Had dinner last night at Tutoni's Restaurant in York. They have a very nice wine list by the bottle and also by the glass. Our waiter Johnny was also the bartender. He was awesome! He helped us narrow down the selections we ultimately decided on and was very knowledgeable on the menu. My wife and I started out with the calamari appetizer, I had the gnocchi with spare ribs and she had the mushroom pappardelle dish. For dessert we split the limoncello cake which was absolutely amazing! The service was outstanding, the food was delicious and the overall experience was 5 star! We will definitely be back! Would highly recommend this for anyone looking for a really good Italian food in York. read more

See all

First visit to this restaurant. The ambience is cool. A bit eclectic but fun. Noticed the wine spectator award of excellence when I entered. We tried four different tapas. They were all good, but a bit undersized even for small plates. The steak was really good, but literally two bites. The taleggio cheese was probably the best. My pasta dish with chicken was good, but nothing to write home about. Very savory. Old-fashioned was good, but really did not taste the seasonal special tastes. The wine pours were underwhelming. Honestly, everything was good, but nothing was great. And I expected a bit more for the price paid. Service was decent. read more

The waitstaff was amazing and super well versed on any questions. The food didn't take long at all. We waited maybe 10 minutes for starters and another 10 for entrees. It was very romantically decorated and lit to just the right dimness. I have never had a better steak. I have tried dozens of other places' luxury market cuts, but this was truly the best steak I have ever eaten. They don't overcompensate with seasonings and instead let the meat speak for itself. This was genuinely such a nice outing, and a great way to spend the hubbys birthday! read more

This has quickly become my husbands and my favorite restaurant in York! The food is always amazing and the service is impeccable! I have gotten the short rib gnocchi almost every time and I am not even the biggest fan of short rib. It is just that good! We have done the "Mercy of the Chef" which was the best food I have ever had! For my mom's 70th birthday they all signed a card and a homemade pasta candle! The ambiance is also great with romantic lighting. We can't say enough good things about this restaurant! read more

See all

We went for dinner and the food was great! We had no complaints! The server was well versed in the menu and the ambiance was cozy! Will be going back! read more

Tutoni's - Cheesecake - Italian Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Cute little place. Limited parking so be prepared Pricing was on par for the area I think The fried calamari was delicious and I had the black pepper fettuccine. It wasn't rrallly that black peppery - maybe jsut a hint, but the mushrooms were good in it read more

Tutonis was such a pleasant find after trying some sub par restaurants in York. Our service was fabulous with a knowledgeable wait staff who really tried to give good recommendations and tell you about the restaurant. The mocktails were fabulous and the wine list is expansive. I appreciate the farm to table aspect and you can taste in their dishes. The ambience is pleasant. A but dark on the first floor but upstairs is nice, however i had to wander around to be seated because the hostess was MIA. however, would absolutely return! read more

Tutoni's - Short rib gnocchi - Italian Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

Visiting one of our satellite offices in York on 8/26/25. A co-worker suggested Italian for supper. I am not a pasta fan but didn't want to be the odd man out. Our party of 5 arrived and a steak was on the fresh sheet. I ordered. I say this as a steak aficionado. This steak was so insanely delicious I could've cried. Wish I lived closer, but from now on, I'm a huge fan of Italian steak. read more

Tutoni's - The Steak - Italian Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Disclaimer: The ambiance and service were very good however my rating is based solely on the food. We chose to do 5 course chefs tasting menu and were unfortunately disappointed. We started with a baked buffalo mozzarella with a tomato agrodulce which was too sweet for my liking. Second appetizer was a salmon crudo with a side salad dressed with a vinegarette. The salmon was oddly quite oily, not sure if it was marinated in something but it tasted more oily than your usual salmon however the side salad thankfully helped cut the oiliness. Our next dish was the first entree consisting of house made jemuli (?) noodles with chicken and chorizo in a grana padano cream sauce. If it was just noodles and sauce, it would've been a good dish however the protein additions did not complement in my opinion. The chicken was bland and the size of the chicken pieces were bigger than my actual noodles, made it very clunky to eat. The chorizo was cut small, almost cube like, and was too salty for the dish. It overpowered the cream sauce. Our second entree was an Australian sea bass over couscous with broccolini, this was my least favorite dish (could not finish it). The fish had a very strong odor and it was salty. Broccolini and couscous were fine but had no flavor (which helped cut the saltiness I suppose). And lastly, we ended on pumpkin cheesecake which was basic, nothing bad about it but also not the best pumpkin cheesecake I've had. For $85, I expected a bit more than what we received. TL;DR: $85/person. food was meh. wouldn't go back. This was my first time here so I haven't tried their regular menu items, but when I choose a chefs tasting menu, I honestly expect that the dishes are better than their regular items. (So I don't have much interest in going back to try their usuals). The silver lining to the dinner was my drink! Despite it being non alcoholic, it was delicious (and was the only reason I was able to power through our meal). read more

See all

Four of us senior citizens gathered here for a Saturday evening dinner. It was our first time together and we sought a memorable experience - it was! Food was delicious. Special thanks to chef Ty! We shared a five course Chef's table. I wish we had kept track of each dish as ingredients and preparation was largely unique. My best memory was that our dishes were: peach burrata, corn three-ways with crab in a bowl of orecchiette, barramundi on a mixed bed with squid ink infusion, grilled meat and chili pepper, and a double serving of mini-cannoli. Please understand - my descriptions do not do the dishes justice. When the servers brought our plates, it was obvious they were excited and proud - as if they had not seen them before? Sadly, none of us could finish any of the portions regardless of how good they were. We never touched the breadbasket. We'd only water to drink, yet beer and wine selections were made by other tables. Service was tight, timely, and professional. I especially appreciated servers offering added details of each dish. Water glasses full, extra napkins provided, timely bussing, and offers for take home boxes as expected. Ambiance was as expected for a nice place. This haven was in stark contrast to the bumping outdoor dining scene across the street that evening. IF we had to quibble, music and patron noise was louder than optimum for us, but well within normal levels. Also: Plenty of free parking in a public garage around the corner. Restrooms were clean and well stocked. We booked our Chef's table more than a week in advance with Manager Amanda. She was delightful and helpful. She even gave us a hotel recommendation for the evening that we were very pleased with. With generous tip, our dinner was about $450.00. This was appropriate IMO given the level of service, food, and attention we received. This was a special event we did not want to end. Note: we were seated at 6:30 PM and remained until after 9:00 PM and we never felt pressure to vacate the table for others....nice! read more

Beautiful Italian spot. No one was in the front when we arrived to seat us but came shortly afterwards. We were seated in the upstairs area. Place wasn't too crowded for a Saturday evening. We started with the calamari which came on a platter with what almost tasted like spicy mayo underneath it to dip. The bread for the table was a hit. Nice and warm and fresh alongside the olive oil and balsamic vinegar. The kids ordered the meatballs with spaghetti which came out nice and freshly made. Enough meatballs to make sure that you're full. I ordered a pasta with mushrooms and duck and WOW WOW WOW.. pretty amazing! Another friend ordered the pasta and mussels which looked delicious. This place exquisite and charming. So glad we chose to come and dine here. read more

See all

A decent Italian place at York town , Pennsylvania. The ambience is great. I think it's worth it to give it a shot. But personally for me, i think the pasta menus could be modified a little bit to something more exciting like making a seasonal menu. The aglio olio was not my favorite, but the meatballs are!! Their meatballs are homemade & i could taste the meaty , juicy, umami flavor. read more

See all

My absolute favorite Italian restaurant! The food is so fresh and locally sourced when possible. The atmosphere is nice. The speakeasy is fun for after dinner. We now live in Texas and crave it weekly/ nothing compares! read more

I'm so glad we were able to be seated on Saturday with no reservation. Great ambience and cute decor. I like their options on the menu and was really excited to try everything. My mom got the rigatoni, my brother got the Buccatini, and I got the ravioli. The portions were a very good size and everything had a great flavor. The only thing I was disappointed in was my ravioli. The dog was way too salty and I actually could not even eat it. However everything else was great. We came exactly at 5 o'clock and the bread was just being made. It came out super hot and the balsamic with olive oil sauce they have to accommodate it was delicious. read more

Tutoni's - Sweet onion ravioli - Italian Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

Great Ambiance and Good Food!!! I went here for a business dinner and loved the vibe of this place. The service was very quick and pleasant. The drinks were really delicious. I ordered Brussels sorout and Gnocchi . BS were really crispy and yummy. My only concern was gnocchi being little too salty for my palate. I would definitely recommend this restaurant! read more

I had the pleasure of coming to Tutoni's on Saturday, November 5th with a 6:45 reservation for a party of two. This was my first time at this restaurant at the recommendation of the other person in my party, who has been many times before. It was a great experience. We skipped the appetizers tonight, even though they looked absolutely delicious. I had the Italian Sangria (White), which was very well prepared and was served in a nice generous size. For my entree, I had the Potato Gnocchi, which was as stated plus braised short rib, some swiss chard and potatoes. It was absolutely delicious and excellently prepared. For dessert, I had a delicious Chia Tres Leches mini dessert. It was so yummy. Although I was tempted to have the entire flight of five varieties, I just couldn't do it. A great restaurant, with a great atmosphere and excellent food in the heart of downtown York. read more

Really tried hard to give second chances. I always try to find the positive in every experience, a bridge too far. We've always loved the food here, and the second-floor bar setting. The vibe in that space has truly changed, for the worse. Two visits in a row, same thing, bummer vibe. This time $24 for a pathetic wine poor and charged bottle price for a different glass of different wine (which I caught and had changed to glass price). I don't know her name, doesn't matter. The young guy behind the bar is actually worse in behavior and vibe... Sorry Tutoni's, but you needed to hear this. read more

Everything was amazing at Tutoni! We arrived later than our reservation (never gets easier leaving the house with a newborn) and they somehow still managed to allow us to experience the chef's table with the wine pairing. I am still dreaming about the gnocchi that we had that night. read more

I will start by saying that the food was good, and I would say it was above average. The service was slow to almost non-existent. This would include management when asked to speak to them. They added an open kitchen charge to our bills and when we asked they said that was by mistake. The mistake was they got caught. I would not buy any gift cards from them. They did not honor ours. They said the company went out of business. I said we gave you the money when we bought them what does that have to do with the other company. The server said the management declined the use of it. I will not be returning here if they need to add extra charges and not honor gidt card purchases and then won't even talk to you when you ask for the manager. Just read your bills closely. read more

Recently popped in for a drink and snack before a show at the Appel, it was one of the only places open on a Monday. We sat upstairs at the Bar area. Great decor and ambiance. Drinks were good. Be a nice place for a date night. read more

Really enjoyed the ambiance and food at Tutoni's. Great staff. The next time I'm in town, I'll be going there again.

I was on a business trip and was brought here by locals for a dinner gathering. The ambience was nice, and we were seated upstairs, somewhat private setting. To start, we had cheese and meat boards- all were fresh and nothing left behind! Plenty of wine selections. For my main, the server recommended the ravioli but said it was my choice (duh). Her description wasn't too convincing, but I took it anyway since the pastas are made from scratch. It was rich and raviolis were sweet, but the dish was mostly overwhelmingly salty. I was raised to finish my plate, so I tried to with a refilled glass of water... I had a taste of the Bucatini & Meatballs, and that was great! The pastas were cooked perfectly, so I can tell they used quality ingredients. I do want to call out, the server gave a strange vibe. I believe we arrived at the restaurant just shortly after they opened for dinner, so it seems too early for the server to be apparently snarky. For example, we were asked the kind of water for the table (sparking, bottle, tap)- we hesitated for a split second, looked at each other, and most of us said tap. She said, "oookay" and actually rolled her eyes as she turned to walk away. I don't think many people at the table noticed, but I happened to be looking at her in that very moment. When she asked about desserts, we wanted to know the different offerings, so she read them off. No one was interested though, and she sarcastically said something along the lines of "have to do that another 40 times this week," as if we wasted her time and in a passive aggressive tone. I originally didn't think much about it, but there were a couple other little things. Nonetheless, I love the story and local resources, and the food was good! read more

Tutoni's - Front: Sweet Onion Ravioli, Back: Bucatini & Meatballs - Italian Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

They ruined my first date. I paid with a credit card. The card was returned. I left a tip. 20 minutes later while hanging outside they lady who I never spoke in my life with asked me in front of my first date if I "did it on purpose ". She told me my credit card was declined and my date thinks I tried to skip the bill and blocked me on everything. Q1: why'd the random 2nd employee take my card and then give it back without telling me the card was declined? I even motioned for a pen and he motioned back that he didn't have a pen, so I assumed York handles cards this way Q2: why'd the 3rd employee, who i've never seen before in my life, act like I did it on purpose. They didn't talk to me in a professional manner at all. Imagine if I had a business meeting, or was with in laws, and the business ppl or in laws thought I was trying to skip the bill? i'm from out of town and banks always decline cards randomly for security. Plus I wouldn't be hanging out outside the front door if I was trying to skip the bill. The whole situation would've never happened if they just let the original waitress handle the bill instead of 3 ppl touching my bill and card. read more

Awesome place with great service. I 100% recommend. Next time I come to York Pennsylvania I will definitely eat here. It has a great atmosphere and my waitress. Tia was awesome. read more

I would give this place 10 stars if I could. My boyfriend and I have been going to Tutoni's for over a year now. From the first time we went there it quickly became our special date night go-to. We just got back from celebrating my birthday there. When we were seated, the hostess handed me a birthday card that all the staff signed. After we ordered drinks we were given a toast of champagne. They also gave me a desert on the house for my birthday. The food here is some of the best I have ever had. The seasonal menu gives the place a unique touch. Are the prices expensive? Yes. Is it extremely worth it? Absolutely. Every dish tasted fresh. We always order cocktails as well as they are always changing and we love trying their new drinks. The atmosphere is BEAUTIFUL. Service is some of the best I've ever experienced. Every waiter we've had has been extremely nice and attentive to us.. I cannot recommend this place enough. We love going here and it will continue being our go to for special occasions (or whenever we feel). read more

We love Tutoni's! I definitely prefer sitting upstairs for dinner, there is such a fun vibe and great decor for the Northern Italian vibe. When we do sit down stairs it's very intimate which is nice when it's a date night. The servers are always knowledgeable about the menus and are attentive. You cannot go wrong with the calamari or any of the 4 staple pasta dishes. We always try a seasonal one when we go and they are always great. My husband has sprung for the steak twice now and he is always satisfied. Wine menu is extensive and the cocktails are always fresh. We want to try the chefs table so I'll update whenever we do read more

Overall I would give 4.5 stars but for the sake of this review I am going all in to a 5 (since I rated it a 4 last time). I had the Veal Orecchiette (restaurant week special) and my wife had the Rigatoni Bolognese. Both were fantastic! The server was great and made solid recommendations. The other couple were with had the Pumpkin Fettuccine and the Gnocchi. They both were very good. They had a great wine selection but I wished they had more "by the glass" options (like Riesling Kabinett Mosel). But the bottle was ok. It is moderately expensive but the ambience is great. It's a great place to go if you are going to The Appell Center for a show. I highly recommend. read more

Haven't been in years. Excited to go to celebratemy birthday month and enjoy time with a dear friend. Didn't disappoint. My friend ordered crab & corn fettuccine and I had aglio e olio ( bartender recommended). Both delicious, so flavorful, and filling. She had the red sangria and I had a glass of port. Place was packed on this rainy, dreary Tuesday evening. Glad to see this for downtown York. Hats off to the bartender. She was making all kinds of drinks, giving them extra touches. Neat to watch her to it. Works of art. read more

We went here during restaurant week, specifically so that my fiancé could get the squab. Upon arrival, we were seated immediately but we also did have a reservation. We both got a drink, I got a glass of wine while my fiancé got a cocktail. We got the calamari as a starter, and I'm usually not a huge calamari person. But this calamari was probably the best I've had! It was absolutely delicious. It wasn't super chewy like most places, it was in small to medium pieces and breaded and seasoned perfectly. We never got bread, even though all of the other tables got complimentary bread, but whatever. I got the crab & corn fettuccine and it was fantastic. The crab chunks were huge and very flavorful. The corn was buttery. The whole dish was honestly one of the best meals I've had in awhile. I loved this place and will definitely be back. My fiancé got the squab and he absolutely loved it. read more

Tutoni's - Crab & Corn Fettuccine - Italian Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Wow! Just when you think you've tried them all, a nice little Italian place knocks it out of the water! Great atmosphere, awesome cocktails, fantastic food, excellent service. I had the rhubarb duck entree and it was perhaps the best duck I have ever had. My wife had the swordfish and my boys each had pasta dishes. Everyone was thoroughly impressed with their meal. The cocktails are well thought out by someone who clearly knows what they are doing. The "it's getting hot in here" and the "king George" were my favorites. My wife went with a traditional digestive, espresso martini and it was perfect, not too sweet, tasted like coffee for a change. We ended with dessert, a variety of small portioned parfaits with an option for every pallet. Competing restaurants can learn a thing or two here. We will be back!! read more

Tutoni's - Italian Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

One of my favorite restaurants in York. The food is amazing! The service is excellent ! read more

Great food and service. Folks sometimes complain about the price, but you get what you pay for Yorkers!

One of our favorites in York, Pa. We meet friends from Baltimore there, it being a good halfway point. Parking is the only problem we consistently face. Street parking is sparse. No valet parking. Once inside, the decor is comfortable. Warning! Do. To eat upstairs if you want a quiet meal that will allow conversation with your friends. The bar gets louder and louder as the alcohol flows The menu is quite limited so check out the website to make sure there is something for your tastes. Once you make your selections, the food will not disappoint. Pricey but good. They use many local sources for their foods which I like. Staff is attentive and friendly. Give it a try! HZ read more

Excellent restaurant. Expensive but less expensive than the melting pot and food is definitely worth the parking garage and walk. Making reservations last minute isn't hard either online and usually something is available as long as it's not Friday/ Saturday read more

Very good food with a warm atmosphere! We ate upstairs where it was very quiet & nice. Service was prompt and constant.

This was a strange experience for me. I enjoyed the food. But I did not enjoy the service or the price. I wouldn't go back. We made reservations for right after opening. But the waitress seemed surprised and annoyed. Have you had the experience where the waitress dislikes your party from the start, even though you haven't even sat down or said anything? That's how the dinner started. Then she seemed to be further annoyed that we only wanted soft drinks, and no cocktails or wine. We ordered several appetizers and a lot of food. I came to try the home-made gnocchi, because it is very rare that places actually make their own gnocchi. It didn't come with a red sauce, but it was still quite good. One of our party got bucatini and meatballs. I sampled both. I thought the meatballs were much better than average. But I felt the pasta was undercooked. Personally, Not a fan of al dente. The sauce was delicious. We had a charcuterie plate which I thought was really well done. I don't have a problem paying well for a nice meal. But the pasta dishes averaged about $25, which seems a little outrageous. And those were some of the less expensive items on the menu. Like I say, it was good food. But the combination of the food, attitude, and price make me think it wasn't worth it. Good luck, Tutonis, but I cannot recommend. read more

Beautiful food and atmosphere. Wonderful for a date and to impress guests. Recommend the chef's choice

Food was good. Our waiter provided terrible service. Didn't bring our wine or bread until after meal arrived. He was nowhere to be found to find out why. Then he made some lame excuse about the bread taking longer than normal. Other wait staff appeared efficient. We were just unlucky to get the one bad one. read more

My boyfriend and I dined at Tutonis a couple of months back. I was afraid we were underdressed, however I was mistaken The atmosphere was relaxing and the food amazing read more

Tutoni's - Shrimp spaghetti - Italian Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

This place was worth the 90 minute round trip! Although service was a tad slow (no big deal), the food was certainly some of the best in the region. Our party of 4 adults enjoyed the green salad, calamari, N.Y. Strip steak, crab & corn fettuccine, salmon, Nutella mouse and Apple fritter. They also have a great cocktail and wine list. I'll note that aside from Mangia Qui in Harrisburg, there's no better steak within 30 miles. Go get some now! A truly enjoyable experience that will keep us wanting to return for some more. Well done, Tutoni's! read more