Been a while since I had Original Presto's, glad I had it again. The best way to describe my experience... I was craving a good slice of pizza, and Presto's just hit the spot. Meat lovers, chicken bacon ranch, both spot on. Just the right flavor and texture. As a bonus, their location is right by the park and JFK blvd E, so perfect place to walk it off after getting stuffed. read more

I have been to this establishments more than once. The staff is lovely but the food, food quality and cleanliness of this pizza restaurant is not very good. The pizza here is not good at all. Save your money! read more

Terrible service and lousy pizza. Too bad ownership has changed so many times...definitely avoid like the plague!

Ate Prestos pizza for 15 years. But since he sold it to the new owner, it has been on a steady decline. Recently that decline is not straight down. Had a simple cheese pizza, same as I've always ordered. It really was t even pizza. It was dough with an eyedropper full of sauce, and piles of mozzarella cheese. It was literally disgusting. Prestos went from a famous Jersey pizza place on the corner to this. Threw most of it out. I'm super sad, used to love the pizza there. The owner should have made the new owners rename it. Awful. read more

This lil pizzeria was recommended to us by our air bnb host! Walking distance from our stay and absolutely delish! I got the pepperoni my dad got the margherita, my mom got the bacon rio! We also got the house root beers! 10/10! So happy we tried this place! And the owner was an absolute delight! Love finding places like this in a new city! read more

Original Presto's - Pizza Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

See all

I love the Pizza and the garlic knots are awesome ! They also have really good sides like empanadas and potato balls. The prices are good too! read more

Original Presto's - The Pizza is really good and I lovee their garlic knots and there prizes are great too ! - Pizza Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

Rude service. I ordered shrimp that app glitched and said chicken. They charged me $29 and would not change to shrimp even tho i paid for it and called little 30 seconds after placing the order. Never again greedy AF read more

Pizza was nice and thin. A bit pricey for a slice but still one of the better pizza options in nj. read more

Original Presto's - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

We loved this place that we went twice in a week...! This is a family owned restaurant with good Italian food. I tried the chicken fingers with honey mustard sauce, garlic bread with cheese, fries, penne alla vodka. Liked all of them. However, I wasn't a fan of chicken rigatoni. The owner was sweet and gave us free dessert. If you are in the neighborhood, definitely give it a try! read more

See all

We love this spot! Friendly service, good large slices. A bit pricey but it's worth it. It's more of a pick up and go or have delivered spot. They have a few seats and tables but the doors are open at all times. If the weathers nice it's a good spot to stay and eat, if the weathers bad, I'd order for pick up or delivery. Just know parking around here sucks so if you're picking up, make sure you have an extra person to wait in the car while u go grab it. read more

I like the consistency of their slices...but the sauce doesn't really do it for me. Franky, it tastes like ragu or those cheap jar sauces from the supermarket....but I'm willing to try them again if I'm in the area. I do really like the slices down the street at West New York Pizza. read more

If you're searching for an amazing pizza experience, Presto's is the place to go! Located on the corner of 60th and Park Ave, my sister and I had the pleasure of trying the margarita and buffalo slices and they were truly delightful. I wish I lived closer to West New York, as I would make it a regular stop, but I'll be sure to drop by when I'm in town. (Didn't take a picture of the margarita ) read more

Original Presto's - Plain Slice (Margherita Pizza hiding on the top right) - Pizza Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

See all

Margherita pizza is sooo good! (with extra basil) was actually on my way to another pizza spot and saw this one on the way and decided to check it out instead. Joseph at the front was so charming and delightful... it was a pleasure talking to him. thank YOU Victor for making phenomenal pies. Would definitely come back!! read more

Old review got deleted don't know how because past pictures are still there, but decided to try prestos again during this quarantine and was pleasantly surprised. The food came in a timely manner (even though I live like down the block lol), food was still hot, left it hanging on door instead of the floor for no contact (much appreciated!) The pizza slice was delicious and pretty big. So much flavor I didn't even need to add any of the spices I usually add to pizza. The penne allá vodka lunch size was also really yummy. I added grilled chicken to my order. I like that they add a lot of sauce, hate when pasta comes dry. The lunch size is still pretty big which was also good for the price with a nice piece of bread on the side. The sauce is the perfect balance of tomato and cream, one of my new fav places to order penne alla vodka from now on! read more

See all

Awesome delivery experience. Great food. The bruschetta and Marsala chicken sandwich were delicious. Delivery was quick. The ziti was a little dry. read more

See all

This place is terrible. I asked for a pepperoni slice and they said they would make a new fresh pie. Instead, they added pepperoni to a cold cheese slice and warmed it up. I also ordered a chicken parm sandwich that barely had any chicken. Save your mo ey and cook a better meal at home. OVERPRICED! read more

Pizza and penne alla vodka always my kids fave. Service is always on point too!! Delivery guys are always fast as well

The food is delicious but they might not send it to you. We have ordered there through Seemless a few times this month and enjoyed the food. Tonight when I ordered my delivery was canceled. So I called to see what the problem was. I was told that since they were busy, they wouldn't deliver to my address because it was too far away. And that the only reason they've done it in the past is because they had other deliveries in my direction. Not a good way to do business. Either make the delivery radius smaller or have more staff on hand to fulfill orders. Don't make it seem like you've been doing me a favor by sending me food. read more

Original Presto's - Pizza Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

Came here for a few slices on a Saturday afternoon walk and we were pleasantly surprised! The veggie pie is really delicious.

Ok, so you're on death row and your time has come. They ask you what you want for your last meal, but they stipulate it has to be pizza. In this situation I would order Presto's Avishai Special small pie (4 good size slices): fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, fresh garlic, ricotta, basil. Tastes amazing. It is a relatively simple combination, but they use good quality mozzarella and ricotta, and the garlic nocks the whole thing out of the park. Another favorite is their Puttanesca pie: tomatoes, olives, capers, artichokes, mozzarella. If you like capers, you'll love this pie. Overall, the negative reviews regarding delivery are spot-on, they take FOREVER. And it does come cold sometimes. But the quality of the pizza, specifically the two I mentioned, is amazing. My man likes the Presto's burger . I have ordered pasta more frequently than I care to admit; sometimes it was good, and sometimes it wasn't prepared very well. I often times was able to order my own custom pasta dishes, which I always appreciated the staffs' complying with my requests. They can be a little gruff over the phone, but if you pick up the order they are always nice in person. read more

We got carry-out, and everything from the service, timing, price, and freshness/taste of the pizza were great. They were able to do a large half/half pizza of Avishai and plain for a reasonable price. The man who took our order was very friendly and polite. Our carry-out order was ready in less than 20 minutes. When we brought the pizza home, it was still hot enough to eat and tasted like it was just made. Try the Avishai if you're someone who likes margherita pizza with a little extra. We also got garlic bread with cheese, which was seasoned wonderfully and had a generous amount of cheese. We unfortunately forgot to ask for a side of marinara sauce. Fyi, I think there is a small additional fee for credit cards. Definitely going to order again! read more

Their pizza and customer service is on point every time. Best in the area, with the right price and large slices. Whenever I'm home I make it a point to stop by. read more

I could not rave enough about this new find of mine. I called tonight to order a veal dish and the owner called me to tell me they were out of veal so I ordered a chicken dish and a few other things for my family. The owner could not have been nicer and when my order came, I had to call the owner back. The food was unbelievably good. By far the best Italian in this neighborhood and the owner was such a down to Earth, genuine person. He called me by my name and treated me like family and small things like that are lost these days with everyone being an "internet expert". I rarely give reviews but this was such a great experience. Wish more people would compliment more than they denigrate. read more

OMG! The pizza here is soooo GUUD!!! Yes, haha! I come here every time i have pizza cravings. Its the magical crust. There is just something so special about the crust. It is hard to explain in words. One just has to eat it in order to know what i am talking about. I order delivery from them religiously, and as often as i can. If not, i'll just come in and grab a slice and soda. However, lately, I've just been doing delivery. Its very painful to come in here and see one of the employees that i have the hugest crush on ever. Its really painful. People have no idea how difficult it is to cope with such an ordeal. I just want him to throw all the red peppers on the floor, and take me on the counter every time i see this Italian stallion. I have the most insane fantasies about him. OMG!! It is just a crime how sexy he is. Panty-dropping sexy. read more

Just saw the guy with the piercing smoke a cigarette outside. He came back inside and began handling pizza dough and making pizzas without washing his hands and without any gloves. Truly disgusting. Especially bc the workers act like they hate being there. The least they can do is practice good hygiene. read more

Today I had the worst experience . I gave them a second chance after I waited last time to get a regular slice for 20 mins . The answer from the owner who ignores you and made racist remarks and then hits you with a welcoming fake "papi". He didn't ask anybody for an ID , but asked my friend who was darker complexion . The second thing is worst ... the guy who handles the pizza goes smoking outside all the time and touches everybody's pizza. The pizza is overpriced and the quality not the best. West New York is a very diverse town and we don't need a pizza owner with such attitude, carelessness and arrogance. Today he lost two more local costumers. read more

If you want to pay $5 for a slice of pizza and wait around and be ignored for an hour this is just the place for you. If you want good service do not come here. read more

Presto, Just a word of advice - please don't tell a hungry group of gals that "it'll be about 10 minutes..." when you don't really mean it. The adorable guy behind the counter said he'd have our pie ready in about 10 and it was definitely more like 20. BUT I'll forgive you because your pizza was pretty darn good. Specifically - that Lasagna Pizza (modified version with meatballs instead of ground beef). Yum and yum! I had two delicious Lasagna slices and couldn't have been happier. I like that the crust is a bit thicker than many of the NYC pizza shops I am usually ordering from. It's nice to have a thicker crust that's able to hold on to the sweet sauce, creamy ricotta cheese and tender meatballs. And I don't know how you you did it but after those slices I felt happy and full but not super stuffed. Bravo Presto! Looking forward to another pie from your West NY location again soon. Alyssa P. read more

If you're looking for the best slice of pizza this side of the Hudson, then look no further than Presto's. This family run restaurant has been making pies their original way for decades and have got it down to a science. The only thing better than their pizza is the owner who is an absolute gentlemen and always generous to his regulars. Don't miss out on the best pizza in New Jersey read more

Mediocre pizza at best. A bit cheap with the cheese and the tomato sauce tastes just like domino's- so if youre into that- you may like it. Have had better... have had worse... just "meh", in general. Will most likely give them another shot- maybe the normal "pizza guy" was home watching the chiefs/bills game. read more

There's nothing like a delicious slice of New York style pepperoni !! We got two slices. It was what you expect-thin, hot, with and good cheese-sauce ratio and pepperoni with almost every bite. There was also a variety of pizza slice selections to choose from. Plus, their pineapple soda was delicious. read more

See all

We were starving. This pizza place was 5 minutes away from us and it literally saved us. The smell was heavenly, the customer service was beyond superb, and the taste...you have to come here to find out ;). This place was a God sent and I will definitely be coming back again. read more

Original Presto's - cheese and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

This is definitely one of those neighborhood classics. I went to grammar school around this area and I still find myself going back for a slice when I'm around. The waitstaff is very friendly, in the summer they have cute outdoor seating and the food is delicious. You can get a variety of Italian dishes, although I highly recommend their pizza. The only thing that sucks is finding parking in the area, hmpf. I guess you can't have it all... read more

Last year my college son and I got a couple slices and sodas while squeezed inside the little and charming old school eating area. Very nice. Coming from northern NJ I craved a fried eggplant parmigiana but had trouble finding one out here in Weehawken. Finally saw it on Presto's menu. Ordered mine over spaghetti. Also ordered a seafood salad which I had once previously. I just finished my second meal tonight and have enough left over for lunch tomorrow. Two little recommendations. More sauce on the eggplant and pasta. Use a full flavored virgin olive oil on the seafood salad, because the perfectly cooked calamari, shrimp, mussels and chopped salad deserve it! I'll be back! read more

They charged me $4.80 for one slice of bacon ranch pizza at the counter ripoff! Try Antonio's Pizza in Guttenberg much much better and not a rip-off! read more

One of the best pizza's anywhere. I have a special place in my heart for this place. Not only did I grow up on their slices before moving to Miami (since the 70's), but so did my aunt's when they first came to the US during their high school years. This place is a few blocks from our old family bakery and was my treat for a job well done while helping my family. Truthfully, if I had been a bit mischievous, I was stilling getting a slice from Presto's...There are at least 20 different pizza joints between where we lived near Blvd east and 47th and the bakery on 65th and Hudson. If you go as far inland as Bergenline, that's a large area full of pizza joints. Throw in the fact that NYC is across the river full of them and you can easily compare them to Presto's and always come up with Presto's as the better slice. I have had a few other items on their menu over the years and whenever I've visited the city. But I tend to grab slices overall. I'd recommend it as a must try pizza spot if you happen to be in the city or are visiting the area. read more

The pizza here was ok. Its better than the regular pizza joints but not better than most of the brick oven pizza places that I ate at. The prices were a bit high for what you get. I would eat here more often if the prices were lower. I mostly order here because there's not much brick oven pizza places around and they do deliver pretty fast. read more

Today it was the first time in a year that I hadn't placed an order from Presto's again and They did not disappoint. I was elated when I received my food! I ordered a chicken parm with penne but I like my cheese well done. When I opened my bag and saw the order was to my liking, I had called them to let them know. I had to absolute pleasure of speaking to the owner Joseph. They have my word I will continue to order again from them! read more

Meh :( the pizza tasted so old and the crust was so dry and the pizza is so sloppy and falling apart. I'm not going to order from here again :/ it was the only place that accepted our order on the night of the superbowl and I guess I know why now read more

Original Presto's - Look at how much cheese is missing - Pizza Near Me - West New York, New Jersey

My go to pizzeria/ restaurant.. everything is good. It's also the only pizzeria I'll Order seafood from. I love thin crust margarita pies, penne vodka, cavateli with shrimp& broccoli. But like I said, it's all good. Chris, the manager is always so nice every time I order. And Joe, the owner appreciates all his customers. read more