We ordered oysters, truffle fries, and sliders. Some of the oysters were huge! They were good. The sliders were really good, however they were not warm enough. The truffle fries were delicious. The fries were crispy, cooked perfectly, and had the right amount of truffle. The food was good, could have been better. I had the Espresso Martini and really liked it. The waitress was nice and attentive. read more

See all

I normally don't leave reviews, but I felt compelled to share my experience. The food was good, and we enjoyed the outdoor patio atmosphere. I was even telling my family that I'd happily come back because we enjoyed the food. Unfortunately, the service changed my opinion. We were celebrating my birthday, and when my dessert arrived, the candle wasn't lit; the server simply handed it to us and walked away. What made it more disappointing was watching her spend time trying to light the candle for another birthday celebration while making no effort at our table. It may seem like a small gesture, but it would have made the occasion feel special. The inattentiveness continued throughout the meal. We rarely saw our server, and when we did, her interactions felt rushed and unfriendly. It genuinely seemed as though she did not want to be there, and that attitude came through in her service. I'll be honest: seeing the difference in treatment made me uncomfortable. I don't want to assume or suggest that it was racially motivated, and I'm not trying to go that route. However, it almost felt that way in the moment. I trust my intuition, and throughout the experience my family and I did not feel welcomed. I've lived in Illinois for 8 years, and this was honestly one of the worst service experiences I've had at a restaurant. While the food and atmosphere were enjoyable, the poor service overshadowed the entire visit. I hope management takes customer service more seriously because the restaurant itself has potential. Unfortunately, based on this visit, I do not plan on returning. read more

This place is so cute! It's a nicely decorate bar but they had a really yummy brunch! It was served on vintage dishes and was plated so nicely! I got the French toast and my husband had the veggie omelette. The servers were also attentive. read more

Pennyville Station - New American Near Me - Park Ridge, Illinois

Came in on Memorial Day. This place you can see into the kitchen from the bar. The two guys that are the two main guys in the kitchen were off so I wasnt to sure about ordering dinner. I'll never think that way again. I ordered porkchops. Came with a sauce of peaches. Also garlic and spinach mashed potatoes. Out of this world fantastic. The B team hit it out of the park. Good job boys. Best dinner I have had in awhile.. read more

Pennyville is always a reliable choice. The food is consistently good, and the Wagyu burger is excellent. They also have a solid beer selection, and having Allagash available is always a win. What really sets this place apart is the family that owns it. Everyone is genuinely kind and welcoming, which makes each visit feel easy and enjoyable. The restaurant itself is a great size. Room for large groups but also a bar for solo diners. A great neighborhood spot that delivers every time!! read more

Pennyville Station - Allagash - New American Near Me - Park Ridge, Illinois

See all

Really good spot for drinks. There are two bar areas and we always come for an after dinner drink. If you are eating here, they have great food. The chopped chicken salad is delicious and fills me up. My husband loves the turkey burger and the prime burger. Amazing food but it is pricey. The service is wonderful they do have the best waiters/waitresses. The ambiance is amazing as well and always crowded. One of our favorites in Park Ridge! read more

Pennyville Station - Manhattan - New American Near Me - Park Ridge, Illinois

The food was fine. And the drinks were good--they didn't seem to skimp on the alcohol, because I was pretty buzzed after a couple and glad I had plenty of time to chat and eat and burn it of. (Though who knows, maybe it's just that I haven't had more than a glass or two of wine in over two years.) The service was relatively competent and not too overbearing... though they brought the wrong item for me and the server came back with it within a minute or so, so I'm really hoping they didn't take it to someone else's table and bring it back to me. The most glaring issue is that it's really expensive. I'm not sure the food justifies this sort of price. I'd rather go to my favorite brunch place, in Andersonville, and leave with a smaller bill. And their menu seemed smaller than I anticipated. If not for the pleasant company with a couple friends it would have been a bummer of a meal. The menu was somewhat small, and I only found one, possibly two, things I would want to order. This was for brunch, though; perhaps their main menu is more extensive. The parking along main can be sparse since there's a lot of restaurants and businesses here, and that parking gets even more constrained during the spring or summer when most of the parking spaces are taken by outdoor seating. But there are at least one or two parking lots a block or two away which is for Metra and is often pretty empty. There's also three-hour parking near the library and along Prospect, and the Metra station is directly across from the restaurant. read more

See all

Been here twice now for the team dinner. They have a bar section which is perfect for the gathering and mingling. They gave the decent choices for the group. My favorite is teriyaki cauliflowers. They have the big windows next to the sidewalk. And lots of folks sat outside to enjoy the weather. Always enjoyed the services here. The parking could be tricky but should be able to find some closer to the metra parking which is free after 11am. read more

Very disappointed. Both orders of filet medallions were tasteless & came out cold along with cold fries. Sent back without an apology. Another in our group got cold sweet potato fries, but ate them anyway. The Margherita pizza didn't came minus the fresh mozzarella. totally missed the farm to table vibe. read more

Delayed posting from a few weeks ago... Went here for a group dinner for work. We arrived with a slightly larger group than expected and a bit earlier than our reservation. The manager quickly got us the space we needed for our party and had us seated promptly. Our waitress was friendly and efficient, quickly getting our orders for drink and appetizers put in. Pennyville Station pays homage to the town's former name from the early 1900s. The outside patio is adjacent to the train tracks, which adds to the restaurant's moniker. We sat on the outside patio and the weather was perfect for it in early September. With such a large group, there were plenty of appetizers to share across the table. The mussels appetizer was delicious and tender. I could've drank the flavorful white wine and garlic sauce. Perfect pairing with the mussels. I also enjoyed the crispy Brussels sprouts with bacon. I ordered the salmon entree. It was served over a cauliflower rice, pilaf style. The salmon was moist and perfectly seasoned. The corn in the cauliflower rice added a touch of sweetness. If I'm ever in town again, I would definitely eat here again. read more

See all

Gem in park ridge. They have happy hour favorites 7 days a week. Love their mocktails. Lovely town

3 people in our party and all entrees were disappointing. Waste of money. Would not recommend. read more

Pennyville Station - New American Near Me - Park Ridge, Illinois

Enjoyed the drinks and filet sliders from this spot with a work colleague a few weeks back. The outdoor seating area was fantastic - lots of people watching and a lovely setup. Service was a bit slow, although our server definitely hustled to get us taken care of - in general it seemed like they just didn't have enough people on staff. I'd definitely go back, there were a lot of interesting things on the menu. read more

Terrific hostess who happily accommodated our early arrival before our reso. Our server was friendly, funny and checked in on us often. The food and drinks were delicious. Looking forward to return! Thank you for a marvelous lunch! 5 stars! read more

Have eaten here many times and they never disappoint. My favorites are their chopped salad, Wagyu burger, and the 1# bone in pork chop that would easily feed 2. Their food quality is top-notch. Very friendly servers (especially Emily). The restaurant is especially accommodating for groups with special areas, splitting desserts, & separate checks. Watch for their 1# special priced King crab legs in Jan. read more

This place has gone downhill. Went in tonight with my son, got a chicken sandwich and sweet potato fries. The sandwich was bland and burnt; chicken was dry. The fries were room temperature, so I don't know how long they were sitting there. I didn't eat them. When I told the waitress, the manager didn't come over to apologize or anything. They "graciously" took the up charge off my bill for the sweet potato fries and gave us a free dessert that I didn't want and was probably just laying around. Pretty disappointing; this used to be a good place. read more

Service is good, I won't even question that. Unfortunately, the menu is ... different. First of all, many things from before are not on the menu anymore, and the ones are there- their prices can compare to downtown's prices. :-( even though I am usually not paying attention to that, this time it was sooo obvious, that I had to notice it. We were there around 11 am, got a lunch menu, so, not many things you can order. I choose burger, which was good, but besides that, not many breakfast options. Not coming there soon, but will check in a while to see if anything has change because I use to like this place read more

See all

Let's just say their food quality is what raised the score. If it was based just on service, unfortunately, I would have lowered the score. Parking in this area can be a pain. Be patient as pedestrians are walking, and you may have to park a block or two away. They have daily drink specials and offer seasonal cocktails as well. My friend and I started with the oysters Rockerfeller. They were seasoned well and really delicious. I ordered a burger that was pretty tasty. I enjoyed the spicy mayo on it. My friend had the scallops and he enjoyed them. Service was incredibly slow. It took our server 25 minutes (yes, I timed) for our server to just take our drink order. She had her hands full so was unable to take our food order. It took her another bit of time to take food order. She was friendly. I would recommend and return to try other entree items. read more

My friends and I met up for brunch here and had a great time. We had a semi big group(10 in total) and they easily accommodated us. We have a reservation and called to push it up and it was no problem. I LOVE the ahi tuna nachos. I wish I would have just ordered it as my main dish! I ordered the lump crab eggs Benedict and a mimosa. The eggs b was very good. Lots of crab and very flavorful. My toddler accompanied me and I ordered her fries and a side of bacon and two scrambled eggs. The fries basket was very big and tasty. We shared with the two other kids at the table and still had plenty. The service was great. Our server was very nice and so patient with us. I know with big group and with kids it's hard. She was awesome. read more

See all

The outdoor patio had a really nice, chill vibe--perfect for a sunny day. We started with the lemon basil hummus served with watermelon radish and pita. It was delicious, and I especially loved the whole chickpeas for a little added texture. I had the salmon burger and swapped the bun for sourdough to make it open-faced--highly recommend. I also subbed in sweet potato fries for a little extra, but they were totally worth it: crispy on the outside, soft on inside. (Unpictured: my husband had the carved turkey sandwich and loved it!) Service was great overall--nice staff, a little slow to start, but we didn't mind relaxing and taking our time. read more

See all

Walking around Park Ridge and decided to stop by. The location was open on July 4 which I was surprised. We got seated right away. The decor inside is really nice, it doesn't all go together well but I like that, gives it some old time esthetic. 2 Small Caesar salads: 10/10 super good dressing could tell it's house made and loved the shaved parmesan. Fish and Chips 10/10, the best I've had yet. Light and airy with flavoring. The tartar sauce went so well with it it wasn't too overpowering and of course the slaw and fries were very very good. Had to bring leftovers. Wagyu Burger 8/10, flavors were very good. The meat was cooked medium but the mistake made was putting the chipotle mayo on the burger. If we hadn't done that it would have been perfect. Fries were also good. Had a ginger beer and a coke on the side they were very good. Service was amazing and will be coming back read more

See all

First time trying out the restaurant Food was great Service was great rating the 3 P's On Brunch Price 9 Portion 9 Presentation 9 9/10 read more

Pennyville Station - Mmm Tiramisu - New American Near Me - Park Ridge, Illinois

See all

Pennyville Station is awesome. I have been here multiple times. The food is always really good. Have been here for both dinner and brunch which I highly recommend the brunch. The food, service, and the atmosphere is all very good. You won't be disappointed. Solid place to get some food. read more

Pennyville Station - New American Near Me - Park Ridge, Illinois

See all

Great food and service, the back party room is great for any type of shower or large gathering.

If I could give this restaurant 0 stars I would. I'm not someone who normally leaves negative reviews or posts publicly about bad experiences at restaurants. If something goes wrong, I usually just move on and don't go back. But what happened at Pennyville Station in Park Ridge--twice now--has been extremely disappointing and upsetting, especially given how meaningful this event is for our family. Back on October 29, 2024, I reserved the Nook Room at Pennyville for my daughter's First Communion on May 3, 2025. It seats 18 people, and I booked it for 16--our close family. I asked if a deposit was needed, and they said no, that my reservation of the room was sufficient. Since then, my husband and I have called several times to confirm, and each time, we were assured the reservation was in place. Just two weeks before the event, I received a call today (day before a Holiday)--not even from the owner--informing me that they can no longer give us the private room and are offering just a table instead. They already ruined our other child's baptism years ago, when the table was too small and the experience was unfortunately very disappointing. This is the exact reason why I booked the private space since just having a table didn't give us the space we needed last time. We reserved the Nook Room so we could have privacy and space for the family event. Apparently, a 60-70 party was booked after ours, and since they're bringing in more money and left a deposit, the space is being given to them instead. We were told there was nothing they could do and that this decision was final. When my husband went to speak in person, the owner reportedly said, "It is what it is." We tried to explain how important this day is to our daughter and our family, but there was no effort made to find a solution. I'm sharing this because I want others to be aware in case they're planning an event there, and also because I'm now scrambling to find another space for 16 people with only two weeks to go. For what it's worth, every server we've had at Pennyville has been kind and professional. This experience has been strictly an issue with management decisions. This is the link to the Private Events info page after you click on private events from their Pennyville home page. We booked the Nook Room as seen in the link https://457ee3c3-6465-41bb-b881-676a33d986d8.usrfiles.com/ugd/457ee3_961830b019fe4ac784f65bcce6139a98.pdf read more

Pennyville Station - The Nook Room info we booked - New American Near Me - Park Ridge, Illinois

We were really looking forward to trying Pennyville Station for the first time, but unfortunately, the service left a lot to be desired. Our server, Juan, seemed less than enthusiastic from the start. One of the serving dishes we received still had food particles on it--not a huge deal, these things happen--but when I politely asked for a clean one, he silently took it and brought another back without so much as an apology or acknowledgment. A simple, "I'm so sorry about that, let me get you a clean one right away," would've gone a long way. After finishing our meals, he came by briefly to ask if everything was okay. We said yes, thinking he'd offer dessert or ask if we needed anything else--but he just walked off. We had to call him back to let him know we wanted crème brûlée. It just felt like we were an afterthought, which was surprising given that it was mid-afternoon and only two other tables were seated with two servers working. The food itself was good--no complaints there--but we specifically came for the king crab, which they were unfortunately out of. That was disappointing but understandable. What's harder to overlook is the poor service. Being in the service industry myself, I know how important those small moments of care and attentiveness are. That's what keeps people coming back. Sadly, this first visit may also be our last. read more

Love the patio seating and ambiance here. Customer service was also good. The Prime Burger and sweet potato fries w/ chipotle sauce was delicious! read more

Pennyville Station - Prime Burger (well done) Sweet potato fries - New American Near Me - Park Ridge, Illinois

Great patio great atmosphere but wow I've been here 5 times in the last month bragging to everyone how great the food and happy hour is here but the service is absolutely so bad. So so bad. These servers are moving at a turtle speed. I'm a server and you have to pay attention and be alert and fast. Needless to say the place and happy hour is great but plan on slow slow slow service with no pre bussing read more

What a disappointment. We ordered Lemon Basil Hummus - $15. Hummas was fine, veggies were old. Dry carrots and radish slices. We ordered the Eggplant Caprese - $21. Eggplant breading was very dark, but Eggplant was barely cooked. Really tough to even chew. And the tomatoes were mealy and mushy. Like really bad. I think sometimes the line cooks think the customer wont notice. But i sure did!! When two of the main ingredients in a dish are bad, it shows. I questioned the freshness of the mozzarella, as well. As a chef, all I could think was, "I could have made this so much better. " read more

Great food great drinks excellent service Love the atmosphere whether you're eating inside or outside read more

Cute area. Thursday afternoon with a group of 6, seated immediately. Menu is diverse and delicious but pricey. Had the Ahi Tuna fancy nachos. American Wagyu burger decent Appreciate the water pitchers and lovely glassware read more

Aww shucks we liked Pennyville brunch! We ordered the oysters which was very delicious, the salmon burger, and the veggie omelet! It was a fun brunch, fun ambiance and very crowded barely could get a table! read more

See all

Loved their outdoor patio and the service was so great, they even brought a bowl of water out for my dog which we really appreciated. However I was let down by the food. I ordered the Wagyu burger and didn't even care to eat more than half. My boyfriend got the chicken sandwich and said it wasn't that great. The fries were pretty good though. Please consider improving your food read more

Went early on a Friday evening. Very noisy (which I sort of expected). Service was awful. Server read specials with no mention of price. Food was okay. Busser broke a wine glass at the table & really took his time cleaning large pieces, no sweeping, then left the broken glass at the table. For the prices I expected better service. I will not return. read more

I ordered the one pound pork chop . It was tender and delicious. We were there for a 60th birthday party and had a semi private area for dinner. The service was very good and it was a great time. My experience exceeded expectations based on the ratings I saw. read more

Nice place to meet friends for a meal. Close to the train station and easy to access if driving. Food selection is great and meals have a great taste. read more

Pennyville is so beautiful, especially by the big patio doors! Drinks were delicious! The "cool as a cucumber" with a touch of elderflower liquor was perfection! I ordered the chopped salad and truffle fries for food, and thought both were good! Pretty big portions, even though I only got a half salad. Service was super sweet, and I'm pretty sure the owner was there the night we visited, too, which was good to see. The ONLY weird thing was that they started closing down the restaurant (all the chairs on the table around us were placed up, bill came early, etc) when we were still there. We thought we had overextended our stay, but it was 8:24 and they supposedly close at 10:00pm. We popped down the block for another drink because we felt a little uncomfortable. Maybe it was a slow night! It definitely wouldn't impact my decision to go back though. I would happily return. read more

Waitress was really nice and knew the menu. Steak sandwich came out and was so fatty it wasn't even edible. I'm not sure how a cook could look at that piece of meat they gave me and think that it was ok to serve. read more

Came here on a unseasonably warm 65-degree day in Chicago March. They had outdoor seating, and an area of the bar, where they had giant windows opened to the outside. We opted to sit indoors, but still have the benefits of fresh air, minus the somewhat busy foot traffic and loud Metra outside. The place has a decent sized bar, and friendly staff. We shared a chicken sandwich, which was phenomenal. Washed it down with the house margarita. This guy, is a pro-salt on the rim guy, and this place did not disappoint. Margarita could have been bigger and stronger, but so can I. read more

Pennyville Station - House margarita - New American Near Me - Park Ridge, Illinois

See all

Good food, outdoor seating and when it rained they quickly moved us inside, though it was a little expensive for the portion sizes. read more

Pennyville Station - Lobster roll - New American Near Me - Park Ridge, Illinois

See all