Pink Pony makes really fantastic soft serve ice cream! They are located in an itty bitty store around the corner from a strip mall on Menaul Blvd. There's a small row of stools at the window and a few chairs, but it can get tight in there if there's lots of customers! Service was great! The gals behind the counter were working so hard and turning out ice cream sundaes quickly! The space is super welcoming. The banana pudding sundae was delicious! The toppings are generous and beautifully presented, and the ice cream is super creamy. There's plenty of parking in the strip mall or street parking outside. read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Banana Pudding Sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

It's delicious. Friendly. Never dissapoints. Good classic options and fun, new options.

Pink Pony Soft Serve is an absolute gem. The banana pudding sundae and the Dolly were insanely creamy and packed with flavor. The server (honestly an artist) was so kind, and the Dolly Parton theme adds such a fun touch. Cozy indoor seating; small but cute, and they even sell Lactaid. read more

See all

Let's just be honest here haha ... we went twice in one week! This was our first time trying pink Pony and went back three days later! The first time I got a sundae "Mah Favorite" the swirl soft serve with Carmel, bananas and a delicious cherry WOW! Wife got a chocolate ice cream with pistachio, dusting, and sea salt with a vanilla toasted marshmallow. Second visit wife got the same thing and I got a vanilla cone dipped in cherry now that was 100% phenomenal! Can't wait to go back oh and to go we got strawberry marshmallow which a put in my morning match and what a wonderful pairing ! read more

See all

The ice cream is unbelievable. The flavor choices are wow-I had the Italiano and my husband had the Dubai. Just go you will not regret it. The server was lovely, efficient and friendly. Not a complaint but wish the shop was a little bigger as it can get tight. Still, we'll be back!! read more

Mediocre ice cream and soft serve. Save your money, not worth it. If you make an error in the tip amount (accidentally type $20 instead of $2) - even before submitting it - you can NOT correct it! This place is a complete rip off and the service is poor. read more

I've been here a couple of times and I really like it. The soft serve is high quality and the selection of toppings is varied and enticing. On my most recent visit I overheard them accommodating a customer's allergy and also noticed they had individually wrapped lactaid pills for sale, so they're definitely doing their part to make sure anyone who wants to enjoy their wares is able to! The only thing I could honestly complain about is that it's a small space and a bit cramped when it's crowded, but that's not something that I would base a rating on. read more

See all

An amazing Albuquerque gem!! Come support a small local business that really does soft serve ice cream well. Our favorites are the classic twist in a cup with a toasted marshmallow, or the Cherry dipped cone! This cute little building is always full of folks stopping by for a treat, and I love to see it! read more

Let me start by saying it is tradition for my boyfriend and I to come once a week- Pink Pony is a fabulous ice cream establishment that is always keeping things new and exciting with rotating sundaes & special treats. The shop is super cute, clean and bright. The owner & one employee are extremely sweet and helpful- even with a full shop they always have your ice cream in hand quickly and ever so kindly. I can't speak enough on what a wonderful place pink pony is! I am extremely partial to the banana pudding sundae- but you can't go wrong exploring the menu. Their topping list is extensive and will definitely be back to try a new flavor combination after the first visit. They are like my personal heroin and I can't stop and won't stop going- what can I say, I love a soft serve with a hard shell. I love ya'll thank you for feeding my addiction. read more

See all

We tried a variety of their soft serve from the very simple vanilla to a Dubai chocolate version. While tasty, I felt it was like any other soft serve and a little overpriced for the amount we got. We'd go again for a special occasion but not frequently. read more

Super hot day.. why not enjoy some soft serve..... 2 sweet girls working here helping people on this hot day. They were both delicious. I loved the toasted homemade marshmallow. My daughter said the brownie... some were hard and some were chewy which was weird she said. read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Brownie sundae and smores sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

Such a cute and hip ice cream parlor. It's nestled in between business but has on-street parking. They make homemade marshmallows for sell on a variety of flavors and have such fun flavors or ice cream. Everyone seemed to be trying the Dubai ice cream but I went for the classic Dolly ice cream. It was delicious! This place gets busy, which is great, so don't mind the line because the staff is friendly and makes your order fast and with love. read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - The Dolly! Vanilla ice cream with strawberry topping and crushed Graham crackers. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

Albuquerque has been a desert for delicious local ice cream shops, and I know I'm late to the game on pink pony! I was so happy to find this place when I moved back to NM. Delicious creamy ice cream and INCREDIBLE toppers, the homemade marshmallows are amazing and I love the variety they have on their menu. Service was great, woman working the counter was kind and knowledgeable and helped everyone in the shop in a timely manner. It was busy for a Wednesday night 30 minutes before close, and she handled the volume like a champ! The shop is small, which isn't an issue once we hit spring and you can enjoy your cone outside the shop! We will 100% be back!! read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Vanilla soft serve with Pistachio Dust - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

See all

This is a wonderful soft serve shop in Albuquerque! It's so cute and just right! I got the Dubai chocolate sundae and it was delightful! read more

See all

First time here and we will be back. Pink Pony is a hidden delight on a side street. The ice cream was great - I had the Dubai sundae and my wife had the Italiano. The service was super friendly. It took a lot willpower not to go back and order another sundae but we will definitely be back to work our way through the menu read more

Amazing ice cream concoctions. Our first time here and it was all-around really good! Really good service. There was a line out the door (literally) with only two people working and they handled it with grace and a smile. It's really small with just four stools so Support Local Businesses so they can grow. read more

4.5 stars I had been seeing a lot of chatter about Pink Pony from my boss and in the "ABQ Foodies" group on facebook. My first thought was that it was just simple soft serve, but it was so much more than that. The shop was around the corner from the main shopping center, so it was a little confusing to find at first. There is some seating inside and some benches outside, but as popular as this place was with seeing everyone come in and out, I think that should definitely be the main point of expansion. My mom got a root beer float and I the s'mores sundae (~$7). The marshmallows and toppings are all homemade (and the marshmallows come in several flavors). The sundae itself was a good size and topped with a gooey marshmallow. The brownie sundae also seemed to be a popular one. Love supporting local. 2024 #1 read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

See all

The soft serve is sooo good! I also love the homemade marshmallows and pistachio dust! Not to mention the wonderful staff! Looove

Who wouldn't like a glorious dessert? Pink Pony is such a treat! They offer selection of soft-serve ice cream with a variety of toppings..and I was so mesmerized by so many interesting toppings that they offer. I tried their Italiano Sundae cup (vanilla softsetve with olive oil, sea salt..and roasted hazelnuts)...and i asked if I could add a lil bit of sesame paste too. .and wow...I love such unique combinations of things that I wouldn't even think of trying on my own...but the sundae simply had my taste bud exploded that I wonder if I could try to imitate some of the toppings for my ice cream consumption at home even! I love this shop. Such interesting combo of things to explore..and even if you are a lil plain type of person .they still have your regular/more common toppings for you to try, too. I will definitely stop by this local dessert gem again for sure! P.S. this shop is located at the same spot as Tonari no Mise shop that closed down a year ago. I asked the staff at Pony Pink if they were somehow related..but the answer was..no..I think that Japanese family relocated to New Zealand (!) post COVID era already. That said, Pink Pony is still just as wonderful as the previous ice cream shop...and is definitely many steps above your regular dessert places in ABQ. read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Italiano sundae cup ($7)--i asked to add sesame paste to my cup, too! Yummy! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

See all

Such a fun and unique ice cream joint! So much variety and the owner was very nice and helped us pick out a yummy combo because we had never been before! The roasted marshmallow topper is to die for. Can't wait to go back. read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

See all

Wow is all I can say to this place. Great local spot. My Dubai chocolate sundae was everything I wanted, needed, and more! There are just so many options I could hardly choose and am dying to go back to try other flavors! Such a cute and welcoming spot with really friendly staff. Highly recommend stopping by for a sweet treat on a hot day this Summer!! read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Dubai chocolate sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

I couldn't walk by an icecream shop named the pink pony. it was good. i got the chocolate soft serve in a little cake cone dipped in cherry. $7 seemed a little pricey but i guess that's how things are these days. their menu is limited but looks delicious. i'll be back to try the italian ice. read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

This place is so cute and cozy! Their toasted marshmallows are BOMB! & They have lots of flavors of ice cream, Italian ice and toppings! :) thank you Pink pony read more

I have a problem with wanting to try all thing Japanese/Asian from a non-Asian store especially if the flavors are harder to come by otherwise. Not the black sesame flavor I was hoping for. Reminded me of chia seeds almost instead of kurogoma. A very friendly nice person serving us in a little cute shop. I want to try other flavors :) read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Black sesame shake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

See all

Well I finally came to try it out! Every time I came it was on a Tuesday and they're closed. Well it's Saturday and I was near by. Great selection, homemade marshmallows and they even have cherry dip for a limited time. My ice cream was smooth and creamy with homemade strawberry sauce, it was lovely. They have specials too. It's kind of in an odd spot but it's worth finding and tasting their delightful options. read more

See all

Great ice cream for what it is - just basic soft serve with sprinkles. Nice staff but a tiny bit on the pricey side.

This place is very cute and cozy. The 2 women that was running it the night my family and I went there are very nice and welcoming. You are greeted with a genuine smile. I got an Italian ice which was very good and had pieces of fruit. My boys got ice cream which they said was amazing and the toppings you get are incredible. Must try and must see. read more

Was skeptical about this place because it's soft serve and what can you do with soft serve?! However, this place has changed my mind! Lots of great options and each one we've had has been tasty. Interior is quite small and it can get filled/busy fast. On the side of a small shopping complex so there is never trouble parking. read more

Tiny little shop with legit ice cream and homemade toppings . I tried the Dolly with homemade strawberry sauce.. vanilla wafer crumbs and whipped cream . I bought a HUGE house made raspberry marshmallow . They also sell a toasted marshmallow on a stick .. yummy ohhygooy goodness. I'm thrilled to find a good sweet spot in ABQ read more

One word- delicious! This is what abq needs because the toppings go beyond traditional with homemade toasted marshmallows (to die for and a must try) to Amerena cherries (no sickingly sweet merichino cherries here). We got the the chocolate dip Dee doo sundae and it was fantastic. Can't wait to try another sundae next time but with the marshmallow, of course. read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Dip Dee doo chocolate sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

Super cute little hidden soft serve shop off of Menaul. I haven't had soft serve in a hot minute and man did it hit the spot! I got twist with chocolate sprinkles and honeycomb. get the honeycomb!! They make it themselves and it's such an underrated ice cream topping! The sundaes are unique and they do weekly specials based on the seasons! It did drip all over my dress, but that's what I get for being a slow eater on a hot afternoon! read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

ABQ doesn't deserve Pink Pony Soft Serve! The menu is simultaneously limited and complex with great flavors and combination possibilities. The place is small in size but large in character. Prices are reasonable, and the service is owner operated friendly. There is plenty of street parking, and two large benches, and a table and chair set, to sit on out front to enjoy your dessert. This place is on Alvarado Dr NE--a side street off of Menual Blvd NE. Take it from this Professor, A+++++++++ all around. read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Front of Pink Pony Soft Serve - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

Pink Pony offers 3 kinds of soft serve. Vanilla, chocolate, and swirl. I think that's important to know when coming here. They do have a wide variety of toppings and if I can recommend something you must try, it's their toasted marshmallow. I had the burnt honey and it was so so good. I will be coming back for the marshmallow alone. read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - The Dolly - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

I love me some soft serve, and Pink Pony hits the spot! I got the swirl option in a cone with sprinkles and a toasted marshmallow, and it was amazing. The waffle cone was fresh and really tasty, and I loved the chocolate coating inside of it. But really the toasted marshmallow was the star of the whole thing. It was thick and gooey, and I would just eat 10 of those if I could. The soft serve did melt pretty quickly though, so when I go back, I'll likely get a cup with it. Definitely will be going back to try the milkshakes too! read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Swirl with sprinkles and marshmallow! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

This place is awesome. We stopped by for the first time today and were surprised by the number of choices available for coffee and ice cream. We had a s'mores sundae and a coffee milkshake. Both were delicious and Unique made to perfection. The s'mores marshmallow was toasted and accompanied delicious chocolate soft serve. The coffee milkshake was creamy and not too sweet. Just right. read more

See all

A new dessert find in ABQ! Ice cream was yummy and there where some choices that you good pick from! From ice cream flavor to toppings to the drizzle on top a variety, but each come with a cost too. I got vanilla ice cream, electric dust and rainbow sprinkles all in a cup! read more

Pink Pony Soft Serve - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Albuquerque, New Mexico

Love this place! Great tasting ice cream. Service is friendly and helpful. Small area to sit inside and one table outside. We've heard the homemade marshmallow are good so we plan on trying them next time. read more

I find this place to be grossly overrated. Their soft serve doesn't taste very good. I think they need a new recipe or machine. Service was slightly rude to me but not to my partner. Location is small but overall nice and cute. I think this is a good place to go if you have young daughters. read more

Husband and I stopped here 40 minutes before close for a pre-dinner dessert, and it was such a great experience. The inside is cozy, but with a bright ambiance. So many choices for toppings and ice cream vessels. And the person at the counter was super gracious with their patience for our decisions as first timers. Friendly service. We will definitely be returning! read more

See all

So good!! Friendly staff every time One of the best ice cream in my opinion! What really makes it is the toppings the roasted marshmallow. I always ask for another one because it's so good and the chocolate top with the graham cracker sprinkle is so good!! read more