Came in around 7pm and they still had a couple pie slice selections. We chose a slice of pecan pie and a peanut butter slice. My pecan pie slice was so delicious. I thought I was gonna eat half of it there and take the rest home and then I decided just to eat it all there cause it was so delicious. The crust is thick and crunchy and the filling is perfect. The service was wonderful and the employee welcomed us with a smile. I took my boyfriend here for the first time and he really eyed himself. He loved the peanut butter pie. It was pretty quiet in there and clean. read more

See all

I finally stopped by after hearing people mention this place for a while, and it ended up being a nice surprise. I went after my morning shift because I was craving something sweet before heading back to the office. I grabbed a slice of the pecan pie and a slice of the peanut butter pie to take with me. Between the two, I think I liked the pecan pie a little more. The filling was rich without being overly sweet, and the crust had a nice bite to it. The peanut butter pie was also good, just a lot more filling than I expected, so I'm glad I shared it later instead of trying to finish it all at once. Minor downside is that seating is limited, so if you stop by when it's busy, you might end up taking your dessert to go. That worked out fine for me since I was already on my way back to work. read more

Friendly customer service. The pies were reasonably priced and VERY yummy. The inside was super cute and colorful. They offer desserts, pot pies, and more. read more

See all

I love this part of OKC and of course I had to go in because I saw they had coconut cream pie (a favorite of mine). The reviews for this spot said the pecan pie was a must try. I was torn so I got both. Coconut cream was quite disappointing to be honest. It had no flavor. Tasted like not much. But the pecan ... WOW. I'm not a huge pecan pie fan but I would crawl back to OKC for this pie. It wasn't overwhelmingly pecan-y and it wasn't outlandishly sweet. It was rich and smooth and every bite tasted better than the next. Oh and the crust? Perfect. read more

Yummy!! Long time "junkie" here! Been enjoying this dessert shop for years. Staple store front in Plaza District. Slices are about $6 each but they are oh so worth it. I recommend the apple or the strawberry rhubarb. They make excellent fruit pies, not too sweet. The peanut butter or chocolate are a hit too! Really can't go wrong with any slice if you're a dessert lover. They even have a punch card! Don't wait, stop by and grab a slice! ...Or a whole pie - they offer those too! ;) read more

See all

I have rated Pie Junkie before but they make it so easy. They offer the best pies at a great price! No matter which pie I try, I know I'm going to love it. The crust is always perfect! This trip I had the holiday mint pie. Normally I'm not an Oreo fan, but even the Oreo crust was delightful. The Andes on top made it perfect. read more

Pie Junkie - Holiday mint pie - Desserts Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

No smiles behind the counter tonight. Just blank stares. No helpful recommendations. Ended up with the Kentucky bourbon and a coconut cream. The Kentucky bourbon was Very good! Very rich! Definitely a shareable slice. The coconut cream I could've done without. Aside from the coconut bits in it, if I had put it in my mouth blindly, I wouldn't have been able to tell you what it was. It had absolutely no flavor of coconut, and none of the creaminess that that particular type of pie normally has. The filling was mealy feeling, for lack of a better description. Sad. read more

See all

Tasted great! Coconut cream pie- Tasted very creamy and fresh. Cherry Limeade pie- Sweet and creamy as well. Would definitely recommend! read more

Pie Junkie - Tasted great! Coconut cream pie- Tasted very creamy and fresh. Cherry Limeade pie- Sweet and creamy as well. - Desserts Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

A friend had told me I needed to try Pie Junkie. Seeing as how I have a huge sweet tooth, I made sure to stop by and give it a try. I've been several times now and I must say that I am never disappointed! Pie needs a delicious feeling, but I feel the crust is such a crucial ingredient for a pie. I like my crust to be flaky, moist, and flavorful. Pie Junkie meets all my crust expectations. I've had their peanut butter pie, chocolate stain, pecan, and turtle. If I'm being honest I can't pick a favorite because they are all delicious!!! Anytime I'm in the area I stop in and grab a couple slices to go! Give them a try! read more

Pie Junkie - Chocolate satin - Desserts Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

Great service and awesome pies!!! Loved the location and the staff.. they made great recommendations!

Food: Chef's kiss on the chocolate silk pie!!! I could eat that whole thing myself in a couple settings. This is the best pie I've had in my life. Now I see why they do pre-order for Thanksgiving so early in November ! Sold out already! $30 pies but worth it, $5 slices even better for you on diets. Order online also! So glad to have found this amazing bakery!!! Definitely will be a pie at my table for every event!!!!! Also dinner selections available!!! read more

Pie Junkie is a must visit!! The only drawback is limited seating. Their pies are delicious and they are one of the best you'd want to eat. I purchased the Bird Dog & Coconut Cream. Their Coconut Cream is one of the best I've tasted. My wife preferred the Bird Dog and yes it was tasty just not for me! I would recommend trying this place! read more

See all

Pie Junkie serves awesome pies of all varieties, including chicken pot pies and casseroles. I got their key lime pie and also turtle chocolate ones - both were very good. Service at the counter was great. Cute interior atmosphere where you can sit down at counters. They also have merch for sale. Definitely an awesome place to check out in OKC's Plaza District! read more

See all

A great spot where you can find all kinds of delicious pies! My coworker recommended this place to me last fall for Thanksgiving, and I've been a fan ever since. I especially love their fall pies you really can't go wrong with the pecan pie or the Kentucky bourbon pie. I also heard their other pies are really good! read more

Need pie?! This is the perfect place to try! Not only do they have sweet pie options, they also have pre made reals ready to go. Definitely helps take out the guess work of what to cook! There's merch, there's a small counter top so you can enjoy your slice instantly and the service is super friendly! read more

See all

Love the peanut butter, s'mores, and rhubarb pies. They're about $6 a slice but so so good. Clean small shop, very cozy. A plus! (Skip the birthday pie--kinda flavorless) read more

Pie Pie where are thou my Pie. Let me say this, there aren't many place or any good places for that matter that has great and amazing pies to try. Keep in mind I said pies, so with that being said, this place is a definite must try. Come early so that you get what you want because they do run out towards the later course of the day. The pecan pie is to die for and I am not even a fan of pecans. So, try the pecan pie and also the peanut butter pie and you will not regret it one bit. Will be back. read more

Pie Junkie - Pecan Pie, Peanut Butter Pie, and Turtle - Desserts Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

My husband had a slice of Apple Pie. He said it was okay but not as good as mine. But I've made pies for 50+ years I would recommend it though. The service was good. read more

So so good! One of my favorite places when I get a sweet tooth. The banana creme pie is so dang delicious. Smooth, creamy with a hint of heavenly vanilla. It's to die for. read more

Pie Junkie - Desserts Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

So so sooo happy!! I've been looking for a good key lime pie and this just made me happy! We also got the s'mores slice and that was amazing too! The service was also amazing and the ladies were very helpful. Another plus was their whipped cream that was not from a can and it was homemade!! read more

Pie Junkie - Key lime pie - Desserts Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

Pie Junkie is an absolute must when visiting OKC. I spent a summer living in OKC and used to go all the time, now I go every time I come back to visit the city. You can buy slices of pie, whole pies, frozen pie, microwavable dinner pies. It is all pies. They have plenty of different flavors to choose from, it is honestly so hard to choose. If you need help choosing, the people working are always helpful. This last time, I got the strawberry diner pie which is a summer special. It was incredible, the crust was perfect, the strawberries were cut into full fresh chunks and the whipped cream was piled high. The inside of Pie Junkie is small, they had one little table and a few high tops against the wall. The shop is located in the Plaza District, parking can be difficult so give yourself a few minutes to find parking. read more

See all

Pie Junkie was always one of my favorite stops in the plaza. But lately it seems that the prices have gone up and the quality has gone down. The pie crust isn't flaky instead it's hard and dry and has no flavor or body at all. I thought it me but I was talking about it with a flirt and they said the same thing. Everyone is very nice when I come . They are all so pleasant whenever I come in but the pies are just not the same to me. Something is missing. read more

Pie Junkie can honestly just take all of my money now. While they're known for their sweet dessert pies their veggie pot pie is my favorite. It does a wonderful job highlighting the vegetables instead of leaning on fake meat. read more

I love stopping by here and getting pies to go! My favorites are the savory pies (the dessert pies are also good, but just too sweet for me to purchase an entire one of!) I highly recommend the poppyseed chicken (I literally pick one up every time I'm in the plaza district) because my kids absolutely DEVOUR this!! It has just the right amount of cream to chicken ratio. If you haven't tried it yet- please do, you won't regret it! read more

This is a very good pie shop in the Plaza district. The space is simple with basically just a line and a counter. The service is efficient. They sell pie by the slice as well as whole pies and they also have chicken pot pies and quiche. I tried the coconut cream and the chocolate bourbon pecan. For me the coconut cream was excellent while the chocolate pecan was just ok. The coconut cream was light with a thin crisp butter crust. The chocolate pecan was much more sweet with a graham crust that was less tasty. I would definitely come here again to try more selections and pick up more coconut cream. read more

Love this place! I love that they have their originals and seasonal flavors. I got the pumpkin chiffon pie that I tore into before I remembered I needed a pic. Staff is always friendly and the place is always clean! Whatever pie you might like head that way and cure your pie craving! read more

Pie Junkie - Pumpkin Chiffon - Desserts Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

I am beyond happy with my choice of pie. The drunken turtle is everything great with Chocolate, pecans and Carmel it's delicious cold or at room temperature. I also chose the bird dog buttermilk it's pretty sweet with a hint of blackberries it's wonderful cold and a slow delicious sweet treat. I'm so happy I stopped in and tried something new. The staff was helpful and the line flows seamlessly. read more

See all

I think the pie is delicious but expensive. The vanilla ice cream didn't taste good and was hard, I just think if you're ordering a slice of pie with a scoop of ice cream, it would be nice if it was served on a plate. They have barely any seating, and the pie is all served in plastic to go containers and the ice cream is also in a to go container. It definitely feels more of a to go place, which is a shame, I want to sit and enjoy a nice slice of pie ala mode with a hot cup of coffee but this isn't the place for that! The service was lack luster, nothing special, no smiles, my six year old went to the counter to ask the girl a question and she completely ignored him. Pie tastes good, but the lack luster shop and price will keep me from returning. read more

The service was super quick even with the line out the door. The staff were very friendly. There was also some take home pies and quiche in a freezer with many options. Both pies we tried were delicious! read more

Pie Junkie - Peanut butter pie and cookie cake pie - Desserts Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Amazing deserts, taste like grandma used to make. Friendly and helpful staff. Great place to meet and enjoy family and friends. read more

Pie Junkie - Pecan pie is amazing! Gooey goodness! Crunchy and flaky and a lot of stuff like that there.... Best ever!! - Desserts Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

5 stars all day... no matter what your sweet tooth is craving they have you covered. Chris K. Cool Guy Coolers read more

Very delicious, highly recommend.. it's worth every penny... you won't be sorry! The most talked about at our '24 Thanksgiving.

I could go on all day singing their praises!! This place is a MUST TRY whether you are looking for dessert or if you have a sweet tooth like me . ALL of their pies are made fresh and they have just the perfect amount of sweetness to them. I've tried many pies here, but just to rank a few: Coconut cream pie: 5/5 Pumpkin pie: 5/5 S'mores pie 3.5/5 Birthday cake pie: 4/5 The service was 5/5 The pies were 5/5 The ambiance was cool and the place was clean! read more

See all

AMAZING PIES! The people there are wonderful and very helpful. They are super sweet as well.

If you crave the most delicious pie, you NEED to stop here! They have every kind of pie, quiche, pot pies, casseroles and cookie cake! They are friendly and fast and will recommend something if you aren't sure what you want! The store is in the Plaza district, and like everything else has the cutest vibe. There are little bistro tables where you can sit and eat and have their coffee! I recommend almost everything, but what I recently discovered is that they have the best cookie cake I've ever had! It's so moist and soft . Grab your girls, wear your florals and hit the district! read more

We were heading to Oklahoma and saw Pie Junkie was rated number one for desserts in OK. Was a bit confused when we got there because the picture on the review showed all different kinds of treats but they only have PIE. AMAZING PIE! Chicken pot pie, quiche, cookie pie, banana cream pie, bourbon pie, chocolate pie, coconut pie, and so many more. We bought a lot of pie. We were visiting friends so we tried one of everything. I remembered to take a picture a bit too late. None of them were overly sweet, the s'mores pie said to heat to melt together and it was a delightful campfire mess! The banana cream was a crowd delight. All of the kids loved the cookie pies and I am grateful we had 4 of them. The turtle pie and bourbon were just bitter enough to make you crave more. The store itself was incredibly clean. I was impressed that they make all of the pies there in house. The staff was kind, answered all of our allergy questions and concerns. The pie is so delicious I am glad we live in Texas! read more

Pie Junkie - Lots of pie - Desserts Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

While visiting OKC, I enjoyed the best slice of Key Lime Pie I've ever tasted in my life! It was sublime! Pie Junkie has a variety of pies you can buy by the slice, albeit hard to decide on one flavor, I went with an old faithful and was not disappointed. Excited to go back and try other flavors! Deliciousness!!!!!!!! read more

Terrific! I go there every few weeks. The dessert pies are excellent, but don't overlook the savory pies for dinner! Service is prompt and friendly. read more

One of my favorite place to grab dessert. Located in a fun trendy area. A great place to grab something sweet after dinner. My favorite is the butter milk pie and birthday cake pie. My son loves the seasonal strawberry pie. The staff is friendly and the place is small and quaint. Highly recommend! read more

Been here a few times. Most of the pies are really good!! The strawberry, apple and French silk are some of our favorites. Over the years they introduce seasonal and specialty pies which are all fairly good. This is a very fast paced place and the wait time is sometimes too long. If we see people standing out the door we usually skip it because likely what we want is sold out. If make it early enough it's worth the wait. Very casual and fast paced atmosphere. There isn't a lot of room for dine in but normally we are fine to take dessert home! read more