Service and food were great. We got the food to go. The salad was fresh and especially good. The pizza was liked by all and we ordered way too much as the pizzas are large. We will return. This restaurant also gives a military discount so those from base should definitely try them out. read more

We called Brooklyn Heights for takeout one night -- our first time trying it. The space used to be a Chinese restaurant, and you can still tell from the layout: just a couple of tables, a restroom, and a pretty tight area if there's a crowd waiting. The person who took my phone order was super friendly, confirmed everything clearly, and let me know the total and pickup time. There's plenty of parking since it's located in a small strip mall, which makes pickup easy. The prices were a bit on the higher side, but honestly, the food was worth it. The pizza was excellent -- not too doughy, with a perfect balance of cheese and sauce. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

After seeing the positive reviews, I was really excited to try this place. We ordered a salad and sub, both which were underwhelming. I will say the staff were very friendly, and their pizza looked great. We went on a Friday night and the place was mobbed, which makes me think you should really stick to pizza here. We sat down inside (there are a few tables inside though it's a very small place). The Halloween decorations were a bit over the top but that could just be a personal bias! read more

Brooklyn Heights New York Eatery - Roasted chickpea and avocado salad with grilled chicken - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

See all

Though the food was overall good, I really was not digging the whole ambience of this place. It's mostly a takeout joint that apparently has some really good pizza. My wife ordered an empanada and they're crazy bread. I must say that the crazy bread was tasty. My salad with grilled chicken was OK overall. When we walked in and saw only three booth, we should've just went to the place next-door. I must say, while we were there, there were plenty of people getting pizza to go. read more

See all

I tried Brooklyn Heights for lunch yesterday because I was excited to see some vegan items listed on the menu and wow it was delicious! I got the vegan antipasto salad (chickpeas, tomato, banana peppers, red onions, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, peppers, romaine, basil and herb oil) and the Atlantic Ave vegan bomb sub (LTO, roasted red peppers, mushrooms, cilantro-garlic fries, banana peppers, vegan cheese, pepper-jalapeno and cilantro sauces). The salad was heaped with fresh ingredients, I just wish it came with more dressing (maybe some more vinegar with the herb oil?). The sub was amazing - super messy and difficult to figure out how to eat but loaded with flavor and they certainly didn't skimp on any of the components! I ate most of the garlic herb fries straight off the top and they were some of my favorite fries I've ever tried, the garlic really packs a punch! I definitely recommend eating in if you order the sub because it starts losing structural integrity almost immediately and you don't want to take home a soggy sandwich. The staff were friendly and I really enjoyed my messy meal. The shop is small but they have a couple tables - most of their business seems to be to-go slices and pies. I will definitely be back to try the vegan stromboli! read more

Brooklyn Heights New York Eatery - Atlantic Ave vegan bomb sub - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

See all

Tried this place just tonight, and I'm so glad I did. I got a gyro and a slice of pepperoni pizza, and my teenager got a slice of cheese pizza. The pizza is outstanding. Super thin crust with just the right amount of flop. Good cheese/sauce ratio. The pepperonis were very tasty -- and they did not just put a bunch of pepperonis on a cheese slice like some places do. They reheated the slices, which gave them a little extra crisp. My kid so enjoyed her slice that she ordered a second one. But let's talk about the gyro. It was a Greek-American style gyro, but not your standard sub shop gyro. Thing was huge. Big slabs of delicious meat. The cucumbers, lettuce, tomatoes all super fresh. The tzatziki sauce was ample and the flavor spot on. The fries were hot and very crispy. Easily the best Greek-American style gyro I've had in years. I believe I used most of their paper napkin supply. I should probably go back and apologize for that. The service was great! Everyone was super friendly. The gentleman making the pizzas (the owner?) checked in on us to make sure everything was good, which was appreciated. The space is pretty small, only three booths, but we were able to get one. No Coke or Pepsi: they had mostly craft sodas -- which I generally like. All in all, great food, great experience. So glad we gave them a try: I will definitely be back! read more

Brooklyn Heights New York Eatery - Gyro - outstanding! - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

Best pizza on Cape. No comparison. True NY style pizza. Lots of pizza varieties that might seem "different" but then you taste it and the combo of flavors is awesome. read more

My friends & I got a large order of apps & pizza from here on Sunday night & they absolutely did not disappoint. The establishment was clean & the staff was extremely friendly the moment we walked in. Out of the 5 different specialty pizzas we ordered, we had ZERO complaints. Wish we lived closer so we could return sooner! read more

Brooklyn Heights New York Eatery - Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

Was really excited to try it out. The place looks great (as does the food) on their website. But....once you get there it's quite disappointing. The pizza was above average but no New Yorker would say it lives up to NY standards. I might have felt different if I hadn't been so surprised by what I saw and felt when I walked in vs how the place looks on their site. Night & day difference. Sorry. read more

Great newer location in what I'd call a crowded marketplace. It's now my go to pizza place. Their Gyro is hard not to take down, the best. The online ordering site allows to customize the order. Never understood French fries in a gyro, so that can be dropped. Got hooked on them in the UK where that's not a thing. A big part of the appeal is that the people & owner show their enthusiasm and energy. Always an X factor in a restaurant. Care is taken. It's mainly a take out place. A fan. read more

pretty sold pizza in cape cod.. I'm from NY and this is probably the closest I've gotten to NY style pizza in MA...thin crust, large and foldable read more

Brooklyn Heights New York Eatery - cheese slices - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

Crappy sandwiches. Avoid this pretentious place. It also has pizza, which we did not try. It might be allrighe.

Amazing pizza! Such a nice family. We order there regularly and are always impressed! The best pizza we have found near us, and we get it almost every Friday! Had one bad pie, which I do attribute to someone getting ours, and we got theirs, who had ordered much earlier than us so the pizza was cold. A simple mistake. One call, which I rarely do, and they gave us a credit. I was not looking for one, just wanted to provide feedback. They are amazing. Their food consistent and fantastic!! So nice and friendly! Try them... they will not disappoint!! read more

This was a really good slice of pizza. Counter help was fine, no complaints there. It's a hole in the wall pizza place, a little funky, but clean. They had a lot of halloween decorations up, which I heartily approve of. Mmm....that slice. read more

I've ordered take out twice. Only a few tables inside. Nice big pizza with plenty of flavor. I'll be ordering again real soon.

Great NY style thin crust pizza! Cheesecake from Mia's Bakery (based in Brooklyn, NY) was delicious.

This was my first time ordering food from Brooklyn Heights Eatery and it will be the last. There are few things to regret in life but this decision has made that short list. The Philly Cheesesteak was so salty it was inedible and the quality of ingredients was "not good". There was a stripe of grease that went through the wax paper and the paper bag the sandwich was wrapped in. The cheese pizza was below average. You can get a far better plain cheese pizza at Barnstable Market and pay 18% less. We also got two of their specialty pizzas and they were loaded with cheap tasting ingredients. Just awful. Look, I grew up in Philadelphia. Obviously I know what a good Philly Cheesesteak is and I had access to great NY style pizza which my family and I ate frequently. This was very far from that. Everyone in the group I shared this "not good" food with agreed that the food should go in the trash and we should chalk it up to experience and find something else to eat. Honestly, it would have been better if we just threw the money in the trash because it would have saved us the time and the gas money to pick up the "not good" food. The girl who greeted me when I went to pick up the food was nice so this review does not reflect on the staff at all. It's not really a place to sit down and eat unless you're desperate. The man at the register who handed me the food was unable to look me in the eye. I think that says it all. Maybe this was just a bad day for this place but I'm not going to pay to find out ever again. read more

We went there for the first time last week. The pizza is thin-crust, but sturdy enough to hold the toppings. We got the Hawaiian pizza with bacon, grilled pineapple, pepperoni and hot honey drizzle. Delicious!! It was our first time, and the people at the counter were super friendly and patient! Would definitely go back! read more

Please go out of your way to try this place. It's small, so you'll likely drive right by it--New York style pizza with fantastic ideas like the Hot Honey Hawaiian pizza or the Buffalo Chicken. We're a picky bunch but these were an easy WIN and I'll be back without a doubt. $20 and the 18" is $25 which is a great value for what you're getting. They have things well orchestrated which makes them better than most. Even in the middle of 5 easy competitors, they review high above most. Thanks for making our Friday! read more

Having grown up in NYC and eaten at probably every pizza place in midtown and downtown, I finally found the real deal in Sandwich MA. I've lived here for almost 30 years and have been searching for pizza like you get in NYC. THE SEARCH IS OVER!! read more

Brooklyn Heights New York Eatery - NYC style pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

Very yummy food and outstandingly nice service! My daughter found out she is celiac a few months ago and that was the best food she has had since diagnosis. She got the chicken strips and it was a huge portion, deliciously crunchy and cooked to perfection! I had the italian sub and my husband had the pizza, both were wonderfully NYC. read more

Carlos has hit it out of the park. My wife has celiac and the gluten free crust is the best we ever had. I also tried the regular pizza and it was outstanding. It was very busy but we still got our 3 pies within 20 minutes. The decor is really cool and Carlos and his staff were great. read more

This Pizza is incredible!!! Sit's right up there with New Haven Pizza!! You won't be disappointed.

We really liked it. Nice food. Friendly attitude and gluten free pizza available. Recommended!

This may be the best pizza on the Cape. Closest thing you're going to get to NY/NJ style.

Delicious pizza. Truly some of the best around. Unfortunately, their wait time has been double what I was told every single time I've ordered (5-6 times now). The pizza is great so it's easy to hope for a change the next time, but it just hasn't got any better. I hope that they can start giving more accurate timelines as they become more established as this will stop people from coming back. read more

Brooklyn Heights is definitely a place not to be missed. The owners are great people and care that they sell you something that is awesome and that you will enjoy! I love the pizza so much that it is usually my go to food there. Growing up in New York this pizza is as close if not replicated to the pizza I ate in NY. Their other offerings are also very good and I go every chance I get, and you should too! read more

Amazing Pizza. Great food. True NY pizza. The owner is right there making the pizzas. To the right is a nice spot to sit by the waterfall on the wall and wait for your hot pizza. Limiter seating for dine in. Lots of thought has gone into making this food. Expect to wait 30 + min for a Pizza on Saturday evenings. Worth the wait!!! read more

Minimal seating but the food was sooooo good! My sister and I shared the Italian sub, the bread was perfectly toasted, the meat was cold, but honestly it was such a nice contrast. The Brooklyn tater tots were so crisp and the sauce was delicious. The garlic bread was a large roll and that was also toasted and covered in seasoning. The woman and man running it were super sweet, helpful and kind. Totally recommend. read more

Great place and great food. Friendly employees. The lamb gyro is awesome. Also give the vegan bomb sub a try as well, so much flavor in it. Crazy bread tastes great but maybe a bit hard to chew. read more

I just left this business, I ordered at 540 was told 20 minutes, was ready at 620, twice the wait time I was told, and it was not that busy, I understand that shit happens but the young kid handed me my order and never apologized, even after I was visibly upset, he just handed me my order and that was it. Too bad as the owner, who was making pizzas seemed like a good guy. If no one responds I will not be back, sorry read more

their pizza is good, better than the longtime places in its vicinity. we will definitely return for the pizza. we also tried their sandwiches. that's a big NO the bread was old and dry to the point where it fell apart as I was eating the sandwich. they didn't pack it with contents either, skimpy. for a $13 sandwich it should have something in it. I can buy a sandwich at market basket for half the price and be loaded with contents. so if it's pizza your after, I give it a thumbs up, but definitely not sandwiches, I hoped for a new place to get a decent sandwich in town. these owners of places selling sandwiches here should take a ride to Marzillis bakery in Fall River and order a large sub, they are 2 feet plus long, no exaggeration, always bread made that day. If a place like that opened here they would decimate the competition. I will continue to wait. read more