Papa&#x27;s Pizza

It was good pizza, I gave it 4 stars because I watched the cooked take the pizza out the oven and…read morenotice it was missing a few pepperoni's, add them, cut the pizza and then hand it to me.

There is not much meat in my sandwich will not come back and there's food or trash in my drinkread more

Fried zucchini

Medium pepperoni pizza

Dimaria's NY pizza and Italian restaurant

See all

Two Cousins Pizza & Italian Restaurant

3.9(53 reviews)

0.6 mi

We were in town for a meeting, and looking for a place to grab a quick dinner. So thankful we…read morefound this one! Staff was friendly and helpful, ambiance was fine for grabbing a bite, and the food - top notch! I asked if they had any gluten free pasta, and I couldn't believe my luck when he replied: "I think we have some GF lasagna." Wow!! Homemade lasagna with homemade pasta. I could've eaten half the pan - it was so good. Wish I lived closer!

The Italian sub is great. The rolls are wonderful! We get it with no onions but with pickled/spicy…read morepeppers. Just the right amount of meat.

Cheese calzone

See all

Pizza with all toppings

Today's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

3.7(70 reviews)

1.9 mi

We were wanting pizza but wanted it delivered, so we remembered a menu we had gotten in the mail…read more Delivery for $30 order. Easy! We ordered a med cheese calzone, a med NY Style cheese pizza, and a tour of italy including soup and garlic bread. We ordered that for tomorrow night. Such a friendly staffer took our order and delivered it! The portions are huge! The taste is very good, worth the price to get delivery. We have enough for 3 meals I'm sure! The only hiccup is the tour of italy was missing the lasagna. It only had spaghetti and stuffed shells. We are very happy with our decision to stay in and let fresh made Italian food be delivered to our door!

Very good cheese steak! Bun was exceptionally fresh and hard outside soft inside. Very juicy and…read moretasty! Want Angelo's in Philly but i liked!

SpongeBob Squarepants!!!

NY style cheese

See all

They gorgeous a new sign! - February 2026

Amato’s Wood Fire Pizza & Italian Restaurant

3.6(34 reviews)

0.5 mi

This was our first visit, and we were surprised by how busy the place was on a Thursday night. The…read moresignage refers to essentially 3 different kinds of restaurants: a dining room, a pizzeria, and a takeout counter. We were in more of a dining room mood but we weren't asked for our opinion and were taken to a high 2-person table in what we assumed was the pizzeria. I have a temperamental back, so these chairs were not going to work for me, so we asked to be relocated to a nicer table. We were shown to another table right away. Both the dining room and pizzeria were nearly full, and hopping with energy! Our expectations were high! Any restaurant that serves Guinness beer on tap earns a bonus star from me! Unfortunately, the flavor was a little off and I get the impression that not too many customers drink the Guinness. It struck me as beer that was a little past its expiration date. Thankfully our food was very good. Everything had a distinctive and agreeable flavor. Even the bread and olive oil had us cutting extra slices. I ordered the quattro formatti pizza and added bacon. It was as unique and tasty as it sounds. If you look closely at the picture you'll see that someone took a bite before I had a chance to photograph it. But apart from that, notice all the different colors and textures, which made for a nice, lively pizza. In the other photo you can see the chicken parmigiana, which they agreed to substitute Alfredo sauce instead of marinara. That was a delicious dish as well! We ended up way too full for dessert!! It's too bad because there were lots of interesting options to choose from. If we ever find ourselves in Mount Joy again we'll surely consider coming here again. The only thing that left a bad taste was the old-tasting beer.

We were here this past weekend. We got there early, absolutely desolate. Absolutely nobody was in…read morethere that we could see. We ordered our drinks and our food. You would think a restaurant would bring the appetizers out first but no that's not what happened they brought the appetizers with the main meal. That was ridiculous and should never have happened. They were not busy whatsoever. Our waitress was also not very good, again no one in there at all that we saw. She seemed more annoyed with having to wait on us. Very disappointed. My sandwich was great. Calamari was just ok! Not horrible just ok. Boneless wings were not good at all, hard and lacked sauce. Cheese steak that my other half order was strange more like chopped burger than steak! Disappointing visit will be quite a while before we return!!!

Cheeseburger

Cheese Pizza with Marinara Sauce - thin crust

See all

Crispy wings...best around

Ruffino's Pizza & Pasta

4.3(55 reviews)

7.3 mi

LOVE the cheese steaks and onion rings!…read more This is a favorite stop when we travel between MD and Douglasville, PA. The cheese steaks are served on pizza dough rolls that are phenomenally good, and the sandwich is otherwise very much in the Philadelphia tradition. We discovered this place before having to give up gluten, and we still go back: it's worth the consequences of "cheating" on our GF diet - it's THAT good! The onion rings have just the right ratio of batter to onion and are cooked to perfection. Service is always friendly. Highly recommended.

Ruffinos has always been our #1 go to place! The food is delicious, service is always great and…read moreLinda is wonderful! Very accommodating and friendly!

Perfectly cooked underside

Large pizza 50/50 (mushroom/cheese)

See all

Menu

Garofalo's Calabria

5.0(1 review)

4.7 mi

I stay at the Comfort Inn and Suites in Manheim Pa at 543 Champ Blvd a couple times a week. That's…read morewhere they are located for now. Finally trying the food tonight I am blown away and stuffed. I had the stuffed manicotti with bolognese sauce, the margherita pizza and the zuppa dessert. Everything was great, better than great. It was amazing and Ryan is an awesome person to talk with as well. Whether you are travelling along Hwy 283 or live in the area, make sure to stop by and give this place a shot. You won't regret it.

From the owner: Italy has many influences and is not like any other Italian cuisine that you may have had before…read more By being a sustainable country in itself, a lot of the practices are reflected into our business. Whole utilizations of all food product, respect for the environment by which it is grown in, and the influences of conscious farm-to-table practices are very important to us. We source locally so we know exactly where our products come from and how they are grown. While supporting our local economy, we strive to make a positive impact in the Culinary Arts and the Food Trucking industry in hopes to boost said industries in a direction of healthy eating and more diverse food options. Respect for food goes beyond sourcing locally, it is to serve it as beautifully as possible, one ingredient at a time. Your food should be enjoy, not just eaten. Our exotic Calabrian foods will accentuate the palate of the consumer, while building long lasting relationships. We wish for you to follow us to Italy...

I love margherita pizza!!

Join Us ALL day long on June 16, 2017! Terrific Old World Italian Cuisine Lots of fun and Give-a-ways

See all

Love the location. The grass is so green and soft.

Joy's Tavern

3.5(45 reviews)

0.5 mi

Now don't get me wrong the food was great. We got their pizza pretzel nuggets, boneless wings, and…read moretheir French Dip sliders! If it was just based on food we would have scored this establishment a 5 star. The server we had was very friendly and was working incredibly hard! He was great! Unfortunately, we got there at 6pm and didn't receive our food until around 730pm. The restaurant was very understaffed. I believe there was only 2 servers/bartenders and 2 employees working in the kitchen. Joys is clean, we'll kept, and has tvs at every table which is a plus during NFL season!

Visiting from out of state, after a long drive, we stopped by Joy's Tavern for late eats. Service…read moreby the waitress was little to none. Never welcomed to the establishment. Found our own table in the dining area. Located our own menus to review. Waitress never introduced themselves. "Did you decide want you want?" Never received napkins without asking. Actually, had to utilize the restrooms to wash hands as the waitress did not return to the table. Ask for the TV channel to be changed, never addressed. The topper was that the water glasses were refilled with hot water as the ice melted instantly. The waitress seemed more engaged with their required server closing chores. Definitely, shared a more generous service tip than the service deserved. Suggest a little staff training, because a successful restaurant will not be successful without patrons.

Finger something flavor

See all

Pizza Pretzel Nuggets

Marco's Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.3(53 reviews)

4.5 mi

Marco's is head and shoulders above an unusual glut of local pizza options in a small river town…read morelike Marietta, PA. Their pizza has a good crust -- thin enough to fold and eat, but with a good flavor as well. (Sicilian style also is available if you prefer a thicker crust.) Like all good pizza, you don't need to hide this under a pile of toppings. Just the pizza, maybe just add pepporoni or mushrooms or whatever your favorite is. When I was new to Marietta, I tried all the local places and Marco's is #1 for pizza, and also #1 for having a full menu. Marco's also has a meatball sub that would make your Italian grandma blush. Order it with a layer of mozzerella on top and it comes out all toasted and crispy and tasting like childhood in NYC. The menu has other Italian staples like pasta and garlic bread, but it doesn't stop there. If you want some turkey with mashed potatoes and gravy, Marco's has it. Or for lunch, go for the burger special. It's all good, and served with a smile every time!

Not fancy by any means. If you are looking for ambiance, go elsewhere. The menu is varied, you can…read moreget sandwiches, pizza, Italian food and other choices. The prices are very fair and the bar prices are also affordable. Down home friendly service. Had zeppolis for dessert---$4.10 and 3 people couldn't finish them. My wife had veal parm and I had chicken cacciatore. Both dishes were very tasty. Again, not fancy, not gourmet, but very good for and wholesome. Great value.

Grease, a soggy gross pile of grease.

Tell me you have no clue how to make and box a pizza, without telling me you have no clue how to make a pizza.

See all

I was served a warm ass beer too. Lol!!

Caruso's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.8(44 reviews)

5.6 mi

We are very particular pizza entrepreneurs, this is our favorite in the Mount Joy/Columbia area…read more Great onion rings, delicious shrimp salad too. Yummy!

Pizza is incredible. Cheese is always melted and not too greasy. The undercarriage is perfect and I…read morethink even Dave Portnoy would like this place. Two slices for five bucks is a great deal and they normally give you big old slabs. Love this place great service great atmosphere.

Dairy-free (vegan) pizza. Yum!

See all

Cheese stake

Parma Pizza And Grill

3.4(33 reviews)

5.7 mi

•$$$$

First time here. Interior is much smaller than I assumed based on exterior. There is a parking…read morelot for convenience. They have a nice selection of options in the display counter including paninis, pepperoni rolls, and different pizzas. I chose to go with the Build Your Own Cheesesteak. First you choose your meat (beef or chicken), type of cheese, and toppings. It did not seem like there was a limit to how many different toppings I could add before there would be an additional upcharge. I ordered steak, provolone, sauce, fried onions, mushrooms and hot peppers. The steak lacked seasoning so I added salt and pepper on my own. I must admit the roll was stuffed and often little bits of the filling would fall into my plate while eating. The roll held together despite me believing it wouldn't. The young men behind the counter were helpful with making my selection and were patient with me while I asked questions and pricing for items on the counter. My food was prepared quickly and served at my table in less than 10 minutes. Overall, I might stop in again if I'm in the area. The experience was decent but didn't stand out.

Great service, great food, great price. I got a medium cheesesteak calzone with onions and…read moremushroom. Normally would be 20 bucks but with local flavors, got it for 10 (tip not included). Great flavor on the crust, super cheesy, and awesome.

Mozz fries

Cheesesteak Calzone with mushroom and onions

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Em A.

0

3

1

16 years ago

We recently moved into the area and heard fabulous things about Papa's Pizza. And everything we heard was correct and then some. We have never had a less than wonderful experience. The food is amazing, generous in size and well-priced. We especially like the Sal's Stromboli, but everything we have had from Papa's has been delicious. I guess the only negative thing I could possibly say is that I wish they had a larger variety of sodas to choose from, but it's really a non-issue compared to how great this place is. read more

Justin B.

0

1

0

15 years ago

I am not a huge fan of their pizza, however I love their cheese steaks!

Deborah C.

6

2

0

7 years ago

Cold hard crust pizza. Delivered 1/2 hour late.

Papa's Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Papa's Pizza also viewed

Amici Pizza & Restaurant

4.4

(92 reviews)

A few weeks ago, Amici showed up on social media for me and I wasn't sure where it was. Fast…read moreforward to today when I went grocery shopping and realized it was right across the street from where I was! I opened their website and ordered the pizzaboli online, to be picked up in about 25 mins. I received notification that the food was ready right as I was getting in my car to head over. I am a pizza snob and truthfully, boil isn't my favorite. This however made my whole night! The sauce, the meats, the never ending cheese? Perfection. And at 26.50 because of 1 topping, it was more than worth it. I cannot wait to order again! I want the million dollar cheesesteak next!!

When a place advertises something called the "Million Dollar Cheesesteak," my participation is…read moreguaranteed. Their description alone sold me: "Seeded Hudson roll, shaved ribeye, caramelized onions, and Cooper sharp cheese melted into a sauce. This right here is the main event." Say no more. Take my money and hand over the cheesesteak! At $16, I was optimistic but a little cautious. It arrived in a hefty white Styrofoam box that smelled incredible. The moment I opened the lid, I knew I had made the right decision--it was massive, drool-worthy, and everything I hoped it would be. One bite in and I was in food-vana. The meat-to-cheesy-sauce ratio was perfect, the roll was dense and chewy with just the right crisp on the outside, and it held everything together beautifully. No soggy mess, no flimsy bread--just pure cheesesteak glory. Honestly, it really did taste like a million bucks. We paired it with bacon cheese fries for the ultimate heart-stopping combo, and together it made the perfect carb-loaded, finger-licking, "oh my God this is good" kind of dinner. The total was $27.18 with tip--not cheap for cheesesteak and fries, but definitely not robbery given the quality and portions. Parking is plentiful since Amici's is in a strip mall, but we opted for takeout because the dinnertime rush was a little too chaotic. Either way, if I'm craving an amazing cheesesteak, Amici's is at the very top of my list.

Christopher's Pizza & Subs

3.4

(63 reviews)

A former coworker introduced me to Christopher's because she lived nearby. I've been coming by for…read moreyears for lunch when we're in the area. My visit today was great: had delicious pizza and an oven-baked Italian hoagie. The service was friendly, food was made and brought to the table quickly, and tasted delicious. Thanks!

Completely agree with Steve S. The food and people are not anywhere near like it used to be…read more Pretty sure the high reviews are from friends and family members, ha! I went in there to get ONCE slice of pizza, and when checking out I heard her say under her breathe, 'No tip?' Is giving a tip for buying a slice of pizza the norm?? If so, please accept my apologies - damn. It's not like I was sitting at a table and she served me. Also, I asked for ricotta cheese and got an extremely thin layer - same as Steve's experience. Other places put a few globs on. Anyway, bad experiences from myself and others.

Infinitos - York

3.8

(32 reviews)

first time at this location, but have always had good experiences at the other locations when the…read morekids were younger. Stopped in with my youngest daughter (now grown) for old time's sake ;) Everything was as I remembered: small salad & pasta bar ...and a LOT of different pizzas. Probably tried a 1/2 dozen or more - all good - place was lively as Infinitos is big with families. Price still isn't bad & you wont leave hungry! Was busy (Saturday) but the fresh pizza kept flowing - did not have to wait long if they were out of a particular variety.

Don't come when it's busy... came here at 6:30 Friday and there were only 2 slices of pieces totalread more

Mamma's Pizza

3.5

(22 reviews)

Eh. Wings burnt to a crisp. Pizza was actually very good. Horrible wings ruined it for me. Place is…read moreclean. Service was fast.

Best pizza and Stromboli in town!!! Even when they are busy their delivery times are fast and the…read morefood is delicious!!

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill

4.1

(147 reviews)

100% the real deal. If you told me this was from nyc, Long Island or jersey I wouldn't even…read morequestion it. I got the garlic knots, Sicilian pie (great price by the way), and an eggplant parm sub and everything was seriously on point. Without question the best pizza and eggplant I've had outside the nyc area without question. They deliver via Slice for a fee by the way... totally worth it.

We ordered onion rings and their Grandma Pizza. It's kind of what they are known for and now I know…read morewhy. I wanted some comfort food for the snow storm and this hit the spot. The service was great. They were full and seemed to have a lot of to go orders but they were fully staffed and super friendly. Our food was hot and ready on time. It's a cute little place that is cozy with tables and a nice casual atmosphere. I'm so glad we went.

Trail Pizza & Subs

4.3

(6 reviews)

This was first time here after hearing good reviews from others. We got a medium 1/2 bacon and 1/2…read moremushroom and it was delicious! I would advise that the mushrooms are canned and not fresh and that is my only complaint! They were generous with the toppings and it was very tasty! Will go back

Place always hits the spot. I always stop by when taking my dogs to John C. Rudy. Trail steak sub…read moreis awesome and pizza is solid. If you are in the area- it's worth trying it out

Naples Pizza

3.1

(27 reviews)

Skink skink shrink!!! Cheese steak of a hotdog/sausage roll & a fountain drink $11.00 got my last…read moretwo orders wrong!!!

Naples is our favorite pizza in the Palmyra area. We think they have the best flavor and…read morecheese/sauce ratio to crust. I love how fast they are too.

Vito's Pizza

3.9

(97 reviews)