The establishment is bustling taking and making orders. Patrons can eat in or take out, enough tables and stools. The crew is polite and friendly; you can tell they enjoy working together. Tom made my ham and onion pizza. (I enjoy Tom's customer service as he greets people by name and will ask how they are doing) My pizza was perfectly crispy and flavorful. Plenty of onions and ham in every bite. I recommend Pizza 1 & Subs 2 for lunch or dinner. read more

Pizza 1 & Subs 2 - Ham and onion pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marstons Mills, Massachusetts

This used to be my favorite pizza. It seems like it is more oily now. Or maybe because our delivery was delayed by a large order to a school (No complaints) it wasn't as tasty. read more

Bruce and his team are just awesome! Their steak and cheese sub is one of the best I've ever had, and their chef's salad (yes, very different ends of the spectrum ;) is fresh, crispy, huge and delicious. They are quick with deliveries and whenever I go in to pick up my food, they make you feel like family when you walk in the door. I now live on the West Coast, and miss going in there a few times a week like I did when I was back living on the Cape. Without fail, the first place I go to anytime I am back there is Pizza1. I can't say enough good things about this locally owned, family business, and am so thankful that they are here for all of us! Thank you, Pizza 1 Subs 2 for consistently being awesome!! read more

Love this place but over the past few years the quality has changed drastically. The pizzas are no longer edible , the amount of grease that comes with the pizza is insane . Hope things change read more

Sunday night after 7pm and Regina's is closed... what to do? We remembered seeing this place and decided to give it a try. It seemed busy for a Sunday night, but that might have been the combined traffic of the fish place next door. We ordered 2 large cheese, 1 pepperoni, chicken fingers and fries. Prices seemed about average, it was a 30 minute wait. Chicken fingers were decent, the portion was good. French fries were surprisingly good. The pizza was not at all my kind of pizza. They were small, extremely greasy and something was off with the dough. It didn't seem like the rising/proofing process was successful. It was flat. It tasted fine and if that's your only option, what can you do? Overall, we'll stick with Regina's at the mall. read more

So so wrap, nothing special. I was in the area and needed something quick between meetings and decided to try it out only because their is nothing else within 15 minutes. It had a couple large chunks of chicken in it that were kind of plain, other parts had a lot of dressing. Overall a little below average. Decent food, but not for a foodie. read more

Pizza 1 & Subs 2 - Chicken Caesar on wheat wrap - Pizza Near Me - Marstons Mills, Massachusetts

Been visiting here for years! Recently I've developed a dairy allergy, and when I say they were accommodating, that is an understatement! Friday night and they had no problem really looking into this for me! working in the industry for a decade I know allergies can be a pain, especially when busy, but I truly appreciate the lengths they went so I felt comfortable eating out! EAT LOCAL! read more

This review is for the steak and cheese sub. It is fire, it's the only place on cape that I will get one now. It's a must anytime I'm nearby. Great food and Great staff read more

We have been going to this place for well over 10+ years. Been noticing this place starting to slide in terms or quality and quantity for a while now. Got a steak tip Caesar salad. 6 smallish tips and a really small salad. Total cost 17 and change. I get that there is inflation, but this was a bit of a rip off. At least the pita was fresh. read more

Pizza 1 & Subs 2 - 17 dollar steak tip salad next to a bagel for scale. - Pizza Near Me - Marstons Mills, Massachusetts

Love this place! Great, friendly service, great food (big yummy subs and non-greasy pizzas with plentiful quality toppings - Thoughtful allergen-controls. Definitely will be back! Only thing we hated was the name. We just don't like it and they have two different locations with the exact same name! They have a Falmouth location and a Marston Mills location. The Marston Mills location is on Falmouth (Rd) so when we ordered and asked if they were the Falmouth location... (You can see where out-of-towners are going to be messed-up lol) So now I get to leave reviews for both locations :) read more

I have been a customer for over 25 years. This used to be such a great place to get pizza and subs, not anymore. The quality of the food they put out now is inconsistent at best. To many kids who don't care. There used to be the same people all the time but the new employees don't have pride in a job well done. I am done as a customer. I asked for my pizza tonight to be lightly cooked on the crust and when I got home it was borderline burnt. Same with the other food on this order. Look for yourself. read more

Pizza 1 & Subs 2 - a piece of bread with cheese on it - Pizza Near Me - Marstons Mills, Massachusetts

See all

I just bought a chicken cutlet sub and a small onion ring,,, I get it home, open up the rings & they're hard and overcooked.. No good to me=trash barrel The sub was the same way, I never asked them to toast it. WAY overtoasted, I wear messed up dentures so I take them out when I can, Thats why I can't eat toasted subs Now I remember why I don't eat there.... Cost me like $15-17 for this lesson. read more

Small pizza place, very outdated decor. With that said VERY YUMMY!! The staff is super nice. It was my first time there and the young girl was patient answering all my questions. My family and I got a cheese pizza, garlic cheese bread (BEST I EVER HAD), chicken fingers and fries. All really good. My husband said he felt sauce on pizza was a little watery, but I didn't mind that, so that is totally preference, but he and I both enjoyed what we ate. Not really good for large groups as tables only fit 4 people comfortably and there are only 4 I believe and then 4 chairs on a bar like area. Good variety of food and I am excited to go there again when I am down the Cape on vacation to try more things. read more

We weren't sure what to expect since the reviews were bad. So we ordered Steak Bombs were very delicious. Another person ordered chicken stir fry wrap which came as a sub. She thought it was delicious. Another ordered Italian which was great as well. The couple we stayed with said they agreed with a review which stated to stick with pizzas and certain subs as they've had mixed results. We thought we'd offer ours as we liked what we got but we also ordered mostly "safe" stuff. Apparently there aren't a lot of options on the cape. read more

Pizza 1 & Subs 2 - Steak Bomb. 2 of us think it's pretty darn good! Wasn't sure with the reviews but was delicious. - Pizza Near Me - Marstons Mills, Massachusetts

I ordered chicken fingers, fries, Italian sub, and a steak and cheese. Everything was good. Except the steak and cheese. I personally won't order one again. The meat was so chopped, it resembled dog food. The texture was awful. Complete mush. My suggestion don't order it. Yuck! But the other things were fine. Nothing amazing but good. read more

Pizza 1 & Subs 2 - Steak and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Marstons Mills, Massachusetts

See all

This is your typical take-out for pizza, grinders, onion rings etc. Buffalo chicken pizza is good. Onion rings good. Nothing compares to western Mass pizza's...but this is ok. read more

Don't recommend the raw chicken tender wrap! Wasn't able to get a refund. Instead, they gave me credit for a free wrap, but not too enticed to head back anymore... read more

Pizza 1 & Subs 2 - Pizza Near Me - Marstons Mills, Massachusetts

Average quality at Pizza 1 & Subs 2, but impressed by their speed especially on a Friday lunch rush. We ended up ordering a small cheese pizza while traveling through the area and we were give a 15 minute pick-up time. We showed up after about 10 minutes and when we walked in it was coming out of the oven. The staff here was decent, but depending on the day and the time, you will get different experiences. The dude in the phone wasn't the most pleasant, but the cashier was very polite. All in all, no reservations about stopping here in the future. read more

Pizza 1 & Subs 2 - Storefront - Pizza Near Me - Marstons Mills, Massachusetts

See all

Pretty good pizza for the Cape, and the cheesy garlic bread is nice and greasy. If you like greasy, cheesy, crunchy try these items. Stay away from the subs, never eat-in, and expect to get, not rude but very close to it customer service from any one of the 8-10 workers that seem to be in the open kitchen at any time. I really don't know how they employ so many people. I would give more stars for the pizza but the "sub-par" ;) subs and crappy service bring it down to a three. read more

Pizza 1 & Subs 2 - Large Half-Pep. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Marstons Mills, Massachusetts

We love the pizza and grinders. Always consistent. Recently started getting it delivered and the drivers are always punctual with hot food.

One of the few pizza places on the Cape that orders premium ingredients. The pizza is terrific. Old-school. Handcrafted. The subs are terrific. Everything is fresh and well-made. The sides are fresh and terrific. Local. Kids who work there work their butts off. I order from here almost every weekend. read more

Solid sandwich and pizza shop. Freshly made and great service. We had the steak bomb and it was excellent.

This little hole in the wall pizza place seems to be a well guarded secret by locals. It is delicious. I LOVED the large pizza (best pizza cheese I have ever had) with pepperoni and black olives. BUT last time I had the steak and cheese with some garlic butter on the toasted roll and that was just as fabulous. LOVE LOVE this place but shhhh don't tell too many people about it otherwise there will be huge lines! OH, and they deliver in the freezing cold and rain!!!! read more

Pizza might be good but they sit for an hour before they get delivered and the grease is literally coming through the bottom of the box. Don't take the order if you can't delivery within a reasonable time period. read more

One word... gross. Avoid unless you like to get food poisoning type symptoms, grab some extra soft tp for your poor bum. Had to add more after reading a few reviews. First off get the expression"good for Cape pizza" outta yo mouth. This ain't good pizza for Ethiopia. We are an hour south of Boston, no excuses, either it's good or it sucks no location biases. The guy who wrote there are always like 10 people in there working and how do they employ all these people is so right. Every time there's like 10 or more 17-21 yr old stoners standing around the open kitchen, it's like a hippie commune. I think you could make a case that 7-11 next door had better pizza, seriously. Have Mohammed fire you up one and do a taste test next time. I am actually shocked people actually go here. Must have extra time in their day to spend on the toilet. read more

This place was great, super nice people. Pizza was great and the steak bomb sub was sooo good.

Looking for pizza/subs delivered in the Marstons Mills area? We are long time fans of Pizza 1. Recently, we put them to the test, ordering the same steak bomb sub from Pizza 1 and two other restaurants. Not only was the Pizza 1 sub delivered in 20 minutes, but it was the tastiest of the three. Highly recommended! Update 9/9/2012 Pizza 1 consistently continues to provide excellent service and THE BEST subs in the Marstons Mills area. read more

Delicious subs, grinders, pizzas, salads, and sides. The pizza is gorgeously greasy in a delightfully delicious way. Definitely a guilty pleasure :) Their subs are really excellent, and I've always had 100% accurate orders from them whether in house, for pickup, or for delivery. This is a rarity in my experience growing up on the Cape. The staff are wicked friendly. Lots of bottled soda and drink options as well as chips to choose from. The fries and onion rings have a fried but not overdone taste- really yummy. and their mozzarella sticks are melted in the middle to perfection. Greasy pizza isn't for everyone, but I love it. Friends of mine enjoy the greasiest combo ever- the bacon pizza with extra cheese (: and the booths are comfy, as well as the counter chairs. ADORE THIS PLACE! read more

The menu pretty complete here. A lot of stuff and made the way you ask. Not being from the area I had no idea what to expect. Hot Ham and Cheese was done right. And so was the Meatball Parm sub. The employees are really nice and quite helpful. Since I'm only in town for a week I will try to make it bake. It was that good read more

Pizza 1 & Subs 2 - Pretty good food. Big dam menu - Pizza Near Me - Marstons Mills, Massachusetts

Staff was friendly but it was very disorganized. Ordered 1 large and 1 small pizza for take out and were told it would take 15 minutes. It took them 50 minutes and the pizza was extremely greasy. Taste good but it was hard to eat as the cheese and rest of the toppings would slide off due to how greasy it is. read more

I love everything about this place. Staff is always friendly and welcoming, the dining area is clean, and the food is delicious. My favorite is the chicken cutlet sub. Portions are generous. Order a large sub and either share it with someone else or eat half now and half later. It's also conveniently located off of Rt. 28 and a quick skip away from Rts. 130 & 149. read more

Go for the takeout, don't plan to eat here. I don't think I've ever seen anyone at the tables except for people waiting for their food. The kitchen is open and you can see the million-person staff running around filling orders. I always like that, it's fun to watch! They ring a bell when you tip so make sure to throw something in the jar - you can tell they're working hard! Their pizza is great (not too greasy), chicken Caesar wrap is good, ravioli with garlic bread is surprisingly excellent. We've only ever gotten takeout, not delivery, so I can't vouch for their delivery skills. read more

Spent last weekend on the Cape. Decided Sunday night we wanted to grab pizza for the Pats game found this place and called and asked if the delivered - Nope. Next asked for their address so I could pick it up. Took 5 mins for kid to figure that out. Go get the food, bring it back, it's cold and greasy. Steak and cheese sub was dry and over salted. Pizza stunk. Pass on this place. read more

We order from here frequently and usually everything is ok, not outstanding. Tonight we picked up a large cheese pizza and it was burnt and tasted like cardboard. Called to let them know and they didn't seem to care much. Time to find a new pizza place. read more

Pizza 1 & Subs 2 - Not good - Pizza Near Me - Marstons Mills, Massachusetts

A very tired, dirty pizza joint in a town full of tired pizza joints. Very generic menu without any signature meals. The food is edible, pizza sauce is pretty bland. If you're looking for a quick sub or pizza while on lunch break you can satisfy your appetite pretty easily without hurting your wallet. The staff can be friendly if they have had a good day but they can also talk loudly about any issues they have in their lives. read more

I've gone to this place multiple times over the years and the service gets increasingly worse. (Call me a glutton for punishment but something inside me keeps hoping that maybe it will get better!) We usually order takeout because there's not enough seating in the restaurant to stay and typically you have 10 workers standing around shoving pizzas in boxes and putting them on the oven instead of asking the people who are waiting if they are there so they can give them their orders. Finally somebody takes initiative and asks if the customer is there any turns out that they are! So not only do they have to wait a long time for their order, the pizza is probably cold on top of it! The pizza is not even really that good and definitely not worth the wait. There is another place a mile down the road which is much better and I highly recommend going there instead of wasting your time getting bad service and bad pizza from this restaurant! read more

Greasiest pizza I have ever had. Ordered a slice for lunch and had to sop up the grease/oil before I could eat it. Not good.

Definitely one of the worst sub/pizza places I have ever had food from. The prices are outrageous for the quantity and quality of the food. I just had a small chicken stir fry sub that had a minuscule amount of green pepper, an even smaller amount of onion and absolutely no mushrooms! Ofcourse I am used to getting decent subs in Boston where I used to live, but have very quickly realized that the Cape is in a world of their own, and unfortunately no one here realizes there is a whole world of really, really good food just over That Bridge! read more

I had a really weird experience here. called and placed an order for pickup to get dinner on the way home. i ordered a steak tip salad and they told me it would be ready 15 minutes on the phone. i got to the store about 15 minutes later. i walked in and said i was picking up a steak tip salad and they said it was just about to be ready and told me to just wait a minute. so i sat down and started waiting. over 15 minutes went by and i was still waiting, and the counter girl asked me what i was waiting for. I repeated that i was waiting on the steak salad, and she walked back in the kitchen and then came back and said they had no orders for a steak tip salad. so apparently they never even took my order when i called. but when i walked in and said i was picking up the salad they told me they were making it and to wait. but they actually werent even making it. they told me they were making my salad, then they watched me sit there and wait over 15 minutes, and then told me they actually werent making my food and they didnt even know what i ordered. really bizarre, it sucked because i was starving for dinner on the way home from work on a busy night and i just wasted so much time sitting there. it was just so aggravating i would never go here again. 1.whoever took the order over the phone didnt place the order 2.when i got to the store they told me the wait for my food when they weren't even making it. they said it was almost ready and they weren't even making it 3.they waited over 15 minutes before they even let me know they weren't making my food. and then claimed i never placed an order so weird i dont understand how you treat a customer like that read more

This place has great pizza for the type of place it is... it's in a strip mall next to 7/11 so don't expect some fancy dining experience. If you like a good greasy Greek pizza this place is pretty consistent with their quality! I've really never been disappointed with their pizza or meatball or Italian subs. read more