We were referred to Patterson Autobody by the dealer we bought our car at, Village Subaru when it needed bodywork done. The damage that needed to be fixed was to the right rear bumper and wheel well. We gave a copy of the insurance adjuster's notes to the owner, Frank Patterson Sr. He told us it would take a week to fix. We left him the car for 2 weeks while we were on vacation, but it still wasn't ready when we returned. It took 16 days.
After driving the car for a few weeks, we noticed the bumper was separating from the car. We called the shop to schedule a time to bring it back and left the car. They called us 24 hrs. later saying the car was ready for pick-up. They determined the problem was the clips holding the bumper had given out, said it was rare, and replaced them. When we picked up the car, they had already closed, but it was obvious to our untrained eyes that the bumper still did not sit correctly on the car.
We had to call them back and go in a third time. They made my husband wait while they took apart the car, but more importantly were rude to him throughout the process. The technician told him the problem was the replacement bumper they used to do the initial repair was defective. He was told to come back a fourth time to drop the car for repairs the next day, Friday 8/5/11, and it would be ready for pick-up Monday 8/8/11. Given that they would need to order a new bumper, install it, and have our insurance company, approve the charges, we were concerned this timetable was not realistic since business tends to move slower, if at all, on the weekend.
You can appreciate that the area we live in does not have a subway or bus system. This makes being without a car difficult, especially for us, as my husband is active duty military and gone often during odd hours, including weekends. Dealing with Patterson's business hours of 8am-5pm was extremely difficult, however, at the prospect of having to do it a fourth time we didn't think it was unreasonable to ask if they might be willing to provide us with a loaner vehicle.
When we voiced our concerns to the technician and asked if we might be able to get a loaner car for the weekend things started to get ugly. The technician said, "This wasn't Patterson's problem and if we ever wanted the car fixed we would need to deal with it," along with some other choice words.
We took our concerns to the owner, Frank Patterson Sr., asking if they would be able to stick to the timetable given and if a loaner car might be provided given they did not accurately diagnose or fix the problem the second time we were in. Frank became so aggressive over the phone that we had to get our insurance company involved. He screamed at my wife, called her names, told her that he took zero responsibility for the problem, and told her never to call or come back onto his property.
In the end we followed the advice of our insurance company. We dropped the car for the fourth (hopefully final) time after business hours and picked it up after business hours. The insurance company coordinated everything with the shop so we did not have to speak to anyone again. Our insurer was horrified to hear the way Frank Sr. spoke to us, especially my wife and has flagged Patterson Autobody in their system. read more