GRILLED MAHI MAHI AND SHRIMP SCAMPI WITH ANGEL HAIR 9/10. Jam packed, but they seated my group of 2 withing 20 mins. Wonderful lighting and the waiters are so nice. Love all the fish on the wall as well. read more

Great service Amazing king crab legs Party of 7 seated and fed timely Drinks apps and dinners done perfectly read more

This is my go-to seafood spot in Fort Myers. Every time I'm here I come with family to have an amazing seafood dinner. Always seated quickly, the table has brown paper on it (which, BONUS!!! If you like to doodle is very fun). The staff are very attentive and you can't beat the view. On the water, pelicans outside and the sun shining. I ordered the blackened mahi mahi and the blackened grouper with fresh cut fries and rice pilaf. The fish were both seasoned and cooked to perfection. The fries had some amazing seasoning on it, I legit could not get enough. If you like seafood, this is the place!!! read more

Pinchers - Blackened grouper with French fries and rice pilaf - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers Beach, Florida

They have really good food. Love the blue crabs and oysters. Friendly staff. Eat in or take out

Table of 6, food was 2nd to none! Service was spot on! Ambiance was very welcoming! The Phelan Family knows how to do customer service and sea food! BRAVO!! Our Server Nikki was outstanding! BRAVO! We will be customers forever! read more

Pinchers - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers Beach, Florida

Food here is good. Service was fast and friendly. We came for lunch. It was very nice and quiet. I can see how it would get louder in the evenings-with 2 for 1 drinks. There's even a bucket drink for $19. We had conch fitters and gator bites for apps. We got two grouper sandwiches and the kids ate free (cheeseburger and popcorn shrimp). The entire meal was $100. The almost exact same meal was $193 at another restaurant on Sanibel Island, and Pinchers's food was much better. I'd recommend this place for sure and we'd definitely come back for more fresh seafood. It was delicious and affordable! read more

See all

The hostess was really nice and attentive, we were sat pretty quick. Our server, Carla, was very nice and attentive. She asked us multiple times if we were okay, how was our food, and gave us refills without asking. Unfortunately our food was very very bad. The conch fritters and the clam chowder and the side of baked beans were the only thing that were good. The burger was super salty, had our party try it as well and yes they also thought the burger was salty. The fries were brought out cold as hell as well. My dad is a big fish guy and he said it was the saddest fish he has eaten. It was salty, super tiny and just wanna not good at all. I got the fried fish and chips with the green beans. The green beans and the fries were good but the fish was hmm more batter than actual fish. Yes we got two big pieces but really wasn't much flavor. I'm really sad that I had to give this place a low rating, we used to come here years ago but it's just not the same anymore. read more

See all

We went in for a light lunch and weren't disappointed. The waitress was cheerful, helpful and patient as we went thru the menu. We decided on the crab cake which was awesome. Full of delicious crab. The filler seemed non existent. Then we had stone crab with a mustard which didn't disappoint. Then we topped it off with shrimp cocktail. The shrimp was of good size cooked perfectly. They had wonderful flavor. We'll be back to try more seafood. We were so excited that I didn't get a chance to take photos. read more

We had a big group of eight people, or four couples if you prefer your math. It was a rainy late afternoon, and we didn't need reservations. I haven't been to a Pincers in ages. I have no idea why I have not gone. But this Pincers really hit the mark. They had fresh fish, crab legs, oysters, and grouper dip. The grouper dip had a nice kick to it that really set it apart from the rest of the fish dips I have eaten. Mrs. K. had their fish sandwich "TONY'S BIG FISH SANDWICH." This sandwich would feed two people with ease. I had the fish and chips: darn good fish and copious amounts of chips. read more

Large menu. Great appetizers, crab dip was recommended & did not disappoint! Crab legs, crab cake & haddock all good. Great drink special too! read more

Pinchers - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers Beach, Florida

Highly recommend stopping here if you're in the area! My husband and I aren't locals so we randomly spotted this place on our drive and went with it. We were very satisfied with everything! The crab and cheese dip was delicious. We also had speedy and friendly service. Plus, the hostess sat us right by the window which had a lovely view! read more

See all

Pinchers was a hit-went twice in one week! TBH, going in I thought it was going to be a run of the mill tourist spot and I was wrong. Fish was so fresh and delicious! Stone crab claws were great, too. Key lime pie was great and one of the few places in the area that have the graham cracker crust-do many places put nuts in the crust now and we have nut allergies I our big family so we enjoyed it. It was a nice thick texture as well! Friendly service and a family casual atmosphere. Easy parking. read more

Food is always good here! A FL institution (small chain). Stone crab claws were awesome. Always friendly service, family friendly fun place go! Funky vibe with the decorations...beachy like you'd want at the beach!!! read more

Absolutely loved the food here! Came with my wife and just under 2 year old son and the service was great as well as a neat atmosphere right on the water. A little pricey but standard for the area. Shrimp Alfredo was delicious! read more

Great place, many options! Wait staff very helpful.. Coconut shrimp was very good and also the Grouper! read more

We really enjoyed this place. The wait was a little long but we would definitely go back. The food was really good! Kids eat free when you buy an entrée!!!! read more

Really cool restaurant with signs and fish all over the walls. Our waiter was Steve, he was friendly and attentive. Margaritas were good. Calamari needed salt but other than that nice and crispy. I didn't like the seasoning on the shrimp and the lump crab cake was quite small. Lump crab Alfredo was pretty good just needed some salt and pepper. Wish I would've gotten that instead of the shrimp and crab cake. But overall not bad, would go somewhere else considering price I feel you could get better in Fort Meyers. read more

See all

This location is now a part of every beach day in the near future! The ambience and food is outstanding, and our server Megan is a rockstar. Will be back very soon read more

We really enjoy Pinchers. The food is delicious with a wode selection of items in the menu. Staff is very friendly and efficient.

A very large local seafood restaurant right off the edge of the marina. Beautiful view no matter where you sit, especially in the daytime! Service was quick and friendly The conch fritters were fresh and the sauce made it even more delicious. The fish and chips is a great deal for the price, you get so much grouper and 2 sides of your choosing. I got the soft shell crab dinner, which honestly was way too salty - I wish I had gone for the fish and chips dish that my parents ordered. There is a little sticker that advertises the restaurant's fresh greens - they're actually very fresh, plump and seasoned with a lot of garlic. One tip I wish we knew before coming was the amount of fries we received on each of our dishes - there was way too much for any of us to finish. I wish only one of us had gotten a side of fries, which would then free up getting to try the other sides available on the menu. read more

See all

Stopped in after an amazing day at Fort Meyers Beach. Sat at the bar and ate. They bring you a big piece of paper to put under your food. Cool idea. The young lady working the bar was great. They had 2 for 1 drinks, kids eats free and Happy hour food specials. I got the steamed oysters and the fish dinner. Both were really good. They make in house cut fries and they give you a ton of them. I like my fries a little cruncher than these came out, but they weren't terrible. Their coke slaw is fantastic! Creamy and a little sweet. My wife got the coconut shrimp and she got so many big shrimp that she couldn't finish them. I'm not sure if they were frozen or fresh, my wife thought frozen. Over all we loved our experience here. Good food, great atmosphere and friendly staff. Thanks for a great experience. A couple of the pictures I stole and cropped but the majority of the pics are mine. read more

See all

Very basic small portions at premium prices. Service was less than average. Two for one drink special was a scam. They charge double and try to pass it off as a special! read more

Set at the bar the worst service I've ever had in my life with each other. King crab legs, each a pound food was fantastic unfortunately the worst. I don't go out to spend a tab of $150 to be ignored and then after I even clean my own spot off they asked me how everything was. I saw normally I would've had a bottle of wine, but I just terrible absolute terrible. read more

Four of us went to eat this evening, first time at this location. They had a hog fish special. I was excited until it came out. $32 for two very thin and small pieces of fish. Definitely not Hog Fish. Hog Fish is my favorite fish. I sent it back after talking to the waiter. He said that many people think that hog fish tastes like red snapper so maybe I was confused. He agreed to take it back and exchange it for Grouper. It was much better than the first fish they tried to pass off as Hog Fish. Still, one piece of Grouper for $30. Too much $$. There are too many good seafood options for me to play these games. The Pinchers in Bonita Springs has always been good. read more

Pinchers - What they claimed to be Hog Fish - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers Beach, Florida

I stopped by here a couple of Wednesdays ago with my family for lunch. We had driven by Pinchers a number of times throughout our vacation but what really drew us in was the fact that kids eat free. The inside of Pinchers is actually quite nice with vaulted ceilings and many different types of fish up in the rafters. Those fish are labeled too and so you can see what you are eating or what you can catch in Florida. We ended up being seated near a window with a view overlooking Pelican Bay. For lunch on this day I decided to go with a blackened gulf grouper sandwich and then chose the fresh cut French fries and rice as my sides. My wife had the shrimp tacos while my twins shared popcorn shrimp and butter noodle meals both with fruit cups. First off my twins loved the fruit cups with their lunch and dug into the popcorn shrimp and buttered noodles as well. The noodles portion itself was pretty massive and so it worked for both lunch and dinner for us. Then my sandwich was decent as I liked the blackened spices on it. It was a bit fishy though (my father in law thought the same about his grouper tacos). My fresh cut fries were definitely the star of my meal as they had a sweet and salty seasoning on them and were cooked nicely. The bottom line for me is that I would likely stop back here again in the future. While I wasn't a fan of the taste of my fish, the rest of our food was good and our kids eating free was a bonus too. read more

See all

Pinchers is a fun restaurant. The food is not the best in town but it is good and reasonably priced. I had the Happy Hour 2 for 1 sangria and split it as suggested by our server. For appetizers,!we had calamari and bang bang shrimp. I also had the crab and corn soup which was highly recommended by a Yelp review. I could not tell there was crab in the soup at all. For my main course, I had snow crab which never disappoints. Our server was excellent which made it a pleasant experience. read more

See all

We stopped here on the way back from the beach because of the all-day happy hour. We had never been to Pinchers before so we were inquiring about the two for one and my husband asked about what well vodka they used. After being told he ordered a cranberry with the well vodka and I had a whiskey sour. After we finished our first, I asked about our 2nd one since it was two for one and the bartender stated those were not included in happy hour. She pointed out mine was ordered from inside the drink menu and not on the front cover so it didn't count. She really couldn't explain why my husbands didn't qualify since it was their well vodka and cranberry. I told her that would have been nice to know when we ordered since we directly inquired about the happy hour menu. Overall, outside of the cool looking interior with signs and a beachy theme, we were disappointed in the lack of communication. read more

These other good reviews have got to be friends, we are local and went there today to eat, my wife used to love the crab dip it is now "queso" so much cheese in it when it gets cool it goes hard "absolutely horrible", I had the clam chowder they need to rename it potato soup because its potato and milk, the beer 2 for one, what a joke $9 for a draft Michelob ultra, I will say the bar tender "as we sat at the bar" was very pleasant, we went there to eat a meal but after 2 crappie starters we decided not to chance it, the owner needs to go to SOB and check out their food, I don't know if they got a new chief or what but it will be a cold day in hell before we go back there. read more

Cold food, expensive and the whole place needs a windex wipe down. The restaurant was freezing and the bartender was not friendly at all. The whole restaurant was dirty. From Sticky menus to a dirty bar! I would not recommend. The manager stopped by and offered me a free dessert on our next visit, however based on the crappy food there won't be a "next visit" read more

Talk about ambiance. On the water, decorated to the hill. Very well planned and roomy. Love this place. It's a touristy destination but does have a Florida homegrown feel to it. Now the food.... The crab and corn chowder is to die for. Flavor bursting with each bite but not over salted, it's seasoned to perfection in my opinion. Oh the mussels in Marinara is so so good, healthy portion and see me here a lot while working in Ft. Myers área. Remember to support your local grubbers so we both don't starve... By the way, the bartender is the mojo. Attentive, proud of the food and just a well rounded good soul. I was too embarrassed to ask his name after he told me earlier. Wait! His name is Ryan... read more

See all

I was in town for a work trip and restaurants by the water not back up since hurricane. This place was close to the beach (about a mile out). Sat quickly and told about the BOGO beer so ordered some blue moon. Pretty large place and super clean. Checked out the menu and decided on the small plate of crab w their spices. It was amazing. I was afraid the crab wouldn't be enough if i got small and it was perfect. The green beans as a side were soo good. Service was good - especially loved when the food came and the server said "looks like you are the one w the crabs" read more

Pinchers - Inside - Seafood Near Me - Fort Myers Beach, Florida

Good service and great food with a nice atmosphere. Even though they were extremely busy on our last visit, it did not affect the quality of service that we received. read more

Our server was wonderful. We had Alaska king crab legs they were simply excellent.. We were seated in a window overlooking the water. Definitely coming back again . read more

Wow!! My husband had the snow crab and I had coconut shrimp. Both were amazing! It came with fries and Cole slaw and both were also outstanding. Fresh cut fries that were super crispy!! Portions were huge. I got "lil less" and still couldn't finish it. Drinks were 2 for 1 also. Very good deal! David, our server, was helpful and attentive! read more

The staff was great the cold slaw green beans Caesar salad was also very good. The blackened mahi mahi was delicious but it was an extremely small portion. The fish and chip (fish) was the worst we ever had. The fish inside the coating was as thin as paper and the coating was tasteless. Maybe being from the northeast we expected better. read more

Ok the kids eat free gets us in every time wile in FMB even though bill is almost the same as places that don't have that offer. The server was top notch 10 out of 10. He kept the drinks full and another glass on standby so we didn't need to ask for refills. This is our second time here eating with 6+ people and the only thing that almost everyone in our group had to say both times is if the Famous Fish had seasoning from the kitchen! You need to have hot sauce and salt & pepper to get some flavor happening. 1. The corn crab chowder is the 2. Fries are great! 4. Fried fish needs some seasonings options from the kitchen. (I will ask next time to see if they have any options for that) Inside is your typical seafood restaurant style with a picnic feel paper towel rolls and most of the spices and sauces in the middle of the table. read more

See all

We will never visit this location again. I called to join the waitlist and was told 15-20 minutes. We get there after our excursion at Salty Sam's and I'm told it's a 20 minutes wait. What's the point of the waitlist then. We he hostess was completely rude and when I asked to speak with the manager, he was equally as rude. So we took our party of 11 elsewhere. read more

Went here for dinner with my girls. Easy place to stop if your leaving Ft Myers Beach. Very big inside. Food and service were good. Lots of parking. We went early (4:30pm) so it wasn't crowded. The only thing I would complain about was their selection of crabs. Very limited. Strange for a place called "Pinchers". read more

See all

Location is beautiful and restaurant décor is fun and kitschy. We came in for a late dinner midweek after arriving at our beach Air BnB. Service when we walked in was meh (we almost thought we had arrived right at closing with the looks we received from host and our waitress). There was only 1 other party in the whole restaurant and we were places RIGHT behind them (chairs hitting back to back when sitting down!).. alas we requested to be moved over 1 table (followed by huffs and puffs from host). Note. Several other families and parties walked in after we sat down, so No we were not the last ones there before closing. We ordered crab, blackened fish as well as fish n chips. Food can be described as mediocre at best . We were all left quite unimpressed with the entire experience. read more

Food was awesome. Always top notch, never had a bad meal here, ever. Come in hungry!!!