Where you grew up in Kearny usually determined which pizzeria you thought was the best and everyone else's opinion was wrong but yours. (You know how it goes!) Decades ago (in my neck of the woods) - it was Romeo's or Big Nick's. Middle of town - Peppino's or Peter's. At the other end of town ("the Manor Section") - Joe's or Pizzaland (which is in North Arlington as I'm sure all you Sopranos' fans are aware of). I worked just a block from Peter's original location and while it was never my favorite it was convenient (especially when your "lunch hour" was only 15 minutes). The original owners moved to this location (expanding to the adjoining space, which is now a completely different/separate restaurant), eventually retired and while the new owners kept the "Peter's Pizzeria" moniker they've changed and expanded the menu. We've tried the 'current' Peter's twice now and... it's not very good, sorry to say. The pizza - what you'd expect/receive from a bowling alley. The garlic knots - overcooked and they looked like they'd be bursting with flavor but were duds. The pizza sandwich - remember the scene in Ratatouille when the critic (Anton Ego) has that first bite of Remy's ratatouille and it brings him back to his youth and all those amazing memories? - that's how I get when it comes to a pizza sandwich. A 'regional delicacy' (popular in Kearny back in the day, I'm not even sure if you can find them in other towns/states) that I loved as a kid... Peter's was completely overpriced for the portion size but it was my favorite item of the three we tried. Very disappointing all around. read more

For the last few weeks, I have seen Peter's Pizzeria on Instagram posting strong about this new burger that they are claiming to be the best around. I've been hesitant because let's face it; why is a pizza joint pushing a burger so hard? How good can this be? Is it a ploy to get customers? My mind was racing. I called and told the girl that answered that I wanted this famous burger that I've been seeing everywhere. You're not just ordering a burger. She was asking how I want the burger cooked, type of cheese, do I want mushrooms, onion rings, bacon on it? I also got an antipasto and a square pie with half pepperoni. To start off with, the service was excellent. The girl was so polite and made sure to pay attention to every detail. It was so comforting. The burger came with some type of sauce on the side to put on as desired. I felt it was a thousand island based but I could be wrong. Let me tell you, the burger was very good. It was fresh, juicy and flavorful. The sauce was a good compliment to the burger. I have to admit that I was pleasantly surprised. The antipasto was excellent. Packed with meat and cheese, and didn't just have a bed of lettuce. This baby had carrot slices, cauliflower, olives, onions. I'm talking the whole shabang here. The Sicilian pie was equally as good. You would've thought I ordered extra cheese. Great cheese pull and a generous amount of mozzarella. Crust was very good. Could've possibly been a little more well done, but that's my personal preference and not a deal breaker. All in all, Peter's knocked this dinner out of the park. read more

See all

Horrible over salted food. This restaurant not worth your money or time. I didn't like their pasta or their garlic knots at all.

This place was a top 3 pizzeria in town for many many years. I understand that nothing lasts forever. I'm giving it 2 stars out of kindness. Since new ownership has taken over, I've seen the quality of food and service drop steadily. The pizzas are basically Ellios now. The ingredients they use are so cheap. What a shame. I can post a picture of my garbage can if you like, cuz that's where the last pizza I ordered belongs. read more

I feel bad leaving this review because I've lived in kearny all my life and I've had Peters Pizza many times growing up... but today I came in to grab a quick slice for lunch and the pizza was not good at all. No flavor at all! Unfortunately I won't be coming back here again. read more

I love their mushroom pizza. one of the best in the town. I shifted in another town but couldn't find any other pizza place matching their level of quality. read more

Peter's Pizzeria - Mushrooms Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kearny, New Jersey

This place used to be the best pizzeria in Kearny until they sold it a few years ago. Now this place is average at best. Their subs are still good but the pizza has gone down hill. The last four times we ordered either pick up or delivery the order was wrong. I probably won't eat here again unless there's really nothing else. Update: I have recently ordered from Peter's on three separate occasions and my experiences have been great. Our orders have been correct, the food was really good, and their pizza has improved drastically. I tried their burgers and I recommend them, especially with the onion rings. I have increased my rating from three stars to four stars and if they continue with this level of great quality and service I may increase it again. read more

Stopped by a week ago, knowing they'd sold the business and reading so-so reviews. Had not been there since Covid and that we moved about 40 minutes away - and Covid had the same effect on this business that it did so many others - and if you were a Peter's customer, please come back and patronize them again. The food is THE SAME. Same recipes, same food. One of the original owners was actually there. We had a nice conversation - I said I heard you sold the business and retired - he said yes, sold the business, and I am semi-retired. Give them a shot, especially if this was one of your old hangouts - let's keep them in business. read more

Pizza went way down hill through the last six months, the Brazilians that own this place must buy cheap ingredients. Pizza is horrible. Gotta find a new place. read more

This place has gone way downhill. I believe Pete sold the place to Brazilian's recently and you could see the food quality and customer service go downhill. The girl they have working the front (register and phone) is horrible and has no interpersonal skills. They seem to have a lot of workers who do nothing but stand around awkwardly near the front. The pizza is really poorly made. When you have a pizzeria in this area with a great location like Pete's, you really need to do better. I'm looking for a regular spot since Joe's Pizza closed, but Peter's won't be it. read more

Honestly, best place I've eaten at. Their linguine is high class and very sought after. Service is Amazing! They have a friendly atmosphere. Evelyn is vey nice and cooperative with customers! read more

Hands down I think this might be the best pizzeria in Kearny! It can get a little pricey, but the pies are most definitely worth the cost. The crust is pretty good and has a semi thick bite to it and the sauce is great! The toppings are always fresh and y'all get all this excitement at $16-$19 a pie! I've never dined in and always pickup my order. The decor inside is of a classic pizza joint. Service regarding pickup is pretty good. So good that I can double park in front and keep it moving lol. Be warned its cash only, so bring them dollars baby! They just recently opened a Walgreens next door so you might be able to get cash back or use the ATM there. Enjoy folks! read more

Peter's Pizzeria - Margarita pepperoni pie! - Pizza Near Me - Kearny, New Jersey

I've been trying to find a good pizzeria in the Kearny area for a few months now as I'm not originally from this area. Gave Peter's a try and now it's the only place I order my pizza from. Good pizza, not pricey, and they deliver pretty fast. The pizza is still hot when it arrives!!! read more

I love Paulie still making pizzas but in the kitchen it's a total disaster poor quality small portions and just crap In the front of the house I know it's 2022 but are we over trying with a welcoming crew straight out of a comic book Avoid this place Sorry but you were good once read more

Ordered a grilled chicken Cesar salad. What a disappointment. Chicken was thin hard and dry. Got iceberg and not romaine. If you're screwing up such a simple salad, I can't imagine what the rest of the food is like. I miss the old owners. read more

If you're not going to treat your customers the way Angelo & Peter did then you should change the name of this place. Horrible service every time you call there. Over an hour delivery every time I order this is the last I'm letting this happen. Don't waster your time, go somewhere else. I worked here for 13 years and I would never have treated my customers this way or make anyone wait over an hour for delivery. read more

Always order from this place & disappointed on their customer service! Ordered 1/2 cherry peppers 1/2 plain thinking I could give my child a slice from the far side nope! Not sure how pepper seeds made it all over the plain side! could have had a very bad experience! Called to just notify them of the situation & they said it could happen don't understand how it could happen on every slice! Very disappointed on the way they treat a constant customer read more

Peter's Pizzeria - Pizza half cheese half with cherry peppers - Pizza Near Me - Kearny, New Jersey

See all

I actually just ate the delivery we received from Peter's. Hungry as we were, the pictures I had every intention of taken were not willed into existence so I apologize. After the pic of the Margarita with pepperoni I saw here on Yelp when looking at reviews a few months ago, I'm pretty sure it's the only pie I have ordered from there since. Their Sicilian pies are also good. I'd pretty much be willing to bet that you'd be ok just about anything on their menu. This has become my go to if I am in the mood for pizza. Give it a try and maybe it'll become yours to...ENJOY!!! read more

My boyfriend and I live in Kearny and we order from this place all the time! They are absolutely delicious. I recommend the burger with mushrooms. The mussels are also very good here. read more

Ordered the Italian hotdog with everything (potatoes, onions, peppers, ketchup and mustard). It was delicious. The bread was spectacular Ordered cheese pie. Good sauce. Would order again. Delivery prompt. read more

We used Peter's Pizzeria for our 40th High School Reunion, let me tell you, they are the best! Awesome, amazing couldn't have been more accommodating... We didn't want to have hot food so they made us turkey and cheese and ham and cheese sandwiches which were fresh and delicious! .. Dimitrius was spot on ! I have catered from them in the past and always the best!! Keep up the good work and I advise anyone that wants to use them for a party , call and have Dimitrius help you out. Thanks again Sharon Mathewson read more

Used to be pretty good place, but has gotten progressively worse, if you order a pizza, put your oven on you will need to finish cooking it, even if you ask them to make it well done, they dont listen and dont care read more

Not a fan of the pureed marinara. Tastes horrible. Pizza isn't the best, but it'll do if you're starving.

The pizza is good but I came in for a pasta they charged me 12 dollars and the Alfredo sauce looked like milk

We ordered veal Principesa with penne and sauce.. Amazing! We also ordered eggplant with angel hair. Great combo! I would order the veal again! read more

So I've always been a fan of peters pizza but I have my go to pizza to order from another spot but with Covid and all that craziness going on I've been trying to order from local spots and trying out different spots to support. So when I saw Peter's on Grubhub and Uber Eats I was excited it took me back to nostalgia. I had an issue with grub hub which wasn't the restaurants fault so I now just order directly from them. Anytime I call whoever I speak to is so polite and sweet even their delivery drivers. I'm a crust lover so their pizza is perfect for me I'm also very picky about the flavor of sauce and their sauce is perfect just the right amount and the right tang of garlic! Today i ordered one pie half pepperoni/mushrooms and half pineapple and a regular pie(which I ordered after I called in the original order and the girl called me back to make sure and confirmed it as I was paying with card what a doll!)... as well as some eggplant rollatini and I asked for sub vodka sauce and they accommodated without hesitation, no garlic knots tonight but no big got some garlic bread instead. By the way the garlic bread went like crack tonight!!!! I was not expecting the rollatini to come with a big side of pasta but hey I'm here for it. Their not stingy with their portions and the price is great and let's be real the food is amazing!!!!!! Oh and did I mention I'm obsessed with eggplant parm/rollatini anything eggplant and I'm very picky (again I'm a connoisseur) and it was perfectly sliced and the vodka sauce was nice and creamy and had just enough amount of flavor that I didn't have to add salt or anything. Unfortunately I couldn't get pictures because everyone's hands were in the way but the food was amazing. This is my go to for the last few weeks and will stay that way!!!! Please support local business and I would say directly order from them if you want the pleasant experience. Thank you peters everyone was super happy today. read more

BEST Italian Sub of my LIFE!! Ham, Salami, Provolone, Mayo, Heavy on the Oil, Light on the Vinegar, Lettuce, Oregano and Hot Peppers on the side!! Get it....NOW!!!! read more

We used to love Peter's but now it's just a tad below average. Ordered 2 chicken dishes which were heavy on the pasta and lean on the chicken and shrimp scampi, which was bland and skimpi on the shrimp. The bread was delish and the delivery was fast, but they charge for it read more

Service is good the margerita pizza could be alittle better , it was undercooked to my liking and the dough was very chewyy read more

Peter's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Kearny, New Jersey

I love their food however the soup is packaged in a aluminum container that isn't for liquid so, the soup spills everywhere. Not effeciently packaged. They should invest in plastic containers. I'll give them 5 stars if they change to plastic. read more

Love the food here dinners and sandwiches are very good and so are the prices. The pizza I am not a fan of but you may like it more than me. They finally take a credit card so I can now recommend. Also the little blonde girl who takes the phone orders and gives you the food when you get there is great, always polite and gets the order correct! Take out, eat in, delivery, credit card, good price and great food Perfect! read more

Peter's Pizzeria - Italian sausage sandwich $8 delivered it will feed two! - Pizza Near Me - Kearny, New Jersey

Horrible food!! I got sick from a chicken dish. Even the pizza here sucks. I tried multiple times to call the owner and never got a response back. I used to order from here all the time but will never order again. The food is really terrible and the service sucks. Don't waste your money! read more

Terrible service now. Last three delivery orders were missing food or they just flat out sent the wrong meal. This is the last time we order from here. You just lost a long time customer. read more

Called at 8:10pm ordered a small pie and side salad, nothing special. At 9:20 the order arrived pie was ice cold and dried out. The dressing was already on the salad so paper bag was wet and soggy. Will not order from them again! read more

Ive been going there for 14 years and it is so good. Delicious Food, (Penne Vodka with Grilled Chicken) and always so fresh and so clean. I always look forward to eating a slice while waiting for my order. read more

I've never been motivated enough to write a bad review but this place takes the cake. All I ordered was wings and a Sicilian slice. What I got was salty soggy wings which weren't even spice and burnt cheesy bread. After I called to complain I was given attitude by the manager and he continued to argue with me over what a Sicilian slice was. If I could give a no star rating I would. DONT EAT HERE! Oh and he said he'd refund my money. Nope. read more

Very disappointed in the spaghetti and meatballs. I will spare you all the negative details. But in short, it was smelly and probably old canned tomato sauce with tap water added to it. It was more of a liquid than a sauce. The meatballs were not pleasant. On top of that, I asked if my to-go order came with forks, the man said yes, and once I got back to my job to eat the food, no forks or napkins were provided. I had to go back. No paper towels, or toilet paper in the bathroom. The older man who I assume is the owner seems very nice. I just had a really bad experience with their pasta. I'm sorry to leave a negative review, but I really would encourage them to make a change. read more

We've ordered twice, delivery was late both times, and both times we were surprised by the price. The prices on the Facebook page are apparently old, their prices have gone up. They charge a delivery fee which I can't find mentioned anywhere on the menu and it was not mentioned when we called to order. That's not very nice now, is it? Pizza itself is good, but the misleading pricing that they have posted, and extra fees, were no fun. Don't plan to call again. read more

Great local pizzeria. Love all their dishes. Amongst my favorites are the chicken parm and veal princepessa. Call ahead and pick up or delivery available after 4 pm. read more

Classic pizza joint that makes the best pies in the area. Also large menu at very reasonable prices