The food is absolutely amazing! The best pizza I have ever had. The service was also good. The ambiance isn't the best. It's very small and tight seating but the food is worth it. read more

Took a quick trip to Staten Island to give a visiting friend the ferry experience, and we stopped by this Italian restaurant for lunch. The interior was comfy with a classic old school feel. I ordered the Pan Seared Salmon, which was served with potatoes and broccoli, along with a squiggle of olive oil and balsamic vinegar. This came with a choice, and I went with French Fries, even though had I known the dish was already coming with potatoes, I would have gone with the Pasta. The Salmon was oh so tender, flaky, and slightly crispy. Potatoes and broccoli were both fresh, well seasoned, with a bit of a crunch. Olive oil and vinegar added to the deliciousness of the dish. Steak Fries were addicting, and full of pure potato taste. Service was solid. Our waiter was welcoming and made sure we were taken care of though out our meal. Prices were decent. Since I'm not in the area often, I probably won't return. read more

See all

Got a plain slice and a white slice to go. The slice shop portion of the space is small (understandably so) but they have a whole restaurant too if you're going for a sit down meal. We liked the super thin crust on our slices! Quite a lot if ricotta on the white slice as well, which made my husband happy! read more

Pier 76 - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

My food was delivered at least 20 minutes before my husbands. No explanation. We had to get our own utensils and napkins. The waitress was eating and priming a keg as we waited for the rest of our food. read more

Great deal that they have on week days- large pie for $11! It's super delicious and you can't stop eating it. Pie is super thin so it's very good for a diet. It's our place to - go. read more

Pier 76 - Amazing pie! And for $11 it's excellent - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

5/27 UPDATE: I placed another order for delivery today and I just don't know what the deal is with this place and forgetting ingredients on their pizzas. I placed a similar order as last time, a calamari spinach pie and a royal pier but instead of a 10" royal, I got a 16". They managed to remember to include mushrooms but forgot the damn peppers this time. Are they ever going to get it right? ORIGINAL REVIEW: Ordered two pizzas for delivery. The Calamari Spinach pie was unique and delicious! The Royal Pier pie was also great but I took a star off because mushrooms were forgotten and I was a little disappointed since the description included it. I would order it again though and hope they'll remember to add it in the next time. read more

See all

Visiting from out of town and was craving some Italian. Checked out Pier 76. Was disappointed 100%! Pasta was overcooked, sauces were under seasoned, and menu was outdated. Crab cakes on the menu but not available, only 4 beers on tap, 2 wine selections, and fruit flies flying around your food. The poor server felt so bad because he kept saying, "sorry we don't have that.", or, "sorry that's not correct". You shouldn't have to put him on the front lines because ownership fails to do their part. He is a great guy and super sweet, too bad his management doesn't have his back and makes him serve half a** food. Not much ambiance if we're being honest but I hope your server finds a better place or better team to work with. To top it off there's a 4% credit card charge even if you use debit. Unfortunately there's nowhere this is posted. read more

See all

First off food was quite tasty. I went with the Yelp recommendations and ordered a slice of arugula as well as a slice of calamari pizza. I got there when they opened, so the food didn't come out until noon, which was an hour later. I had a beer while I waited, so that made it okay. The ambiance has a diner/bar feel to it. Overall it was a welcoming Staten Island experience. read more

See all

I must say I had the crispiest most delicious calamari I have ever eaten at this restaurant. AMAZING!! The waiter worked nonstop to take care of the needs of our group of around 20 people. There seemed to be a very long wait for our main course, but everyone was satisfied with their choices. My chicken parm was thinly sliced and expertly breaded the way I like it and served with penne pasta. If I ever find myself in this area I will definitely stop in. Worth the trip. read more

See all

Great food amazing service. The ambiance is cool and comfortable.. we love their pizza

Delivery person actually FORGOT my pizza. I called Pier 76 to inform. "Oh we're so busy (because money hand over fist means you ignore an order that was paid for but never received). I just got my pizza I've been waiting almost two and a half hours. Don't call this establishment if you want you and your treated with respect and I just got my pizza read more

My wife, daughter and I visited NYC 10 days and on our first day, we took the Staten Island ferry to get a view of the Statue of Liberty. While on Staten Island, we walked over to Pier 76 pizza. We ordered the Royal Pier pizza which is sliced meatball, pepperoni, peppers & sausage. It also comes with mushrooms but we held that off. In short, the pizza was fantastic. I would heartily recommend it. Service was great as well. A few days later, back in midtown, we ordered a pizza from Joe's on Broadway, and while that pizza was good as well, between the two, I would have to give it to Pier 76. Worth a stop! read more

We ordered pizzas from here while day drinking at Flagship Brewery. I would stack this pizza against any pizza spot across any of the NYC boroughs any day! Pizza was absolutely delicious. It's a very thin crust (à la Scarr's, Rubirosa, or New Haven style), but has a bit more give and flop to it. The toppings and pepperoni were bomb, crust/dough was perfect, sauce/cheese ratio on point. I can't speak to what it's like to dine-in here, but I do know this is some top tier pizza - people are seriously sleeping on Staten Island pizza! Can't wait to come back and eat at the actual restaurant. read more

Pier 76 - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I just had two cheese slices an hour ago and the texture looked so beautiful. Even the quality of the taste was beyond delightful.

My brother and I came here before heading on our ferry I had spaghetti and he had pizza they were both amazing! The service was good just the waiter kept forgetting about what I asked him like I asked him for check he took another tables order and then told him again for check 10mins later and he said oh I forgot my bad but ok! The ambiance is nice but loud! read more

Holy pizza batman! Sicilian pizza at it's best. We ordered a couple of pints, bartender poured pitchers...all good. No problem with extra beer. Ordered the calamari and a 14in sicilian pepperoni pizza. Calamari came out piping hot. He said the calamari just came from the fish market. You could taste the freshness and it was super tender. Pizza was top 5 of my all time faves. I eat a lot of different pizza and am very picky. This place had a great crust, tasty sauce, and a great chew to the pie. I'd fly to NY just to eat this pizza! read more

See all

An old go to Things sure have changed Man the people are rude as hell Used to be the best friendliest spot in the area I can't believe how bad it's gotten Also Pizza went downhill bad read more

Great service. Waited not a long time and the food was excellent. So many different options of pizza to choose from. Will come back again!

Ordered a $17 butternut squash ravioli, looked horrible and tasted worse. Took one bite and threw it in the garbage. I also ordered a chicken parm hero but they gave me meatball, which wasn't good either. The pizza here is hit or miss, but food from the kitchen is inedible. read more

Pier 76 - Butternut Squash Ravioli - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Great food service and ambience. Will definitely go back. Staff was very friendly. If you're ever on Staten island this place is a must! read more

Pier 76 - Had Cheese Pizza (10 Inch) with eggplant and mushrooms! The best! Great staff and atmosphere. - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

This pizza was delivered by Berto. The man the myth the legend. Great food better service. read more

Pier 76 - Large pizza - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Pizza is always delicious however staff were discourteous & rude. We order from this location almost weekly for pick up. Placed order, arrived 30 min later for set pick up time & order wasn't ready. When staff at counter was asked if the order was just put in, she said 'no' it will be 2 mins , 15 min later, still waiting, apparent she was not being honest about order preparation but she refused to apologize or acknowledge the oversight.. courtesy goes a long way & plenty of other businesses who value their customers to support read more

This has potential to be a good neighborhood spot, but the disconnect and mediocrity is disappointing. The server disappeared for long periods of time. Our drinks remained empty for most of our visit. We had to flag someone down to finally get our closing ticket. The pizza was dry and not the best I've had. Pasta was okay. Cheese garlic bread wasn't the worst I've had, but definitely not the best. Would not recommend. read more

See all

Greatest pizza I have ever had. There will not be a better pizza place than this for a long time.

Pretty neighborhood spot to get a pie on a weekend night or quick bite to eat inside. Came here with a friend for food and it was ok. The service and ambiance just ok. The busboy was attentive but I think the server was overwhelmed by 4 tables being there. The drinks and food was good sized portions. We order the appetizer sampler and it came with normal variety. The food was just ok. Wouldn't recommend doing buffalo calamari again. The experience was nice. I would come back for the heart shaped pizza! read more

Pier 76 - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

The short girl with black hair refused service for me for an unknown reason. I honestly can't understand why. I was in uniform at the time so maybe that. Definitely won't be going back to them. This is the third time I heard she did this as well. read more

I will start by saying the pizza was great, but the service terrible. we were the only ones in the restaurant and after waiting over 30 minutes I had to find someone to ask where our pizza was (the cook was on his phone, the bartender was chatting with the take-out girl, and I never saw our waitress or the hostess after we were seated) - it was like they totally forgot we were there. Nobody asked if we wanted another drink, or checked on us after giving us our pizza, thank goodness the pizza made up for the lack of service. read more

The neighborhood is rundown. Boarded up businesses everywhere. We went into this place because we were craving an authentic NY pizza experience. The place was nearly empty. We ordered half Margherita/half royal Sicilian. The mushrooms, peppers and sausage were soggy and not fresh. I ate a single slice. Our server was nice though. read more

I am so torn on how to rate Pier 76...I was at a friend's house on Staten Island with a group of folks, and they suggested that we order a bunch of pizzas from the restaurant. While I had never had their food before, the others had and simply raved about it. When the pies arrived, I sampled 3 slices (they are medium-sized, but not huge) of the Plain Cheese. I was immediately in awe of the thin, crisp crust, the sweet marinara sauce, and the flavorful cheese. At that point, I was ready to give it a 5 star rating. However, a few hours later, my stomach was not feeling great. Since there was really no way to know if the pizza was definitely the cause, I ate a leftover slice the next day and again my stomach was uneasy. I hate to say this, as I really loved the food, but maybe something (assuming the cheese?) was just off that night. read more

The arugula pizza is one of the best I've ever had. It's nice inside classy etc. good service inside too

Stopped in to Pier 76 on St.Patricks day while we were in the area for a work location/job. Very professional and friendly staff, very COVID safe with temperature checks, staff masked, and contact info left for tracing. We decided to order a pizza for the both of us, and I had a Guinness as an appetizer and Irish Coffee for dessert, Bartender was easygoing and service was quick and prompt. Gotta admit, it was a solid pie, and we split it 3 slices each, very feeling, light crust, crunchy and not too thick. A good choice to stop in for some good food. read more

Pier 76 - Serious Looks while drinking Guiness - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

The food is delicious. First time here with my friend. Service is Amazing!! I have been eyeing this place for a while. read more

See all

5 stars on food, service, and ambiance. Their pizza was delicious. We ordered a couple different pizzas. Their vodka pizza is popular and yummy, but their regular pizza sauce is the star of the show! I don't even usually notice things like the sauce, but that was the best sauce on pizza I've ever had, and ultimately some of the best pizza I've ever had. We also ordered the lobster mac which was fresh and full of lobster flavor. Definitely delicious. We dined in, which I highly recommend. The setting was leisurely. The service was just right. Servers were friendly. I recommend you visit this one. You're in for a treat. read more

Pier 76 - Vodka Pizza Personal Pizza (cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms) Lobster Mac & Cheese - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

19.95 for fettuccine alfredo with no protein just broccoli. I ordered delivery and it took 45 min, i live two blocks away. Portion was enough for lunch and dinner but honestly for this price and quality, i shouldve just gotten my cheese fix from a box of mac and cheese. read more

Pier 76 - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

I was torn between 3 and 4 stars, but decided to go with 4. I had the bbq chicken pizza at the recommendation of the staff (it was ok) and a grandma slice (I've had a lot better, especially at Frank Pinello's Best Pizza in Williamsburg). That being said, I had two slices, a Diet Coke, and paid a big percentage tip for 15 bucks. Service was great, server very nice. They have indoor dining, but I sat outside at big, comfortable picnic tables. It has a harbor view, and there is just something refreshing and fun about the atmosphere and surroundings. read more

Pier 76 - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

So many pizza options while visiting New York but this place takes the prize! Delicious thin crust pies with tons of expected and unexpected topping options... Caring and attentive employees and decent bar options too. Not fancy, not pretentious, just good ole tasty pizza!! read more

Staff was accommodating and pie was DELICIOUS. The chef even apologize for prior incident as the staff was pleasant read more

Pier 76 - Our Fried Calamari and Spinach Salad Pizza DELICIOUS . - Italian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I have been in this pizzeria multiple times and it is worth it! Several pies are amazing. The baked clams are a must. The ambiance is relaxed and welcoming. The service is good, the guys at the bar want to bring you what you want without exaggerating the quality or the intensity of the service. read more

Came here last weekend and it was the highlight of my trip to Staten Island. For years all I've heard of is the Staten Island Shuffle - i.e. people jumping on the Ferry from Manhattan, landing in SI, and then immediately hopping on the ferry back the other way. And for years I've heard people bash Staten Island for being boring, or weird, or barely accessible to the other Boroughs. I wanted to prove them all wrong, and did some exploring to see for myself on a Sunday whether it was all baloney. Unfortunately almost anything I tried to see within a 30-min walk of the Ferry was closed temporarily or permanently, or way out of reach unless you have a car - churches, bars, restaurants, stores, you name it. All shut down. It also happened to be pouring rain. And the famous $5 tallboy beers weren't available on the Ferry. So...yeah, fun times. So imagine how happy I was when we finally stumbled into this place (hey, a place of business that's actually open past 12:00 pm on a Sunday - what a shock), dried off, sat down, and almost immediately got served 4 slices of good, tasty pizza by the chillest, most laid back barman. He insisted on us sampling 2-3 of his beers on tap, with a generous pour on the samples too, before we ordered any of them - so we basically got 2 (solid) beers and a half for super cheap. He then set us up with cutlery and spices / parm / pepper to sprinkle on our slices of (tasty) pizza, and practically tucked us in. Then he left us to our own devices while he took care of other folks around the bar - which is nice. I hate it when people hover over you while you're trying to relax. Solidly good food, great service, and great hours & location. Not much else you can ask for. If I ever go back to give Staten Island another chance, I'll start from here and see how the rest compares. read more

I dont visit staten island often but Ive always heard great things about their pizza. Pier 76 is right by the ferry so whether your waiting to catch the next one or want to take a trip yo SI for pizza its doable. Its easily some of the best pizza I've had in NYC. It was slappin!!!! Yes I had just finished a 50 mile bike ride but man slice after slice the pies did not disappoint. The margherita was great, the veggie pizza was packedddd with vegetables and the wine pours were generous. It was like a little slice of affordable pizza heaven lol. read more