The outside of the restaurant now says Hook Pizza but the boxes still say Peel Pizza. We are visiting in town and stopped to grab something quick. We ordered 2 calzones, cheese bread sticks and 2 sodas. I couldn't believe when we got the bill. The meal was 74$ before tip. They charged us 3.12$ per topping. Sadly, the food was terrible. The calzones were doughy, barely any topping and mine had pepperoni in it, which I didn't order. The cheese bread sticks were more like crackers, very thin and not much flavor. I absolutely would never recommend this restaurant. read more

Best pizza in the area we go there every time we head through Scituate Prepared on time, served hot wonderful The chicken wings are the best read more

We ordered on-line with delivery to our home. The order arrived sooner than expected and was complete. The pizza had cooled as expected and were very good. I bet they are even better eating at their location when hot. Would certainly order from here again. read more

Best pizza ever! Loads of garlic, perfect amount of char, a little salty, thin and steaming hot out of the oven ... loved it. Definitely coming back to this location read more

See all

Holy sh*t. This is amazing. Whoever decided to put potatoes on pizza? I love you. Their staff are so friendly and bust their a$$ to deliver this good of pizza. On a Friday night no less? I hope y'all are getting paid good and know how much your appreciated! read more

Peel Pizza - Irish Riviera Signature White Pie - Pizza Near Me - Cohasset, Massachusetts

I've had pizza here at events but I came here for a light lunch since I was in the neighborhood. The pepperoni slice was large and hot. Additionally, the crust was thin and flavorful. The cheese was at a reasonably amount and the tomato sauce was savory, not sweet. The quality is evident here and is worth paying a little more $ than other spots. read more

Peel Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Cohasset, Massachusetts

Sorry folks this ain't great pizza. Came in from CT to visit family and then begged us to consider anything but pizza in the area. We persisted and unfortunately dismissed the warnings. Long story short the pizzas were dry, the crust was crunchy and flavorless and I'd not recommend to others. I see that Peel has 2 other locations?? That's concerning on multiple levels.... read more

I give this 2 stars because the pizza is actually good for the area but the management and way this business is run is the worst I've ever seen. It says online that they close at 9pm, however if you show up at 8:20pm they say they are closed. Lights are on, door is open but they lie to your face and say we "close" at 8:30, well if that's the case place our order 10 min before "close"--also change your website. It's like they decide they don't feel like working anymore so they just turn loyal business and good money away. This has happened to us at least 3 times, at this point we are idiots for ever trying to get pizza from them again unless it's before 7:30. I've never seen a business actually turn away good money, just completely absurd. Will never go back again and we have been loyal for years. read more

The family orders here often. Sometimes it's very good. Other times you end up with something disappointing like in this photo, where you ordered a pepperoni calzone, but got something more like a loaf of bread with "a" slice of hidden pepperoni and shred of cheese. It sometimes feels like someone is not trained right, out of ingredients, or operating on the cheaper side of things. read more

Peel Pizza - Where's the pepperoni in this calzone? - Pizza Near Me - Cohasset, Massachusetts

Peel what happened? When u first opened was delighted by the actual flavor your sauce had!!!!!! Not bland/typical tasteless New England. Over the last year or so it has disappeared. What gives? Complaints form the hordes of vanilla lovers? Now only Rivas makes a pizza with sauce that has actual flavor. Sad. OTH....crust done very well. Service in shop excellent. Good toppings and overall very good job....but bring back the old sauce! read more

Great local pizza place located in downtown Cohasset. Got a large pizza and calzone along with wings. We ordered right near closing time and were pleased with a short wait time. The pizza was delicious. We got half onion and half cheese, and it had the perfect bite. The crust was not too soft but not too hard and the sauce was amazing. In terms of the calzone, it was underwhelming. We ordered it with chicken parm and were surprised when it came with what seemed almost like deli chicken with a cold marinara soupy like sauce in a side tub. The calzone was dominated by cheese and lacked the flavor of the pizza. The wings were solid and had nice flavor. My sister who loves hot food was impressed with the buffalo sauce. Overall a solid place, and hope that the calzone underperformance was due to coming in so close to closing time. read more

Peel Pizza - Half onion half cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cohasset, Massachusetts

Best pizza on the south shore (that isn't bar pizza). Don't listen to the haters in the reviews. Yes you need to eat it hot and yes the calzones can be hit or miss. Their wings are very good as well. Maybe it's not saying much, but it is the best non-bar pizza from Quincy to the cape. read more

Expect long lines and flat customer service for mediocre and crispy thin pizza. It was a disappointment unfortunately!

RAW calzone, completely with raw dough on the inside, and no this wasn't the cheese, aside from being raw it tasted terrible, I requested buffalo chicken but there was barely any chicken or buffalo sauce, basically all cheese, couldn't eat it! read more

Peel Pizza - That is the dough not cheese - Pizza Near Me - Cohasset, Massachusetts

See all

I heard about this place from a pizza-lover who raved about it. I never had the opportunity to go but I happened to be in the area today and popped in for a slice. There's a cute little patio with metal chairs and tables for outdoor dining. It's quiet quintessential New England and you can definitely tell it's an enjoyable place to relax outside on a nice summer day. while small, the place is clean and the server was friendly. The pizza itself is delicious. This but not so crispy you feel like you're eating a cracker. Not too greasy. It tasted fresh and it was flavorful. I can't speak on the merits of the gourmet versions because I decided to not be too adventurous the first time around and stick with pepperoni. I also had a side salad that was fresh and had a wonderfully tasting dressing. But you're probably wondering why I would rate it 4 stars with such a glowing review. Well the folks at Peel pizza seem to think that cohasset pizza must be more special than other pizzas. The single slice and handful of greens I had cost me a whooping $9. Even the upper crust is more reasonable with their pizza/salad combos. Also, I had a garden salad. Not a Greek salad which is what the cashier/server rang me up for. Not to be picky but if you're going to overcharge I expect perfection. read more

Peel Pizza - A bit much if you ask me. For that price I could have gotten more value at many of the other shops around. - Pizza Near Me - Cohasset, Massachusetts

Got Greek Pizza. It was okay but lacked flavor overall and was a bit soggy, especially toward the center of the pie. We got a large which I think for that pizza and others didn't cook as well in the middle. I wouldn't not go there again but would stick to the basics and get a small. I like the crust, not too heavy, crispy, good flavor read more

I wanted to grab a hot lunch by work. Online, this place looked really good, so I ordered a calzone which was pretty pricey after the toppings I added but i was willing to pay that for a good calzone. I took about 2 bites before I realized the dough was still raw. I'm willing to try this place again because the pizza sounds/looks incredible, the calzone was just severely disappointing read more

Peel Pizza - a half eaten piece of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cohasset, Massachusetts

Owner reached out to apologize for the bad experience I had during my last visit. Nice guy, although what happened was not acceptable and quality has been hit or miss for a bit, these are hard times for everyone so I understand. Gave it another shot at the owner's urging and the pizza was excellent. read more

So, ''twas the night before Thanksgiving and all through the land, people wanted to not cook. So what did they do? They wanted a pizza, so upon yelp they searched. They found the Peel Pizza, and gave them a call! An hour fifteen to hour pick it up, so away they ordered! Upon pickup they paid their due fees and brought the pizza back home to me! We opened the pizza and what did we see, cheese and veggies and cheese galore! One of the pizzas was gluten-free so upon it I did bite, and what did I see? Burnt bits and grease and oils and burn, and woe was me! I still downed it quite fast, for this boy was hungry and pizza he did have. Everyone else did eat, and similar experience they did have, so next year a different way we will path. read more

DO NOT ORDER ONLINE!!! Ordered 1 pizza online for delivery at 5:25 pm on July 14, 2019. Time now is 7:45 pm and no pizza - so far we have been waiting 2 hours and 20 minutes. Very disappointing service and the wait time is way longer than their estimates. just called Peel Pizza and they said it is in the oven and our house is not far away so it should be coming soon. Major disappointment. Delivery service turnaround is unacceptable. have no idea what condition our pizza will be here when it finally gets here. Pizza may become obsolete by then. update -- our pizza arrived at 750pm. so total wait time was 2 hours and 25 minutes. DO NOT ORDER ONLINE!!!!! read more

I have to say the Peel Pizza has stepped it up the last few months. A new look and better service, the pizza comes out faster than ever and the new guy there is very friendly and accommodating. Keep it UP! So good read more

This place is the worst. Takes forever to get an order and when you come in they lie about how long it will take. Made the mistake of giving them a second chance so shame on me. Never again! read more

We are visiting the area for a few days and decided to get pizza for dinner. We ordered carry out, and the pizza is very good. My husband ordered a pizza which he thought wouldn't have cheese on it. I called the shop to explain the situation (he cannot have cheese due to a medical issue). They nicely delivered a different pizza without cheese. I will say this is very exceptional customer service and the staff at Cohasset went above and beyond to accommodate our issue. Thank you! read more

The best pizza around. The chicken wings are mind blowing. Absolutely amazingly delicious everything. Yum!

Peels has gone way down since arriving in Cohasset 3 or 4 years ago. After being dissatisfied with our last 4 orders we are swearing off. The toppings are rediculously skimpy. Salads are almost inedible (limp lettuce) and the pie was soggy. Former quality control has disappeared. read more

It may just seem like a normal small pizza place but it is one of the best pizzas I have ever eaten.and don't get me started on the wings soooooooooo good.we eat here at lest 15 times a month read more

Peel Pizza is my latest addiction. Enter, The Wheelhouse Pizza. Perfection! Give it a shot. read more

It pains me to leave a negative review for a place with so much promise, but the truth is the truth. 2 and a half hours for a pizza pick up is just unacceptable. First the good - the pizza is really outstanding, especially relative to the competition in the area. Riva in Scituate is nearly as good, but I give Peel the edge as I prefer their crust. The specialty pizza combos they concocted are compelling, and the Parmageddon is fantastic (we've ordered it twice). Now the bad. Seemingly a ship without a captain, there just is no management going on here. The last order we placed was fielded by a young female employee and was advised by her that they were busy and the order would take 45 minutes (the last time we had called it was only 15-20 minutes). For a Friday night, I wasn't too offput by 45 minutes and had groceries to pick up so I sad "No problem". An hour later, I arrived to pick up my pizza - giving them an additional 15 minutes (as my 3-year old and I got distracted by the impulse aisle at Stop & Shop). Upon arrival, 4 high school girls working the small counter greeted us (not really sure why 4 were necessary, 1 or 2 seemed sufficient or at least one of them could have started rolling dough when volume ramped up) happily took my payment. 68$ for 3 pizzas. I was THEN told that my order wasn't ready and would take 20 more minutes. "No, probably less - maybe 15 minutes!" Trusting this to be true, I said OK, paid, and took my 3 year old daughter outside and sat on the patio patiently. 15 minutes later, after seeing a half dozen patrons receive the same message, I started to get nervous. After 25 minutes I went in to check to make sure the pizzas weren't done and they just dropped the ball in coming out to call for me. No dice Chicago. No pizza. No ability to tell me where my order was in line. No real adjusted time frame. Just a "Give us 15 minutes". "But you said that last time?" I think I muttered some other choice words, which is regrettable and I apologize for. So I asked, "is my pizza at least in the oven or being made?!" I had 4 families at our house for a pizza party waiting on me so things were getting dicey. If kids of a certain age don't eat by a certain time... hell can break loose. They then sorted through 2 dozen receipts on the table and found mine burried. It was clear that no organization was going on here. Receipts were on paper, in a computer, and some just verbally maintained. No real regard to timelines was being issued to customers. Orders were not being processed in the order they were received. Finally, the guy making the pies found my slip and said, "I'll make yours next". 30 Minutes later I was given my 3 pies and I was on my way. Home close to 3 hours after ordering. No offer for a discount. No apology. No refund. No repeat business. read more

Pizza itself is one of my favs in the area - but service is horrendous. After ordering about 5-6 times now both pickup and delivery the wait is 2+ hours. Once they didn't even start cooking the pizza until it was 30 mins after the estimated time to pickup, 2 times delivery was quoted at 1.5 hrs and took 2.5. Sitting here waiting for a pizza at 8:30 pm when called in an order at 6. Unfortunately, our family is done with this place. read more

Even though I live in New York and should not be able to say this, Peel Pizza is some of the best pizza I've ever had. The crust is a perfect Neapolitan style, and the sauce (which I think is homemade) is awesome. I would use that sauce on everything if I could. My parents live in Scituate and I used to go out of my way, driving all the way to Hingham just to get a slice of this pizza. There were even times when I bought a whole pie and strapped it into the passenger's seat just so I could have some later. Thankfully, I no longer have to do that, as the Cohasset store delivers to Scituate! I'm a huge fan of this pizza and will definitely be ordering more the next time I'm home! read more

The pizza is inconsistent, never shows up on time and the service is easily the worst of any business in Cohasset. I wish the owner/ operator would sell or close. Really poorly run business. read more

I'm from Western MA but I can confidently say this will not be my last time at Peel Pizza! The thin crusted pizza is amazing and the tomato sauce is soooo good as well as the ratio of cheese to tomato sauce. To die for I'm craving it as I type!!! read more

Excellent!!! Great staff, I love the pizza, thin-crust great toppings. They know there craft very well the sauce is brought to the edge of the pie and cooked to a light crisp. read more

Great pizza. Very thin bit crispy and chewy crust. Excellent quality ingredients. Delivery is reliable and usually fast. It's a tad pricey for pizza, but easily the best in the area. read more

Tried the Luau pizza and stuffed pepper calzone, they both were delicious. Can't wait to try there other pies.

Very good pizza, exceptional. Thin crust and Greek salad was very good. Fast delivery to Scituate.

Wow, what a difference a day makes! I recently gave Peel another chance and they really pulled through! Great pizza, and worth the wait! I'll return, but will confirm the wait time in advance. :) read more

First off I'm no Italian but even I know BBQ chicken is not the chicken u put in a chicken parm calzone. Secondly I would like my calzone cooked next time. When I bit into it I thought they might have stuffed the crust only to find out it was half cooked dough instead. This place sucks. read more

If I'm in the mood for pizza this is always the place I go. The Parmageddon is amazing and my go-to and the wings are really good (although they used to come tossed in this amazing parmesan dry seasoning and the last few times they've come plain with no seasoning??). My only gripe on the pizza side is that the sausage topping is little slices and not crumbled italian sausage, which is a personal preference. read more

My wife is a pizza snob (from NJ). This is the best pizza we've had, ever.