Come for the beautiful view of Yellowstone, but don't stay for the food. We've definitely learn our lessons here. But after a long, tiring day of sightseeing, who wants to cook? There are not that many options to eat at Gardiner, our bar was low but Outlaw's Pizza exceeded our expectation. As you walked in, you are warned there are NO pasta or salads served here. Fair enough! It also looks a bit run down but we were seated right away. The 5 of us shared an order of chicken wings, some fries and 3 large pizzas. Note that all appetizers are fried in peanut oil here. I haven't seen that in yearssss in LA, and boy were the fries and wings extra crispy and tasty. For the pizzas, we had the Outlaws (ground beef, bacon, tomatoes, green peppers), The Cowboy (Ground beef, tomatoes, mushrooms, olives) and the Frontier (Canadian Ham & Pineapple). Surprisingly the Frontier was the 1st one to go, the whole pizza was gone. The next favorite was The Frontier, love the crispiness of the crust. We definitely had ordered too much, however the leftovers were just as good the next morning for breakfast. With expensive restaurants all around the touristy town, Outlaw's Pizza pricing is very reasonable. read more

See all

Ordered for pickup a large pepperoni, sausage and extra cheese. Also ordered mozzarella sticks and these corn poppers after they were recommended. I wanted to like this pizza but I have to say the crust is horrible, no lift in it and lacked any flavor or depth beyond the cardboard flavor and texture. The sauce was processed. The saving grace is we ordered toppings - so we ate those. The mozzarella sticks were average and the corn poppers were, different and not my forte. Very few pizza options in this area and I suggest making this your last resort. Also for the price they no doubt cleared 10x the cost to make it. read more

We stopped in for dinner on a recent road trip to Yellowstone. The staff were really busy, but they were friendly and professional despite the rush. I loved the rustic decor. We ordered the corn fritters (?) and the Gambler pizza. The corn fritters were quite the surprise, they were more like fried creamed corn balls. They were good, just not what I expected. I expected them to be more like hush puppies. The Gambler pizza was a meat pizza with bacon, sausage, pepperoni, and ground beef. It was really good. The crust was on the thinner side and a little crispy. Definitely worth a try. Cheers! read more

Don't give 1-star ratings often. Perhaps by Gardiner standards, it could eke out 2 stars as it's pretty challenging to find a really good dining experience of any kind in town. When we ordered, the tipoff was that there was "no small pizzas available." Well - that means they don't make their own crust. Yep, pre-made cardboard crust with some canned sauce thrown on along with a few toppings. Ambience - let's call it "80s Pizza Hut." Highlight was the service, which was polite and reasonably attentive. Some reviews have panned the other pizza alternative in town (Yellowstone Pizza near the park entrance). While it is also not anything to write home about (we ate at both), it is a much better option that this establishment. read more

The waiter was great and everyone was very nice. Also the atmosphere was great. However, all good things come at a cost. The pizza seemed oddly similar to the frozen premade kind and there was no pasta or salad bar as advertised. Due to these circumstances I have left a 2 star review and stand firm in my decision. Additionally, upon further research it has come to my attention that Carl B a dedicated patron from 23 days prior ran into the same misfortune. I am confident that with a little further investigation I will be able to get to the bottom of this but for any future customers please reference the photos below. read more

Outlaw's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, Montana

See all

Just want to say the pizza is tasty. Ordered one to go while waiting at the bar on the 1st floor. Service is another thing. The bar is understaffed. I sat down at the bar and made direct eye contact and said hello to the server and she looked back and gave an annoyed sigh and went about her business. I get that you're busy, but NOT acknowledging waiting customers is just bad customer service. Finally she acknowledged my friend that just stepped to the bar while I was already there waiting. Pizza took about 45 minutes to come out. Delicious pizza, but perhaps go to the upper floor where the restaurant is to order pizza? Anything to avoid the horrid service downstairs. Too bad, this place deserves a higher rating for their food. read more

Be warned! Do not go to this establishment. Terrible food and service, and your clothes will stink when leaving. Setting is OK but frustrated customers ruin it. read more

Nice decor, nice waiter (accept he forgot part of our order. You can only buy fried stuff or pizza. We ordered fried zucchini and fried onion rings (same batter - good taste), and pineapple black olive pizza. Pizza was yuck, but we were hungry and had to wait a long time to get our order (1 hour). The poor couple behind us had to wait longer because they "forgot to place the order." I wanted sweet potato fries, but they were out. Overall, great atmosphere, sorry service, and nasty food. The sign out front says pizza, pasta, and salad," but they don't have salad or pasta. Poor management and PLEASE hire a cook who loves what they do. read more

First Thursday night NFL game of the year and our gang was looking for a place to watch it and Outlaw's delivered big time. Old, western bar atmosphere with an inviting group made this the perfect place for a football game. The pizza was outstanding and the beer was served cold in a frosted mug. The bar has a few slot machines and games to enjoy as well. Due to being short staffed, the main dining room was closed, but I was very impressed with the staff that night. They were hard working and made sure we were well taken care of. All in all, a great place to catch a game with some good pizza and beer. read more

Outlaw's Pizza - Frosted mug Beer - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, Montana

See all

Okay pizza...kind of in between frozen pizza and chain pizza. Would probably take better if you had a couple beers.

If I could give absolutely zero stars I would. Walk in and the first thing is the sign read that there was no salad or pasta. So we decided to each get a small pizza. Couldn't do that either. They were out of small pizzas. We split a medium half and half pie. When it came out, there was barely any sauce, cheese, or toppings. I had two slices and left the rest. The server was very kind and attentive. But, that won't make up for a terrible dining experience. read more

I've never left a review in my life but this experience was special. It's impossible to screw up pizza. High profit margin, easy to make, quick to serve. However this place is clearly out to set records. They actually managed to destroy every aspect. 1 1/2 hours for two completely burnt and over-priced 'pizza's'. We had animals get in our trash that evening. The only thing left was that 'pizza'. Completely untouched. Not even fit for animals. The box would have been a better alternative. I recommend truck stop sushi over this place. read more

The decor of the restaurant is quaint with different fixtures of sandals, guns spurs, and shackles. The pizza and wings that we ordered came out and were good. Pizza was reminiscent of what we got at home. They seem to be out of most of their beers on the menu. So we decided on a red ale, which was OK. Service is short handed and individuals helping were inexperienced. It is sad to watch customers come in and then get up and go. We're not being waiting on for 15 plus minutes. We were there for an hour 45 minutes and got up to ask for a container and bill. read more

The food was surprisingly good, and the service felt very "small-town" and personal. If you're in Gardiner for a visit or just passing through on your way to Yellowstone, stop in and grab a pizza. You won't be sorry! read more

Good pizza. Atmosphere the setting is less than ideal , little run down, needs some upkeep. It's a bar with some casino games, dingy. After trying Yellowstone pizza the night before, it was absolutely the worst tasting pizza I've ever had ! Hands down when it comes to what a pizza should look and taste like, Outlaw is superior to the other overpriced garbage they serve at Yellowstone pizza. The only advice is to get it to go . read more

Ok, I really don't know why this only has 3 stars maybe it's because people in the summer get impatient or whatever or just really rude to the staff, but this pizza is legit. Erin, the front of the house/bar lady was great! She was pleasant and got our order promptly. This is one of the better experiences around here that I have enjoyed. I can't rave enough about this pizza. Crust is homemade, sauce homemade. Just wow! Delicious! If you are having to wait, I promise it's worth it, have a little patience for where you're at. We came from Texas and this pizza blew my mind! Really great all around! I would leave a picture but I ate it too fast lol YUM! read more

We stayed in Gardiner for a week. Found this place 2nd to last day. Cost effective place to dine. (In Gardiner, that's hard to find) The pizza is near perfect!! We absolutely loved it! read more

Outlaw's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, Montana

Tourists Beware! For 3 reasons. 1) pizza here is not great, not even good; it's better than a Red Baron frozen grocery 'za but not better than any national chain pizza you've ever had. 2) Service was terrible; we ate downstairs in the bar/casino area and were flat out ignored as I waited 5 minutes _at the bar_ to order; we were eventually rescued by the waitress from upstairs who came down to help (thank you). And the place was quiet. 3) They SNEAK in a 20% tip and don't tell you (regardless of the size of your party, since we're just 2 people). You won't catch this when you are finalizing your tab on the little credit card machine (they really should tell you that you've already handsomely tipped for the poor service!). So we -- feeling bad for the bad waiter -- then tipped another 20% on top of that! Even in Gardiner there have to be better places.... read more

Good food, good service. We almost let the other reviews deter us but glad went - we really wanted pizza. Give it a try!

Good food, very bad service. If you're not in a rush and have 45 min to wait for a drink refill then you're good.

Ok. So have seen the reviews about this place....stop an think about it, this town is SUFFERING from Yellowstone being shut, so...places are running on low staff, low customer counts etc... We arrived, the young lady ( Jenny ) was running the place on her own, and succeeding! Food: medium pizza ( Cowboy) was fresh, very tasty and cooked to perfection! Beer: range of the usual rubbish ( Bud etc) and a good range of local brews...I was impressed! Prices: beer was great prices, pizza was ok. Overall: Jenny was a dream! Food was good. Please go and support these guys. read more

Great food. Strange experience. We decided to eat dinner here instead of elsewhere because it was walking distance to our hotel, which meant we could secure parking for the night and not have to worry there wouldn't be any later. The outside of the restaurant advertises a salad bar as well as pizza and pasta. It does also mention there is a bar and casino on the outside. What caught us by surprise was that the building is very large and spacious and yet they only have the bar and casino area open to customers. There was evidently "to go" order pickup upstairs but nothing else. We are a party of 7 - 4 kids and 3 adults and were initially sat at 2 tables far enough apart from each other (not next to) that we couldn't have a conversation, nor would it be convenient to share a pizza or appetizers. We wound up pulling 2 chairs over to the other table so we could all sit together. This also allowed another family of 3 to be seated shortly after we arrived. The menu was pretty limited. I didn't see any kind of salad bar or pasta offered. We got the mozzarella sticks, breaded zucchini, and a large pepperoni pizza. The food was delicious with generous portion sizes. Our server was the only one with at least 5 tables plus the bar to handle on her own, so service was understandably a little slow but it was clear she was trying her best. Overall, good food. Just not what we expected. I'd still eat here again if we weren't hoping for a salad bar to go with our pizza. read more

I think the thing that works best for them is that in a town where everything closes early , this place is open till late and tired and weary travelers from the park as well as locals seem to find respite in that fact . After trying almost all options nearby , we stopped here to get some food for the road. You order at the counter and grab drinks downstairs and since we were doing take-out we decided to wait outside where we found some empty tables. The places was brimming with people and the staff was clearly overwhelmed . we ordered Chicken wings , Jalapeno Poppers , chicken strips and two medium Pizza. They initially gave a wait time for 50 minutes , which was then further increased . Food was good but the wait time for over an hour was a dampener , we did order some more stuff in the meanwhile from the Taco place across from them .They had an arcade downstairs along with a bar but it takes considerable time to get the bartenders attention . The prices are very reasonable and the service is average , however with no other options around , this place seems to be a clear choice for many . read more

See all

The best food at the best price in town. They have limited dine in seating and a lot of takeout orders. The pizza was excellent but you are better off calling ahead because it usually takes 35-45 minutes before your food is ready on a normal night. The young lady handling the bar and dining area handled nine orders at the same time while doing the bar tending and being the fry cook. She did a great job but could really use some help. Medium pizza with 2 toppings and 2 sodas was under $25 with tip. There also is no longer a salad bar (I assume it was a covid casualty). read more

Worse place to go to. They fight right in front of you. I wouldn't recommend this to even to the animals. They tell you they are out of food when they are just lazy to cook more. The waiters sat outside on their phones when they had a bunch of tables still. They left one guy to do everything. I would put negative stars if I could. read more

One of a kind place... still cannot believe. After waiting for more than an hour, upon my asking the waitress for our pizza, she told me that we won't get our pizza because the kitchen was out of dough !! Then asked us if we want more appetizers instead... wow. Still can't believe..... we walked out read more

We ordered a pizza and it didn't come for over an hour. Don't come here if you want to wait for frozen pizza. And the signs lied, they don't serve pasta OR salad but they advertise it. Thank u for nothing. read more

I was looking for hot food after a full day in Yellowstone Park. Most restaurants were closed after 8pm. Fortunately, this pizza restaurant was conveniently close to my hotel and open later than others. Great prices, great pizza. Ordered a ham, bacon, extra sauce pizza to go. Delicious with good proportions of toppings. read more

We came here a couple of nights ago and the pizza took forever. It was good, so we came back tonight and found multiple hairs in our pizza. gross. read more

Outlaw's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, Montana

Tastes like frozen pizza. No salad no pasta even though advertised on sign. Overall it was super expensive for what tasted like frozen pizza. 0 stars read more

I don't know why this place has bad reviews, because the food and beer is great, as is the awesome Jen, our server and bartender. She busted her butt all night and we could tell she was stressed, because they were understaffed, but she smiled ear to ear, when we said we thought she looked like Carrie Underwood. The pizzas only took 25 minutes, even though we were told it would take an hour. Well worth the wait, and I would go back just to see Jen's smile. Thanks for a great meal and evening! read more

It's alright if you want good pizza just don't come here. It's mediocre and too expensive for what you get.

Jenny was handling all the tables and doing a fantastic job!! Very friendly and helpful! The pizza was so much better than the thin-crusted pizza we had at another place! read more

This food was a bomb . The server was really nice, all the people here are so awesome read more

Outlaw's Pizza - The cowboy corn bites - Pizza Near Me - Gardiner, Montana

We were driving through but my kids said it was good. Not all the options were available had a bit of a wait. They ran out of options we wanted so had to change it around but everyone was fed so that's a plus read more

Honestly, based on the star count, we didn't intend to go here. We had our eye on places that had 4+ stars. But we are here in off season of October, and other places weren't open. I think Outlaw's wasn't quite prepared to be one of the only places in Gardiner open, because they were running out of food. Luckily we got there in time to order a pizza and some breadsticks. The breadsticks were fine but not outstanding. The pizza, however, was surprisingly great. We got a regular ole pepperoni pizza but it was awesome. Give this place a try! Bonus - they required masks read more

Fair pizza for not having much opened since most places were closed or on limited hours, of only afternoon times. Flavor was fair, thin crust. Down side....no paper plates since they didn't have their dining room open and no salad to order either. read more

False advertising! Their sign says "Pizza, Pasta and Salad". We got inside and the man at the front said "We haven't had salad in quite sometime". My family came for pizza so they sat while I walked across the parking lot to get a salad. I came back with a salad with me and the waitress said "you can't eat that here." I said I'm going to eat with my family. She said they don't allow salads "because of Covid". Mind you she wasn't wearing a mask for being so militant about COVID. They were very rude. Unfortunately we all had to leave so we could eat together. We walked back to the NICE restaurant across the parking lot which served us great food with a friendly smile, including salads -- called Tacos, Burritos and Salads. read more

Short-staffed, menu was limited to only appetizers and medium pizzas? After placing our order, the only staff member taking orders and delivering to the tables completely skipped us, delivering drinks to a table that arrived 10 minutes after we even ordered our drinks. Eat at this place as your very last resort. read more

Do not eat here. This is some of the worst pizza, no, it is the worst pizza I've ever had. Any frozen pizza is better than this. The crust is clearly frozen and has the texture of cardboard, that's not hyperbole. No topping can help this pizza. It's bad. read more