Paesano&#x27;s Pizza

Good food, good drinks, good service and great vibes. There is patio seating if you prefer to sit…read moreoutside. Fun fact: it was once a church so it makes it even more interesting.

We have been to Victors 5 times and the food has been great every time. Service has been great 4…read moreof those times. We have a 6 year old that comes also and the wait staff knows how to get her food out asap. A lot of other places just dont get how much that helps. We will keep coming back.

Inside

Sad example of "jumbo lump"

See all

Exterior

Tutoni's

4.0(278 reviews)

5.7 mi

Had dinner last night at Tutoni's Restaurant in York. They have a very nice wine list by the…read morebottle and also by the glass. Our waiter Johnny was also the bartender. He was awesome! He helped us narrow down the selections we ultimately decided on and was very knowledgeable on the menu. My wife and I started out with the calamari appetizer, I had the gnocchi with spare ribs and she had the mushroom pappardelle dish. For dessert we split the limoncello cake which was absolutely amazing! The service was outstanding, the food was delicious and the overall experience was 5 star! We will definitely be back! Would highly recommend this for anyone looking for a really good Italian food in York.

The shrimp tasted store-bought, the charcuterie board did not have everything that the menu said it…read morewould, and the service took longer than necessary. #OverPricedOliveGarden Do not recommend

See all

Outside of the restaurant

Nonna Rosa Traditional Italian Kitchen

4.2(135 reviews)

32.3 mi

I like their spaghetti /garlic bread and Italiano selections…read more the service where excellent to the patrons in the diner the ambience was classical musicas in the background great afternoon and evening pizzas and Italian types of foods.

We had the mozzarella fritta, arancine, Caesar salad, and carbonara pasta. Everything was solidly…read moreokay. It was very busy on the Friday night we went with friends, so reservations are a good idea. Getting seated was a bit chaotic, as the same area is used for both takeout and dine-in. The servers were clearly busy--managing multiple tables while also plating and serving desserts.

MOZZARELLA FRITTA

See all

Drinks

Buon Appetito Ristorante

4.3(81 reviews)

10.4 mi

Went to dinner here after other dinner plans got canceled. We did not know what to expect. At first…read morethe restaurant seemed like it was not the fanciest. The restaurant its self looked very vintage and dark. But once we got our appetizer I was surprised. The food was delicious and made fresh. The bread was warm and soft. Service was on the slower side but this made for a very calm dinner and made you kind of relax and enjoy the company you were with. The main entrees were delicious and we got stuffed fast! We got some tiramisu to go and it was out of this world. I will definitely go back again for another dinner night!

Food was good and the service was very attentive. Best part was their soup and stuffed salmon…read more Worst part was the noisy tipsy clients but that's of no fault of the restaurant. Overall I would come here again.

Dinning area

Roasted vegetables

See all

Dinning room

Fratelli's Italian And Seafood

3.6(448 reviews)

18.8 mi

Wow, and that's an understatement!!! From the Mojito Sangria, to the Calamari, to our delicious…read moreentrees, just amazing. I haven't had crabmeat like this in a long time. The staff and the bartenders, well top notch and wonderful too!!! We'll be back!!!

Warning others with young children, but hopefully my experience was an anomaly. I made a…read morereservation a few days in advance but when we got there we were told that we had to wait a few minutes. We wound up waiting 28 minutes past our time to be seated. We did ask about it and I didn't find the response to be helpful, however, I liked the younger hostess so I will leave it at that. She shouldn't get in trouble as my issues are with how reservations are managed (or not managed). While I was just happy to be seated, the rest of our party grew restless and it apparently took 55 minutes from the time we entered to place our order. Having a one year old with us, this made it extremely difficult. It was very busy, however, it would've been nice to have the breadsticks and salad earlier to keep the kids happy. It was over an hour since we entered the restaurant before we could give them anything. We were able to leave after 2.5 hours, which was just very long with small children. No one in a position of power seemed to care about all the hiccups. No one apologized for anything being late or that we had to wait so long with a reservation. The food was good, but honestly, Olive Garden tasted better. Finally, they tack on a 3% additional charge to us for using our credit card. It wasn't mentioned, just tacked on at the end. I know smaller businesses sometimes can't absorb that cost, but they have always mentioned it in the past. I found that in poor taste. I will not be back in the future and I was very disappointed in how little regard there was for us as customers.

Birthday decor in private room

Birthday cake

See all

Southern Italy trio

Vincenzo's Place

4.3(64 reviews)

2.2 mi

They never fail! !They have the best pizza . So fresh and hot ! ! The place is clean and the staff…read moreis friendly.

Pizza: WOW! I have made special trips to New York City just…read moreto have Joe's pizza. Now I just need to drive around the corner to Vincenzo's. My daughter brought this home for the first time last night and it was so good. We went and got another pizza tonight for crying out loud.

Meat Lovers Stromboli-forgot to ask them to slice it. Lol

See all

Supposedly a cheesesteak

Tapenade Bistro

4.2(63 reviews)

2.5 mi

Food is always good when we go. Their service is professional and efficient and friendly.read more

Love the food and the service.Wished I lived close thanks for the hospitality if you want a great…read moretime eating nd talking and you mind at peace eat here

Cordon bleu and Tollgate crispy chicken salad!

Chesapeake Omelette Special w/ Fresh Fruit

See all

Green tea

Ferrante's Pizza and Italian Restaurant

4.1(20 reviews)

3.7 mi

There Stromboli is the best yet. There was so much spinach . And it was presented nicely.read more

College football Saturday! Pizza and beer time. Gave Ferrante a try based on reviews and pictures…read more The pizza was OK. We had a margarita and a sausage and mushroom. I think they fell down mostly on the marinara. It honestly didn't taste homemade. The highlight of the night was the shrimp appetizer in a bread bowl with creamy scampi sauce. The shrimp were huge, perfectly cooked, and the sauce was delicious on the bread and shrimp. I'd come back just for that.

Margherita pizza

See all

Dinning area.

Paesano's

3.9(82 reviews)

10.0 mi

Family owned and run sub and pizza shop. They also have meals and portions are always perfect…read more Staff is friendly and cordial. Price is also right.

I ate here with four other hungry peoplerail. We thought everything was great, but we were…read moreespecially impressed with the gluten free pizza. The crust was thin with a good chewy texture, and it was able to hold up a lot of toppings. They had a good selection of cold drinks in their fridge, their bathrooms were top par, the table and chairs were clean, the staff was friendly.

SHRIMP FRA DIAVOLO

See all

Super Italian Sub

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Fred W.

4 months ago

Paesano Pizzeria is a great family-owned pizzeria in Jacobus. The restaurant was clean, welcoming, and had a genuine family-business atmosphere. The fresh bread on my Italian sub tasted homemade and perfectly toasted, and the sub itself was delicious. One thing that really stood out was the value. For lunch, I got a half Italian sub, a bag of chips, and a can of soda for under $10, which is hard to beat these days. As soon as I walked in, I could hear Italian being spoken in the kitchen, which gave me confidence that I was in the right place for authentic food. The restaurant has a cozy dining area with four booths and two tables, making it a comfortable spot for a quick lunch. I also appreciated that the location is accessible, with handicap parking and seating available. If you're looking for fresh food, friendly service, and a local family-run business worth supporting, Paesano Pizzeria is definitely worth a visit. read more

Moana S.

4 years ago

Delicious food and great customer service. I think they serve one of the best pizza's in York County. It's a hidden gem. One of our favorite places to get pizza. read more

Paesano's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Jacobus, Pennsylvania Things to Do near Paesano's Pizza

BEST of Jacobus, Pennsylvania Restaurants near Paesano's Pizza

BEST of Jacobus, Pennsylvania Breakfast near Paesano's Pizza

BEST of Jacobus, Pennsylvania Desserts near Paesano's Pizza

BEST of Jacobus, Pennsylvania Coffee near Paesano's Pizza

BEST of Jacobus, Pennsylvania Dinner near Paesano's Pizza

BEST of Jacobus, Pennsylvania Shopping near Paesano's Pizza

BEST of Jacobus, Pennsylvania Burgers near Paesano's Pizza

BEST of Jacobus, Pennsylvania Thrift Stores near Paesano's Pizza

Best of Jacobus

Things to do in Jacobus

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Paesano's Pizza also viewed

Primo Pizza Express

4.2

(31 reviews)

Always a favorite! Whether it's the pizza, stromboli, or subs, every bite is a winner.read more

Pizza shop done right…read more The place is spotless clean every time I walk in. The staff could not be friendlier. The pizza is absolutely amazing. Crust is perfect thickness, baked to perfection. Sauce is spot on; just the right amount of cheese and never shy with toppings. The prices are great. Pizza isn't the only thing they do right. Their subs and wings are amazing too.

Marcuzzo’s Pizza

3.8

(97 reviews)

Always good . Love the phillies. At any of their pizzas is good. They have many different options…read moreand have not had one bag meal there.

Absolutely amazing pizza, crisp undercarriage flavorful sauce. Best pizza and boli in York and…read moresurrounding areas without a doubt.

Pizza by Alberto

3.1

(46 reviews)

I wanted to like this but it wasn't that good imo. Something was missing. No flavor. Service was…read moregreat and prices decent. Plenty of other pizza shops in the area that have better pizza.

Pizza By Alberto 10-17-24…read more It's been 3 years since we stopped by simply because we moved to another state. While we were back in town, we just had to stop by our favorite Pizza place to see if they still had the best pizza in this area. We arrived there about 1:20 pm on Thursday. They were not full and only had one other booth with someone in it. The place was neat, clean, and smelled great. In fact, I believe they were cleaning the kitchen as we walked in. From what I could see it was spotless. Our waitress came over introduced herself as Jace and took our drink orders. We ordered water, tea, and a beer. She then took our food order which was the Albertos Special. This Pizza has your choice of 8 toppings. We ordered the Peperoni, Ham, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions, Bacon, Extra Cheese, Black Olives. Every time we go there, we always ordered this Pizza special. We also ordered two side salads and an ordered of garlic bread. Our salads came out fast and were good as was the garlic bread and the beer was cold and tasted great. About the time we were done with our salads the Pizza came out. It looked very good and tons of toppings. When I bit into the Pizza it was very hot and the toppings were so good, and the crust was done perfect. I can't tell you how much I loved this, Pizza. I knew then I was giving it 5 stars. If you want to best pizza in this reviewer's opinion, go here and get one you will not be sorry. I give this Pizza 5 out of 5 stars. Follow me on FB for more reviews. Gulf Coast Terry

Bella Roma

3.6

(15 reviews)

Our orders are always correct. Timely delivery. The food is always decent. Common items we get here…read moreinclude pizza, Stromboli, chicken Caesar salad, fries, hot subs. Prices reasonable. Have not been inside lately. Inside always left a bit to be desired but we rely on their delivery or pickup.

Have been a customer ever since it was called Franks! My family and friends enjoy the great pizza…read more Huge fan of the prices for the food you get! The cheese pizza is great and they do an amazing job with the cheeseburger sub. Have not been disappointed in my many years here. Unfortunately I moved out of the area and when I come back to visit family we order from here. Highly recommended.

Pizza Town USA

3.8

(11 reviews)

Great pizza, a little floppy, but the undercarriage was crispy and it was an eight out of 10. Great…read moreservice and atmosphere plus The Walking Dead was playing in the dining room.

Always professional always nice they are very very comfortable and what they serve and confident…read morethat anyone buying at this franchise are not going to be disappointed

Mapa's Boli

3.3

(3 reviews)

Finally got to visit Mapa's and it was THE BEST experience!!…read moreI read about the recent opening of Mapa's Boli and knew that this was a place I wanted to support and the food looked absolutely spectacular! I visited yesterday with my partner and a few friends from Lancaster. We got a pepperoni pizza and a spinach and feta Kiki bread (love that name!!) to share and OMG everything was so good! The pie's are very big and great for sharing . They also have a nice selection of baked goods and we were so happy with our meals that we snagged some cinnamon-chip scones and red velvet cookies and well as a nice hemp drink to take home with us. The staff was so warm, welcoming and attentive and the space is great for the community and offers a wide variety of social gatherings for everyone to come to and experience joy, friendship and safety . I absolutely can't wait to go back!

$28 a pop for boli's that are 75% dough (halfway raw dough, at that.) is outrageous. The 45 minute…read moreprep time was just an insult for this. Never again.

Primo Pizza By Ryan

3.6

(14 reviews)

Still the best pizza in our area. Great wings too. At a reasonable price. We don't eat out much but…read morethis is worth it. Also, the customer service was great!

My husband and I are in love with this pizza. Willing to drive 30 minutes to get it. They use fresh…read morerolls delivered from a bakery in Philly. Tonite we will order a cheeseburger sub and I'll post what we think about it. But the pizza is darn good. The crisp texture of the crust is perfection and the sauce ( we order extra sauce pizza) is fantastic. The negative reviewers out there should give Primo another shot. I am so glad we finally found great pizza in our region.

Jim & Nenas

4.6

(12 reviews)

Read solid reviews, had to stop. I simply had a slice of cheese pizza @ 11:30 am…read more Friendly service. Slice was a bit under/chewy but good flavor. I asked for it not reheated much bc I had to drive and eat, so I'm not complaining! I look forward to trying other items next time that I visit. Here's an updated menu pic for others.

This unassuming little restaurant, particularly this location, is a favorite spot for my wife and I…read moreto get a really good pizza, some amazing appetizers like mozzarella sticks and chicken wings, and great subs (my favorite being the cheeseburger sub). The staff is always friendly, and the food always comes out hot, fast, and tasty! I love how no matter what time of day we show up for a meal, they are still slammed for business with tons of take out orders, which they get done just as fast as our dine in orders. We've consistently had amazing meals here, and I'm so glad we discovered this place!

Mignano's pizza

3.9

(9 reviews)

Food is good. Not like store bought. Appearance ok. Love the staff the are nice and it is clean.read more

Love their food 100% would recommend this to anyone in the area or visiting. Can't wait to have…read moresome soon again

Marino's Pizza & Pasta House

3.5

(102 reviews)