Great service from a friendly waitress and tasty burger/fries and bangers and mash. Good music!

Tried to stop and get a drink to watch the football game. Bar was empty and bartender decided to play Barney Fife and didn't accept my ID that I used to fly on TSA down here. Will not be coming back read more

The loudest and most obnoxious place I've ever been to. Can't even hear the waitress talk to you right next to you. It's not even a live band, just a young kid playing DJ. Bring ear plugs. read more

My friends and I went into Paddy Murphy's to enjoy dinner on a Sunday evening after seeing a show around the corner at the Marco Arts Center Theater. We were able to get a table right away for our group of 6, which was awesome. We sat inside and because Masters golf was on TV, the live music that was scheduled to play that night was delayed. I have heard that when the music is going at Paddy Murphy's, it becomes impossible to have a conversation so it was not a bad thing that we were able to have dinner and talk to each other. Though we will have to return one night for the live music. Our server was awesome, very helpful. There were a few things on the cocktail menu that were not available but he guided us to other options. We started with the Mac & Cheese Bites which were delicious. Though I really wish they had some potato skins and mozzarella sticks on the menu, too. When I think about fall football at the local pub, those are the snacks I most enjoy. For dinner I had the fish & chips which was awesome. It looked like a heavy batter, but it was so light. The fish was cooked perfectly, and the batter crunched so nicely. The French fries were wide steak fries, which were good and crispy. I usually like my fries a little overdone and skinny, but these fit the meal very well. Prices are incredibly affordable, especially for Marco Island. We will be back! read more

My second try for the Reuben......Bread was hard/stale and over toasted not grilled. Corned Beef was cooked on griddle and tough but only 4-5 slices. Fries were cold and soggy. I do not recommend! read more

See all

A great little Irish bar and restaurant located in the back of a strip mall. Bartenders were awesome, good crowd, but younger. I had to get the Guinness and the bartender poured it perfectly. They also let my wife try a couple drafts before she settle on one. We didn't get food, but the food menu has some great options read more

Paddy Murphy’s Irish Pub - Guinness - Irish Pub Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

Ambiance: very good. Noisy and friendly like a pub should be. Service: Good. Friendly bar servers. Attentive. Food: in an Irish pub food may not be the big draw however it can't be bad as to making people not want to be there. The kitchen at Patty Murphy's has just opened within the last few weeks, and I will give them the benefit of the doubt that they don't have their act together yet. Your menu is not extensive and that's not bad. But you must make sure that what's on the menu is good and memorable. I thought I couldn't miss by ordering the fish and chips but, alas, I was wrong. Here's where I'm assuming that they'll get their act together pretty soon. Good fish and chips are not soggy and should be crisp with a crunch to the bike. Unfortunately, the fish didn't have the quality to it although it was a quality piece of fish just not with the better and frying done to standard so far. As for the chips/french fries They were awful. They tasted like Millie mashed potatoes formed like a chip and lightly brown with no detectable flavor or seasoning and in general the worst I've ever had. I hate to say this I really want this place to do well, but I don't want them to assume that they're done yet. While I haven't tried anything else, I would assume that if one of the crown and entrées of the menu is what they should be proud about is not something I would brag about, then we need to let them know that there's improvement here. All in all I enjoy the place and hopefully they will get their kitchen up to par and be able to sustain themselves. One thing I've learned in Marco Island over a period of 25 years. Is that drinking places come and go by drinking places with good food seem to make it And I hope they do read more

Great burgers and fun trivia night. Try Irish music on Sundays 11am-1 pm. The portions are large.

I am a full blooded Irishman from Kinsale and was very excited to find a pub on Marco. My husband and I went for dinner and we were utterly disappointed in the food. The french fries were cold and the fish was greasy. Husband's steak was unremarkable. The saving grace was the guiness. Will return for the music, but no food. Noonan from Kinsale read more

Well I want to start out by saying I don't usually write a bad review but the food really was less than mediocre. Cold fries, mushy fish and a very boring ceasar salad. Even the Diet Coke was flat! No return for us in the future. Hope the beer is good cause the food lacks read more

Only enjoyed drinks. Friendly staff. If you love Irish bars/food, this is your place! Clean, new place, nicely decorated sports bar. Four person band played pleasant Irish music. read more

See all

Great people, great space, and great live music! Watch the games, grab a perfect pint and enjoy good times!

The bar has always been second to none. Now they have food and it is delicious!!! So far had the smash burger and shepards pie. Both were excellent and very flavorful. Terrific service too. Live music most days. Only true Irish Pub in town!!! read more

Im from the east coast and came by Marco island for fishing , the pub was busy but got my food out quick I had got the Irish pubs burger and it was the best burger I've tried my whole life I hope to come back one day and try it again read more

always a great experience. Solid drinks and great food. I really appreciate the fun environment always.

Incredible job by this Family and friends, nicely done , this is one place that you do not want to miss , it is worth your time too ENJOY , I am Capt MAX read more

Paddy Murphy’s Irish Pub - My boat that I arrived in from Matagorda, Texas....... - Irish Pub Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

Danny took care of us. great place, super clean, good times. Will come back numerous times. first time here but will be a regular place. read more

Paddy Murphy’s Irish Pub - Danny - Irish Pub Near Me - Marco Island, Florida

Went to Paddy Murph's for dinner and trivia. The day shift was nice and friendly. The other people at the bar were friendly and polite. The guy next to us recommended the Rueben or corned beef sandwich. Both were great choices. Then we decided we were staying for trivia. Had a good time the first couple of rounds. Then a couple sets of drunk locals (regulars) came in and were being excessively loud and disruptive. A few customers had to ask the trivia guy to repeat questions. The drunk locals decided that was a cue to get louder. The bartender/manager jokingly asked them to not call out answers. That made the drunken locals get even louder. Several people playing trivia said something to the trivia host. The trivia host said talk to the bartender/manager. The bartender/manager again joking asked the drunken locals to not call out answers. After the event had concluded I asked the bartender/manager to step outside to talk to him. I told him of my disappointment with the events during his bartending/management shift. All he could say, "Is they are locals and they are here every night. They pay the bills." This was said with a smirk on his face. That tells me he doesn't care about the general customer. We came here based on a recommendation from our hotel. We will make sure that the entire Marriott Corporation never recommends Paddy Murphy's Marco Island ever again. read more

Food was great! Music fun! I've know Paddy for over 30 years! I believe he is over 90 now and back in Ireland! I had a really great time with my family! read more

Went this evening with some friends. We thought it would be early enough to avoid the wait time but this place was happening and had to wait 30 minutes. We ordered the nachos, fish and chips, and Smashburger, and for dessert we had the ice cream sundae. Everything was delicious! Was not disappointed SERVICE was fine. Only complaint was really loud, but everyone was having such a great time you got used to it. definitely would go back. read more

No where near what an Irish Pub should be: 1) need to have a notice on their website food is not available yet...bad customer service 2) Playing country music? At least play some good Irish music, ever heard of the High Kings? 3) Learn what a Blacksmith is...half Smithwicks, half Guinness What they did right? They did me right on my whiskey pour. read more

Stopped in for the first time today, Tanya took amazing care of us! Great place for a laid back lunch/dinner with amazing food. We will be back soon read more

Paddy Murphys left us with the best impressions! I recommend to everyone! I would like to come back here again and again Excellent and attentive staff who are friendly read more

Just opened after long delay. No food until this Fall. Drinks weak and poorly made. Stick to beer. Just a watering hole if you have a brogue. read more