Always love coming here for the blackened mahi-mahi sandwich. It is one of the most incredible lunches you can have in the area. The owner is wonderful and the way Staff is very very hospitable. It's an old-fashioned type ambience not the most comfortable seats in the world, but it is a pub an Irish pub at that! read more

Just had to add they have the creamiest, freshest, Guinness on tap. The food was excellent again. Scotch eggs and Irish poutine. Stop in for a Guinness alone. read more

See all

Was in town for work! Went and grabbed lunch at this cute cozy place. They have some neat decor with some beautiful birdcages. Food was Spectacular and service was friendly. They accommodate gluten free diets and take the time to ask questions. If I'm ever back in town I'll visit them again! read more

Paddy Coughlin’s Irish Pub - Irish Pub Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

See all

Paddy Coughlins was a recommended restaurant when visiting someone at Fort Atkinson hospital. My brother and I were delightfully surprised at just how adorable this lil treasure was and the food??? Absolutely EXCELLENT ! We are at the bar and couldn't have had better service, atmosphere, dinner & dessert ‼If you find yourself in the Fort Atkinson area, you MUST give them a visit! read more

See all

Arrived without a reservation on a Friday, near noon with a group of 7. The staff was fabulous. Our server was quick, friendly, and easily let us get separate checks. My Ruben on rye was exactly what it should be, and the fries crispy but not dry. A few of the ladies got dessert. The servings were huge and they claimed the flavors yo be wonderful. Thank you for a great experience read more

Coleslaw- sweet and tasty 5/5 Fish fried- buttery flakey, well seasoned, crispy 5/5 Fries- mid 3/5 Service-5/5 18/20 In conclusion, this place is solid. Fish is fresh, well seasoned. Guinness was good and poured correctly. Service was fire! In an out in less than an hour for lunch. Really nice server. The only thing that could be better in my opinion, are the fries. Could have been in for a tad longer. But who cares about fries right? All in all, solid restaurant and will be back. 4.5 / 5 on my scale but we will yelp it at 5/5 Would come back read more

We have been there quite a few times For fish fry and love all of it. But my daughter had a burger and I looked over and it looked amazing. I looked Back and saw her eating the last bite. I thought she had cut ot in half but it was gone. I'll Get one of those next times read more

It was busy and we got one of the last tables. We both had the fish tacos and they were excellent! We enjoyed the atmosphere and the food; it was the second time we have been there--both times were great! read more

Big chef in a small kitchen is pumping out some darn good eats! Our unruly group of 20+ was served perfectly in the cozy basement room. They even somehow got all our checks right. read more

Paddy Coughlin’s Irish Pub - a giant pretzel - Irish Pub Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

Awesome peeps there, excellent food as well. The special of the day is always awesome. read more

we came here while driving thru town. i was glad we stopped. the food was very good and flavorful. waitress was attentive and had a great attitude. we will definitely be back again. read more

Paddy Coughlin’s Irish Pub - scotch eggs, and rueben egg rolls. - Irish Pub Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

Good food and service. Had lunch placed packed. Hard to carry on conversations due to all the chatter. I like quiet restaurants better. A little pricy for my taste. read more

Was extremely busy when we got there; the server never let our glasses go empty and was friendly. The vibe is warm, friendly, and welcoming. Food was amazing! read more

Paddy Coughlin’s Irish Pub - Irish Pub Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

See all

One of my favorite go to Friday night fish fries. I love the ambiance, the friendly waitstaff, delicious food, and Irish influence! This Irish gal loves this gem! Tonight we had the Irish cheese curds. What makes them Irish? Being served in an Irish pub! We of course ordered fish, the panko parmesan crusted haddock, mashed potatoes, and veggie of the day! I cannot wait to try is the Guinness cake! read more

Pretty limited on drinks. Atmosphere very pub like and great social distance between tables. Pretzel was a little disappointing. Not worth the $15. Whiskey burger was an absolute delight. Serving staff was friendly and attentive. A little pricey and the food really took a long time. Probably 30 min. Looks like they have a good variety of food. read more

See all

This is a great, small, beautifully decorated pub located just off of Main Street. They offer many different food items, and have an great drinks menu as well. I liked all of the decor in the building, which included different photographs, painting, and vintage signs. The service was also great, and we liked our server that we had. If you are visiting I would recommend this pub for some good food and drinks at a reasonable price! read more

Paddy Coughlin’s Irish Pub - The deluxe grilled cheese sandwich. - Irish Pub Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

See all

The service was great. Our waitress was friendly and efficient. The food was so good. We had the Poutine, Reuben eggs rolls. I had the grilled cheese with the pesto on it. I loved it so much that I made a dupe at home. I'm looking forward to going back and trying more things! read more

Great food and drinks with parking across the street. Many local beers and of coarse Guinness. read more

Paddy Coughlin’s Irish Pub - Main room - Irish Pub Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

As always a great place to go- love the food and atmosphere. We had our wedding reception there in the side-room and was awesome- keep on going back... read more

Good food, good atmosphere, good service, good price. Of course you can get a Reuben here. Delicious and well balanced!! The rest of the menu looked awesome. We had so much food I couldn't eat it all. I would go back. read more

Fun atmosphere. Friendly, welcoming staff. Food was piping hot and was brought out fresh from the oven. We could tell the food had quality ingredients. My family of 4 had a fantastic dining experience and our server knew the menu well. Our special favorite was the cheese curds. We highly recommend this fun spot! read more

Paddy Coughlin’s Irish Pub - Shepard's Pie - Irish Pub Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

My mom took me here recently as it's one of her favorite places to go. We went for a late lunch and were almost at the cut off point before the kitchen was closing. No one was there so they could have easily turned us away and made things easier for themselves. They did not. Our server was great and our food was delicious. read more

Great food. Took a little while with five for lunch, but worth the wait from kids hotdogs to magi sandwich to bangers and mash and burgers, everyone was pleased with the food. read more

Nice place in downtown Fort. I went in for lunch but it looked like a place I'd like to come back for drinks some night. I have heard that have live entertainment at times. The lunch was very good. My rueben was toasted perfectly and had good flavor. The Irish Stew was thick and tasty but could have been better if it was served with some type of bread. I have relation in Fort Atkinson so I will be back anytime I'm in the area. read more

A well worn and comfortable Irish pub with good food and good beer selection. Really not much more to say. If that is what your interested in you will not be disappointed. It's won several best of the area awards, and I can see why read more

Paddy Coughlin’s Irish Pub - Yes, they have guinness on tap. harps also - Irish Pub Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

The service there was excellent. We had a couple of different items from the menu. Everything was fresh and hot when we received or order. The atmosphere was very comfortable. I will say they can get crowded and do not take reservations. Will definitely go there again. read more

The place was just "okay", we walked in around 4pm on a Saturday 8/13/22 and the three people behind the bar just looked at us, no greetings~ When The young Gal approached us I asked if she has a favorite martini or gimlet she likes to make, her response...."no"......hmmmm and she left it at that ~ Bartenders are the star of the show, and while they are making drinks, cleaning and restocking, they should be entertaining the guests! The warn out seating and bar was cool and would have been even better if the bartenders had the history to go with it~ I probably would have liked it better if the Bartender was more hospitable~ Probably not going back~ read more

Great service and amazing drinks. I'm not sure I've ever had a bad meal here. Would recommend the Guinness cake.

Stop here if you're in the Fort. You won't regret it. Jerry is 100 percent on his game. Great service, great atmosphere, great pretzel. Don't skip it. read more

I have been there twice, not long after the place opened. Good food; cold beer. I have not been back, however I continue to hear good things about this establishment. I would recommend this business on the strength of the reviews of more recent patrons. read more

Delicious food and amazing service! This little pub is everything you want in a local eatery. Erin and Mitch are amazing owners who take pride in the service they provide and the contributions they make to their community! read more

Nice little gem. Irish pub with a nice layout. We got cheese curds: light and airy, pickle grilled cheese (weird sounding I know): surprisingly amazing, Rueben: great, Fresh fries and Guinness gravy. Worth the stop. Definitely on our radar now read more

Wonderful neighborhood bar! Friendly service, yummy cocktails and some of the best fish fry in Fort Atkinson.

Paddy's has some of the best food around. Their menu is awesome, and everything I have tried is great. Fort is lucky to have a place like this! read more

The many times I have picked up food here, and more recently stopped in for a couple drinks and food it is always top notch. The food is always hot, the drinks are always cold, and the service is always impeccable. read more

Had a horrible experience on a reservation at North Shore Chop House on my wife's Birthday dinner. Left after 35 minute wait and went to Paddy's. Have been there numerous times so we made alternate plans. Courteous reception and saved our family's special night! Had Scotch Eggs and Reuben Egg Rolls for appetizers, entrees included Shepard's Pie, Pickle Burger, Irish Stew, Reuben and Patterson Sandwiches and it was all amazing!! Fudge covered Cheesecake for dessert. Won't make the first mistake again and (should have) will go directly to Paddy's first next time. Hope you might learn from our mistake. read more

I stopped in for lunch, and it was busy so I considered it a possible good choice. I ordered the Irish stew, and the Shepard's pie. The stew had more of a gelatinous consistency, and the meat was dry. The flavor was okay, but nothing exciting. The Shepard's pie was basically some of the same Irish stew, with a bit of mashed potatoes and Parmesan on top, and a few frozen veggies mixed in...definitely not like any Shepard's pie I've ever had. The service was good, and ambiance was nice, but not enough to make up for the lack luster food. read more

My favorite place in town! The food is homemade and mouth watering! Every time we come there is always friendly staff and prompt service. High recommended! read more

Paddy Coughlin’s Irish Pub - Heart Shaped Chicken Sandwich - Irish Pub Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

We have never been here before. Wait staff and bar tenders were especially attentive and accommodating. The food was top notch and beyond our expectations. We had the ruben rolls for an appetizer which were quite tasty. For our dinner I had the Saint George burger (I think it was George) which was fantastic. My wife had the ruben and absolutely loved it. As sides we had a cup of Irish stew and a special of cheese curds, French fries with cheddar cheese and green onions in a savory gravy. That knocked our socks off! To finish it all off we had the bread pudding for dessert and if you like bread pudding dont pass this by. We did have 1/2 of each of our meals left and took it home so the portions are plentiful. The only down side that I could say anything about is I like the beer colder. Dont get me wrong it was cold but I prefer colder. We will for sure be going back. read more

See all

One of my favorite places in fort to get a stiff drink and great food! I would consider this to be a 4 star restaurant with a full bar. You absolutely need to stop in for the corn beef and cabbage on st. Patties day! Best in the area in my book! The staff here really know their menu and specials, and are always friendly and happy to see you. Tonight I tried the chicken wings with root beer bbq. It was awesome! Literally candy chicken! The wife and I are leaving full and with a happy little buzz read more

See all