Rainy day, delivery. Tonight worth the $4.50 delivery charge. Ordered the 5 topping $12 deal, did half this, half that twice, then 3 whole choice toppings-it was perfect. Straight down a line perfect. I'm slightly allergic to some things on my hubs side, no prob! And, as always, the best crust and sauce flavor of them all. Highly recommend. read more

If I could give 0 starts I would . First of all. Order was delivered at a wrong place . Delivery guy said sorry that's what I saw in the Gps. Store person said that's not my problem, it's door dash problem (I did not order through door dash ). Then delivery guys goes get the order from whatever he left it at. And brought it back to my house . (20 minutes later ) I still didn't complained , but one of the pizzas didn't have an ingredient I paid extra for . I call the store , they said they don't have that ingredient , so she decided it go double up the ingredients (I did saw a bunch of jalapeño and bell peppers ) which I didn't preferred but I guess that's what she thought it was better instead of ask the client before . I called to report this issue. Pizza is extra spicy and was over $25 Total of the order $75 Horrible service . Horrible delivery . I don't about the quality of the food because I won't be able to eat it my pizza :( . I should have gone to the local small pizza place . This big chains are a joke . read more

Papa John's Pizza was so bad that we had to throw it out after eating a piece. I don't do that! I hate wasting food. But it was extremely expensive and extremely bad. read more

We ordered the veggie pizza, medium size and it was $21! Baked it and it was doughy in the middle, could not bake it any longer because it would have been burnt. Chose the regular crust and I think they must have given me the thin crust. What a waste of money! read more

Placed an order 3 hours before closing on DoorDash and as soon as I placed the order they cancelled it and I called and no answer multiple times. I know at this time they don't have customers or a valid reason to sit and ignore the phone lol just lazy workers not wanting to work and make a simple DoorDash order.. so now I have to wait 3-5 business days to get my money back because of the laziness of whoever decided to turn off DoorDash AFTER I had paid and placed my order read more

Ordered $100+ of pizza/ bread sticks for my daughters Bday , specified 5:30pm delivery & it came over an hour early AND without the salad I'd ordered/ paid for! Pretty good pizza but now going to be cold when everyone arrives. Ugh! read more

Ordered a pepperoni pizza online. When I received my pizza, it was plain cheese. When asked about the order, the employees got mad and yelled at me stating I ordered a chefs pizza with a side of pepperoncini. They refused to make the order correct. Last time I'll be getting a pizza here for sure. read more

This franchise is absolute trash. I pre-ordered several hours early. Not only was my pizza 30 mins late, but it was also wrong. Wrong sauce and a wrong topping. I called 20mins after my pizza was supposed to be delivered to ask when it would be delivered and the "manager" had an attitude. I would never recommend. And I want my money back for the pizza that was late and wrong. read more

The pizza here is always good. The people who work there are always friendly and helpful. And the delivery driver (the dark haired man) is great. I wish I could remember his name!! If you haven't tried them I suggest you give them a try. read more

Hard pass on the new Taco pizza. First one of their Pizza's I didn't enjoy! Completely meatless and the only flavor I could detect was olives. I ended up cooking & adding some chorizo which made it tolerable. B read more

Too an hour to get it delivered. Pizza didn't come with pepperoncini. The app showed it had been delivered already so I called the store and they said they alter it and lie and say it's been delivered so that they get better times and clear their orders. The delivery driver also stated the same thing. Pretty sad that papa johns spends thousands of dollars on an app to show delivery time and the employees alter the system when they are late on deliveries to look good. read more

The pizza is good but they continue to rip customers off with their ads. In the Yuba Sutter Shopper they have had an Online Special stating the price at $14.49 and they continue to charge $14.99 on the online checkout. I have brought this to the attention of the owner and others when I pick up my pizza and MONTHS later nothing has changed. So BEWARE! read more

I usually do not write a negative review but feel I must. My husband and I moved to Northern California the end of 2018. We came from Southern California. Where we lived in San Bernardino and PapaJohns was our pizza place. The pizza was above the rest. The quality was excellent and so was the staff. I decided to order from the one in our current location which is Yuba City. I ordered a deep dish cheese and a regular pepperoni. Pan Pizza: I added extra cheese because I love extra cheese but also I knew that pan pizza's have more sauce. I couldn't wait to get my order and delve into my pizza. I opened the box and was extremely upset. The cheese did not even cover the sauce. The sauce was oozing out. I knew from looking at it that I would be having a sauce pizza not a cheese pizza. I called and mentioned how unhappy I was. The manager Dez proceeded to tell me about the sauce and that I should have ordered more cheese than what I did. I reminded him I did order extra cheese and that it should have covered the sauce. He told me next time I should order ever more cheese and ask for less sauce. He would not remake my pizza. To my trained eye it did not look like my extra cheese was even put on there. I was not given a receipt. I was very upset. I did try one slice of the pizza. As expected I had a sauce pizza The cheese that was on there slid off and so I was left with a sauce pizza. I did not want to eat a sauce pizza so, I threw the pizza away. Pepperoni: The pepperoni looked great but was not at all like Southern California PapaJohns. The quality was not even close. The pepperoni was for my husband mainly but I ended up having some. He was far from impressed as I was. After seeing my pizza and having his own , he vowed as I did to never order from them again. As you may know PapaJohns is not cheap. I just wasted hard earned money on them! Like I said never again!! Little Caesars is better than them!! Now that's saying something!! read more

Requested delivery of half cheese and half pepperoni. Delivered on time and with a nice smile. As far as the quality of the pizza, wow, disappointed. I've been meaning to try them since they came to Yuba City, oh well, been there done that. Moving on! read more

Dear Steven W, I am a partner at Papa John's in YC and my name is Dev. I read your review and was disappointed. I assure you we care very much about our customers and product quality. In fact, I would love to invite you for a quick tour of the store where you can meet our friendly team and even make a few pizzas for yourself at no cost! Please contact the store at 777-3925 or email me direct at dev566@yahoo.com Thanks for the tip on the shopper ad, I will have that updated before the May issue. read more

Today on Sunday December 22nd 2019, my fiance and I ordered two pizzas, and needless to say, we were completely unsatisfied with their service. We tracked the order online and it said it would arrive between 5:25 and 5:35, but they showed up at 5:50. Now I get that delivery drivers will be late once in awhile, but DO NOT MARK ON THE WEBSITE THAT THE DELIVERY WAS MADE TO THE HOUSE WHEN IT CLEARLY HASN'T ARRIVED! Also, this is not the first time that the tracker said the pizza would arrive at a certain time and they were late. read more

Best chain pizza in the area. Get a great value from coupons, instore, and online specials. read more

Pros: - Great service - Friendly, professional employees - Food that looks like it came from an advertisement - Clean - Rewards program Cons: - Prices I don't have a Papa John's in my city (please put one in Chico!) so I stop at the Yuba City restaurant whenever I'm in the area. I use the Papa John's app on my phone to place my order and pay for it (It's worth noting that any deals available are on the app to take advantage of.) When I arrive at the restaurant my food is not only ready but everything is the way I ordered it INCLUDING all of the extra dipping sauces! I've been very impressed by the employees. They are friendly and competent. My entire order is always shown to me before I leave. I feel valued as a customer. In the world of mega pizza-chains this is how you do it right. read more

Fist I thought it very near to my house, easy to reach, even by foot, but it is cheap not according the test I like, good luck k to them. Good. Customers service though read more

Quality and consistency whenever I get delivery. The food has changed over the years - not as good as it used to be but still tasty. It's lost the "WOW" factor I think is the best way to put it. But this one always delivers on time and the food is fresh. read more

I always feel welcome in this store. the employees always seem very happy! the food is hella bomb! definitely my go to when it comes to pizza! read more

Got a meat lovers pizza, BBQ wings, and stuffed bacon cheese sticks for $24. Not bad. And it all looks amazing! :) yum!! read more

See all

I have been ordering from Papa John's since they opened. The customer service can't be topped and the food is great. When I'm quoted a time length for delivery they are ALWAYS under it. I will not get pizza from anyone else in town. Thank you for the wonderful service and food. read more

Great time delivery for an early dinner...ordered at 4:45p and eta at 30 mins. delivered...for two med. size pizzas and tastes great too cuz it's still warm. read more

Decided to try Papa John's veggie pizza and it's was really good and the customer service was 10/10. Highly recommend giving it try specially when they have the 12.99 5 topping pizza. Thumbs up from me. read more

I usually like papa Johns but this time for some reason the crust was really thin. I ordered original crust like I always do on both pizzas. I think they may be cutting corners to save money now so I highly doubt I will be going back. read more

I have been to the new store twice,(i like the pizza) it is more expensive then Papa Murphy;s but i like the crust better then Papa Murphy's, i do wish Papa John's employees would wear the plastic gloves while making the pizza,might be one reason ill go back to papa Murphy's , read more

Went their for the first time yesterday. My whole family loved the pizza. Soo good. After hearing so many negative reviews that's why I didn't go but I went to check it out for myself and its great. The crust was perfect and the ingredients were so good too. This is my new fave pizza place and the prices are good too. read more

Do NOT waste your money on a pizza from Papa Johns! We have never had one before & were suckered into ordering one based on all the commercials stating "better quality, better ingredients", etc. We were VERY disappointed & when we called the manager to complain, there was no offer to try & make it right (even though the box says 100% satisfaction guaranteed!) Our pizza had NO taste, was VERY skimpy on the toppings, & was worse than any frozen pizza we've ever eaten! It was just gross!! If there was a way to not give this business any stars, I would not give them even one! read more

Great pizza! Almost always have some type of online coupon to get awesome deals. They're friendly and quick to get your order ready

Great pizza and great service! If you are looking for a quality pizza in Yuba City then this is your choice. Awesome selection of gourmet pizza was well as the classics. read more

So I'm going to begin by talking about the customer service part first. I ordered my pizza online and I made a mistake and ordered cheese pizza instead of pepperoni and cheese. I showed up to pick up my prepaid pizza and the young lady opens the box to show it to me. I was disappointed that it wasn't a pepperoni and as I began to explain to her that they made the wrong pizza she shows me the sticker on how it came through as a cheese pizza and quickly adds that she will remake it for me. I then realize I made the mistake when placing the order online. So, although it was clearly my mistake, she never told me what an idiot I was and didn't argue with me, she just wanted to make sure I was a satisfied customer. I didn't have them remake it but she did add some pepperonis on it and I was embarrassed but happy. I apologized for my mistake and went home and enjoyed a good tasting pizza. Now this isn't the best tasting pizza in the world but for their fair inexpensive prices the quality and taste is perfect. Every time I have ordered from this establishment I have been a satisfied customer. Thank you Papa Johns for your above the top customer service and for your good food on those hot NorCal days when this momma doesn't feel like cooking. read more

We eat here at least once a week. Friendly staff and delicious pizza! Try The Works (red sauce), or the Spinach Garlic Alfredo if you like white sauce. They have coupons and specials all the time making it affordable! read more

Great service overall. Just don't expect any discounts or deals. They always seem to give the coupons after the order has been placed. Go figure. We try and eat here every other week when we're looking to watch a movie with the family or just grab a quick bite. read more

Pizza was done on time. However, the crust was burnt.

The food is whatever pizza is okish. The garlic knot was not cooked fully. Inside of the garlic knot I can smell and feel the dough. I am going to put pictures so you all can see (I am not making this up). I believe in second chances. Boy was that a mistake. The pizzas we order were not cooked well. Some chicken pieces and the veggies fell right off the pizza when I held it up to take a bite. Don't waste your time. read more

See all

Papa john has pretty good pizza. I had their chicken pizza the other day and my family definitely all enjoyed it. They have great customer service and the store next door has the cheapest sodas in town. Great experience. I would recommend others to try. read more

Once again tried after 10 years. This place is snobby & does not know their programs. Ad in the shopper says order on line-but no promo code to use coupon. Cashier said since they had my delivery address. I would get my papa rewards credit. Then I call manager DEV. The guy does not care at all. He is in the wrong town to treat people like that. Ask all the corporate places that are GONE. Pizza is pretty good but after reading that they don't wear gloves. Plus the people who work in the store. I don't trust them not to spit in pizza. To bad they have some creative pizza's. read more

I have ways had a great experience here. The staff is very friendly, they have only made a mistake on a pizza once, they quickly made new one correctly. They always have great coupon deals, fast delivery, and they make a GOOD pizza. The white garlic chicken with bacon... Yeah. Add Jalepenos. You might get heartburn but YOU WON'T REGRET IT! read more

Ask how to cook prior ti leaving, not all pizzas have the same directions. Sometimes can be soggy or under cooked. Staff is nice, clean place. Its cheaper to go sams club and get the ready to cook pizzas. read more