This was a terrible experience. The pizzas are wildly overpriced and are lower quality than if you bought a frozen pizza. Avoid at all costs and don't believe any of the reviews. read more

Island Fresh Pizza - Gross pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

Made us the wrong pizza which I went ahead and accepted. But, the pizza I accepted did not have the ingredients listed. Need to do better!

Pizza is not good by any measure. Sandpaper bottom and crust that is like a cracker. Cheese is ok, sauce average. I know that MV pizza is not NY or Boston, but there has to be some standard and I'm puzzled as to how this place gets 4 stars. read more

Absolutely slow and indifferent service. Not a single smile or happy word. Better to order takeout, and show up when it is ready. If you come in and wait, you'll wait a long time: it took them 55 minutes to make a single sub. A single sub. PS, I wrote this review while I was waiting for my sandwich. At the same time, a young woman came in and asked for a slice of pizza. The counter people just ignored her. She was very polite and asked them why they wouldn't acknowledge her - and they simply refused to answer. PPS, I finally got my sub. It was actually REALLY GOOD. More's the pity, then, that weird customer interactions make this place a no-go. read more

This pizza has 0 love or technique put into it. Very reminiscent of a frozen pizza. The sauce seemingly has no seasoning and the crust tastes like nothing. Underwhelming would be a generous term for this spot. read more

Never ever return Nasty behind counter aggressive to customers. Unbelievably rude. Pizza tasteless overpriced cardboardy. Worst overall . read more

I want to start off by saying, they have super friendly staff. That goes a long way with me. I ordered a small Margherita pizza. It came up to $15 (including tax), this is pricy for me but I like to support small businesses. The pizza ingredients were as fresh as they come but the taste just wasn't there. It was bland, barely any basil, no olive oil and only large cut up pieces of tomato. I'm sure a sauce would have made the pizza a lot less dry. That's why I gave them a 4 star. Maybe if I had tried something different, I'd be happier...for now, it's a 4 star experience. read more

Stopped in to pick up a sandwich. Pleasantly surprised. Great sandwich. The place could be cleaned up a bit; but I would go back for take out. read more

Great recommendations and the sandwiches were delicious, especially with fresh-made bread.

Very friendly staff but the pizza is bad. The crust is like cardboard, the cheese has no flavor. The garden salad was fine, with Ken's dressing. read more

Favorite Pizza place on the Island. Fresh ingredients. Nice people. Get the Paulo Special :)

Too thick for my taste but quality ingredients and generously cheezed. Hit the spot at 9:30 on a stormy evening hungry after getting off the ferry. I think it must be owned by Brazilians after a gander at the menu. All in all, perfectly serviceable but undistinguished pizza. read more

Listen this place has the best food on the island. I visited yesterday after coming to Martha's Vineyard for the second time and this girl at the front have the most amazing personality and her voice was soothing from the phone call to the pick up. I would recommend the food and the service is an added plus for me. The world needs more people like that young lady read more

Very okay pizza, nothing special, but would be okay for a random take out night on Martha's Vineyard. Everything is so-so

They have the best steak and cheese sub on the island. Fresh homemade bread and great prices. The pizza is really good too. We like the "island special" the best. I like how they are open late for the vineyard also. Highly recommend!! read more

The veggie calzone I ordered was AMAZING!!! You the homemade dough was soft and crispy at the same time! I asked them to add Buffalo sauce to my calzone and it was sooo TASTY!! read more

This place may be the best pizza place on the island. They make their own bread for the subs, (which are amazing, so cheesy!) and their pizzas are fresh and delicious. They're Brazilian, so all of the pizzas have quirky modifications that are uncommon and so worth it! Highly recommended! Although, be prepared to wait. With good quality comes a good wait! read more

DELICIOUS! Got on island today with a hankering for pizza. The dough is delicious...and you can specify extra thin or thick crust. mmmmm As a food snob what really impressed me was the quality of the food--you can taste they use top quality ingredients in everything from the dough to the cheese---this place doesnt skip!And they know how to cook a pizza... And check out all the cool toppings! https://www.facebook.com/pages/Island-Fresh-Pizza-Subs/1424011287929696?sk=reviews&ref=page_internal Its not a dine in place, but I enjoyed grabbing my pizza and sitting by the beach up on West Chop. There is plenty of parking and the people are super cool. Get a slice or a whole pie, you'll be glad you did! Get it while its HOTTTT read more

I think this is probably the best pizza on the island. The service was excellent. I ordered 7 pies, and she threw in the 7th for free. The ladies who run it are very friendly and carried my pies to the car for me. We got the eggplant pizzas, the margherita, the steak and cheese, the sweet and spicy (a bit to hot and spicy for us), and the hamburger, and they were a big hit with our crowd, who hail from all over the east coast and are not easy to please. In all honesty, we researched all the places to get pizza, and none of them had great reviews on the island. We felt like we were taking a chance, but it was a home run and we were very happy! read more

We ordered last night. Pepperoni pizza was outstanding! Thinish crust, lots of salty cheese and pepperoni's. We also ordered a veggie pizza which was also good. Very tasty. read more

The best pizza on the island, and the service has no equal, Portuguese pizza the best pizza, delicious and very tasty

Happened upon this place while grocery shopping next door and the pizza was great, the customer service was superb.

I visited Island Fresh again this Tuesday after a mediocre visit a few weeks ago. I had spoken to one of the owners (husband and wife) and had to try it again. Order taken swiftly and politely. Pizza was one of the finest, if not THE finest. One thing this island does not have is great pizza, until I tried theirs. SUPER fresh dough and perfectly cooked. We ordered two steak and cheese subs with mayo, raw onions, pickles and lettuce. They were on a lightly (perfectly toasted I may add!) toasted roll, and when opened up actually had eye appeal! NOT just. Thrown together. Now as I bit into them, the flavor exploded inside my mouth! Perfectly seasoned, and juicy, but NOT greasy. We savored every bite. Our meal was tendered to us by the other owner, Paulo, who took time to speak about how hard is was to operate a business on MV, especially with the lack of help. I am in the service/sales business and know what he is talking about. I give this business 5 stars, as they are a kind and great couple who WANT to EARN your business with a quality meal that is fairly priced. I will make this one of my "go to" when I am on island on Tuesdays. Thank you again for a super experience! read more

the best pizza im recommend brazilians and american subs and good price read more

Island Fresh Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

Great pizza! We went traditional with Paulo's Special (basic combination), a cheese, and one of their Brazillian pizzas, the Portuguesa. We loved the Portuguesa, and would love to try the other Brazaillian offerings. The traditional pizzas were great too. Lots of cheese. Highly recommended. read more

Food is great but I went in to pick it up today and it is as freezing inside as it is out!!! Is is about 20 degrees outside right now and poor kids have to work in this cold there is obviously no heat. read more