I have yet to try any of the pastries but the watermelon and feta cheese salad is amazing!. I'm also fond of the BLT sandwich and the tomato and mozzarella sandwich. The food is tasty and the portions are generous. read more

As a bakery this place is most likely the best in Staten. (I know everyone has their favorite!). Came here for breakfast and had a ricotta omelette with a side of bacon. Whole wheat sour dough on the side. Ricotta pretty much has no taste so the omelette was bland - not their fault. Bacon was good. Bread was amazing. This is kind of self service where you have to order your meal on the bakery side and pay. You get a number for the table. You take your own plastic cutlery, napkins etc. you have to ask for butter. They have an amazing menu. I'd go back for lunch but the bakery selection is still my favorite part!! read more

Piece A Cake - Ricotta Omelette - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

Staff recently have been really nice. Wish they put back breakfast service. We bought the Dubai chocolate cake. By far DELICIOUS a must try!! Not sweet or super rich.. really a perfect dessert read more

Piece A Cake - Dubai chocolate cake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Food was great. Also an employee was great with the service and helped us figure out what was good and where to go. He had a beard and he was super chill. Lol he was amazing. The pastries and everything was just overall amazing highly recommend if you're looking for a nice little brunch out. read more

Piece A Cake - The pastries box - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Coffee's pretty good but the service is even better. Love that it's connected to the cookie jar so you can enjoy the ambiance of both unique places while sharing desserts & coffees .. great date spot! read more

Piece A Cake - Coffees & Open Dessert - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I'm extremely disappointed with my experience at this bakery. I ordered a custom cake and cupcakes on Sunday, paid $135, and everything went smoothly -- so I placed the exact same order again on Monday (the only difference was the name on the cake). When my friend went to pick up the order on Wednesday, the staff told her there were no cupcakes with the order and that the receipt didn't show them, even though I was charged the same amount both times. On top of that, the name on the cake was placed crooked, which made it look careless and unprofessional. I was met with confusion, poor communication, and zero accountability. To make matters worse, the cashier was rude and tried to blame me, claiming the issue was because the cake wasn't picked up at 1 p.m.--even though the receipt clearly says "pick up after 1 p.m.". The whole situation was so disappointing, and the kids were sad there were no cupcakes to go with the cake. In the end, there was no real resolution, just a $26 refund -- which doesn't make up for the mistake or the frustration. For the price I put in, I expected much better quality, service, and professionalism. I won't be ordering from this bakery again. read more

Piece A Cake - cake design - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

Horrible service ordered was wring three times these young kids have no idea what tbey are doing!!!!!!

This business literally just sent a lunch order to a school without one meal. We even spoke to the guy on the phone about the meal after placing it online. NO phone call, NO heads up, NO call to the driver to come back, NO apology. They said, "We were busy" and "didn't have time" to make the sandwich. Instead, after speaking to Shannon the supervisor, we were told that it was refunded. No solution, no lunch. Not a good business practice here. Someone screwed up, didn't tell the manager, and is leaving them to handle this. Zero stars. Get it together. Tell the Carrozzas to come in and work on their business. read more

What a cute bakery on Staten Island! Love the decor and the signs. The assortment of baked goods was almost overwhelming but the attendant was very patient and explained what all the items were. Prices were very reasonable and we were out the door with 3 pastries for about $10. The apple strudel and pistachio pastry were especially delicious. read more

Good: donuts and majority of the cakes Bad: customer services. There is a lot of young workers who has a lot of hostile energies and including their speciality of rolling their eyes. Totally get it , been one and was one. But seriously - adults? Team leader: floor manager- where are you? The lines are confusing as there is two counters where it can be misleading of where to place the order, one near the cakes and a main counter of where you pay. Long story short, there is a lot of items and sorry if we need a little extra time to figure out what we want. There is no need to roll your eyes afterward and talk among each other like we are the problem. read more

Piece A Cake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I've been coming to this place for years and tonight was the worst experience. I had met with some longtime friends for dinner at pizzeria Giove and went there for dessert following our dinner. When we arrived at approximately 730 we ordered very simple items... 3 cookies, an apple turnover warmed with ice cream on top and one other pastry. We ordered some coffee and cappuccino. As we were paying the cashier said he didn't have something for the machine and I switched my drink. They asked if the turnover should go on a plate or box, figuring it's ice cream we asked for a plate to sit and eat. What took almost 25 minutes and mixing orders up they finally serve us around 758 PM. Keep in mind, we ordered 730. We sit down and start eating. A worker comes up and says we have to pack it up and leave at about 802. We explained that there was a delay for the food and my friend was eating ice cream. A manager comes over and says we are being kicked out after spending nearly 40 dollars to sit down and converse at 730. I explained calmly that our order had been messed up and that we waited patiently for our food. We had told them it was to stay and then they waited til we sat and started eating to abruptly kick us out. My firmer said his ice cream would melt and she said she'd box it up. He can eat it and walk on the sidewalk. Needless to say they suck terribly and have teenagers with no respect running the place. On a side note, they don't know what one sweetener is and it tasted like I was drinking pure sugar. *** nobody stated that they were closing. They served us food to stay and my friend who ordered - At 730 waited over 25 minutes for ice cream. A refund for melted ice cream would have been nice and 20 plus minutes to pour and serve a beverage was unacceptable. The worker who stated he should take his ice cream to go on the ride home was really considerate. I'm happy I tipped as well, no thank you or ringing of the bell. Maybe the actions of employees spending over 20 minutes, 28 to be exact, to serve three people in an empty store should be the underlying issue, we didn't want to sit two minutes before closing. Had it even been served by 740, we have been out before 8. Waste of money and tip cause we didn't finish our stuff. I'll never consider going back because it's bad business practice. Is it being internally reviewed or are you saying that they communicated it? Were you there? I should have recorded the way we were spoken to. If you look at my yelp history, I rarely review. I was a customer for years and I will never go back in after the way I was treated. A good company would have reached out direct about the matter. When I was a teenager, I would have never spoken disrespectfully to adults. Times have changed. read more

Took me a very long time to get here, and the fact it's Sunday didn't help me either . Even tho this beautiful cafe is in the island it literally took me almost 2 hours on public transport to get here. If I was driving that would be a different story ! If I will be back here again & again ? I would have if I was driving ! Feeling sad tho.. Lovee the decor . Customer service was great; while I was deciding what to order on line, 3 people already asked me if I was being helped ! That's very rare this days ! Much appreciated ! Lots of options to choose from . I ordered coffee, pistachio & mocha macarons & blueberry turnover. Didn't like the pistachio macaroon tho. I normally love pistachio! For 3$ a piece the size was huge then other places , so I appreciate that . They have so many delicious sweet stuff that I do not wanna leave now ! But before I start testing everything & gain 10 lb sitting right here I decided that it's time to leave. Btw they have enough space to get a cup of coffee & chill out. It's not like some other coffee places where you feel like can't even breathe! If you live near by definitely a Cafe you gotta give a try , you will love it..! One more thing I have to mention that this cafe doesn't have much of seating but they have made a door to the other place called 'Cookie Jar' & both places uses that area for seating . Maybe owner is the same , didn't get a chance to ask . If it's a different owner then I have to appreciate this bonding , love & respect . I will try to post a separate review for that place just to be fair ! read more

See all

Best cakes on the island, I love to get the strawberry cheesecake and I love their marshmallow milkshakes. They even have tons of delicious and creative coffee flavors. Most of all though the atmosphere of this place can't be talked about enough. There has been so much thought and care put into all the decorations, you do not find places that are so vintage anymore. The best way for me to explain how cool the decor is for me to just say you have to see for yourself! read more

with just the service and ambiance alone I give this place a five star. not only were the workers kind and extra communicative but welcoming as well. both piece a cake and the cookie jar share the same owner and the inside also are connected. I heard their cookies are amazing but I had come for the red velvet which I heard from a coworker was one of her favorites. with the cake and the garlic bread chips it came to only 36$ which I thought was a steal considering how much a normal cake costs these days the donut was delicious and the garlic crostini's were as well. Perfect pair for soups during these cold weathers. the cake was absolutely delicious and moist. even after sitting in the fridge overnight the cake was still so soft read more

A family member bought an apple pie from you guys. We were so excited when he came home we put it in the oven. My parents had the first taste, my Dad literally spit it out! Then my mom tried it she started cursing!!! Disgusting!! Then I tried it it tasted like it was sugar free and sour!! It was the worse apple pie I ever tasted. So I called up the business the next to explain that I wanted a refund they stated there are "No refunds" and was so nasty on the phone!! I was very disappointed and disgusted!!! Never going there again!!! read more

Went there yesterday 11/26/2025 the day before Thanksgiving and purchased an apple crumb pie for friends giving dinner I had and we got to the dessert we put pieces of the cake that ppl wanted in the oven to heat up the cake and when it came out it looked disgusting the cake looked like someone threw water on it, it looked like a Soupy mess and also forgot to mention they put confectioners sugar on top of an apple crumb pie who does that I've never seen that done ever in all my years of buying pies unless you ask for it and it tasted like stevia sugar which the ppl stated tasted horrible they also said their were no apples to bite into only little cubes of apples. SIMPLY DISAPPOINTING. Thanksgiving is all about the Apple pie. So I called today on Thanksgiving and a girl answered and I told her what happened and thinking that she would do the right thing and make it right seeing as today is Thanksgiving she tells me that their return policy is no returns . I was so disgusted and disheartened if something doesn't tasty right the company or store should stand by their product and make it right.. I give piece a Cake 2 thumbs down for their disgusting way of handling this situation on Thanksgiving day shame on them . read more

See all

a gem in Staten Island. Full of character yet cozy and makes for a great spot to have your morning coffee or midday meal. I tried the green juice - came out really fast & great! read more

See all

Really adorable, semi-kitschy bakery that makes top-notch apple ring, scones, and ricotta cheesecakes. Deviating from these greats and getting the pesto-egg sandwich and some cookies proved a tad underwhelming. The brioche wasn't very flavorful and the pesto was minimal, surprisingly dry. Get the above pastries and you'll walk out so happy you did! read more

See all

Tried the red velvet iced coffee. Cashier recommended it. All I can say is unless you want to be FREAKING out later on when you use the restroom DO NOT GET IT!! Lets just say it altered the color of my stool. Leading me to FREAK OUT!! Thinking there was something medically wrong. Never again... read more

Such an amazing pastry place. I also got their cake slices. Very good. The vanilla custard cream puff is just amazing. So much custard inside of this thing, so dense to hold it got some weight! so if you're not a fan of custard dont get this. I also got their cheesecake and red velvet slice, the cheesecake is dense and really good too. I'm excited about the red velvet I haven't ate it yet. read more

Piece A Cake - Vanilla Custard Cream Puff - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Cake was dense, delicious, and decently priced. Didn't quite hit the spot for me but I prefer lighter cakes. Staff were helpful at narrowing choices if you are overwhelmed. Seating available through a connecting doorway. Chill vibes. read more

See all

We come here for our pastries for the holidays as the store is down the street from us . As you walk in the smells are wonderful and you want to eat everything in site. We've had the St Joseph pastries and assorted cookies and they've been a hit to everyone's house we've taken them to . The staff are helpful and have you wrapped up in no time . The prices could be a bit on the expensive side but seems the trend everywhere. Parking is limited so finding a spot out front is purely pot luck. Worth a try for all you bakery fans. read more

Unorganized - no type of sense to the lines. Stood in what I thought was a line for pickup then was sent to another area where NO EMPLOYEE was attending customers. The employee that came up provided terrible service. There is also almost never any parking. Avoid this place until they make improvements. read more

I like to stay here.At this point, Piece A Cake is a solid neighborhood staple. We always get their cakes (at least a slice!) for special occasions/birthdays and I love their pastries as well. My husband and I are particularly fans of the Napoleon and - more often than not they taste very fresh! Their pies are amazing, love the seasonal variety. They have a beautiful inside love getting some coffee and just hanging out there. read more

See all

Love how fresh their food is daily. But most importantly the staff is always super friendly. read more

Piece A Cake - Egg and zucchini frittata - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

What very pleasant crew! Stopped in after Hot Pot. All the crew members were wearing masks and although it was busy, we didn't feel rushed at all. My friend got a rice pudding and a cookie. I can't wait to try their homemade Oreo!!!! read more

Piece A Cake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

Great atmosphere quality food and service. Has a real artisan touch to all cakes and beverages. Top favorite on Staten for what it provides . read more

Horrible customer service they spilled a full cup of hot chocolate on my wife and not one person came over to apologize or even ask if she was ok. After she went over she was told that there is no manager on duty and given a card to email her. The email on the card bounced back as undeliverable. We found another email on their website but still no response. read more

I have been meaning to try this bakery for awhile now and never got the chance to do to. Luckily, I was around the area and had some free time to stop by. They have so many options for baked goods. The price is affordable and the staff members are super friendly. I need to come by and try some of their drinks as this will be my goto bakery shop whenever I'm around the area. read more

See all

not really sure why almost everyone in there has a gross attitude and I only go here because of the convenience of it being next to my job but customer service should have a negative 0 rating here. after this time I'm no longer using this service. I go to pick up an order the charge adjustments for sneakily even though it's not extra food so $20 is charged for one egg one slice of toast and avocado on the side. when you get there no one addresses you and I'm so sick of it because I don't ALWAYS have the 20-30+ minutes to patiently wait there that they think they're entitled to taking every time there's a customer like others have said so I asked if soemone was doing the pick up orders after like many people said an employee walked by without addressing I was waiting there. The employee doing it saw me and continued doing other things. So they both looked very put off they had to do their job at all and I was told she's doing it and give her a minute, which I always give them 25 minutes the shortest everytime. she doesn't address me, I tell her the name and she gives me an attitude, I ask for one thing and looking out off she hands it to me. I say thank you and she gives me a nasty look doesn't say anything back and walks away. This is everytime like other people noted. I'm getting my money back and not going there anymore. Is there a reason all your employees have a disgusting attitude? read more

I just bit into a raspberry brownie and crunched into a large piece of metal. I could have swallowed it and gone to the hospital. Piece of Cake needs to be more careful. When we called to let them know, they said "sorry. We will try to be more careful." We are long time customers and will never eat here again. Be careful eating their brownies. read more

Bakery items are usually pretty good. Picked up cupcakes today, they should have been on the days old table.

Get all our bday cakes and brownies here! Most amazing food and cookies! The owners are wonderful, great for grab and go or order and sit!

I don't have a lot to say. A friend told me about this bakery when I was on the island recently. He suggested a friend and I come here but we wanted dinner so we passed. Another opportunity came sooner rather than later. I purchased an obscene amount of treats. Bars, cookies, you name it. And with only one exception, a tasteless scone, everything was outrageously good. I recently lost a ton of weight so a place like this will be an occasional indulgence. But I'm so glad I know about it. See you next time. read more

Bought thIs for my brothers birthday Very disappointing when sliced there was moree cream cheese filling then cake !! It was really nasty way too much ! I bought an individual piece and it was Li Ike two different cakes all together ! The cake to filling ratio was way off Very disappointing read more

Piece A Cake - Cream Cheese Cake with carrot crumble - Coffee & Tea Near Me - New York, New York

This is my favorite place to go for coffee and cake. The food is always fresh and you can buy sweets to take home and share with your family. I saw the review where a person had to take long time on public transportation. I don't understand that because Piece A Cake is close to the train - which is free in Staten Island!! Anyone can get here easily and enjoy the many cakes and cookies (Cookie Jar next door) they have to offer. read more

Food is ok but way overpriced for no reason for what it is. The workers behind the counter are extremely rude and have gross attitudes. Definitely incompetent and slow with huge communication issues. Should probably fire everyone working in the front and replace them as this seems to be an issue for other people. read more

Very poor customer service, the employees are not professional at all, place and lines are very unorganized. Avoid coming here

The workers here are so rude!!! I was talking to an asian woman by the name of Brenda I believe and she had an attitude the entire time and upon asking for a manager she claimed she was one, i don't understand how people like that can manage your store. read more

Simple, sweet, and scrumptious. This bakery offers. cookies, cakes, and assorted pastries with a home-made style. Piece-a-cake has something for everyone (unless you're on a diet). read more