all beef pattie…read morewith crisp lettuce and ripe tomatoes on a large, warm bun. You can add cheese, onions, and the dressing of your choice - it's all up to you! A side of deep- fried string onion rings or French fries and you will be in burger heaven! The chicken fried steak is also a great choice. It's the Monday Special and it is special! Don't forget to get a slice of homemade pie - a choice of chocolate meringue, coconut cream, or strawberry, all made in the Sherrer's kitchen. Delicious! No matter where you live, it's worth the drive to Durant, Oklahoma, for a meal at Sherrer's

Wife and I, passing through, stopped here for late lunch today. I was sorry to hear elder Sherrer…read morehad passed since our last occasion to dine here. However his son and grandson are still operating. The food and selection is still good. The bad news is They are only open now for lunch. 11 am-2pm. If you are like me, I love chicken fried steak, order it whenever, and Sherrers offer it served three ways. 1. Sandwich on a bun in a basket with fries or substitute.(I had a fresh salad ) 2. Traditional plate with mashers, gravy and fresh salad 3. Played open face on Texas toast with gravy, fries and a salad.

My wife and I ate here this past Saturday. Started with calamari, can be a bit of a gamble in OK,…read morebut the calamari was cooked perfectly. The marinara was just ok. Weirdly, they piled kale on the plate first and then put the calamari on that. Seems like a 90's plating style to make it look like there was an even larger amount of calamari on the plate. The calamari portion was just right, so skip the extra kale as all it does is get tossed in the trash. Entrees were kabobs and grilled shrimp, my wife thoroughly enjoyed her shrimp and I too enjoyed the kabobs, well seasoned and the portion sizes were perfect. Since the ownership has changed, the food is definitely better than the last 2-3 years, which is great news. Final comment, even on our entree's, the plating again included a pile of kale and a weird twisted slice of orange. Skip the kale or anything not intended for the diner to eat as it detracts from the presentation. Will we go back? Most likely.

Had some difficulty verify this restaurant because the phone number and website on Yelp doesn't…read morework. It appears it's under new ownership and found a good phone number on Google. The decor inside is pretty nice. It's a little loud but we expected that on a Saturday night. The server was nice but the kitchen didn't help her out much. We got our appetizer salads at the same time as our entree. My wife ordered medium rare steak and got medium. Not so great for how much they charge in Durant. These prices are more in line with the DFW area. I will say the taste of her steak somewhat redeemed it though. My pork chop was good and so was the loaded baked potato. I also ordered the strawberry jubilee cake and it was dry. Also, didn't taste fresh. Almost tasted store bought. Not too good for the price they charged. They are charging higher end steakhouse prices but only delivering lower to barely mid range quality.