Island Fresh Pizza &amp; Subs

Rocco's Pizza absolutely knocks it out of the park every single time. This is our family's (and our…read morerestaurant family's) go-to spot for pizza and Italian dishes, and for good reason--the food is consistently incredible. The pizza is everything you want: perfectly crisp crust, rich sauce, and generous, high-quality toppings. You can tell they care about every detail. Beyond the pizza, their Italian dishes are just as impressive--comforting, flavorful, and clearly made with experience and pride. The atmosphere is welcoming, the staff treats you like family, and the whole place has that rare, authentic vibe that keeps you coming back. If you're looking for a place that delivers both quality and heart, Rocco's is it. Easily 5 stars.

Great pizza! Thin crispy crust! Didn't think I would find such great pizza outside of the NY/NJ…read morearea.

Meat Lover Pizza

See all

Cheese slice and pepperoni slice. Dressed up with oregano and chili flakes.

Porto Pizza

3.3(81 reviews)

0.9 mi

Popped in for an early lunch, as they were setting out the pies for slices and selected a slice of…read morecheese, and a slice of meatball with roasted red pepper. While those were warming they caught me eyeing the just-placed buffalo chicken pie and asked if i wanted to switch. I held my initial picks and was not disappointed. Perfect thin crust with tasty toppings. Nice little shop, friendly staff. Not sure why so many very positive reviews here offer 4 stars, but i had no complaints!

We tried to grab a slice of roni before going to the ferry, and the server behind the counter told…read moreus "that won't be happening" lol It seemed like a wild response to asking "can i get a slice of roni?" I asked if they had cheese they could add roni to - no, we won't be making any more cheese pizzas. Like they were done making pizza at 6pm? I don't know. We switched gears and got a quesadilla at El Barco. Our friends got there before us and did get some pizza, but it looked dry and sad and their kids refused it. Never a good sign when kids won't eat your pizza...

Hawaiian Pizza Sliced and Coca Cola Zero

Deep dish pepperoni and pineapple

See all

White veggie pizza

Wolf's Den Pizzeria

2.8(57 reviews)

0.9 mi

It was our first time vacationing in Vineyard Haven Tisbury area. We ordered the all cheese pizza &…read moreit was very good. Great crust

So we are in Martha's Vineyard and we go to the pizza place called wolf den pizza and ordered…read morepepperoni pizza to . The service was good and the pizza was great and it was tasty and the crust was delicious it was sweet so overall it was good.

Great specials!

See all

So much oil we had to turn some pizza over to let gravity take it off.

Bobby B's Restaurant & Bakery

3.3(47 reviews)

0.8 mi

Excellent coffee and the avocado toast is yummy! I did without the bacon and mayo...that's a bit…read moremuch. Hit the spot on a Sunday morning while waiting for the ferry.

amazing ice cream and food been coming here for years never been disappointed ! The service was…read moreamazing the women and men working gave an excellent experican!

Bobby B's Restaurant & Bakery - Asked for it to be well done with half pepperoni on one side and pepper on the other side, repeated several times. Didn't really happen...

Asked for it to be well done with half pepperoni on one side and pepper on the other side, repeated several times. Didn't really happen...

See all

Offshore Ale

4.2(538 reviews)

3.1 mi

This eatery is a hidden gem in Oak Bluffs! We usually spend…read moreat least one day on Martha's Vineyard during our stay in Chatham MA but this is the first time we tried Offshore Ale! So glad we found it ... on a very calm street... close to the park very little car traffic going by the outdoor patio! The staff greeted us warmly... welcomed our pup and seated us within minutes! A server greeted us instantly and took our drink order and even asked if we needed a nice fresh bowl of water for our puppy!! Extra Points just for acknowledging the fur-babies!! The lunch menu has an exceptional selection of seafood, fish, chicken and even a few beef dishes!! We ordered and the food was out hot and fresh within 10 minutes!! They even grilled a plain /no salt breast of chicken for our puppy too! Everything was delicious!! The fries that accompanied the sandwiches were out of this world! Usually never finish even half our fries but these were so good we finished one small bucket and nearly all of the second !! Definitely worth a try - casual, relaxing and delicious!!

This is what it's all about!! Great good! Great service! An amazing vibe. The interior is very…read morewelcoming, and the team of workers are too! I got a chance to talk with Mrs. Sue and you can tell she loves what she does. She's truly curated an experience. The owners lead by example. They are truly hands on to make sure you have excellent, fresh, hot, flavorful food and quick and friendly service. The fresh cut fries were definitely not out of bag! You can tell by the freshness ! I'm so glad I stopped by here. You can truly tell this is a family restaurant. Operated by love and you can feel it when you walk in! It was so good I had to come back! The ribs were so tender! Fall off the bone! Great flavor! The potato au gratin was crispy and good! The hot honey wings were amazing!! The flavor was perfect, no notes! I love this place!

Offshore ale

Guacamole and chips

See all

Lazy frog

Giordano's Restaurant

3.6(236 reviews)

3.1 mi

PROS: Food was good, atmosphere was decent, Annie the waitress was friendly, place was clean,…read moreprices are fair, menu variety plentiful, and they had a bar CONS: Hostess was a bit uptight and the service took forever OVERALL: They aren't the fastest but they're still a good restaurant for you to come to

Cash only! No credit…read morecards, no debit cards, and no digital currency! lol Pizza by the slice at one counter. Sandwiches and fried food at the other counter. A few beverages as well. Seems to be the only spot to pick up a slice in the area. Cheese pizza was very tasty and came out quick. Chicken tenders were made from processed homogenized chicken, so make sure you know what you're buying. This is not fresh all white chicken breast or an actual identifiable piece of a chicken - let alone the tenderloin. It's like a McDonald's chicken nugget... Processed meat pressed into a mold. Having said that it was hot and reasonably tasty with the honey mustard sauce

Hair in the food

See all

The Barn Bowl & Bistro

4.5(335 reviews)

2.9 mi

they did a really good job the food was very good…read more Mais que sabores, criamos momentos, histórias e boas memórias." * "Um lugar onde o sabor encontra o aconchego."

Had a great time here. Was able to snag a late night reservation for a line. Reservations online…read morefill up quickly so don't wait too long to book one. Nice inside, not huge but good enough. Food was good and drinks were decent. If you're looking for something to do in MV and you like bowling, this is your place to go.

Curry Mussels

See all

Alpaca Punch

Back Door Donuts

4.3(570 reviews)

3.1 mi

Really amazing! We…read morewalked by in the morning and the smell almost pulled us inside by the nostrils. Instead we came back in the afternoon and enjoyed a glazed chocolate cake donut as a late day snack. It was soft on the inside with just a hint of crisp around the edges. The glaze was perfect. The flavor was deep chocolate with just the right amount of sweetness. 10/10. Stop by when in town and have a donut... or grab a box to go.

We saw a line coming out of Back Door donuts and decided to pass on the crowd, then later on in the…read moreday, swung by after 11am, and it had died down a bit - we were grateful to find some quiet on the busy 4th of July visit. Anyways, I was so happy to see something savoury available, I ordered a Spinach Feta Croissant and looking around, I spotted the donut I knew that I had to have. When in Martha's Vineyard, anything Jaws themed is an automatic yes! They have Jaws donuts and they are too cute to not get. Everything was what you'd expect, nothing out of this world, but I did love the theming of the donut. Perfect for a photo opp and a sugar rush.

See all

Merch

Mikado Asian Bistro

3.7(87 reviews)

0.9 mi

Great place. Enjoyed the servive, the food and the not too crazy price. We will come back. Hidden…read morejewel.

Grabbed a to-go order of sushi and sesame chicken. Service was very friendly and the order was…read morecorrect but that's where the good ends. Hubby and i agreed, none of it had any flavor and the texture of the sushi was just mush. I was sooo craving a good sushi night and this just wasn't it. Very disappointed.

Chirashi, Spicy Scallop Roll, Spicy Yellowtail Roll, Spicy Salmon Roll

See all

Spring Rolls- the dipping sauce was 5 Super fresh maybe ginger? Not your typical sweet or duck sauce

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Tom C.

Elite 25

2

155

0

7 years ago

Just up the hill. I was happy with the pie. Will definitely return many more times.

Island Fresh Pizza & Subs - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Island Fresh Pizza & Subs also viewed

Porto Pizza

3.3

(81 reviews)

Popped in for an early lunch, as they were setting out the pies for slices and selected a slice of…read morecheese, and a slice of meatball with roasted red pepper. While those were warming they caught me eyeing the just-placed buffalo chicken pie and asked if i wanted to switch. I held my initial picks and was not disappointed. Perfect thin crust with tasty toppings. Nice little shop, friendly staff. Not sure why so many very positive reviews here offer 4 stars, but i had no complaints!

We tried to grab a slice of roni before going to the ferry, and the server behind the counter told…read moreus "that won't be happening" lol It seemed like a wild response to asking "can i get a slice of roni?" I asked if they had cheese they could add roni to - no, we won't be making any more cheese pizzas. Like they were done making pizza at 6pm? I don't know. We switched gears and got a quesadilla at El Barco. Our friends got there before us and did get some pizza, but it looked dry and sad and their kids refused it. Never a good sign when kids won't eat your pizza...

Rocco's Pizzeria

4.2

(78 reviews)

Rocco's Pizza absolutely knocks it out of the park every single time. This is our family's (and our…read morerestaurant family's) go-to spot for pizza and Italian dishes, and for good reason--the food is consistently incredible. The pizza is everything you want: perfectly crisp crust, rich sauce, and generous, high-quality toppings. You can tell they care about every detail. Beyond the pizza, their Italian dishes are just as impressive--comforting, flavorful, and clearly made with experience and pride. The atmosphere is welcoming, the staff treats you like family, and the whole place has that rare, authentic vibe that keeps you coming back. If you're looking for a place that delivers both quality and heart, Rocco's is it. Easily 5 stars.

Great pizza! Thin crispy crust! Didn't think I would find such great pizza outside of the NY/NJ…read morearea.

Bobby B's Restaurant & Bakery

3.3

(47 reviews)

Excellent coffee and the avocado toast is yummy! I did without the bacon and mayo...that's a bit…read moremuch. Hit the spot on a Sunday morning while waiting for the ferry.

amazing ice cream and food been coming here for years never been disappointed ! The service was…read moreamazing the women and men working gave an excellent experican!

Pizzeria Gemelle

4.0

(48 reviews)

A great pizza option in downtown Nantucket that has limited seating, a fun vibe and solid…read moreneopolitan style pizza. Not large, but enough for 2 people (especially if you have a side salad). I ordered about 7 pizzas online and they did add a mandatory 20% tip and they don't pick up the phone, so you couldn't even order via phone. And then when picking up said pizzas, which was quite a lot to carry, there was no offer to help carry them, paper plates, napkins, etc.. And, some of the pizzas were not cut through (and when they do cut the pies, they only cut them in 4 large slices). Again, just some customer service opportunities, especially if you're going to force a 20% gratuity on orders, but not really offer any great service. So, there it is. Nantucket prices, for solid pizza. Ordering online wasn't the best UX, but you get what you get, sometimes.

Pizza was very mediocre. And the clerk was a little entitled. Total came to $6.42 and I gave $7,…read moreand he didn't give me the change. I was planning on putting the change in the tip can anyway, since I hate carrying change, but to automatically assume that and not give the change is a little messed up.

Sophie T's Pizza

3.4

(65 reviews)

Decent pizza option in Nantucket if you aren't wanting to venture out for the evening. We ordered…read morein and had no issues with delivery. It was a little cold and lacking in flavor overall but not bad. Probably wouldn't order again but it might be better in person and the delivery guy was really nice.

Ordered a $37 custom pizza with pepperoni, bacon and extra sauce, got a nasty plain cold pizza for…read more"Claire" (not my name). This is the second time this place has been the absolute worst delivery option on the island. These is even after i called MULTIPLE TIMES this evening to make sure they knew my order and where to deliver it after last time. I called the restaurant six times after our poor delivery driver was told by Sophie's to bring this pizza to us and got no answer. Guess we'll have to get our money back via disputing the charge? This place shouldn't be allowed to operate a delivery service.

Pi Pizzaria

3.3

(151 reviews)

Great pizza, beautiful outdoor seating, delicious drinks. Slow but kind service…read more Wine was served in a water glass which was very disappointing and negatively affected our experience here. They should consider serving wine in a wine glass, especially if they are charging 17 dollars for one glass of wine.

The pizza is great. Light, crisp and great toppings. The white clam is great. The pizza overall is…read moreon the lighter side but overall surprisingly excellent pizza to be found on an island. Would recommend just getting take out and buying wine at the stop and shop to eat at home instead of buying bottles at the restaurant as they are marked up substantially.

Moto Slice Shack

4.8

(5 reviews)

Good pizza. Got a half pepperoni and half plain. A little too greasy but good. Located in a group…read moreof shops with a mini golf,cafe,ice cream parlor and more.

The pizza is outstanding. So are the guys who work there. I needed 4 pizzas for a wedding party and…read morethey came through quickly and deliciously!!

Fella's Take Out

3.4

(5 reviews)