What a gem of a restaurant. The food and service was excellent. Varied menu each time based on what's available. It's that special occasion place you really don't need a special occasion to go! read more

See all

Love this place and food is elegant. Love the presentation. Friendly servers Recommend this place for any occasion

Amazing food! Totally "authentic" Italian dishes. A really unique dining adventure. There is always a vegetarian option on the ever changing menu. All options are creative and delicious. The staff is friendly and super helpful. You'll need a reservation. There is free street parking. read more

See all

We returned to Autentico after many years and were not disappointed! There is nothing like the food here on Long Island. We throughly enjoyed everything we ordered. I really appreciate that there are always vegan options for each course and love that the menu is seasonal. The whole experience is beyond enjoyable here. From the cute, cozy atmosphere and decor to the amazing staff and service, it is a wonderful special occasion restaurant and we will have to return again much sooner. read more

Autentico continues to delight... step off the beaten path and sit back and relax. Enjoy a leisurely European style meal, unhurried and hand made with care. If you want fast and predictable service, go to a chain restaurant at the mall. Here you will find a eclectic menu with original dishes, hand made by the chef. Something for everyone.. carnivores, vegetarians, vegans. Perfectly mixed cocktails, superb and exciting desserts. This is the only indoor dining that we will go to.. spaced, immaculate, noses tucked behind masks as they should be. Step away from the ordinary and treat yourself to a very special menu and experience. Be patient..go with someone you love sometime soon. read more

See all

There are a lot of Italian restaurants around, but not so many that get close to good food in Italy. This one is very honest and faithful to the good practices of Italian cuisine. read more

Absolutely fantastic dinner. Every dish was better than the next! The meatballs cacio e pepe, spaghetti with clams, arancini rice balls, and bolognese are all next level. read more

Food is extraordinary. Very Authentic Sicilian dishes. Chef is a master in his field. All his dishes are so carefully designed and full of flavors. If you are a foodie, this is a must try place. Service was a little off the night we went. We are definitely going to give it another try. I do have a suggestion for a Sicilian dessert chef should add granita di Limone con brioche to the dessert menu. read more

Newsday review was correct. Quaint Italian Restaurant In Oyster Bay. Don't bother to look at the menu ahead of time you won't find it on line. They have a handwritten menu since the food does change frequently. It was our 1st visit to Autentico. Our table was reserved & we were promptly seated. The Waiter had a wonderful sense of humor. We started off with Salad,Crab Cocktail,tomato & mozzarella and quesadilla which were all amazing. Dinner we had Lasagna, Pappardelle & Eggplant With Ricotta stuffed spaghetti everything was delicious. We ended our meal with the Lava cake. The only negative is that the air conditioner could be higher & the noise could be less. I would definitely recommend this place. read more

See all

A wonderful place to enjoy a dinner for two. The servers were fabulous people and I enjoyed the ambiance. A must try is the bolognese read more

Autentico - THE Bolognese - Italian Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Autentico was truly authentic. Having just returned from Sicily, the land of my mother's birth, we felt like we were transported back there. The ambiance is light and airy, very classy. The staff could not have been more attentive and informative. The chef is truly a craftsman, not only with his innovative ways to prepare classic Italian foods but also in his presentation. Quite the gem!! Looking forward to returning. read more

I had the beet and goat cheese salad and the Bolognese. The salad was not very interesting, needed some acid, the pasta was nothing special. Nice people though :-) read more

Great food and service ! Small place but cozy in oyster Bay will definitely return and tell all my family and friends!

I am a big supporter of local small businesses and Autentico I liked. The atmosphere was cozy and authentic. The food was also homey and cozy as well. The had the sweet cheese ravioli and the Bolognese and artichokes as the starter. Service could have been better but they were super nice. Thank you all for working hard to stay open in these difficult times. Keep it up! read more

Autentico - Ravioli - Italian Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

Autentico is a quaint, truly authentic Italian restaurant, with the chef himself being straight from Italy, and all the dishes made with homemade pasta and the freshest ingredients. Our waiter, Angelo, was amazing. Very attentive, friendly, and made the best recommendations for our table. We'll definitely be going back here! Try the almond cookies. To die for! read more

I really wanted to check this place out over the last few years, but never got around to it because I've been very pleased with Angelina's for my Italian "fix". Well, last week I was in the unusual position of having dinner at Angelina's on Monday evening and needed another place to go on Saturday, so I booked a table at Autentico. Talk about an embarrassment of riches! This spot felt like walking into a well-appointed Italian kitchen in the 'old country ', and the service was informal, friendly and excellent. The food-' oh my'-- the food was absolutely fantastic! The branzino, served over grilled asparagus was perfectly cooked and beautifully presented. The paparedelle bolognese was the freshest pasta I've eaten since my grandmother passed away thirty years ago! The clams oreganata were perfectly prepared, and the desserts were truly epic! The small, aptly named 'Autentico ' is a gem in every respect. I highly recommend it to anyone who wants to taste why Italian food has captured the hearts of people for generations. read more

One of the best Italian restaurants in the area - including NYC / Manhattan. Cozy, quaint and uniquely decorated. Dedicated and hardworking staff that loves to take care of its customers. Food is delicious and prepared with attention to detail and quality ingredients found nowhere else. Better than eating at my Nonna's. Run to this place - yes it's that good. read more

Great food and service. The ambiance is very good. A small dining area so make reservations.

Another great dinner! Zack was great and always serves with a smile - even if hidden behind a mask. If you haven't eaten here, be sure to get the Bolognese! read more

Autentico - Autentico Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Pretty restaurant, but awful martinis and the food was very mediocre. Not sure why there's so much hype.

Lovely Italian place! My friend and I brought our mothers there for dinner. Freshly made pasta and our waiter was so much fun to talk to. Looking forward to coming back! read more

See all

5 stars from service by Zach to food prep by Francesco....I'm never disappointed by this gem in Oyster Bay. Its a must for authentic, creative, fresh preps by a Sicilian chef.....yummy! read more

Delicious farm to table dining. Feels like you took a trip to Italy. Warm inviting service. Don't skip dessert-it's worth the indulgence!

Seriously the most disgusting restaurant I've ever visited. Ordered a dish with octopus, asked for a knife to cut it, the waiter joked that I wanted a "big boy knife". More like I needed a chainsaw, disgusting, sent that shit back. Not to mention, at a table of 5 people, literally no one liked their main dish. read more

Dropped our takeout order because it was not properly bad received the same order back with third less pasta and no meat sauce my husband watched as they grabbed the pasta off sidewalk put back in container they told him they would remake but return outside within 3 minutes it was obvious to us they scraped the pasta off sidewalk and put back in container tried to complained they were rude and dismissive lots of my family and friends eat here never again !!! I would appreciate call from owner with apology . carmela read more

Autentico - Scraped my pasta off sidewalk gave back to us - Italian Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Great food! Wonderful ambiance! Great service! Seasonal menu , freshest ingredients. Our favorite restaurant in Oyster Bay.

OMG! This place sends you back to southern Italy in a flash. The food is the real deal! We will travel just for this restaurant . My wife and I loved it! read more

When you dine at Autentico, make sure to order an appetizer, main course, and dessert! Each bite you take is filled with flavor and freshness. You won't find a more authentic Italian restaurant as this one! It is truly a hidden gem located in the town of Oyster Bay. read more

See all

A small intimate, quiet restaurant with good service and wonderful food!

Delicious, my son and I went there tonight. Very cozy and staff are friendly, welcoming and efficient. Food We had chicken and mashed potatoes, my son had pasta with cauliflower and sauce. He is vegetarian and they have vegetarian options. Now dessert was stracchino mousse and tiramisu both outstanding. Can't wait to go back. read more

My new go to spot in Oyster Bay, this place is worth the drive. Took my adult children there, we eat out together every two weeks or so, they both said this was the best place I've taken them to eat the last few years. Go, its FANTASTIC read more

Like many other reviews with one star, the disappointment is not with the food but with the service . We were the only table and it was our first night there. Important to note that many Italians don't know ( or care ) that the customers can hear and understand different dialects - be careful when you're speaking about a table . We eat out all of the time - we've never been served a 2 ounce glass of wine and expected to pay $14 for it- when I questioned the size of the pour and was told it was well more than 6 ounces I decided to just ask for a bottle - long story short - the server wouldn't take the glass and give me a bottle or just give me the bottle - she said I'm going to charge you for the 2 ounce pour and a bottle - I said that was wrong and not good business practice and I decided to not buy the bottle . When it was time to pay, the server didn't care , I explained that I myself was a server for 8 years and that her response made us not want to return - the other server said there was nothing wrong with the food just the wine and that other places would do the same - I quickly replied not Stellina's, a beautiful Italian restaurant down the block and they both said that that's not a Sicilian restaurant, their restaurant is different and i couldn't believe what was just said - I'm Sicilian ...what an insult , that Sicilians are not as hospitable when it comes to serving people apparently ...they do not know what needs to be done to keep a good customer and acted aloof when I said I'm writing a review . I didn't drink that 2 ounce pour and left it for them . Asked to speak to the owner who was the chef and he refused to come out (speaks volumes ). To argue with a customer and deny that what they did was wrong = Bad practice. read more

This is hands down the best authentic Sicilian-Italian cuisine on Long Island. Elegant food in a beautiful little restaurant. From the hand written menu to the wine and desserts, this place is incredible. I had the Filet Mignon which was cooked & seasoned perfectly & my girlfriend had the swordfish. Now I am not very big on seafood, but I could not get over how DELICIOUS this fish was! I would go back alone just for that! The place is a little small but it's perfect for a date night. 11/10 would recommend to anyone. read more

Tried for the first time it will be last time crab appetizer was good but most crab is Spaghetti with clams very tasty but ridiculously small portion for twenty five dollars. Tuna not cooked as asked for. Chicken dish served over a fruit salad really? Chicken was tough overcooked and banal in taste,many a fast food joint makes better. If you don't mind spending a lot of money for average fare this is the place for you read more

See all

Second time coming to Autentico and it was delicious!!!! I absolutely love this restaurant. My boyfriend and I got the meat platter, which was perfect. I got a limoncello martini. We both got the butternut squash ravioli, if you're not a fan of sage though, this dish is not for you. And our desserts were amazing!! I will say that service is a little slow but that doesn't bother myself or my boyfriend we were in no rush. A little patience for excellent food is all it takes. Definitely recommend getting an appetizer, entree, and dessert when coming here because you won't want to miss any of it. read more

See all

A first visit intended to be followed by many more - but you blew it, Autentico. If I could give this restaurant zero stars, I would. No thought was put into the acoustics, as the restaurant is designed with tiled floors, hard walls, hard metal tables without tablecloths, and a tiled ceiling. There is no wood, fabric, or carpeting to absorb sound. A greasy spoon's decor has more forethought. I can't remember going to a place, ever, that was as loud as Autentico. There was no possibility of holding a conversation, so we just cringed at the noise, ate silently, and left promptly. During our first (and last) visit we were seated in the main area shared by a table of eight obnoxious, foul mouthed patrons who spent the night dropping F-bombs, seeing who could scream the loudest and clapping after every profane comment. These people belonged in a drunken backyard barbecue party. The restaurant did little to quell the noise and hush the profanity, and it was apparent that every other patron could not wait to get dinner over with so they could leave. Management had every opportunity to take control, shut the noise down, and put this unkempt group in the rear of the restaurant and away from other patrons, but instead, it let the night proceed like a frat party gone wild. I guess that placating the party of eight loudmouths was more important than ensuring a pleasant experience for the other five tables who fast-tracked their meals in the one hour period that we were there and left hurriedly. Not an apology or even a visit from the owner or manager during our meal. To boot, food was lackluster. The green salad with avocado was an oily mess of chopped iceberg lettuce with two bite size pieces of avocado. The papardella with bolognese was edible, plain, and a bit sweet, yet the eggplant parmigiana was a tiny, round small serving of mushy eggplant swimming in sauce, each ingredient not discernible from the next, and difficult to eat given the shape of the small pot in which it was cooked. While I had no desire to prolong my visit, to combat the atmosphere, I ordered two glasses of overpriced (and very underpoured) Pinot Noir. It could not improve the ambiance. You'd think that given the circumstances and the displeasure that all patrons were visibly showing, management would have 'comped' some portion of the meal or offered a free dessert or take the wine off the bill, but - no - were were delivered a full bill with zero apology or compensation for an expensive and stressful dining experience. Autentico - you lost a frequent diner. We dine out five nights a week and were really looking forward to finding a nice, reasonable Italian restaurant with a warm atmosphere that we could go to once a week. Your prices are 50% higher than than what they should be for comparable food elsewhere, and the ambiance is downright awful and unbearable. We'll give our patronage to PortoFino, Joanina, Sal D's, Primo Piatto, and Angelo's where we'll be paying a fraction of the price to eat in a safe, comfortable environment and will be treated like valued clients. read more

My husband and I had a wonderful dinner at Autentico on Saturday night. We were here years ago and enjoyed it, but somehow haven't been back in a while. What a pleasant surprise. We were craving a dinner like one we would have had in Italy and Autentico delivered! The service was excellent. The piadina was perfect and the appetizer special of fresh figs and prosciutto was delicious. Even though we were full, we found room for the homemade pasta - spaghetti with vongole for me, the pasta with octopus special for my husband. Both were terrific. We were also delighted by the interesting regional choices on the wine list. We can't wait to return!!! read more

Great experience. No complaints here. Service, food, atmosphere, and drinks were all excellent!

After several visits my last experience is worthy of taking the time to give proper praise n well deserved props to this awesome establishment! Zach was outstanding and went above and beyond to compensate for the short staff**actually he was The Staff... he was a one-man show and his performance did not disappoint n handled a crowded dining room with finesse n signature humor:) Now to the meal..best yet from start to finish this place does not disappoint the chef is brilliant you feel like you are sitting in someone's home in Sicily and getting authentic hence the name true Italian food at its finest save room for dessert we've only gone on weeknights so I can't speak for the weekend crowd but oyster Bay has a true gem in Autentic..oh ohhhh ohhhhh...it's magical! read more

See all

Had dinner last night with my daughter. We sat outside as it was a great night. The chef has a new fall menu which has a nice variety of items from apps, pasta, meat along with Vegan and Gluten free options. I had a risotto with gorganzola and asparagus that was fabulous. My daughter had the always solid spaghetti and clams in a spicy wine sauce. Vegan artichokes hearts was perfect and his desert never fails. Loved it as always read more