Pie Trap Pizza

4.6 (527 reviews)

Pizza

Closed • Closed

Updated a few days ago

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Order Pie Trap Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Order Takeout or Delivery

Pie Trap Pizza Photos

Pie Trap Pizza - Xxplosive - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Pie Trap Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Pie Trap Pizza - The D - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

+549

Pie Trap Pizza - Pep - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Pie Trap Pizza Popular Dishes

26 Photos34 Reviews

7 Photos18 Reviews

5 Photos6 Reviews

Pie Trap Pizza menu photos

See all

PIE TRAP PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

Inside

52 Photos

Outside

36 Photos

Loud

Casual

Good for groups

Good for kids

Order now
Takeout available

More like Pie Trap Pizza

Recommended Reviews - Pie Trap Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Amisha S.

Great ambiance loved that the brewery is attached or shared space! The service was amazing, ordering pizza was easy and very friendly and helpful! The food however was very disappointing. Ordered a large pie and it was completely burnt. We waited 15 to 20 minutes for the pizza. We were starving so we at the toppings and left the crust. Overall I was not impressed at all.

Ann C.

My BFF brought his home for us for dinner... And I was really happy because I've been wanting to try Pie Trap Pizza for a while. He ordered the supreme pizza and buffalo wings. I love their NY style pizza... the flavor was great. I did like the buffalo wings, but they were a little on the salty side. I definitely wanna try their Detroit style Pizza next. Make sure to put this on your bookmark and stop by next time you're in Covina.

Aruna P.

Anthony Bourdain, one of my favorite humans, had a deep distain for Yelp and so, I try to be judicious about reviews. We have two, teen boy, athletes. Given our busy schedules and hosting a ton of boys/ young men, we order a lot of pizza and often, multiple times a week. We order from La Verne, San Dimas, Glendora, & Covina. Well, we've given this place at least 3 opportunities and each time, they've fallen short. On this occasion, we ordered 1/2 supreme clientele add pineapple (yeah, there's a place for it on pizza!) and because in the past, the pepperoni has been so minimal, we ordered and paid for double pepperoni. Well, they did not add the pineapple and you can see from the pictures, they also did NOT double the pepperoni. Caught this at the restaurant, because I knew from previous experiences to check. They did offer to remake the pizza, but we had already been waiting too long, the Mexico FIFA game was about to start, AND I don't want to act as a restaurant's quality control. If you're gonna force me into that role, pay me. So at $56 for ONE poorly made pizza, garlic knots & a few bucks for tip, this place is not getting our business again. Sigh.

Gus C.

The pizza just slaps. Don't even get me started on the garlic knots... a must try. Located next to Arrow Lodge, you can have a fresh slice and wash it down with a brew. The service is great, and the food is served piping hot! A must try!

Ashley F.

Great pizza and great service. The pizza and garlic knots are a favorite for my family.

David C.

Best pizza in the area for sure. Nice thin crust and great toppings. Ordered cheese, xxplosive and pep. I reviewed the buffalo chicken instead of cheese by accident, but decided to give it a try. Didn't love the buffalo chicken and regretted not bringing up the mistake because we liked the cheese best the last time. Anyway, there is really no bad pizza, just degrees better so all good. Happy to keep trying their slices and hope to order a full pie at some point so we can try one fresh. I guess cheese will have to the one we get next time!

Alexandra S.

Pie Trap Pizza absolutely deserves all the hype. The pizza is next-level -- perfectly crispy crust, balanced flavors, and toppings that taste fresh and intentional. You can tell they actually care about the craft. But what really sets this place apart is the owner -- seriously one of the coolest, most down-to-earth people I've met in a long time. He makes you feel like you're part of the neighborhood the second you walk in, and it's clear he's built a place that's about good vibes just as much as good pizza. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or hanging out with friends and grabbing a brew next door, Pie Trap feels like the kind of spot you'll keep coming back to -- for the food and the experience.

Andy T.

Had a friend hangout and needed a food option that could satisfy 5 people. I called in around noon to place a takeout order for two pizzas. I was advised that it would take about 30 minutes for both to be ready. However, it took another 10 minutes before it was ready. As I arrive, Pie Trap Pizza is located in a plaza with plenty of parking. There were also plenty of indoor seating and a patio outside as well. Unexpectedly there were a lot of pinball machines inside and beer on tap. Atmosphere wise, this place was already a 5/5. For the actual order, I got the Xxplosive and the Lodi Dodi. The Xxplosive came with jalapeños, but I asked them to leave on the side for folks that couldn't Handle spicy. This meant we did ate raw jalapeño. This was definitely a fan favorite. Highly recommend if you like a sweet and spicy flavor profile. For the Lodi Dodi, it was good. A few of my friends like it but not something in my flavor preference. It was definitely a more calorically dense pizza! They do accept American Express. Until next time!

Ian A.

My family and I felt very underwhelmed with Pie Trap Pizza (Covina). We were recommended the Detroit Style "White Square" ($35 - 6 square slices), and it tastes like fancy cheese bread sticks. Many of these expensive slices were left half-eaten. I arrived at Pie Trap Pizza (Covina) on Friday (around 7:20PM). The location's main lobby is cramped; it fits about four customers. Pie Trap Pizza (Covina) shares dining space with a connected sports bar. It's extremely loud and cramped with sport fans and pinball enthusiasts. There's also outdoor tables but expect inconsistent cleanliness. Pie Trap Pizza (Covina) is better for to-go unless you're searching for booming, pounding, hyped energy. Staff is busy and frantic. Staff is helpful, but there's a constant nervous energy as staff rushes away from the register to prepare the next order. Pie Trap Pizza (Covina) is definitely popular. I empathize with its novelty. I was recommended the Detroit Style "White Square" ($35 - 6 square slices). It was ready in 26 minutes and 52 seconds. The "White Square" includes mozzarella, ricotta, garlic, and Romano. My family and I absolutely adored its unique & crunchy pan-seared crust; however, its fluffy body tasted dry and muted. This "White Square's" flavor resembled those rubbery cheese sticks we'd eat in a school cafeteria. As my family and I ate this, we pondered how this "White Square" would taste great with spaghetti or... pizza. Pie Trap Pizza (Covina) is unique, pricey, and somewhat small. Similar to an expensive glowing pen you'd purchase at a theme park, Pie Trap Pizza is a "fun" moment. 3.4 out of 5

Cara P.

Fav pizza and even better staff. The boys are always so hard working and kind. My kiddo loves coming here ( and so do we) Ps- heart shaped pizza for Valentine's Day

Jordan H.

Bomb. Crispy, light, airy crust. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio. The XXXplosion (pepperoni jalapeños & hot honey) is perfection. I'd give it more than 5 stars if I could.

Mike C.

First time here and definitely one of the best pizzas i've had, and maybe the best in a 20 mile radius? I tried their "the d" slice. Which is Detroit style pizza with pepperoni and a sprinkle of basil. They used the cupped pepperonis which is crucial because these tastes much better. The only downside is that this place is pretty expensive. The 3 slices I got were $20. The whole pizzas are near $40 which is kinda crazy.

Crystal L.

Great slice to accompany the terrific beer at the neighboring/attached brewery. Their Detroit slices look amazing and will be what we try next time. The standard pepperoni slice had a tomato sauce with a nice fresh taste. Properly greasy, hot and fast. As it should be.

See all

Angie Z.

1 year ago

Not good! Needs more cheese. I specifically said light tomato sauce. Over rated! I asked for cheese and I was given 1 lol read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Haley W.

Elite 26

167

144

299

3 years ago

Came here on a Saturday night and was surprised it wasn't very busy at all. No line for pizza, I put in my order and headed to the attached brewery for a beer. My 2 pizzas were ready about 20 minutes later. I ordered The D and Lodi Dodi, both Detroit style pies. As a Michigander transplant to the area I love trying Detroit style pizza to see if places do it right, and Pie Trap does! Sauce on top, corners extra crispy, fluffy dough and chewy cheese, I was very happy! Only complaint is $1.25 for a small container of ranch is ridiculous. Really fun that it's attached to a brewery with plenty of seating both indoors and outdoors and they had a really cool collection of pinball machines. I'll totally come back again. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Lodi Dodi Detroit Style - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Pie Trap Pizza - The D Detroit Style - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Haley,…

Helpful 1

Thanks 2

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Virginia S.

6 months ago

The crust was good. The overpriced, rather bland sauce and skimpy toppings were disappointing.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Derek N.

411

3 years ago

Everyone knows the rules, good crispy texture, low flop. Good pie and good dudes. Square pies were great as well. read more

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Thanks Derek…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

nina l.

2 years ago

Food is sooo good here. It's my 2nd time visiting and I still haven't been disappointed! Food is delicious fresh and hot!! I'm basic i recommend the D its bomb and their lemon pepper wings are so good not salty ! Their employees are always working hard, staying busy and clean ! Don't forget to tip them their pizza is literally started from a dough ball and ends up looking like art lol. We watched them lol read more

Pie Trap Pizza - I believe this deep dish pizza is called the D! So good! - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Nina,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jesus G.

Elite 26

326

998

3 years ago

This is a small mom and pop pizza joint with the perfect Detroit square pizza. The dough to cheese ratio was perfect, the toppings were fresh, and the price was fair. I ordered over the phone and the team member who picked up the phone was very friendly and patient, allowing me to make an order only 30 minutes before closing and super friendly about it. The place is small so it's best to order pizza to go. It is located next to an arcade bar that gives direct access to this location as they share a door down the inside but they're separate owners. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Square pizza, custom made with marinara, ricotta, mushrooms, jalapeño - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Pie Trap Pizza - Outside view - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Jesus,…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

nancy a.

166

139

1 year ago

If you are a fan like I am of a pizza where you can enjoy all the tastes in a pizza EXCEPT so much doughy bread then come by and try Pie Trap. DELICIOUS. When you walk in you order your food and they text you when your pie is done. There is a lot seating but it's a little noisy. They have quite a few pin ball machines along 1 wall that are very popular. There is also seating around a giant screen TV and another spot that has a picnic bench inside a canopy type covering (cozy) Pie Trap shares space with a bar,so if you like your beer on tap and some tasty pizza along with pin ball then this is definitely your place. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Stephanie M.

Elite 26

3 years ago

Retuned today, early and with my some of my family to watch football and try a pizza. I ordered the pepperoni pie and it was delicious, loaded with pepperoni, tasty sauce and cooked just right. I also ordered a slice of the "D" style pizza to go, yum! My two grandchildren had a great time playing the pinball machines and we sat comfortably watching the Raider game on the big screen tv. I want to thank Pie Trap Pizza & Arrow Lodge Brewing for the hospitality, we will be back! read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pepperoni Pie - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Hi Stephanie,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Edward S.

182

1 year ago

Amazing place all around. The seating area is great, unique set up makes for groups to come out and watch some baseball or football when in season. The pizza is *Cheff kiss* it's a California 10 but a Dave Portnoy 8.4 Like seriously good pizza that even the east coast would respect, didn't get the full experience cause I just came in for a few slices and a drink (oh yeah they sell pizza by the slice, for a good price) but the Dude at the counter was solid and super courteous. Will definitely be back when the Dodgers or Football is back in season read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Raphael A.

7 months ago

This spot contends with some of the big hitters in LA like Appolonias. Not only was their traditional slice amazing, but the square slice was some of the best I've had, did not tire my jaw at all. Plus the service was 10/10 read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Kathy S.

1 year ago

This is my favorite pizza place! Pizzas always great and the customer service is amazing!! Highly recommend! read more

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Kathy you are amazing. Our favorite customer. Thank you for all the…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Neill D.

1 year ago

Habanero ranch! This needs to be a permanent condiment. Pizza is always amazing, great service as well. The guys let me try the habanero ranch and a more concentrated, spicier version. Both amazing but the spicier one was the best. I don't know how I'll be able to eat the wings and pizza without it. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jason T.

938

118

2 years ago

7:00 to 7:30 pm Friday No slices. Little disappointed. Leaving to go somewhere else for dinner. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lola G.

163

2 years ago

Friends invited us to run into them here on a random weekday and it was freakin delicious! We had the Explosive pizza with a few good drinks. Ordering drinks was quick, they're on it. Line moves fast. I love service with a smile. The environment was nice outside, I say we were there close to 7pm. It was perfect. On the second occasion I ordered 2 pizzas for my sister's birthday one pep and another explosive. Some would say the $82 dollars for pizza but man when I tell you they grub both them boxes nothing was left. They were a party hit. I didn't give 5 stars because my order was a bit crisp (too dark). You can also order by the slice I know but we've always done full pizza for a group of 5-6 people. Definitely going to check out some of there events soon I heard they're really cool to attend. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Matt A.

1 year ago

Jarrod and david know how to make pizza ‍‍‍. I can spend hours here. . Thanks everyone read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dave C.

1 year ago

These guys burnt my pie.... BUTTTTT, they started a second pie before I showed up and DID THE RiGHT THING! They even let me take the slightly burnt pizza home. -teenagers will def eat it!! lol. 2 for 1. Im happy. High quality NY pizza. Excellent staff. Attached to a brewery. You'll love it! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Myrion P.

1 year ago

Originally was a bit skeptical about the location because usually pizza places are at Dyme-A-Duzin when it comes to good ones however, me and my girlfriend decided to come here at about 1:30 PM on a Saturday when I walked in. I was immediately greeted by a friendly staff team. The pizza place is connected to a brewery. The slices can't get a bit pricey if you order anything over three slices so they suggested just getting a full pizza we went with the explosive pizza which is hot honey pepperoni and jalapeños. The food was amazing 10 out of 10. We also got a six piece order of buffalo wings 10 out of 10 and the garlic knots, which are eight out of 10 only because I've had slightly better. The food was amazing and we also went next-door to grab an orange cream beer which was also a 10 out of 10 the ambience is amazing and we definitely will be returning. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kayla D.

8 months ago

Amazing isn't even kind enough . This place is heaven sent . Bring your whole family here it is woth every penny

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Noemi C.

9 months ago

I am not really big in leaving reviews but I had to. Didn't know what to eat for lunch and found this restaurant and figured I'd give it a shot. I tried the pepperoni jalapeño with hot honey and a buffalo chicken pizza. Both were delicious crust is crispy and thin all ingredients used are tasty. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Melissa S.

Elite 26

934

1420

1121

3 years ago

Came here by default cause I was actually looking for a pizza truck but apparently they move around and it's not just located in Covina. So it was your lucky day. I got to try this place. It's located conjunctively next to a brewery spot. Smart move. Pepperoni Was five dollars in specialty white girl basic was six dollars. The slices were pretty good in size. They ran it through the oven real quick to heat it up and placed my slices in a box. Pepperoni had a decent amount of meat on it. The flavor was good. It was a thin crust. I enjoyed it. the white girl is a garlic and cheese pizza. Very garlicky. I love garlic so I liked it but something different. Overall not bad their pizzas range from $26-$35 four whole pizzas. That's a bit steep for my liking but I'm glad I could support a local small business. The pepperoni had good taste to it and had a little kick. Overall good pizza. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pepperoni , white girl and garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Pie Trap Pizza - White girl and pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Thank you for the feedback. We have a huge “20 inch pie. Maybe next…

Helpful 3

Thanks 1

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Andrew H.

1 year ago

Best pizza by far in SoCal. I love the hip hop names that this place gives their pies. Customer service is excellent and the workers are great with talking to first time buyers. After trying this spot, I don't wanna eat pizza anywhere else in SoCal. Perfect score 10/10! Nuff said read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bonnie D.

Elite 26

164

175

707

3 years ago

If you want a New York style pizza or Chicago style deep dish pizza, this is the place to try. This pizza joint is connected to a brewery. It's a very spacious and chill spot. As weird as it sounds, sorta kid friendly. Lol. The brewery had a little imitation camp fire area with huge jenga blocks. There were a few kids that were around. My daughter thoroughly enjoyed the notorious p.e.p. The pizza guys were super friendly and gave great suggestions. The Xxplosive is honey glazed so I thought that was very interesting good. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Xxplosive and notorious p.e.p. - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Pie Trap is for the Children! We’re so happy that you and your…

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Joaquin H.

9 months ago

Pizza was terrible. Burn and non tasteful. The brewery company next door, however, has a great beer selection. Would have loved a good slice of pizza with my beer. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christopher D.

143

123

2 years ago

The pinball machines & high quality craft beers nextdoor were a pleasant surprise. The pizza was pretty darn yummy and I could tell the staff was working hard on a busy early evening. The pizza joint is tiny so things move slowly but the pies are very good. I'd give it 5 stars but the wait is a bit tough & the price reflects that of a high quality place. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Slices - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Bigg H.

2 years ago

The pizzza bro Stop playing with my emotions for reals. Do yourself a favor and order a pan pizza. Best in the SGV read more

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Only the SGV? Haha well take it thanks for the love

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Vanessa C.

283

155

2 years ago

Really enjoyed my experience here. The food was delicious. The ambiance was chill and they had various games going on when we went on Sunday. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - The D, Deez Knots and Trap House Salad - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Pie Trap Pizza - The D pan pizza, Supreme Clientele Thin n Crispy, Deez Knots and Trap House Salad - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Business owner information

Shaun C.

That’s a top notch spread you ordered. Thanks for coming in. Welcome…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ryan Y.

Elite 26

249

173

3 years ago

I am so addicted to Pie Trap! This has become my favorite pizza place, hands down. I crave the pizza daily- and can't wait to get back there for my next slice! Hopefully my next visit is around the corner. The store front is connected to Arrow Lodge which is an easy plus for beers + pizza. The store front is an order and go setup, but that's perfect for the seating available next door. The pizzas are clearly fresh, and the variety and customization of toppings is easy! The staff is always upbeat and friendly-- another plus in my book! Y'all trapped me with these pies! read more

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Thank you for the love. We wanted to bring something top notch to the…

Helpful 3

Thanks 1

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Nathan P.

Elite 26

3 years ago

Most authentic NY style pizza in the area. I've been looking in the Covina/West Covina area and all adjacent cities for REAL NY style pizza for a while now and it's safe to say that Pie Trap is the most authentic yet. MUST GO MUST TRY. Crispy thin large slices for only $5 each is a steal. Great sauce, great crust. Cant be beat! Staff was friendly as well which is always a big plus. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pepperoni slice cheese slice housemade ranch - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Chelsea B.

Elite 26

244

628

3 years ago

Servers were really nice and quick. However, the pizza was barely edible. It was a really bland pizza. The crust was hard like it's been sitting for a while. I'm so glad I didn't get a full pie. The interior was cool though. Lots of pinball and seating. Maybe a fresher pizza would be better but I'm not willing to take the chance on it. Don't recommend read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Pie Trap Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Business owner information

Shaun C.

I’m sorry you had a bad experience. We have bad days sometimes. We’re…

Helpful 5

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 2

Hellokittynme ..

355

299

3 years ago

I wanted to name the pizza I got and for some reason I wasn't able to remember it. After searching the photos on yelp, I kinda came to the conclusion that it was maybe a newly added item since it was a meatball, cheese and red sauce situation that I didn't see listed on the menu. At that point, I kinda just thought about the whole thing and wanted to say, it doesn't matter what particular pie I ate, it's all about preference when it comes to pizza. What really mattered here was the dough. -It was crispy and thin, it lacked heavy grease. -They provided the pizza on a nice tray that was designed to keep the pizza aerated, preventing the soggies from building up. -The flavor was there! -They had ample tables outside the brewery so that we could hang out and enjoy the nice weather. -Wait time was reasonable. -When came time to pack up the extra few slices, we had a chance to chat with one of the pizzaiolos. He was very friendly and personable, he helped us pack up our pizzas and recommended the Xxplosive for our next visit. We sure will be back! read more

Pie Trap Pizza - pizzas are giant...my fist for reference - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Hello kitty,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 1

James M.

177

195

2 years ago

Pie Trap has been on my must try list for a minute. I went with the SQUARESPLOSIVE for my 1st try. This is not an assembly line type pizza, the is artisan crafted. The care they take in the presentation on a take out pizza was amazing. Placing leaves of basil on each slice and a drizzle of hot honey to finish. Flavorful and satisfying. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Sandy M.

2 years ago

Love that they offer by the slice! pizza is really good add hot honey delicious! The wings are pretty good crispy and flavorful the service is always on point love Zoe she's always so kind and attentive. Definitely a place to grab a bite when you're grabbing a beer. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Dean S.

1 year ago

This place is killer! Pizza is so good!!! You have to try it to believe it! It's annexed with Arrow Lodge Brewing Company!! Just incredible!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Kayla R.

1 year ago

10/10 food 10/10 customer service 10/10 ambiance Best pizza & wings i've had in a long time and the ranch bomb , my man & i will definitely be back read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Molly K.

110

1 year ago

Delicious pizzas, the family loves Lodi Doddi but everything here is good. The flavors, the ingredients, the texture, the staff- winner all around. So glad this in the neighborhood, I have recommended to friends and neighbors- gotta try it. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael D.

Elite 26

164

3 years ago

My GF and I got the Lodi Dodi yesterday and it was phenomenal. The variety of sauces made me feel like I was eating three different slices in one. I especially enjoyed the pesto and vodka sauces. The cherry on top of the entire experience was the crispy edges on the crust. This pizza is truly to die for! read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Lodi Dodi - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Business owner information

Shaun C.

My guy. You are a true pizza guy. The lodi dodi is so underrated.…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Windy A.

2 years ago

Unsure why we waited so long to try Pie Trap!! All I can say is WOW! We had the Lodi Dodi Detroit style pizza and a good ole pepperoni pizza. Both were exceptional! We can't wait to go back and try more!! We had leftovers and they reheat well too. Thanks Pie Trap!! read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Notorious P.E.P. - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tiffany B.

Elite 25

2 years ago

We recently moved and our usual pizza place was too far so we decided to try Pie Trap and holy smokes it blew our usual pizza place outta the water. We've ordered a number of pizzas since but our favorite is the D. It's a deep dish Detroit style and it's like no other pizza I've had so tasty read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Michelle R.

106

2 years ago

Best pizza I have had in the area. The thin crust was crispy and it was the right amount of hot honey on a slice. The D was very tasty and the crust was perfect! The pepperonis were excellent. Totally recommend. Service was ok and the ability to sit in the brewery next door was a plus. read more

Pie Trap Pizza - Explosive Slice - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

Pie Trap Pizza - Pinball - Pizza Near Me - Covina, California

See all

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Thank you Michelle loved having you. Will get better on that service.…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cesar C.

Elite 26

166

236

3 years ago

Absolutely delicious pizza here! Topping are premium, it's very thin, and slices are huge! I haven't tried their garlic knots, hopefully next time. Service is exceptional, the guys there are super down to earth and honestly, just being guys which I really appreciate rather than fake service. The place there is a really cool hang out, there's a bunch of pinball machines, lots of tables. There's also a spot in the back corner for beer! read more

Business owner information

Shaun C.

Bro!!!! Showing us love on a day off Easter Sunday!!!! We appreciate…

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Page 5 of 14

720 Arrow Hwy
Ste A
Covina, CA 91722
Directions
(626) 591-8637
Call Now
Visit Website
http://thepietrap.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Pie Trap Pizza open?

Pie Trap Pizza opens at 4:00 PM on Monday.Pie Trap Pizza opens at 11:00 AM on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.Pie Trap Pizza opens at 12:00 PM on Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Pie Trap Pizza close?

Pie Trap Pizza closes at 9:00 PM on Monday, Wednesday and Thursday.Pie Trap Pizza is closed on Tuesday.Pie Trap Pizza closes at 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.Pie Trap Pizza closes at 8:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon 4:00 PM - 9:00 PMTue ClosedWed-Thu 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSat 12:00 PM - 10:00 PMSun 12:00 PM - 8:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Pie Trap Pizza take credit cards?

Yes, Pie Trap Pizza takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Pie Trap Pizza have catering options?

No, Pie Trap Pizza does not have catering options.

Does Pie Trap Pizza have a drive thru?

No, Pie Trap Pizza does not have a drive thru.

Does Pie Trap Pizza serve alcohol?

No, Pie Trap Pizza does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Pie Trap Pizza allow dogs?

Yes, Pie Trap Pizza allows dogs.

Does Pie Trap Pizza have TVs?

Yes, Pie Trap Pizza has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Pie Trap Pizza have bike parking?

Yes, Pie Trap Pizza has bike parking.

Does Pie Trap Pizza have outdoor seating?

Yes, Pie Trap Pizza has outdoor seating options.

Does Pie Trap Pizza have parking?

Yes, Pie Trap Pizza has parking options.

Other Amenities

Is Pie Trap Pizza wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Pie Trap Pizza is wheelchair accessible.

Does Pie Trap Pizza have free WiFi?

No, Pie Trap Pizza does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

20” New York pizza pies and Detroit squares on the weekend and when available

More Info

Special Hours

Pie Trap Pizza Reviews in Other Languages

Spanish
1 Review

Ask the Community - Pie Trap Pizza

Do you sell beer?

Yes

View question details

Do you have any white sauce pizzas, particularly slices?

We only sell what’s in display We try and keep a white pie in the display Just depends on if they… Read more

View question details

How many slices in the 20" rounds and the 14"x10" pan pizzas? also i saw mention of a deep dish but it doesn't look like they offer deep dish?

8 slices in 20 inch 6 slices in pan pizza Only pan pizza no deep dish

View question details

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

Italia Pasta e Pizza

We LOVE this place! We come here regularly for The Regina pizza. All of their food is super…read moredelicious and fresh. It's definitely not like your ordinary pizza place. The family who runs the business is also so kind and friendly! There were a few times we showed right before closing and they were still so accommodating and quick! They do a lot of events in other cities so definitely check their Instagram to see where they're at before going!

Italia Pasta e Pizza is a spot I highly recommend checking out! They're a family-owned business run…read moreby owners originally from Italy, so you can expect authentic Neapolitan-style pizza. They're typically located in Covina, but I recommend checking their Instagram page before visiting since their location can occasionally change for events. I initially went to the address listed on Google and Yelp, only to find they weren't there. After checking Instagram, I learned they were participating in the West Covina Electric Boba Fest & Night Market. Each pizza is made to order and took about 15 minutes to prepare. I ordered the Diavola, and it came out with a beautiful char throughout the crust that added a delicious smoky flavor. The pizza was perfectly saucy, the crust was light and pillowy, and every bite had the right amount of cheese. I can definitely see the care, love and quality that goes into each pizza.

Photos

When he preparing this little slice of heaven

Carnivora - salami, bacon, sausage, tomato sauce, basil

See all

Salsiccia pizza

Redwood Pizza and Wings

Let me start by saying, Yes it's a little pricey for a pizza…read more.. I can confidently say I'll pay whatever price their heart desires for that pizza. It's really that good. Seriously. It's a little hole in the wall spot with quick service and immaculate vibes.

Horrible customer service . The guy answering the phone lacks communication and interpersonal…read moreskills. He is short with his words and rushes his responses. I can understand bad days but I've interacted several times with the same csr . Train the guy or have him focus on making the pizzas in the back. This way he doesn't have to interact with the public. What happened to the other CSR? At least she waited until I finished my order and would end the conversation with a thank you. Rude phone order cashier guy is a joke

Photos

Small, inside dining area.

Pepperoni pizza

See all

Fire pizza !

Red Devil Pizza

Love! Love! Love! We went to get some lunch and it was…read morefantastic The vibe in the restaurant is great everyone was super friendly We placed our order and sat and we were able to watch it be made in front of us that was neat It smells delicious in there We waited about 15 min maybe didn't really realize how long it was nice to sit inside and watch a movie that was on The pizza was amazing love the crust! Everything was fresh I highly recommend the pizza to everybody

We ordered three extra large pizzas, breadsticks, and a few bottles of Coke to celebrate your…read morebirthday at the house. Calling in the order for pick up was very straightforward. Our order was ready for pick up precisely once stated and we had fast, friendly service. A young gentleman assisted me to my car with the pizzas. It was a Saturday night and quite windy (March 7th). His assistance helped immensely, and he was incredibly polite and kind. The quality of the pizza, coupled with the impeccable service and spot on pick up times, will always keep me coming back. I've had Red Devil since I was a young child. After three decades, they are still the place to go in San Gabriel Valley.

Photos

Large "Big Bad Wolf" - Meat Lovers pie.

See all

Pizza, Breadsticks, and the Parade

Monstrous Pizza

Seriously-- such awesome customer service! I messed up my…read moreonline order and they not only gave me my mistake pizza, they made a new one - free of charge. They were even nice about it and did NOT make me feel like an idiot at all. Haha! I'll be back!

We are pretty sure these guys closed their business after what happened last night. The website…read moresaid they were open, but the phone kept rejecting our calls to make an order. We figured they were just busy, being July 4th. However, after ordering online, the website could not confirm our order and automatically canceled it after 30 minutes of being unable to connect. So we were on to looking for pizza somewhere else. So ordering pizza took an hour and a half instead of 30 minutes. SMH

Photos

See all

Rose City Pizza

Seriously, love their pizza. I was so sad when they closed in Rosemead... BUT GOD IS FAITHFUL…read morehahahha! Rose City opened right down my street!!! Blessings from the Lord come in all shapes and sizes, and in this case, in the form of delicious pizza. So happy for them and proud that they are doing. They are our movie night pizza choice, always.

I bought this pizza for my pizza-loving friend as part of her bday gift. She's more of the pizza…read moreexpert than I am, and she seemed to love this pizza! I ate a slice and thought it was good, maybe I was expecting more due to the hype around this place. To me it seemed like an average pepperoni pizza. The crust was too hard for my liking but the added dollops or ricotta were a great bonus. I'm interested in returning and trying a different pizza, there are so many interesting options!

Photos

Fettuccine Alfredo Lasagna Chili Spaghetti The Bronx

See all

The Bronx

Triple Beam Pizza

4.1

(172 reviews)

2.2 mi

Love a good pizza that is different than the big chains around here. Its quite affordable too…read more$35-$40 for a large pizza and you can pick and choose to have multiple toppings if you'd like. They are very accommodating and helpful especially when you don't know what you want!

Delicious pizza. We ordered it to be delivered and it came pretty quickly. Whole pepperoni and a…read moreslice of their potato sage pizza. I loved their chopped salad. So good.

Photos

Pepperoni and Cheese After School Special on Door Dash!

See all

2 Pizzas & Garlic Knots

The Artist Pizzeria

This is, by far, one of my favorite restaurants…read more If you haven't tried dining here yet, you're truly missing out on AMAZING food, a fun, positive vibe, and GREAT service from owner Mona and her hardworking, friendly staff. During our recent visit, we enjoyed a Greek salad, Margherita pizza, garlic bread, a chicken kabob plate, and dessert. I honestly can say that EVERYTHING we ordered was DELICIOUS!! Each item was full of flavor and fresh, and seemed to get better with every bite. This restaurant has been in the same location for many years, and it only seems to improve with age. Its location in this very popular, trendy area of downtown Covina definitely adds to its appeal.

Food service really nice. Place has plenty of sitting and…read moreyou're not on top of your neighbor. It's strange that they have kabobs and pizza! Buuuut , I love both and both were amazing! Pizza crust is amazing- soft with a slight crunch. I recommend this place and it's a nice place to watch sporting events on TV.

See all

Baby Bros Pizza & Wings

Locally owned & operated

Large group friendly

Ok someone told me to try this place. Def did not disappoint…read more Food 5/5 Service 5/5 Ambiance 5/5 I really do not have any negatives to say! I love the Vince the interior design of the restaurant, def better than their competitors, you know who I'm talking about. The food was wow! I was impressed, pizza to wings to the potatoes. All good. Pizza was cheese pulling good, pepperoni was little crisp, wings were solid, full flavor and it the tray comes with some garlic butter looking bottom, dam it was crispy and good Service was also good, even the beers were brought to the table to me vs going to pick it up at the counter. Glad I finally tried it here and will come back for sure!

Food is good, service is good and the vibes are good…read more We like to come here after work for some drinks and food. It's like a little maze as another Yelper mentioned and I have to agree with them on the claw machines etc., being so bright and at the entrance. It threw me off the first time I visited, I almost walked out thinking it was some sort of Chuck E Cheese equivalent until I noticed there was a bar sign. Pricing is decent and not overly expensive. There's a bar like I mentioned and if you sit in the dining area where the bar is, don't expect anyone to come take your order because you have to get up and order at the bar for drinks and food.

Photos

Baby Bros Margarita Flight!

Classic Pepperoni!

See all

Our Guava Twist & Paloma will brighten up any day!

Chi Town Pizza

This is a post that I should have written a couple of months ago...but forgot…read more But let me tell you, I have been daydreaming about this thick delicious pizza ever since. I can be driving in New Mexico or El Paso, or just last week in Kapa'a and I can tell you this, that whole time, whenever I passed a pizza joint or had the hankering for a pizza, this was the pizza I wanted, desired, and needed. I watch what I eat so I've been saving this cheat meal for a special cheat train day!

Phone call was quick and easy and good was incredible TRY…read moreTHE CANNOLIS MY FRIENDS You will not regret it!

Photos

See all

Petrillo's Pizza

This place saved the day for my Family and I. The owner was able to accommodate 20 of us for a…read morelast minute Graduation party during the week,after hours .. Absolutely wonderful. The food was served Family style and plenty of food to go around.. The service and accommodations was just right ; ) Thank you.....

The best special pizza, meatballs and mozzarella sticks!!! Yum !! So good!!…read more Everything is good ,

Photos

Inside

See all

Penne Georgino was so tasty and Petrillos specialty pizza was perfect

Rosalie

Great food and service. We had the spaghetti and the Cacio E Pepe & an Old Fashioned. We especially…read moreloved the live music on Sunday!

I came to Rosalie for my birthday dinner and it exceeded my expectations! Everything we ordered was…read moreabsolutely delicious, but my favorites were the focaccia, the rigatoni, and the charred octopus. Each dish was full of flavor and beautifully prepared. The restaurant itself is so cute and cozy, making it the perfect spot for a date night, celebration, or a nice dinner with friends. The service was attentive and friendly, and we never felt rushed throughout our meal. Rosalie truly feels like a neighborhood hidden gem in Covina. I'm already looking forward to coming back to try more of the menu. Highly recommend!

Photos

Interior

Lumache

See all

Spaghetti & Meatballs (Meatball Sliced Open)

Fonda Don Chon

I ordered the chicken fajitas, it came with a plate of rice and beans. The fajitas came with a…read moremound of food. See pictures. Not only was there a lot of food. It was very, very tasty. I enjoyed my meal. Also, had lunch for the next day. Service was amazing, it was a busy night and they had plenty of servers. Drinks were never left empty and all employees were very content on helping all of us. In the way of ambience, this place has lots of seating indoors and a few tables outdoors. Be prepared for a little bit of a wait, depending on the time of day but well worth it. While we were there, they had several birthdays celebrated. With a little song and a little dessert.

I have been to Fonda don chon two times and both times I didn't have a chance to order any food …read more The waiter spoke Spanish to me which is fine but he got irritated that my adult children did not speak Spanish . He lectured me as to why my children didn't speak Spanish . If I work and my children's mother doesn't speak Spanish was explained to the waiter . The Reason wasn't good enough. I went to go eat Mexican food not to get lectured. Another time three of us went to the restaurant. There were many open tables . The waiter places us in a table that barely fit 3 not counting plates when the food was ordered . I told the waiter I wanted a bigger table . He said other times 3 people have fit at the table . Your party can fit at that table. I was trying to eat Comfortably. The waiter Got mad at me for asking for a bigger table . Once again it was at approximately 2:30 pm there was plenty of room. The waiter was so upset he was complaining that others have fit why not you guys. I said you know what I don't want to bother you any more so I told my party let's go. The waiter got mad again as we were walking out and he said in Spanish este gente esta fregando. It's too bad some of the wait staff have an attitude problem. I've heard the food is good at Fonda don chon . I guess I'll never find out .

Photos

Buffet area.

See all

Bottoms up!

Venus

This restaurant is less than 5 minutes from my house, and I'd ordered from them so many times, I…read morelost count. I want to say there had been at least 10 orders before I finally set foot into the restaurant, only because my nephew's birthday was being celebrated there. The place looked like it had been newly remodeled/refreshed. It was nice and clean inside, but as lots of restaurants did during and after Covid, they ended up using some of dining space for excess storage, so there was a little section that was a bit cluttered, but that didn't bother me. I was there for the food (oh, and a birthday party...hahaha!) The food here is solid, and consistently delicious, even after they changed owners. Some of my favorites that I order on repeat: Orange Peel Chicken Honey Walnut Shrimp Salt & Pepper Pork Chop Salt & Pepper Fish French Style Filet Mignon My only gripe, is when it changed owners, the prices jumped quite a bit, so I had to cut back on the frequency of my orders. When I was shopping around for catering party trays, they were higher than all the others. Still though, the food is that good, so while I may not be willing to spend the money on party trays, I'll continue ordering from here for regular meals.

The food was amazing. It was very tasty and well flavored. The service was a bit long on a Sunday…read morewith only 2 staff members working. The waitress and cook were very busy trying to please and prepare food for lots of customers. Ambiance was nice and peaceful. I hope that on my next Sunday visit that more staff are assisting customers and helping in the kitchen area.

See all

Agnii A Fiery Experience

Beautiful restaurant, and great ambiance! Very highly recommend the Chicken Tikka Masala!read more

Food is always delicious and servers are always so attentive. I worry that it's not busy enough…read morebecause I would hate to see this restaurant fail. You won't regret dining here!

See all

Georgie's Mediterranean Cuisine

Great service and the food is amazing! Always fresh and fast. Love the chicken kabab wrap.read more

Super fire, highly recommend to anyone, the best in the city so so so so so good. Bring your kids…read moreand family

Photos

Baklava

See all

Chicken And Beef Kabab Combo Mix

Crazy Rock'N Sushi - Covina

Good Place, Good Food, and Best Quality Food Ever, also Good Service Specially Our Waiters Olivia…read more Very happy to bring family to come and eat at crazy rock'n sushi - covina

Ryan was very polite, excellent service, food and ambiance were great. Will definitely be…read morereturning

Photos

Buy One Get One 50% OFF on Special Roll. All Day Long (Monday- Thursday)

Crazy Boat

See all

Interior of Restaurant

Avolio's Italian Restaurant

This restaurant has good service and the most delicious food! I recently heard what has happened…read moreand I'm so sorry that these individuals are taking advantage of your business. It's sickening to know that these people will use any excuse to justify their actions. Wishing your business continued growth, faithful customers, and multiplied blessings.

Everything we ordered was very very good. Started off with garlic bread…read more. Shrimp scampi portions are pretty big shrimp. Scampi was not too garlicky. Wasn't overloaded with butter flavors were fresh. Linguine with clams all the flavors together we're good nothing overpowered each other Was not a fan of the spumoni I thought I'd be an ice cream. I didn't like it as a cake. Service was great

Photos

Large margherita pizza!

See all

The front of the restaurant

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

22 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Hannah L.

Elite 26

183

292

2 years ago

I am thrilled to support this local business. The pizza was absolutely delicious. I ordered the Lodi Dodi Square pie, which had deliciously crispy edges and soft interior texture. The pizza was beautifully dressed with red sauce, vodka sauce, and pesto stripes on top of mozz and romano. We also ordered a side of house meatballs, which came with three meatballs and three garlic knots, served with ricotta and basil. The ambiance at Pie Trap Pizza is great. They played awesome music that added to the lively atmosphere. Situated next to a brewery, it's the perfect spot to grab a bite. This establishment has exceptional customer service. I had previously had an unsatisfactory encounter when ordering through a third-party vendor, which was no fault of theirs. Paul reached out to me via email to address the issue. He was very helpful and ensured my next order was taken care of properly. I highly recommend trying Pie Trap out the next time you're in the mood for pizza! read more

Terra T.

2 years ago

Pie Trap Pizza has become our go-to spot for pizza, and for good reason - it's absolutely delicious. Yes, it's a bit on the pricier side, but the quality and flavor make it worth every penny. Whether we're dining in or ordering for delivery, Pie Trap Pizza never disappoints. The crust is perfectly crisp with just the right amount of chew, and the toppings are always fresh and generous. One thing we love about Pie Trap Pizza is that their delivery is just as good as dining in-store. The pizza arrives hot and fresh, maintaining the same quality and taste that you get when dining at the restaurant. It's a reliable option for those nights when we just want to enjoy a great meal at home without compromising on flavor. Even though it's a bit more expensive, Pie Trap Pizza is our top choice because of its outstanding quality and consistency. read more

Michelle P.

147

330

2 years ago

Here's my Yelp review for the square pizza called "The D" with hot honey and burrata cheese: I tried 'The D' square pizza at this charming pizzeria, and I must say it was a delightful experience from start to finish! The combination of hot honey and creamy burrata cheese on top of a perfectly crispy square crust was a true culinary masterpiece. The flavors blended together beautifully, creating a unique and delicious taste that left me craving more. Not to mention, the customer service was top-notch - friendly and prompt, making the whole dining experience even more enjoyable. I highly recommend trying 'The D' if you're looking for a one-of-a-kind pizza experience that will leave your taste buds singing with joy! read more

Osmosis L.

1 year ago

I recently visited Pie Trap Pizza and had a pretty good experience overall. The service was fantastic - the staff was friendly, attentive, and made sure we were well taken care of throughout our meal. As for the food, the pizza was decent. It had a good crust and toppings, but nothing that blew me away. The wings were also decent - not bad but not extraordinary either. Overall, a solid experience, but I was hoping for a little more excitement from the food. Would definitely return for the service though! read more

Michael B.

366

9 months ago

The pizza was absolutely fantastic! The crust had a rich, satisfying flavor with just the right balance of crispness and chew, making every bite delicious. The sauce-to-topping ratio was spot on--nothing was overpowering, everything complemented each other perfectly. Even though it was delivered, the pizza held up beautifully and still tasted amazing. That said, I can only imagine how incredible it must be fresh out of the oven--I'd love the chance to experience it hot and fresh someday! read more

Isabella S.

4 years ago

Pie trap was some of the best pizza I've ever had. If you always wanted to try NY pizza this is your best bet out here. The sauce is impeccable , the dough is so soft and chewy but the outer layer is still so crispy! Not even just that all the options and cool names really make this spot a gem. Not to mention its right next door to a brewery , so all those beer lovers out there grab a nice slice and get some good beer and relax . read more

Paul C.

3 years ago

Great pizza. The explosive is incredible. The sweat and spicy is the way to go. There crust is what makes it. Never had such a great crispy chewy crust since New York. The service is great the guys helped me out navigating the menu and we had a couple laughs. Highly recommend. And just tried the straight ballin recommended by Frankie. Best meatball pie I ever had read more

Jaisun L.

771

1 year ago

Pie Trap is a must-visit for hip hop and pie lovers! Their crust is perfectly flaky, and the flavors are both classic and creative. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and there's always something new to try. Whether you're grabbing a slice or a whole pie, you won't be disappointed! read more

Ian A.

3 years ago

This place is legit!! As a former New Yorker I always have had a hard time finding good pizza in California! I'm happy to say that Ive found the spot!! The employees were really cool and there is good seating in the brewery they are connected to. Would definitely recommend it! read more

Emily J.

10 months ago

This pizza place offers generous portions. The crust was soft and easy to bite. The sauce was flavorful without being too heavy. The cheese stretched beautifully with every slice. The staff served quickly and with a smile. I'm already planning my next visit. read more

Mark M.

2 years ago

Hey Shaun, this is Markanthony from Mesa Robles. Finally tried your pizza tonight and it was BOMB!! I'm telling everyone about it. Loved it brother. Glad for you. keep it up and great stuff! Blessings to you and the fam! read more

Michael P.

10 months ago

I feel bad having to give this review but for the price, I was very unimpressed. I'd like to think I just showed up on a bad day or something. I don't understand all these 5 star reviews. I don't recommend read more

Dj P.

3 years ago

Hands down the very best pizza you can get in California. I never ate the crust on the pizza until I had pie trap. The new york pie is the best and if you like ranch make sure you get the trap sauce. read more

Adam C.