I ordered 4 large pizzas for work. Service was fast. Pizza crust was very good. Pepperoni was and sauce was tender. Just a clean fast take out. Do nite when you take out, there is no paper plates or cups. I find that odd. read more

We ordered here and food took over an hour past the pick up time, beyond that they forgot our salad and one sandwich and when I contacted them to get my money back I was met with silence and ignoring. Never give them money.'even if you don't get your food you won't get a refund . read more

Papa Gino's is a pizza chain sprinkled all over Massachusetts like oregano on a cardboard slice. I stopped by the Yarmouth location, hoping for something halfway decent--and left questioning my life choices. The quality is edible, but definitely subpar. It's what you'd expect from a quick, grab-and-go slice--nothing more, probably less. Honestly, it tasted like Costco pizza's less successful cousin. And no shade to Costco which is better in my opinion. Papa Gino's? Just trying to survive one lukewarm slice at a time. Service was fine. Go to the counter, order, they give you your food and you sit. Nothing more to it. The restaurant atmosphere felt like something out of a 90's Pizza Hut. If you're in a pinch and starving, it'll do. But if you're looking for real pizza with any personality or flavor depth, you might want to look elsewhere. read more

Papa Gino's Pizzeria - One bite and I was disappointed. This is emergency pizza. - Pizza Near Me - So. Yarmouth, Massachusetts

Megan helped me today. Amazing service, extremely polite and thrilled to be there. Splendid ambience. The chicken was amazing and I even had leftovers. read more

I have been extremely impressed with the staff at this location. There was a mix up with the uber delivery person twice. Both times I was contacted politely apologized to and it was resolved within 30 minutes by the Manager herself. Bravo to you for being humble enough to do what you have to do for work. Clearly why you have a great staff. read more

How can you mess up on a pepperoni pizza and chicken fingers? I placed a delivery order at 8pm tonight, a Monday night. Called this place at 8:52 and they promised delivery driver "just left." At 9:35 I contacted Grubhub and learned that my order was cancelled. I really hope the owner sees this and questions why their business didn't want to make the $50 I was willing to pay for their probably crap food. Shame on this business. Judging by reviews, this place has totally gone down hill. Pictured is the dinner I got to have. Snacks from the car. read more

Papa Gino's Pizzeria - This was in lieu of the pizza that never arrived. - Pizza Near Me - So. Yarmouth, Massachusetts

I am absolutely gobsmacked at how decent our order was from this place. We had already eaten dinner but were looking for a lil somethin' extra to top everything off. GF wasn't fucking around and ordered a small pizza and some mozz stix. Expectations were guarded but everything arrived quickly and PIPING hot. The cheese was still melty. I wouldn't confuse this shit with anything I could get in NYC but it was surprisingly decent. I really liked the flavor of the sauce. The crust had a touch of that deep dish texture without being deep dish. The mozz sticks were also pretty good. Goldilocks amount of breading. The sauce they provided for dipping, again, was really tasty. Solid work, PG. read more

Great Experience! Megan provided very good service and kept checking in to make sure we had everything we needed. Great food as always.

The service was great and Megan was a great help at the front. she was very kind and helpful. Also the food was great as well.

We were stranded at a local resort with no food options. Amanda and Papa Gino's came to our rescue. The excellent pizza was delivered to our hotel in record time. Amanda even called back to check to make sure the delivery was made and the food was good. Thank you for good food and great service! read more

Used to love this place. Ordered a pepperoni pizza. After delivery fee of $4.99 and tip, it came to almost $40.00. Why is there a delivery fee? I asked the driver and he said they don't receive it at all. So what the hell? It wasn't worth it. I just bought a pizza oven! read more

today I went to papa gino's for a small plain pizza and I got it for free for my birthday. Nice treat thank you papa gino's your little pizza was delicious. read more

The service was slow, and the pizza was quite possibly the worst I have seen and tasted in my entire life. It was drowning in blue cheese to the point where I had to check the receipt to see if I accidentally ordered extra (I did not). The toppings and cheese were basically soup and immediately fell off when I went to separate the slices. I will never be going back to papa Gino's read more

Papa Gino's Pizzeria - Crispy Buffalo Chicken - Pizza Near Me - So. Yarmouth, Massachusetts

See all

Ordered delivery. Boneless wings were basically lightly sauced crumbs. Pizza was okay. No plates included after being requested.

Hardworking crew, nice to customers, and food wasn't bad for fast-food. But it's better not to look at the floors, equipment, or go to the bathrooms, otherwise you may lose your appetite. Owners, please reinvest some money on restructuring the place inside (paint, floors, some kitchen equipments, and that carpet that is smelling). People are supposed to eat your product, your business is screaming for help. We ordered our food and ended up eating in the car. Hope this review helps! read more

Papa Gino's Pizzeria - Barbecue Chicken Wings - Pizza Near Me - So. Yarmouth, Massachusetts

See all

Updated review ! Issue was fixed promptly and decided to order more food it was good no issues with food

Once again ~ FABULOUS FOOD & SERVICE from Papa Gino's South Yarmouth ! The Delivery Staff are Courteous, Polite and Professional ! read more

Quick fast and in a hurry No problems Done when they said done Cheap eat pizza Lots of parking read more

11 am Sunday just opened. IT'S FRIGGIN FREEZING in here, luckily we have sweat shirts in the car. The food was ok. No table service read more

Papa Gino's Pizzeria - pizza and salad - Pizza Near Me - So. Yarmouth, Massachusetts

See all

our order was placed. we were told that it would be delivered in a certain time. time went and not delivered. we called them back and was told that door dash delivers but would be at the desk. I went to hotel's desk at this hotel and the sister hotel next door. no delivery. came back to room and we were told that it was left outside the hotel. went back to the front desk and also checked the sister's hotel. No food left outside. PG was called and they said they had confirmation from door dash that it was delivered. they were told it was not. they would not reverse the charges. my bank will be taking care of this matter. Meanwhile, I will never, ever buy food from them again. poor customer service. read more

My friends are always joking about how "bad" Papa Gino's pizza is/was, since we grew up eating it many decades ago. Well, I always liked it. I bought a few pies and brought them back to the house, and everyone loved the pizza! Fresh and good quality, not too thick, not too thin, and not greasy (like we remembered it.) Nice service, too. read more

Consistently good food and fresh!! Always pleasant drivers as well as in house staff...prices are reasonable and lots of deals available when using the app read more

Pizza was due at 4:30pm, I had to wait until 5:30pm to pick it up. The pizza was not worth the wait!

As a former Papa Gino's employee, I am beyond embarrassed to have been part of this organization. I came in with my daughter and we ordered the lunch specials, thinking that they would be quick. We had an Italian sub and a Caesar salad pocket. After waiting approximately 15 minutes and watching the people on the grill stand around chatting for that amount of time, I asked where our order was. the cashier very kindly went back and he said working on it. now another 10 minutes went by before we received our order. We were not told we could get our drinks out of the cooler or to Pick your chips up on the front rack or anything. The manager did not speak to us, but we did hear her being rude to other people. A man came up to ask a question and he put his arm on the warmer and she said in a somewhat sarcastic tone, "and that would be hot". She told somebody else if they weren't standing in the right line she wasn't going to help them. The food was good. The bread was fresh. All in all I would not return to Papa Gino's again. read more

We ordered on line, it was a 35 min wait, no worries. Then we get a text it will be delivered by door dash, 20+ min later, okay. It gets here an hour later than originally said and the french fries are cold the steak and cheese sub looks like it was sitting and had a finger in it. The absolute worse ever. Never again and will let all my friends know. I am a local year around resident and this is the worse. Tried to call the store and no response, they want you to order online so they can screw you!! read more

Ordered pizza with the works- got upgraded from large to extra large for no additional cost! Yum!

I have had to stop ordering from this location due to their use of Door Dash. I order pizza's for the staff at a business and the last 2 times they call me to say the guy couldn't find the place and he returned the pizza to the restaurant. It's a Nursing Rehab facility literally 3 miles away from Papa Gino's, don't they have GPS? The staff are always polite, the manager offers to remake the pizza for free, but it doesn't fix the problem. Moving on to Yarmouth Pizza by Evan... hoping for a better outcome. read more

Will update my review. Always loved ordering online once a week or so. They changed everything from online ordering to an app that does not work. Not jut me. Family members as well. Used to be super easy. read more

This location is not dependable with deliveries lately - one week they called after the promised online order confirmation time to say that had no delivery person & this week they delivered over an hour after confirmed order delivery time. We have had a routine weekly order going to a local nursing home but since management has changed over the years, it has not had good customer services when periodic glitches occur. When I had an online problem with their website (occurs often), the woman refused to let me use the online code that has to be used within 15 minutes. The previous manager I dealt with yrs ago, Eric, went over & above to exceed customer expectations. I feel like I am bothering them when I have to call on an online delivery problem. It's becoming difficult to continue to support them with so many great delivery options in the area (Dominos & many locally owned stores). read more

Great thin crust pizza. Right amount of sauce couple with the cheese. Good quality control across all the Papa Ginos stores read more

We ordered through door dash but it was a great pizza! A little on the pricey side but overall very great experience!

Amazing service the manager Alaina is incredible super friendly,professional,and respectful,location is always clean my orders are always correct definetly the best Papa Gino's In the area for sure keep it up great work!!!!! read more

Very disappointed with the whole online ordering experience. We were at a local beach in West Yarmouth and when I looked up the Papa Gino's I didn't realize it had transferred me to Grubhub. I was wondering why it was more expensive, the ordering menu was confusing. Two of my children ordered incorrectly because the app was so confusing, I double checked mine, I ordered correctly but they totally screwed up my sub! I was very disappointed in both Grubhub and Papa Gino's that day. read more

This place is trash. I order a pizza to deliver its right next to me 20 seconds away. I see a guy from papa Gino's he has a pizza mind u I live in a complex. So I ask is that for house **** and he says yea so I take it next thing I know their complaining about me taking food. And also they cussed my grandma out and stop delivering to me so FUCK YOU PAPA GINOS read more

What you'd expect from a pizza chain. Not so great ingredients and a not so great pizza. The gentleman who took the order over the phone was courteous and professional, and the delivery person was very nice. But that's about all that we enjoyed from the meal. read more

I placed an order this evening. It was not the first time I have ordered from this papa Gino's. An hour and 20 minutes later, our order had still not arrived. When I called them to see where our order was I was told That I had given them the wrong address and could I please give them the correct address.Are you short time that I had given them the correct address not once but twice when I placed my order.I even told them exactly where we were located with landmarks. I was told initially by the manager that there was nothing she could do about it other than to cancel our order. If I still wanted the order, it would be another 20 minutes. I then spoke to the general manager who did offer to take 20% off of our total but insisted that they had not made a mistake. I found them to be somewhat rude in their customer service. I will no longer support their business. read more

Best food I had all day. Salads were fresh and tasted organic. They accidentally forgot chicken on one of them and they delivered for free not only chicken but a whole nother salad breadsticks and two dressings. That was not something many restaurants do. Also Their breadsticks are so rich and cheesy: delicious. Their buffalo chicken is amazing. We all ate and enjoyed. They are very giving and I downloaded this and logged in to write this because I don't know how to pay them back. I want to visit again before we go back from vacation. Good place recommend. read more

The "pizza" was OK (we are from New Haven, CT so our standards are ridiculously high). It helped for us to think of it as entirely different category of food. What was NOT OK was the FRIGID temperature of this place. When you see patrons huddling together for body warmth while waiting for their food, uh... Adjust the A/C, please. My sons' lips were turning blue. There was a little boy in the next booth who had pulled not only his sun kissed arms, but also his legs, up inside his t shirt. Another woman went to her car and returned with a fleece lined jacket. We ate as fast as we could (before the circulation in my fingertips was gone) and ran out to the glorious humid heat of the outdoors. Please take note. Providing COMFORTABLE air conditioning is excellent. Freezing your customers is cruel. And memorable. read more

This company needs to fix their online ordering. It hasn't worked in MONTHS. The food is acceptable. We order from them about once a month, but you just can't do it online!!!!! read more

I have been going here since I was a kid, always loved the food. It may have slightly changed over the years but it's still great food. The only thing I have never really liked about this place is that it has gotten really out dated really fast. It has been in a dire need of a remodel for over 10+ years now and I hope it gets it some day(I think it got one at some point but I can't even tell). I'm still always going to get their food if I'm in the area but I won't willingly sit there to eat unless the kids really demand so as I'd rather eat in my car. read more