On our last day in Key West, we went for a long walk and came across this hidden gem. Although we didn't make a purchase, I enjoyed browsing the impressive selection of Polish and European specialties. It's the kind of place you could easily spend time exploring. I would absolutely return on a future visit. read more

See all

Delicious homemade Polish soups, sandwiches, pierogis and stews served at this adorable outdoor counter patio. Deli has everything Polish one could imagine - beer, deli meat, kielbasa, herring, etc. What a treat. read more

See all

You wouldn't expect to stumble onto a little slice of Poland tucked away in the middle of Key West, but that's exactly what Pierogies Polish Market delivers. Think of it as a Polish market in miniature--everything you could possibly crave from the old country, compressed into a cozy space just off the beaten path of Duval Street. First off: come early. They close earlier than most shops on the island, and once the door locks, that's it--no late-night pierogi runs. Plan ahead, because this is the kind of place you'll want to linger in. Inside, it's a treasure chest of Polish goodies. Rows of pierogies, smoky kabanosy (those addictive, chewy Polish snack sausages), jars of pickles, sauerkraut, European candies, and all the meats that would make your babcia proud. The sausage selection alone is worth the stop--kielbasa, kabanosy, smoked cuts--it's like a little butcher counter straight from Kraków magically teleported to paradise. And let's talk pierogies: hand-crafted, pillowy, and filled with everything from potato and cheese to sauerkraut and mushroom. You can stock up frozen to take home or get them hot and ready to devour right there. One bite and you're transported--suddenly, you're not in Key West anymore, you're in a Warsaw kitchen on a winter night. Service here is warm, no-nonsense, and proud of what they're offering. You can tell it's not just about selling food--it's about sharing tradition. Pierogies Polish Market is Key West's secret passport to Poland. A compact, flavor-packed shop where "miniature" means you can taste a whole culture in just a few bites. Come early, bring an appetite, and yes--they absolutely have the meats. read more

Don't expect anything fancy, it's basically a neighborhood corner market that sells a lot of Eastern European meats and foods. You go inside and order from the cash register and then wait out on the front porch at the window for your order. We just had an order of potato and cheese pierogis that came with sour cream, they were delicious. It can be hard to find, and you probably have to park across the street along the curb since there are only two spots in front of the market. They have seating with little table tops to eat at on the porch. read more

Love the food! Fresh, authentic, & delicious... We ate here seven years ago and couldn't wait to travel back to Key West to explore some different pierogi selections. Yum! read more

I was surprised with a gift of birthday pierogies and potato pancakes. The flavors and textures were great. I'm used to a thicker, crunchier potato pancake but this version was scrumptious in its own velvety texture and flavor. The mushroom and saurkraut pierogies were really good read more

See all

This is a little Polish hidden gem in the Key West ! The place is filled with a ton of Polish products ranging from candy to canned meats as well as many beers to choose from! They also serve hot food but after asking for some things they said they didn't have them and only had few things which was very disappointing. Seems like they don't update the menu availability at all you just have to hope for the best that what you're looking for is available the day you go. Their food menu is pretty decent with a lot of different dish which are staples of Polish cuisine. I would definitely come back here again to see what hot food is available and get some Polish groceries. read more

See all

Something like a three or four, this Euro grocery gets. The kitchen was closed up for summer or Covid or whatever but you could pretty much make anything you want from the really cool International foodstuffs on offer. Interesting selections of beers, condiments, chocolates and candies, all sorts of really cool stuffs. We ended up grabbing up some perogies, a few beers, lots of chocolates, and enjoyed our own little Euro Trip party in the crib. Fun fun; it's not all conch chowder, hog fish, and lobster in the Keys. read more

See all

A hole in the wall place with a large select of prepared food and food products. It was a nice find for something different in Key West.

I hate to be the person who leaves a bad review for a place that has a huge menu on their front porch but doesn't serve food, but that's what this is. I walked all the way here from my hotel hoping for some delicious polish food and was excited that the place was open and had a nice menu right out front. We decided what we wanted, walked in ready to order, only to be told that they aren't serving food. Why in the world have a giant menu out front then? I mean this is really irritating. I asked when they would be open again and the lady said she didn't know. read more

What a great find! It's nice to have a Polish grocery shop in town. Sadly, the cafe was closed for the summer. I would really like to try them when they open again. The market offers a fun selection of items. I was going through the aisles and looking at everything. Ended up buying the potato & cheese pierogis and a bunch of chocolates. Yum! read more

See all

Great food and service - authentic polish food in paradise ! This is a must stop every time we're in Key West

Walked a mile just to find out this place only sells FROZEN pierogis. They said they won't be making and selling them until maybe October 2022. Super disappointed. They do have a nicely stocked polish store but that's not why I stopped by. read more

Valerie W. teased me for coming here and said I'm probably the only person who'd seek out and find Polish goodies on a tropical vacation. It's a badge I'm proud to wear. The shit is legit! The shop itself is a bit small, but it's packed with tons of cookies, juices, spices and other favorites from the Eastern Bloc! They have a nice selection of smoked meats and cheeses near the register, too. But the kitchen is what you need to come for! An hour after the shop opens, a small window on the side opens and the kitchen starts churning out some of the best pierogi I've found in the US. I ordered a dozen cheese/potato and a dozen meat. They even have sour cream available there, so I didn't have to stop anywhere before going back to my friends' place and digging in. I know Polish cuisine might be odd in the Keys, but you need to make a stop here! read more

See all

They have wonderful menu with real polish dishes Boczek Myskiwski( hunter bacon ) Combo come with dessert Indoor market has good selection of can goods, sweets, drinks, and sausages. Not your ordinary fare for Key West read more

Pierogi Polish Market - Delis Near Me - Key West, Florida

Good stuff here and surprisingly affordable. Well done Polish Market. Want to try much more.

Pierogis are worth stopping for! First visit and we will be back. Had the potato and cheese pierogis and was please with their size and taste. Was disappointed that they didn't have blintzes today though. read more

Steer clear and head for open water. These people must moonlight at the gates of hell. Being of polish decent I was excited to find this a few blocks from the AirBnB, hoping I could rely on it for lunch. They seemed very surprised to have customers and were out of several items. Although the pierogis did seem to be homemade, everything else was caked in dust and appeared as if it's hay-day had long past. The (possible) owners made the experience as transactional as they could and appeared to want us gone once our pierogis were done. There is a for sale sign in front, and for their sake, I hope it sells. They don't seem happy nor do they want anyone happy. read more

In LOVE with this place. Having a Polish grandmother it is as close to her food as possible. Amazing food ! The stuffed cabbage is incredible! read more

Umm... pierogi. Go for the cheese and potato variety. Grab a cold beer inside, but be forewarned. 3 is all it takes to kill your hunger. For a family of 4, 12 should do it. The place feels like a neighborhood spot from up north, that was ripped and moved down to FL. Don't let the 'funky' locale fool you, they've got the goods. read more

Dropped in to grab some pierogies for lunch, as I read this place was a hidden gem. I got the kraut and mushroom. They were super delicious. Enjoyed a nice Polish beer to go with. So glad I stopped by. Definitely recommend if you enjoy homemade pierogies. read more

Pierogi Polish Market - Delis Near Me - Key West, Florida

Y U M!! This place is such a gem in Key West. It's run by a Polish family and it's not much bigger than your average bedroom size, but it's chock full of authentic sweets, sausages, pierogis, and canned goods. We grabbed a few packages of the homemade frozen pierogis and cooked them up at home. You don't know what you're missing if you're eating pierogis from your local chain grocery store. Now I'm back home in Buffalo, NY and craving these like nobody's business. What have I done to myself?! read more

First, let me state clearly at the start of my review that this review is ONLY for the take-out food window located on the left side of the porch (to the left of the store's door), and which is open for only considerably shorter hours than the market/store itself. The porch covers the ordering window, and also provides some makeshift stools that allow sitting at nearrow shelves built on the porch railing. I ordered a number of take out items from this place repeatedly across a recent 8-day stay in Key West at a nearby hotel. The menu for the take-out window is quite extensive, and offers quite a few foods from Eastern European countries. The quality of the food is quite good. However, in general, and largely due to the incredibly tiny kitchen space, it takes the staff quite a bit of time to prepare any one food item once it has been ordered, although most of the order window staffers make an effort to provide very accurate estimates regarding how long it will take to prepare the foods that were ordered; wait times of 10, 15, 20 and 25 minutes are not at all unusual, even at times when you are the only customer, and on days when they are crowded, well, wait times can be quite extraordinary! I stayed in Key West and visited this place during the off-season, aka the low season, in August of 2014, and during my 8-day stay in the area, the posted hours (on a large sign mounted on the porch near the take-out window) were stated as 11 AM through at least 7 PM pretty much every day, and these were also the hours that the staffers would recite if asked. The reality was far different, however, perhaps simply because it was the low season for Key West, and in reality, I NEVER found the take-out window open even by 11:30 or 11:40 AM on most days of my stay, and sometimes it was not open even at 12:30 PM or 1 PM. On several of the many days when the take-out window was still not open by about 45 minutes after the posted opening times, I would go inside the little store/market and ask the person at the counter if and when the take-out window was going to actually open. And, each time I did this, the check-out counter person acted a bit surprised, and a bit embarrassed, likely over the fact that the kitchen was not yet open, and then they would invariably grab a nearby cell phone and call someone and jabber in some kind of Eastern European language for about 30 seconds, after which they would put the phone down and tell me that if I were to come back in an hour, I would find the take-out window open, albeit quite belatedly! And yes, when I returned an hour or two later, I always did find the take-out window open! Most of the staff who work at the take-out window are quite helpful and pleasant. There is one exception, an older man who seems to not only have a very hard time understanding even the simplest English-language statements, but also seems to have very poor short-term memory retention, and some other major cognitive difficulties as well. The shop and take-out kitchen would really be doing themselves a major favor by keeping this older man away from any customer interactions at the take-out ordering window, but I suspect that he is part of the family that owns the place, and thus it may be very hard for them to actually put this rule of thumb into practice! read more

Walked by on vacation my wife and I noticed this oddity. A polish market...in key west?! Being of polish descent I had to stop in for a taste. So glad we did. The pierogies were delicious...tasted as if my grandmother made it. So good! read more

Pierogi Polish Market - Delis Near Me - Key West, Florida

Best Polish Sausage in South Florida, if not all of Florida. The Polish food here is great as well as the Pierogi's. I wish there was a place like this in Miami, so I would not have to drive down to Key West to get great Polish Food. If in Key West and you like Eastern European food, this is the place to go. read more

Best Polish and Hungarian food I have had since Grandma cooked when I was younger. Close to the beach in Key West I wish it was bigger and had in door seating but food was . I had a beef stick this time excellent read more

We didn't see anything that we liked on the menu and we love pierogi. Language difficulties and indifference in employees attitude made us leave without food. Kinda sad because when you want a pierogi, you really want one. read more

They have so really good cold cuts, even some caviar and many Eastern European delicacies. We had the Polish plate special. The stuffed cabbage and the hunter stew were ok. Nothing to make you go back for that in particular, those get two stars. Otherwise, GREAT Polish deli, cheap beer and nice people. read more

Pierogi Polish Market - Delis Near Me - Key West, Florida

The potato and cheese and meat pierogies were so delicious! I tried the kraut and mushroom and thought they were just okay, they had a strong flavor I hadn't anticipated. They were all soft and moist, and covered with little pieces of onions sautéed in some sort of fat that was absolutely delicious. It's a nice change if you get tired of Cuban and seafood! read more

Great legit Polish food. Got the spinach pierogi, meat and cheese pierogi, kraut and meat pierogi, and blueberry pierogi (6 each, shared amongst a group). All were delicious, served boiled with sautéed onions on top and a healthy sized scoop of sour cream on the side. Accepts all major credit cards except American Express. Great place for authentic food and something different than your typical island fare. read more

See all

Some friends and I were excited to have some delicious pierogis (I had talked the place up as I have been here before and had some delicious food). We showed up at around 5:30 pm and were told that the café was already closed even though their menu as well as yelp say the hours are until 7:00 pm during the week. If you are going to change your hours, then make it know. read more

The sales people were not friendly or responsive. There was one guy in front of me, and the sales guy kept talking to him even after the check-out. I understand that the Keys is a chill lifestyle place, but you have a paying customer waiting for you to stop yapping at the workplace. Maybe, I should have eaten all the ice-cream there and left. To say the least, there is a total lack of politeness. They look careless or even angry, and aren't accustomed to a civilized form of basic greeting, and appreciating the customers despite the very little traffic at the store. I felt more as I had bothered them than giving them business. Suggestion: Acknowledge your customers with a simple "Hello", and a "Thank you". It matters. read more

I was really excited to find this place. I took a walk here while my laundry was drying at the Marina. I tried the pierogi's from the cafe window. They were served the way by grandfather liked them, with sauted onions and sour cream. They weren't as good as I would have hoped for. I also had a Dadu ice cream. The market though is great. Full of Polish and other Eastern European goods. Pierogies and sausage. Cheese, butter, chocolate, cooking mixes. I wish I had brought a bag to pick up groceries in. If I am in Key West again I'll definitely stop by here again. I'll skip the cafe window, but do some grocery shopping. read more

Did not expect to find the best pierogis in the world in Key West Florida, but we did. Never go to the Keys without stopping here for dozen + read more

Amazing Pierogi! (Pierogi is the plural folks, stop adding an "s" at the end) We always order from here when we visit Key West. I'm Polish and very particular about my Pierogi, Mrs T's are never an acceptable option. Lol. We always get a few dozen of the potato and cheese and a mixed dozen of the mushroom and sauerkraut and the meat. They aren't the quickest, so it's always good to order ahead of time and pick up. They also aren't very friendly but since it's take out it's only a mild annoyance. read more

This is the real deal! Loved loved loved the stuffed cabbage rolls! Pierogis are off the hook! Definitely coming back here again!

Stopped by to grab some pierogi and was very impressed. You get 6 for $5.49 or mix them for $5.99. We order a couple different ones and they were delicious. They also have a Polish Grocery store attached for fun candies and spices and such. read more

Stumbled across this place while walking to find some Cuban food. It had been a long while since I had true perogies. My impulse visit didn't let me down at all; after fumbling thru broken polish-english, the owner talked me into the 6 pack for starters. Great snack for the pedestrian life of Key West! Oh and yes my sweet tooth bought all kinds of polish chocolate cookies inside their grocery store. read more

I'm Polish. This place is authentic! Just like my grandmother and mother used to make. Delicious stuffed cabbage, picked beets, mashed potatoes, potato and cheese and sauerkraut and mushroom pierogi. Super delicious! Great prices! Would have loved to try the kielbasa! Next time! Get yourself a carry-out and enjoy authentic Polish cuisine! read more

We were excited to try this place upon reading reviews. My fiancé's family is Polish and we love a good pierogi. This place is authentic, no doubt about it. We got the potato and cheese pierogi and a side order of golabki (comes with 2 golabkis) and beet salad, which was basically pickled beets. The pierogis were good, but nothing special. It had a good amount of filling, say compared to the frozen pierogis you get at the supermarket. The beet salad was also good, but again, nothing special. Golabkis were not good at all. They had a tomato sauce on top, which I think ruined it. Tasted like it came out of a can. Good, not great. And of course, not like how his babci used to make them. But everyone has different variations on the recipe. However, we would like to come back to try more things on the menu. "The smell coming out of the kitchen reminded me of babci's apartment." So we will come back when we visit Key West and update the review upon trying more Polish goodies. read more