I ordered their meatball platter, which consisted of three tasty meatballs slightly larger than golf balls and four pieces of pita bread, at 12:30am. It was delivered by Doordash at 1:10am read more

Best gluten free pizza I've ever had (I have celiac disease). Huge portion sizes. Amazing food.

Been here several more times, usually on the late night after a night out in Fells with friends. Pizza is amazing. I especially like the taste of the thick, chewy, doughy, delicious crust! Sauce is great and topping quality is superb. This is perhaps my favorite pizzeria in Baltimore. To top it all off, the owner is extremely friendly and kind. I hope people give this place a try as it is a great addition to the Fells restaurant scene. read more

If you're in Fells, Pie in the Sky is worthy of satisfying that pizza fix. Upon entering, I had an immediate thought... that the atmosphere was very sterile. One star was lost here because there were a few things going on. There was way too much white, no contrast. Nothing leaving the customer feeling relaxed like they're in a jazzy place. The second was the music. Great choice, but where were the retro seats and barstools to match? Something just wasn't jiving. Ordering was easy, walk up to the counter and pick what you'd like from the large chalkboard, or menu. Plates, napkins, etc are all self service. When the pie comes out, it's just the pie. We each ordered an individual pie and none of them were leaking toppings. I ordered the eggplant pizza and substituted the garlic sauce for red sauce. Great choice in my opinion, loved it. The olives are not chopped and cooked within. They're whole on top of the pie, which worked for me because I'm not an olive fan. A table nearby ordered pies and sandwiches. The sandwiches were massive. Definitely worth it if you're wicked hungry, or hoping for leftovers. Overall experience was great! It's just the atmosphere. Somethings gotta give. read more

Called today after being out of Baltimore for 4 months. Had the most recent menu. Prices have gone up over 15%... Calzone, $12 to $13.95 10 wings, $9.50 to $12.95 Really? No thank you. read more

Along with the friendly customer service the food was amazing. Very highly recommended if your around the area. You will not be disappointed! read more

Fun atmosphere. Delicious pizza and Yeungling on tap! (Can't get that in CA) and where else can you watch sports in Turkish?

Another good restaurant opens in Fells Point. Hopefully, PITS won't put BOP out of business. Pizzas are amazing here. I've been here twice in one week - it's that kind of place. The owner is very nice and takes a lot of pride in delivering a good product. They have many options on their menu including pizzas, pastas, sandwiches, and desserts. I'm tempted to try some of their pastas, especially the homemade beef ravioli with yogurt sauce. Try it now, because it is bound to become very popular. read more

Pie In The Sky - Casual but tastefully decorated - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

The pizza at Pie In The Sky is legit! It comes out hot and fresh. The crust is AMAZING. We had the Portobello Mushroom. SO good! It is made with fresh mushroom, red peppers, kalamata olives and a sprinkle of feta cheese (and mozzarella).I love that it has garlic herb sauce instead of the traditional red. But the best part is the staff. SUPER friendly and generous. If you're in the area and have a hankering for pizza... this is the best place to go. read more

Pie In The Sky - Portobello Mushroom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

I honestly can't describe the type of pizza I got other than just wrong. I ordered a margarita 10 in and some wings. The wings were seasoned nicely but pizza is a no read more

Pie In The Sky - 10" Margarita - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Super good, solid local pizza! I love a place that does make your own with all of different options for crust and toppings. The pizza tasted really good and not greasy at all. My only grievance was the toppings were kind of pricy, especially as you add on more than one. The 10" also looked pretty small.. I doubt it was actually 10" but it tasted good so it was worth it. read more

I was excited to try the vegan options at Pie in the Sky. I ordered via their website and tried using the 15% off code on their website, but it didn't work (strike 1). The actual prices were higher than the takeout menu prices posted online (strike 2). I really should have just not proceeded with the order but it was the closest vegan-friendly option. Upon arrival to the restaurant, I went to the register to pay and asked about the discount code. The manager came over and said the website was out of date and he didn't have a button to honor the discount. Bad business. When I got my receipt, I noticed that there was a 10% service charge (FOR PICKUP!) that they had not disclosed (strike 3). On top of all this, the food was just okay. Will definitely not be back! read more

I ordered a late night small pizza from here and honey old baywings. The wings didn't really have any flavor, the sauce was all liquify at the bottom of the container and the pizza was maybe the worst delivery pizza I've ever had. read more

Nice restaurant, Best staff, masoud and Sidan Good manner Good foods Delicious Try chicken sandwiches And caesar salads yummy read more

I called 20 times to place a Togo order while waiting in a line of 15 people. Watched the host hang up on every one of my calls. Reggie G is not the friendliest of employees. Hopefully the food will make up for his poor attitude. read more

Ok, place is a life saver for a vegan at midnight looking for something to eat. Great wheat crust and veggie options... I'm still on the fence regarding the pizza sauce but when you're hungry in the harbor area and everywhere you turn it's a bar or burger joint, this place feels like it came from up above! read more

Pie In The Sky - Vegan veggie wheat crust pie (half vegan cheese). - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Terible food and service. Was out with friends and the security guard was cat calling at us and made us very uncomfortable. Fries were soggy and pizza wasnt even that good. What is funny is my friend left a 1 star review about this place last week for the same reasons and now it is gone and doesnt show up. Some kind of scam going on here...I'd stay away read more

Great pizza! Tastes super authentic and has quality ingredients for a good price. Staff is sweet and atmosphere is nice:)

Sid is the best bartender/worker here! He made sure that our order came efficiently and correct! He made our experience so pleasant and the service was great! thank you sid!!! read more

Open Late Night!!! When everything else had closed, Pie in The Sky will be there. Don't let their 10" pizza fool you. It will leave you satisfied and full. I recommend a 14" pizza for more than one person though. read more

Nice small bar/pizza place..we were very late and were out of option to find a place to eat. Found this place open late at night. We did not have a high confidence, however ordered Spinach/Artichoke pizza and Vegan Calzone. Turned out to be a great decision..The food was warm and delicious. Took us no time to finish it all. read more

If I could give them a zero I would. Worst service and disorganized place that I've ever seen! They literally told me to cancel my order with grub hub to only tell me they couldn't order. I spent an order going back and forth and all we wanted was to get an order delivered. Worst pizza place I've ever dealt with! read more

This place is lovely. It's cute and usually quiet. Their pizza is amazing, but you can't go wrong with just about anything on the menu. I've been here many times and have tried many things. Their portions are a good size for their price. Plus everyone is so friendly and patient. read more

Their Pizza is everything ! Trust me on that. Being originally from Jersey, it's been HARD to come by pizza that I won't complain about. Hah! Pie in the sky has NOT disappointed me. There menu doesn't only stop at pizza either. I've ordered their delicious spanakopita and dessert as well. If you're looking for a new pizza spot, look no further! Yummy ! read more

That is not a muffuletta. I can forgive a muffuletta being on chibatta but it was unacceptable it was hot. There was rosemary on the bread which is also is not a part of a true muffuletta and imposed on the flavor profile. It was more like a thin olive tapenade that lacked the hearty pickled crunch of a true muffuletta. The meat was lacking and was not the same types of meat as a muffuletta. Lastly the toasting made the sandwich dry as heck. A muffuletta is the antithesis of a dry sandwich so pretty much everything went wrong here. read more

Sure, it SAYS vegan friendly. But here's this: making your own pizza costs $10.95 without any add-ons. One third of $10.95 is $3.65. Adding vegan cheese $3.25. There is NO WAY I'm paying nearly a third of the total price JUST to make it dairy free. Are you serious? read more

First order from this place was not properly prepared. Wrong wing flavor, and one of the pizzas (portobello) was missing most of its toppings as described in the menu. It's not bad pizza. The wings were dry rub instead of sauce as requested. People preparing the food should just pay closer attention to the ticket. read more

Definitely the best late night pizza option in Fells point! The place is very clean, and there are a lot of great options! The dough is fresh, and they use the highest quality cheese. Everything was cooked to order but the wait wasn't long! read more

Pie In The Sky - Mushroom tomato pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

I am gluten free and they have the best crust of them all! I love the pizza! If it's late night sometimes your order might be wrong, but mostly because that are busy. I love this place!!!! read more

This is a fantastic little shop has outdoor seating and a very affordable menu. We got the prosciutto sandwich with fries and a 10 inch mushroom pizza with garlic sauce and sweet roasted peppers it was delicious. It was enough food for two adults and one child and we left very happy with our meal. Additionally the server gave us theEvening special so the whole meal was under $25 including tip which he didn't have to do. We really appreciated the service and the shops nearby recommended them highly. read more

I went there with friends for MOnday Night Football ***1st of all anything you order comes with a 20% COVID charge ** This is one the menu and the receipt. Your paying plus 20% on anything you order The game was on mute. Two other TVs were showing Netflix and some other tv show. The bartender was a young woman who had her homeboy at the bar chatting it up with her. The guy bartender placed the drink dispenser in the trash can. The actual drinks were terrible. The sprite was flat. A person ordered a drink with soda and instead got seltzer water in place of the soda. When the food came they wrapped it in a to go box even though it was obvious we all came to stay for the game. Our food didn't come until we made it clear we had been waiting since the beginning of the game (about 35 mins) This isn't really place to go with your friends for food and drinks it's actually more of spot for the bartenders friends to hang out. I will not be returning. Fells point has many bars to choose from and this place is bottom of the barrel. The food is not good. The drinks are expensive and poor quality Plus you pay a 20% fee on everything you purchase. read more

Dining in, we got the Mediterranean Vegetable Pizza. The pizza and service was great. Only thing we didn't like wS that they are adding their own tip - 20%. We would of given more. Which we would of liked to have decided ourselves. read more

I ordered 3 items for delivery and they somehow managed to get ALL 3 wrong. To give you an idea, I ordered a 14" Fell's Pie, 2 sodas, and salad with special instructions stating NOT to put cheese in it. I received a 10" vegetarian pizza (the Fells Pie is a meat pizza), 1 soda, and salad with feta. I mean how is it even possible to screw it up this badly? Easily the worst online order I've ever experienced in my life. I do not recommend this place and will not be returning. read more

Popped into Pie In The Sky today while down in Fells Point. I really just wanted to try it and you can tell a lot by one slice. Inside the restaurant seemed clean. I ordered a slice of cheese. I really didn't find the pizza to be anything more than pretty average. It didn't seem like it was cooked evenly. I also found it to be a bit doughy. The gentleman working seemed nice and checked on the table. We couldn't find plates nor were any brought out when the slices arrived. There's one bathroom, but it was fairly clean. I was was also glad they had highchairs as I had my son with me too. Although I wouldn't return for their slices I'd consider trying one of the more gourmet pizza creations. I really didn't look that hard at the menu so perhaps next time I will. I really want to give the plain cheese two stars, but overall it was about a 3. read more

Pizza was awesome but price is way to expensive smh. 40.00 for a 10 in pizza with toppings of my choice which made it cost to much and delivery. But it was so good. read more

Best Calzone I've had in a long time! Great people, great food. I definitely hit them up next time I'm in town

Vegan calzone was really good. Knocked off a star because the delivery experience wasn't great. But the calzone itself was beautiful. It was easy to eat, which is unusual for a calzone. I got it with garlic, artichokes, and black olives. It was nice. Not too heavy or cheesy either. read more

Pie In The Sky is excellent! It has a very modern interior and an excellent menu with great salads, sandwiches, pizzas, and calzones. The self service helps it be efficiently run. I got the Greek salad which was fresh and paired with a great sauce. The Margherita pizza was very solid, excellent crispy crust that I dipped in some warm marina and ranch. The only negative thus far is some of the prices. They charge $1.50 for any extra toppings including menial things like garlic. Overall though would come back. read more

Pie In The Sky - Pizza Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Having this new spot pop up on my Yelp feed was a very pleasant surprise-- Fells Point has tons of food options and it seems that a lot of those are pizza joints. That does not mean though that they're all worthy of your business. Pie in the Sky, however, is. Step inside the bold red exterior and you're instantly greeted by edgy, modern decor very representative of the outside. You've got marble-slated tabletops and counters and clean lines all around. Seating is more than plenty in the long, narrow dining area. You walk up to the counter, place your order, and take a number to your table. The owner, Murat, is extremely polite and a genuine pleasure to talk to. He will go out of his way to ensure you get what you want. His credit card machine wasn't working on the Friday afternoon that I went in-- naturally, I offered him cash. However, I sat and observed his interactions with every other customer who came in. He told them all to place an order and just pay him back later-- absolutely no worries. This kind of attitude, trust, and charm is what makes Baltimore 'Charm City' and I'm glad Murat embraces it. Moving on to the food, you've got everything you'd expect from a pizza joint like this. Gourmet pizzas, sandwiches, pastas, breads, and the like are plentiful. I had the lunch special-- for $7 you can pick any sandwich, receive a side of potatoes, and get a soda fountain drink. This is a fantastic deal and one that you'll be hard-pressed to find this cheap in Baltimore. ---- I Liked: Chicken Sandwich - The initial bite is chock-full of doughy heaven. The bread is baked in house and it really shows-- the crust is perfectly crisp without being tough to chew and the bread is light and airy. The sandwich had flavorful red peppers, tomato sauce, and marinated chicken. Every ingredient tasted fresh and was bursting with flavor. My one criticism would be that the chicken pieces are lined up on the edges of the sandwich-- this makes for great presentation but ultimately it also means that the middle of the sandwich is void of any chicken. Not a big deal, but worth noting. (You do not receive a breast or large piece of chicken, instead you get chunks of chicken, which is just fine). 5/5 Potatoes - The potato-wedge fries are delicious. They're crisp on the outside and soft on the inside; they don't feel too heavy from all the oil either. A generous slathering of garlic paste is evident and adds a ton of flavor-- though there may have been just a touch bit too much garlic. 4/5 I Disliked: Nothing so far! ---- Insider Tips: * Check out the lunch specials * Chew gum after having the fries-- the garlic taste will never leave * Customize your pizza if you don't want too many toppings and save money vs the $11 gourmet pizzas. Pie In The Sky is a welcome addition to the Fells Point neighborhood and I wholly recommend it to anyone looking to try something new. Prices are reasonable, the food is fresh, and the service is spectacular. Best of luck, Murat! read more

See all

4 stars because the pizza was really good in my opinion. The toppings seemed to be quality. There were a lot of toppings on the pizza. The crust was delicious. The pizza was cooked well. I really don't have a single bad thing to say about the pizza I got! One of the saddest parts about my visit was the ranch. I love a good homemade restaurant ranch and this ranch was not good. I would have rather had hidden valley. The guy behind the counter was very unenthusiastic, borderline rude, to customers. He literally had over the ear headphones on the entire time i was there....yikes. It was lunch hour too so that truly was an inappropriate time to be doing that. Someone asked him whether they were supposed to leave their plates at the table or take them somewhere and he looked at them, didn't respond, and kept walking. I believe it was the same guy photographed in a previous post where someone said the only time he was able to be bothered by anyone was if they were a pretty young lady and I had literally the same experience. The only time I saw a sliver of personality from this guy was when a pretty girl bought some tea. Personally, none of the negatives listed above would ever deter me from returning. I don't really go into a pizza place for the quality service, I go there for delicious pizza and I would definitely return if I'm back in the area!! read more