Giving this 5 stars for a few reasons. 1 - we got a cheesesteak and a pizza and it was one of the best cheesesteaks I've ever had and the pizza reminded me of Sam's in wildwood. 10/10 2 - Saw a nonsense 1 star bitter reviewer. Didn't even get food, just trying to tear down a business. What a goof. read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

Very good vodka chicken parm sandwich, one of the best sandwiches I have had. Will definetly be back read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

We saw how amazing the food looked in social media and finally decided to make the 40 min drive....let me tell you we'll make that drive again and again and again! When they say CHEESESTEAK, trust that they aren't playing around. The flavor of EVERYTHING was on point, and the owners are truly the nicest people! We also picked up their homemade vodka sauce to-go......it should be on the shelves in the store! We will most definitely be back with friends! Thank you Peppino's for being you and throwin it down in the kitchen ITALIAN STYLE!!!! read more

I am a chicken Cesar salad wrap snob and Peppinos wrap is INCREDIBLE. I've had it both with the crispy chicken and with grilled chicken. Great proportion of chicken dressing etc. It's amazing. And very nice people when I go in. read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

Paid over $21 for a mushroom cheesesteak with fries. Massive cheesesteak but lacked flavor and not enough to cheese for all the meat. Had to add hot sauce to it for flavor. Fries were ok. Cheesesteak tasted oily; perhaps they need to tone down the amount of oil they put in the grill. Told it would take 10 minutes but took 20 minutes. Left sitting there while young counter girl failed to tell me until I asked. Perhaps their pizza is better? read more

Saw these sandwiches on TikTok and had to try them, TikTok did not lie. The Italiano is like the Ferrari of deli subs, crispy chicken, prosciutto, fresh mozz, arugula, roasted peppers, and a balsamic drizzle that makes you feel fancy. But the Cali Turkey? That's the one I'd run back for. Avocado, bacon, gruyere, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on multigrain, basically California sunshine in sandwich form. If you need me, I'll be over here plotting my next "just one more bite" moment. read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Italiano Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

See all

We stopped at lunch for cheesesteaks. I got a chicken and my bro got a regular. I would call this more of an old school cheesesteak. It was huge and loaded with meat. Cheese ratio was perfect and we ordered the seeded rolls and that was maybe the only place where there might be some argument about whether it was a great roll . Good ...not great. Very clean place and the other food looked great . The steak would easily feed two . read more

Stopped by with friends for a quick bite to eat. Ordered a calzone which was absolutely huge. Filled with mozzarella and ricotta with a marina dip. I was able to eat about third of it and took the rest home. My friends all enjoyed their meals. Will definitely return to try out other items. read more

I wouldn't know what anything tastes like bc when I went in, there were two girls waiting behind the counter. The one was taking an order on the phone and the other was standing there doing nothing. They didn't say hello, and neither did whoever the other employee was just sitting at a table waiting. It looks like any other pizza shop with pictures on the wall of Italy and family. I can't give you any advice one their food, but their service was god awful and rude. This use to be the location of Organico Pizza, and I miss it. read more

Ive been curious about Peppino's since it changed hands (less than a year ago, from Organico) . Today I got try an array of their offerings at a graduation party. Everything was excellent! The eggplant parm, the chicken parm, and the fettuccine Alfredo. Joey and my son really liked the meatballs and sausage with broccoli rabe. Im so curious to try their pizza! read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Peppino's catering (6/30/24) - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

See all

We came for the cheese steak, came back for the pizza and will be back again for sure. Don't miss out on Peppino's. We are Philly folks but I'll gladly drive the bridge for this steak. Rich full flavored, gutted out Lisios roll. Cheesy melty heaven in every bite. The staff. Superior. FRIENDLY. welcoming and genuinely glad to serve. Pizza hearty. Enough crust to hold the toppings that are all of the finest and freshest around. Located in a small shopping center with limited parking Peppinos is a traditional pizza shop. A small dining area where you can order and eat in. Grab some slices or just grab and go. I highly recommend stopping in when that cheese steak craving sets in because if his steak doesn't squelch that craving nothing will. A++ 5+ star review for stellar service and extraordinary fare. read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Cheese steak - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

See all

Peppino's cheesesteaks are the real deal! I have been seeing rave reviews of their cheesesteaks now on Instagram and have been wanting to give them a try. My girlfriend was craving a panzarotti and offered to order delivery from Peppino's for dinner. This is the first time either of us have had food from here and we were both really looking forward to it. We already have a few great spots for cheesesteaks nearby (Lillo's and Donkey's) but I'd always welcome another good restaurant in the area. There is also a brewery (Zed's) in the same shopping center which is very convenient if you want to order a pie and wash it down with a cold beer. The food arrived warm (we're around 10 minutes from Peppino's). The cheesesteak was enormous and was overflowing with steak. The sandwich looked and tasted great. I chose American cheese (the only two options they have are American and whiz - I wish they had Cooper sharp too) and didn't want any toppings so I could judge the steak sandwich by itself. It definitely can match up with both Lillo's and Donkey's - I really enjoyed it and will order some toppings next time. The fries were very good and was plenty for both of us. We actually had leftovers that reheated nicely in the air fryer. We weren't too crazy over the panzarotti though. While the dough tasted good, the edges were large in relation to the panzarotti as a whole. It was served with a side of marinara - the inside was just cheese. We ended up ordering another panzarotti from somewhere else. All things considered, it's 100% worth coming for the cheesesteaks alone and I still have to try a pizza as I've thought their pies have looked very good on social media as well. read more

See all

An awesome place, between rt70 and Main Street in Marlton. The service and hospitality is over the top, had some great conversation with the owners while we were being seated, and our server was quick, courteous and knowledgeable of the menu. We each had a delicious chicken entree with sides and a soup or a salad.. the chicken orzo soup was just like Mom used to make and the pasta fagiola soup was hearty and delicious. We could only eat half our entree because the portions are huge! Each of the food items was perfectly seasoned and expertly prepared. I just can't wait to come back to try some more things off of their menu. There is some quaint indoor seating, and a lot of their business looks like takeout or delivery. read more

See all

I think overall the experience was good (3.5). Restaurant was nice and clean! Service was good, food came out in a timely manner I was definitely disappointed when we got their garlic knots only to just get garlic bread rolls. It was miss leading. We got a personal loaded supreme which we enjoyed. Crust was just right and I like how to sausage was sliced thin instead of the crumbles. For the sandwich flight we got the italiano (new menu item), cheesesteak, and the vodka chicken parm. If you buy three or more sandwiches for the price of the three sandwiches, you can get the flight that includes fries and a drinks. without tip yet our total came to $88 using card, we had a lot of left overs read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Personal Loaded Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

See all

Consistency is key! Good pizzas every time. HUGE fan of the sliced sausage. What makes it better is the sausage is delicious. They don't skimp on toppings and everything is always hot and delicious. Super friendly staff on the phone, and when you walk in the same. Very helpful. Inside has some tables, it's warm bright and inviting. Other Italian favorites available, pastas sandwiches etc. read more

See all

I'm adding another review (or maybe this will just add an "update" to my last review) in the hopes that this place can show the rating it deserves! It's a shame because if you read the reviews that brought their rating down, it wasn't about the quality or taste of the food, which is what the rating should reflect (for the most part). Anyway, ordered my fave- their chicken cheesesteak. This time with some sweet peppers. It remains one of the best chicken cheesesteaks I've ever had. Perfect amount of cheese, tender chicken cut perfectly (not too big, not too small), and delicious fresh roll. Thanks for the consistently great food! read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - The most delicious chicken cheesesteak (with American cheese and mushrooms) - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

See all

Been there multiple times everything was over the top! The Vodka Chicken Parm is beyond words. Pizza is phenomenal. Cheesesteaks fantastic and the chicken Caesar wrap is a 10. Great service and Owners are awesome! Should have a 5 star rating on yelp! Definitely going back! And the place is so clean! read more

The first time we ordered from Peppino's, we ordered a half white, half Bella Rosa, but got an all white pizza with one side having some type of garlic oil spread, which was still pretty good. We called and let them know of the discrepancy (even though the cook had claimed that they only forgot the basil on the pizza), and they gave us a discount the next time. We also have tried the Bella Rosa (really good) and Rustica pizza (too many tomatoes for me, which caused it to be more moist but the pepperoni definitely made it taste better). We usually order takeout, but the service is friendly and be aware that there is a surcharge if paid by credit card. The restaurant is located in a plaza, and there is parking but the lot can be tight. 3.5/5. read more

See all

For lunch me and the wife got to finally try Peppinos Pizza. We split one of their massive cheese steaks with fried onions. This thing was loaded with very tasty meat and tons of cheese so do not order extra cheese It is absolutely not needed. You have a choice for a seeded roll,we prefer it without seeds and the roll from lisicos was great. We also got a large pepperoni pizza with intentions just to try and save the rest for later and the pizza was just as good. Everything was excellent, if you live nearby you scored having such a great pizza spot. read more

See all

Amazing. Worth the wait if it's busy. Highly recommend. Try a little of everything and you can't go wrong!

UPDATE Welp, I guess too good to be true. Cheesesteak is still outstanding. One of the best. But the online menu is not accurate ... online menu prices a cheesesteak ($13.99) with mushrooms ($0.75) and onions ($0.75??? Not listed as an extra topping though) ... should at most be $15.49 plus tax. Instead was billed $14.99 + $2.00 + 0.50 = $17.49. That's 0-for-3 on accuracy. I was overcharged last time too, but didn't catch it. Brought this to the attention of cashier, who was very nice (not her fault) but was charged the higher amount nonetheless. Oh well. Original review still stands in terms of quality, but now this is VERY pricey and can't be the go-to cheesesteak, especially if the billing/advertising continues to be inaccurate. read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Receipt - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

See all

Their new Chicken cutlet vodka sauce Pizzola-amazing!!!!!! Ordered at counter, fast service, nice cashiers too read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Chicken cutlet Vodka sauce Pizzola - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

See all

A change of plans from takeout to sitting and ordering more food did not upset them or bother them at all. They allowed me to take my takeout bag to the table and when my niece joined me they added her order and brought it out. This is the second time I've ordered from Peppinos and it was delicious both times. The first time I ordered, It was a delivery, which was fast, and the order was absolutely correct, a rare thing these days. I would recommend this restaurant anyone looking for a really good Italian food ! read more

We decided to try Peppinos tonight for dinner since it took over Organico's spot. We called on a Friday around 5pm and only waited 25 minutes for pickup, which was great! We liked their sauce, however the pizza was pretty mediocre. Also when it sat out for only a few minutes, the cheese hardened really quickly and the pizza did not taste good by the time I got to my second piece. Unfortunately, Organico was a lot better in our opinion. read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

We placed a delivery order. Food was very good, very large portions. Four stars because we ordered bread rolls with our salads but never received them. read more

My husband and I were in town for a funeral and this place was recommended to us to try. It was undersold to us. This place is amazing and the owners are even better. When you walk in it feels like you walked into their home and the food is delicious. My husband is from the area but I'm from TX- he told me I had to get the pizza. It was the best pizza I've ever had! It was so good we actually had another pizza delivered to our hotel the next night. read more

Wish I could leave this place ZERO stars. I ordered an 8 piece garlic parm wing with ranch xtra well done. What I received were 6 drums 2 flats. Slathered in what looked like minced garlic, parsley and cilantro mixture (never seen that kind of garlic parm before) there wasn't even any PARM. Also the wings were not well done. Not even close. Not to mention they were completely unseasoned. No salt no pepper just plain wings fried and smother in goop. I also did not receive ranch but blue cheese. I paid over $15 and picked up my order not delivery and when I complained I was offered a $3 refund. Never in my life will I ever go back and if you're thinking about it. SKIP IT. read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Garlic Parmesan Wings - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

Great place good food nice ambiance. The walnut salad was delicious. Philly cheesesteak was huge and tasty! The burger was juicy and very flavorful. Good place! read more

I look forward to ordering their vodka rig pie every Friday! It's amazing. And they are kind enough to add ricotta cheese to it as well for me. Definitely recommend ! read more

Amazing cheese steak. Next time I'll ask for an extra roll and make two sandwiches! Nice job! read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Cheese Steaks - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

My order was wrong the toppings were supposed to be for the same side and they put them separate on both sides. Also the pizza was extremely undercooked and doughy it was more like a pizza for children. This is my second try here and both were disappointing. I didn't think it could be worse than when it was Organico in the same location. read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

See all

Extremely friendly service but there's nothing going on with this pizza. Barely any sauce and what was on there had no taste. Gotta do better than this in NJ. read more

Dont take the score into consideration my whole office has ate here and never had an issue. People in this area are just high maintenance so they want a song and dance with everything. If you want good food and nice and quick service this is a great spot. A read more

not the first time they have messed up my order. would not recommend ordering from here on weekends bc it's almost messed up. This time was the seeded roll which I clearly ordered. read more

Peppino’s Pizza & Trattoria - Pizza Near Me - Evesham, New Jersey

See all

Was surprised to see the reviews in the mid tier range after getting our food because I thought it was great. I got the chicken Milanese and the chicken cutlet was thin, crispy, and delicious. I wish they would've listed on their website that they put black olives on this dish because I would've asked for them not to be there. The flavor of them seeped into the chicken cutlet a bit, not the end of the world but not preferred. The fries were actually really good. We also tried the chicken parm sandwich with vodka sauce that was also great. My fiance got a Sicilian pizza which I didn't try but he enjoyed it. After reading a few reviews I can see that the owner/social media person goes at people a bit with the replies which I find a bit odd but nonetheless, we will definitely try some other options from this place and look forward to it! read more

This place is legit! Best food I've had in years. Never disappointed. Garlic knots best over ever had

Love the cheesesteak here. The bread can be a bit better in my opinion but the amount of meat cheese and fried onions you get make up for it

I can't get enough of Peppino's Pizza! From their cheese to their Hank's BBQ pizza, it's amazing! Crispy crust and great cheese makes it a perfect pie for me. Don't forget to try the wings! The Honey Hot wings are on point as well!! Sometimes the wait is long due to being busy but it's worth it to me. Perfect for an easy quick dinner or having a party, it's always a favorite. The staff always welcomes me and I feel like a regular. I have to say, it's my new favorite spot by far! read more

Order from here every week or two. Great pizza. Just had a chicken parm sandwich and love the seeded roll.

Fast delivery, very nice margarita pizza and possibly one of the best cheese steaks I've had.