Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Payne's Pizza & More

    3.0 (43 reviews)
    Ultra High-EndPizza, Salad, Sandwiches
    Closed 10:30 am - 9:30 pm

    Payne's Pizza & More Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like Payne's Pizza & More

    Recommended Reviews - Payne's Pizza & More

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Different menu items we ordered.
    Jessica B.

    Cute little spot you will miss just driving by... the love for Ohio shows inside, small dining area but fit our party of 13 and had a buffet they were setting up as we were leaving. The pizza was delicious along with the garlic cheese pizza. Order at the counter when you are ready, bottomless dine-in fountain drink. It is a must try in Delaware if ur tired of the same ol' pizza. The chicken Alfredo with tomato was great and the taco was delicious to just name a few. I didn't try the fries but my nephew did and they looked good. Pass on the Mac n chz bites. And they were incredibly quick with our big order. Price is also reasonable and a special everyday.

    See all

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Payne's Pizza & More Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Payne's Pizza & More

    Review Highlights - Payne's Pizza & More

    Very happy with the quality of everything we ordered, big daddy pizza, garlic bread and side salads.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 5,661 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    My Little Kitchen

    My Little Kitchen

    4.9
    (18 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$

    This is a great good truck. I was at Zaftig with my two daughters and we had the hot dog, shrimp…read moretacos and beignets. The staff was friendly and very accommodating to my kids. They offered to make the fries with only salt without me asking which was a big help. The seasoned fries are excellent but they are a bit much for my little ones The shrimp tacos were excellent. They were loaded in shrimp and the right amount of sauce. The hot dog was really good. I'm always situated when the dog and bun alone can stand apart. Theirs does and it's a credit to the quality of the dog and the preparation of the bun. The best perfect finish of the meal was the beignets. They were cooked perfectly and were light and airy and topped with powdered sugar. Some may think the powdered sugar was excessive but I thought it was spot on and a huge hit with my kiddos. I'll be back again be t time they are zaftig and if I happen upon them when I'm out and about I'm Definitely ordering beignets on the spot!

    My Little Kitchen is a food truck lurking around Delaware. It has a small simple menu. There's…read moretypical stuff like chili dogs and pretzels. It's price isn't that bad. There's a few more healthy options. I found this at Staas. It's usually at a brewery. The places typically don't have their own menu. It's where this food truck comes in. You need something to eat with that beer or liquor. I had the pretzel bites. These are about $5 for a basket full. It's usually somewhere in Delaware. It can also be in Powell. There's good opportunities to catch it at Staas.

    Photos
    My Little Kitchen
    My Little Kitchen
    My Little Kitchen

    See all

    Restoration Brew Worx

    Restoration Brew Worx

    4.2
    (180 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$

    Late night dinner for me and my husband (9pm) this place is one of the few places open after 9 in…read moreDelaware that's serves food. Pretzel bread made with Ale cheese- heavy on the ale. The bread itself also had an alcohol taste to it- maybe it's the batch as the last time I had it I couldn't taste it but this time I may not pass a breathilizer from it alone I had the RBW Burger and the aioli was tasty. The pickles were unlike any I've had before- like the thing between a pickle and a cucumber. The wait staff were nice! The volume was pretty standard for a bar. Only gave it a four because the food can be inconsistent between visits. (Last time the fries were way too salty and this time they were perfect- also the bread)

    Absolutely love this place! Great food, clean, great employees! We started with their sweet potato…read morefries, they were hot and crunchy, sprinkled with cinnamon sugar and drizzled with caramel. So good, decadent really. I had the RBW Sloppy Joe- Chorizo, BBQ sauce, cheese and onion petals on a pretzel bun! This sandwich is to die for!! I will be making this at home if I can figure out the right mix. My wife had the Mexican salad with chicken and she said that it was awesome. I also tried two of their beers and a cider. First I had the Delicious which is a light wheat beer, very refreshing. Second was the Webrewedabeertogether which was a Bock, great tasting dark beer and then I tried the Eat a peach cider, also light and refreshing.

    Photos
    Restoration Brew Worx
    Fried pickles, 12 wings (Buffalo, creamy Parmesan)
    Fried pickles, 12 wings (Buffalo, creamy Parmesan)
    Comedy

    See all

    Comedy
    The Backstretch

    The Backstretch

    4.2
    (85 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$

    Came here for the tater tots and wasn't disappointed! So good and the star. My wife had the nut…read morecrusted chicken salad which was also good. I had the Reuben...big mistake, not a lot of meat. Get the tots when you come here and thank me later!!!

    Have to say this has become one of our favorites for casual dining with amazing food. Drove to…read moredowntown Delaware and found easy parking on the street (there are also nearby lots). Backstretch is super casual (given Ohio Wesleyan is nearby - its almost a college/town bar) but great to come in a sit at the bar or one of their booths. It isnt big, maybe 15-20 bar stools and 12 booths and 1-2 tables. This time we picked a booth and a great server (Jacobi) helped us right away. Fun part of backstretch is the staff. Servers are friendly, you can watch the cooks prepare your food, and they have a full bar. Note they dont have many draft beer options, but servers tried hard to get us something we liked. Food here is fresh off the grill and tastes like home cooked food - from their Reuben(which was amazing) to Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich (has kick but so good) - you cant go wrong. This time we added Tots, Mac and Cheese, and the Deviled eggs (most sandwiches are served with a deviled egg - tasty). We also tried Jacobi recommendation of Hencock Tots - wing sauce - cheese and bacon. Should have just made that my meal. Amazing. They dont take reservations but unless there is an event in downtown, you can usually walk in for dinner. This was our third visit in 60 days! Ready to go back - thanks Jacobi for a fun night and see you all soon.

    Photos
    Patrons at the bar
    Patrons at the bar
    Tator tots -12
    Tator tots -12
    Outside front

    See all

    Outside front
    Hamburger Inn Diner

    Hamburger Inn Diner

    4.2
    (492 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$

    After the Delaware Farmer's Market, my wife and I wanted to rewind time at this old school diner…read more Leave it to us to go to a place called Hamburger Inn and not get a hamburger. And I think that might have been our downfall. We went the breakfast route and started with a Cinnamon roll made right on the griddle. It created this crispy char that gave the roll more of a funnel cake texture. Unique,and the icing definitely enhances it (as it does most cinnamon rolls). Their special breakfast sandwich, "The Morning Wake-up" touts a "2x the size English Muffin" and they were not lying. This sandwich had cheese, multiple meats and vegetables, and I needed to take half of it home due to sheer size. What it didn't have... sauce. What it needed... sauce, syrup, aioli or something to lubricate all of those toppings. The breakfast potatoes on the side needed salt/seasoning/sauce, too, to be more to my liking. It was a similar experience with my wife's Reuben and the fries that she ordered; the sandwich had its moments, but it made me wish one of us got a burger like most of the other patrons.

    They word "hamburger" is in the name for a reason! We had a Western burger and fries, it was…read moreexcellent! Perfectly-cooked, topped with bacon and onion rings. The side of fries were perfect, make sure you douse them with malt vinegar to have the optimal experience. We stopped by during the Gilmore Girls event when they rebranded the restaurant as Luke's diner. Super cute idea for a fun night in downtown Delaware!

    Photos
    Another view of the dining area.
    Another view of the dining area.
    Reuben
    Reuben
    Entrance

    See all

    Entrance

    Payne's Pizza & More - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...