This is just such a wonderful little spot. Amazing food. Good vibes and prices that can't be beat for the ocean side view!!! Lovely staff too!' read more

The food was tasty, the service great, but the parking a pain in the A... when the Scream Park down the street is open. If you are in the area and want good food definitely check it out. I would not make a trip to come here though. read more

Piccolo Cantina Bay - Loaded Nachos - Italian Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Quaint little 8 table restaurant serving up some sizable and authentic mexican dishes. Doesn't hurt it also offers a beautiful beach front view of Long Island sound. The cocktails are prepared well, appetizers fresh and if I must say, the carne asada is mind blowing good. I've been coming here for few years now and the friendly atmosphere makes it all worth while. It's a bit out of the way, but trust me, they're worth the trip. read more

See all

Fantastic food cooked by wonderful people. My bf and I frequent this restaurant a bunch. Their food is so so good and my favorite meal is the steak fajitas, and their sides are all too good as well as the guacamole and chips. Jarritos and margaritas are also fantastic as always. We love that this is a family ran restaurant. They really make you feel like at home. The restaurant is very cute and has a warm feeling. You also get quite a view as it is beachfront!! read more

The food is so amazing. Mexican and Italian both superb. Service is always very good. The owners and staff are all family. So personable, friendly and accommodating. My family and I have been dining there more than 15 years. Try it. You won't be disappointed. read more

What a hidden gem this joint is! The place is small so make a reservation. The food is just outstanding and delicious. It's as if you were going to eat at your Grandmother's house. We had the Mexican Pizza, the Burrito Supreme, Crispy Tacos and the Flautas. Everything was delicious and home made. The service was excellent and the people were fantastic. There was so much food that we had to take it home. You'd be remiss if you didn't try this joint. read more

Everything you get here is extremely delicious and authentic. Absolutely perfect balance of flavors and the cocktails are incredible also. Nice and strong but not overbearing. The steak quesadilla is my go to, it comes with some of the best guacamole you'll ever have. Not to mention the rice and means is phenomenal. I love the fact that this is a family owned and operated business. Everyone is quite friendly and happy to answer any questions. HIGHLY recommended!!! read more

Piccolo Cantina Bay - Beautiful rice and beans and guacamole and sour cream. All full of amazing taste - Italian Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

I've been coming here since they opened and they just keep getting better and better. They have Mexican, Italian and seafood options to choose from. Also a great place to eat outdoors in the summer as it's right across the street from a beach. The staff is also very friendly and patient. read more

Piccolo Cantina Bay - a plate of mexican food - Italian Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Very hospitable staff, very friendly enjoyed that. Margaritas were good/strong both frozen and rocks Plenty of food pork chop was massive and very good but be sure to order it medium not well done Hot sauce on the pork chop was awesome please bottle and sell it. Mariachi platter was filling but calamari was dry. Would try a different app next time read more

See all

Y'all are crazy for giving this place anything but 5 stars!! The food here is delicious - we go here at least once a week. Any friends who come out to stay with us from the city beg to go here!! The Fajitas are the best I've ever had, and I've had many. They always have specials that are always smothered in the most delicious sauces. The Pollo relleno is also 5 stars! The restaurant also serves Italian food if Mexican is not your jam. The restaurant is family owned and the family is awesome! So friendly and nice - shoutout to Jose and his mom for always taking care of us! (And chef Jose too) Do not miss out going here, it's one of the best restaurants in Nassau! read more

My wife and I planned to take our kids to Bayville Adventure park. We were running late and needed a place to take the kids. I'd been dying for some Mexican food and La Cantina Bay came up. I'd seen that one of the things that separates them from the other restaurants in the area was their customer service. The other reviews did not lie. This place was fantastic. From the minute we stepped through the door we felt welcomed. The view from any of the tables is pretty great, we sat window side and had a great view of the water and the park. Right off the bat, my kids also loved it because they offered several flavors of "Jarritos" (fantastic Mexican soda). We had the Nacho appetizers, it was a great choice. The pico de gallo was fresh, the black beans were flavorful, the beef was juicy and the chips were nice and warm. The nachos did have a bit of kick so watch out if you have little ones. While on the topic of kids, they had a pretty good kids menu. My son had the cheeseburger. This thing was huge and I"m pretty sure it was had made, my son demolished it. I had the steak fajitas, absolutely amazing. The steak and onions, peppers came out on a searing hot skillet. It came with a side plate with the refried beans, fresh guac, more pico de gallo and some of the freshest tortillas. My wife the had the steak burrito, this thing was the size of a football. And I stole a bite from my wife, I wished I'd had that as well. If you wanted place to sit down and enjoy an authentic meal, with a great view this is the place. What also made it great was the fact that they catered to kids. They stayed calm before the park and let my wife and I eat in peace. This is definitely a go-to place. read more

Piccolo Cantina Bay - Steak Fajitas, AMAZING! - Italian Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Yes they finally have a liquor license, plenty of beers and all tequilas !!! The food is very good almost like homemade the fajitas were gynormous, and delicious, we also tried the shredded pork it was very well flavored and the view of the water with the Mexican music in the background made you feel like you're on vacation read more

Piccolo Cantina Bay - Combination fajita, steak chicken and shrimp it was huge and delicious - Italian Near Me - Bayville, New York

Stopped in here with my wife today. It was 3:30 on Friday, we were the only ones in there, as we expected at that time. It was nice to see a family run restaurant. The owner was the chef, his wife and daughter the servers. Food was really good. We started with the guacamole and we ordered the mussels. The chef came out and said the mussels came in a little small today and asked if we would like the clams instead. We said why not. The broth in this clam dish was fantastic. Then he came back out and asked if we want to try his carrot soup. One of the best soups I've literally ever had. Then we finished with steak fajitas and the flautas. Both great dishes. They were really friendly and nice people. We really appreciated their service and kindness. Also don't forget to get the red sangria it's amazing. read more

Food is great servers are very nice and I recommend the enchiladas and Carne Asada along with there Cheese Quesadillas They are delicious. Lots of groovy, Mexican music playing in the background read more

Yummy Mexican food and surprisingly good Italian dishes. The ingredients always feel fresh and the service has always been good. You can tell the family that owns this place care. Only knock is the food is slightly overpriced for what you get.... especially for take out. Otherwise great! read more

This is my favorite Mexican restaurant. Their steak fajitas are absolutely delicious and the best I've tasted. They are served sizzling hot with refried beans, sour cream, cheese and salsa. Our friends also enjoyed what they ordered (I forget what the ordered). The staff is friendly and it's nice to be able to sit and look outside at the water. Next time you're in the mood for Mexican food, give this great restaurant a try. You won't be disappointed. read more

Great fajitas!! Delicious margs, and out of this world pork chop! This place has it all. The pasta and sauces are great too. At a new location in Bayville with a punch of flavor and the sweetest staff. read more

See all

During the past year they obtained their liquor license and it's no longer BYOB. I do miss the BYOB and it seems that they may have lost some regular customers that were attracted to BYOB. I must say that a glass of house wine (generous pour) at $7 IS reasonably priced. Earlier this month I visited again and upon arrival I was greeted by owner/chef Jose Morales who just happened to be standing in the open kitchen facing the customer entrance. White board specials continue to be featured without pricing and are priced high. (See my previous review.) I had the chicken francaise and it was tasty with a generous portion. The chicken francaise came with a side of pasta. The wait staff asked me what sauce I wanted and I ordered vodka sauce, just as a member of my party was having with penne and chicken as their main course. When I received the bill I was surprised to see an additional $5 charge for vodka sauce and I questioned the wait staff, especially since he didn't mention any additional charge when he took my order. He said that he'd ask the manager about the charge. When he returned to take my charge card to settle the bill I asked him about the charge and he told me that the manager confirmed to him that was indeed the correct charge. In my opinion that's just poor customer service not to tell the customer that there would be an additional $5 charge for vodka sauce when the wait staff asked me for the type of sauce AND perhaps even poorer customer service for the wait staff not to get back to me about my inquiry. read more

Great cuisine i enjoyed my mean very much great Italian food and Mexican food definitely recommend

Can never decide whether to get a Mexican dish or an Italian one. Whichever one is chosen it will be delicious. Highly recommend.

Piccolo Cantina Bay is situated in beautiful Bayville and couldn't have a prettier view of the water. It's large windows allow guests to enjoy those views while dining in. Unfortunately the food is not anywhere as good as the views. Not only are dishes overpriced but both the taste and quality are mediocre. I have visited a few times, each time hoping the food will be better but am disappointed each time. That being said, service is great and the venue itself is nice so it would be a great place to grab some drinks and enjoy the view! read more

Went to stop by a friends friends house and she wanted lunch. She picked the spot she was in the mood for Mexican. I didn't argue, it's best to never argue with a lady. So we came to this spot. First good news was plenty of parking. Also I Must say I enjoyed the feel of this place, I felt like I was far away on vacation with the Spanish look and music playing in the background. This place his family owned and that means they run it with love! They proved it with the great service. It wasn't busy at all so we had are run of the place. I got a chicken burrito that was good, I mean really good. My friends got tacos and she liked them a lot. They also said they plan on opening more locations, I hope they come out East, it would be a welcomed addition. I would definitely come back with a group because you feel like your on a Mexican getaway. If you do go pack sun screen because this place is hot! read more

See all

Great Food, BUT DOESN'T SERVE ALCOHOL. That's right, this place doesn't serve any type of alcoholic beverages - wine beer or liquor. HOWEVER, you could BYOB! So, drink up! This is a family run establishment and the workers are beyond nice! I love the wait staff and service. This place was very accommodating to myself as I added more and more people to the table each time. They eventually moved us to a bigger table with no issue. We came here for Cinco De Mayo. I had the Carnitas dish which was marinated pork with refried beans and rice. Everything was tasty. They give you a generous amount of food - sour cream and guacamole. The cheese quesadillas were great - my favorite part of the meal! The steak fajitas were some of the best I have ever tasted. Everything else was good. Tres leches cake was really tasty, Flan was okay in my opinion - I Don't care for flan idk why I always seem to get it! They had a tent set up with a DJ for the holiday - I recommend a Mariacha Band or however you spell it. Overall: Great Food, Rec the quesadillas! NO LIQUOR OR ALCOHOL SERVED. BYOB ONLY. Try the Tres Leches. Amazing Service! read more

See all

I remember when José and his family originally ran café jalesico (I'm sorry if that's incorrect spelling) in Glen Cove when I was little. When I found out that his phenomenal nachos and fajitas had left Glen Cove I was quite upset and worried where I would get comparable quality and prices. Those nachos deluxe could not be replaced. Where else could I find paella made with love! This family ran restaurant was irreplaceable. I thought I had lost the most delicious fajita on Long Island. But fear not! I randomly walked into La Cantina Bay with a good friend of mine who was looking for a good burrito. Despite it's odd location we ventured inside. Immediately recognized the woman at the door! To my astonishment it was mama from Café Jalesico! To this day they recognize my family and I. You can't beat that kind of love and service. And BYOB is always nice. read more

Noticed a parking lot full of customers while driving by and decided to give this place a try. La Cantina Bay is a Mexican / Italian restaurant Located on the border of Locust Valley and Bayville; just off the bend of Bayville ave looking toward Long Island sound. This smallish sized restaurant seems a bit outdated; complete with outdoor sconces indoors and a glass wall giving the illusion this is a larger restaurant than it is. With a couple of flags on the wall and colorful tables; this place is casual and nothing fancy, but I like it. More importantly, service from all the courteous staff was noticeably exceptional and appreciated. We ordered a sizzling broiler plate of steak fajitas and some nachos grande to keep it simple and everything was great. The flank steak was well marinated and tender, vegetables were fresh and flavorful and made great leftovers. Just those two plates were perfect for two with plenty to take home and enjoy later. The menu is split between Mexican and Italian dishes which originally made me wonder what to expect. However, we noticed other couples digging in to seafood and pasta dishes which all looked good. I'll be sure and give their Italian side a try next time. Keep it simple, ask for pricing on the specials and you'll go home happy. read more

Very friendly atmosphere and amazing food! Really delicious!!! I can say, that best tacos in my life I tried here! I'm not an expert, but I understand when food is more than just delicious! My best wishes to family holding this restaurant! read more

I have 2 best options for Mexican food... and "La Cantina " makes this short list easy! What a nice bunch of fellows! They make you feel like home... and treat you with excellent food and drinks! read more

Very nice small, family run Mexican restaurant with views of the sound. The service and food were really good. Fried calamari sample was given to us on the house and was tender, nachos were very tasty as were the burritos and fajitas. Con leche and tiramisu desserts were very good as well. The servers were very attentive and accommodating. Will return! read more

Imma keep this short, have a friend who works here and went to suprise her, she was the waitress and did her job, but we waited 1.5 hours for our food and didn't even get our appetizers in that time, and our food had hair in it. Total waste of time and money. Would not recommend if you want food out in under an hour! read more

This place is a Mexican food restaurant. It says they have Italian food there, but it's such a bad version of Italian food that it really shouldn't be called "Italian." The Mexican food was just ok. The plastic table cloths are sticky--not sure how clean they are. The service was ok. read more

BYOB is a big plus. Food is good, certainly worth the price. Friendly servers. Kitchen has a tendency to get backed up but it's worth the wait. Update- more I come here the more I like it. read more

My family and LOVE La Cantina!! It has become a family Christmas Eve tradition. We have been going here since they originally opened at the Tides Motel. Great food and service!! You cannot go wrong with either the Mexican or Italian food. read more

This place has a new location and I was hoping for the best,but NO. This restaurant was not the best to start with. It was plastic tablecloths and sticky menus. The special board is so messy it's hard to read. So with the new location I thought it would be clean and well decorated....no now we eat off of plastic thin plates that they can hardly pick up . I tried again but we won't be back . read more

I'm here right now. Service atrocious, presentation worse, taste mediocre. There's no good reason to come here. read more

Piccolo Cantina Bay - I ordered chilaquiles... - Italian Near Me - Bayville, New York

So lucky to have this restaurant in our little town of Bayville. All of the Mexican dishes we've tried are delicious. I haven't had an opportunity to try the Italian dishes but my friends who have - say they are delicious as well. All of the people who work here are friendly and give great service. Love, love love this place. read more

I order from here at least once a week and the food lasts me for two days! Never had a dish I didn't like!

La Cantina is a great place for a good and inexpensicve meal. It's family owned and operated. BYOB is a fun and unusual way to dine, esopecially with a large group of friends. The Italian food, in my opinion, is better than the Mexican, Their seafood fra davolo is the exrtaordinary. I reccommend La Cantina. read more

The food was border line inedible. No flavor on the nachos at all. The tacos they brought out without tomatoes when they say on the menu that they are served with tomatoes.. The waitress said a lot of people request no tomatoes so they Dont put them on anymore. The entrees were lacking a lot of flavor. Didn't even finish eating it. The service was terrible and they only had 1 other table. They sat us down and never brought water. I ordered my daughters food right away and they brought it out after the adult entrees. The entrees were served within minutes of dropping the appetizer. The wait staff never came over to ask if we need anything.. Had to get up and ask for sour cream for my nachos read more

I wanted to love this place, I really did. The people are great, BYOB policy worked for us. But the food just wasn't good. Very bland and mediocre. read more

This place is absolutely shameful. I've been there twice and each time the food is disgusting. I've tried both the Italian and the Mexican, and I wouldn't feed either of them to my dog, let alone another human being. The pasta was obviously microwaved from an old batch of pre-made dishes, as it came out 3 minutes after I ordered it. You could make better pasta and sauce at home from a can. Don't waste your money here. read more