Still going strong. We love ordering from Pizza Brothers. The food is always hot, they give us special requests and we have no complaints about them. I hope people give them a try! read more

Pizza Brothers - Stromboli! Hugh. Sausage and onions. Delish - Pizza Near Me - Green Brook, New Jersey

See all

It is marked as closed but it is still open and making the great Pizzas I get from them every week.

I wanted good pizza in the neighborhood and I wavered between various restaurants (all were on the verge of closing bc it was late) and I finally chose Pizza Brothers bc of a previous review I had written... This time has to be better than last. This was arguably the best cheesesteak pizza I've ever had. I don't really love cooked peppers, but the balance was perfect. The pizza was heavy, but perfectly done ... I had a plate, but didn't need fork/knife... kudos to a solid crust! The person that answered and delivered the pizza was super pleasant and is perfectly Spanish-English bilingual! I highly recommend for so many reasons! read more

Pizza Brothers - Cheesesteak Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Green Brook, New Jersey

I give Pizza Brothers 5 stars on my review.The Pizza is great. The food is fresh. The pizza is great.

If I could give them zero stars I would. My family & I have ordered from this place regularly for the past 2-3 years & it took today's horrible experience for us to Never order from here again. We got a delivery order & upon arrival were made aware policy had changed which wasn't the real problem. My partner called the restaurant to confirm & the attitude of the employees was surreal. We were told there was a $2 "technology" fee & a $4 delivery fee now & followed up by saying we call all the time to complain but completely false ? The guy on the phone passed the phone to who he said was the owner but then told by that individual he wasn't the owner therefore didn't care about negative feedback & if we weren't happy to never order again which is exactly what we will do nor our family & friends. We've gotten multiple pies for parties in the past for parties & like today our regular Friday dinner However it is Completely unnecessary for both employees to curse amongst each other in Spanish on the phone & to on top of that tell my partner he was a "fake gangster" in Spanish when we were completely respectful. I can't make sense of this joke of experience it even took my appetite away, whoever is running this place needs to do something about their employees. COMPLETELY UNPROFESSIONAL. read more

My first order was Pepperoni and a chicken salad. Pizza is very tasty, great quality, delicious dough, and toppings. Salad was perfect as well, lots of chicken and veggies. Very high quality food for reasonably priced. They delivered faster than expected. Driver was sweet and polite. Def my new go to place for pizza. Gonna try a calzone next time. read more

We love the sausage pie! Very tasty and has a great crust to it. Definitely recommend their pizza!

We were looking for a local pizza place to order delivery Friday night. Thanks in part to the flyer and coupons in the mail, we gave pizza brothers a try and we were not disappointed. We kept it simple with a cheese and margherita and both were simply delicious! Everything from the crust to the toppings was tasty and it had the right amount of cheese, not too much and not sparse. Will definitely try again and like that they also have Cluck U chicken. read more

We love the pizza here. Ordered a Sicilian pie with mushrooms and onions. The crust crust, cheese, sauce and toppings all tasted really great! Really seems like quality Ingredients are used and there was plenty of cheese. We enjoyed our meal very much read more

I loved the scheduling of a delivery time on their app, my food was delivered exactly on time and better yet- hot . The calzone was so so good , the lasagna, meh. But was impressed enough to try other menu items in the future. read more

Although this place doesn't look like much from the outside on the inside it was surprisingly bright and clean. The pizza was fine and the slices were pretty big. They didn't have much flavor but they did have a thin crispy crust. read more

Pizza Brothers - Good size slices - Pizza Near Me - Green Brook, New Jersey

Not ordering from this place again. Management should check more closely on the employees that work in this company. The driver that came to do the delivery at my house was someone with such a poor behavior. "By mistreating your clients and insulting your clients with racist comments you are not going to succeed in life my friend, period", it is not a way to do business at all. This delivery driver specifically should not be working at all. I'm reporting this place tomorrow to BBB first thing in the morning. ......All we wanted is to eat some Pizza, after this incident I never did! ..... remember: clients do matter read more

Pretty good pizza! Its not anything special but if you are in the mood for good pizza, this is a great spot! The staff are always nice and I never had a problem here. read more

Ordered baked ziti....didn't eat it b/c I don't eat meat and this had Bacon in it. Seriously, who makes that with Bacon? It wasn't listed on the menu with it and if they deviate from standard and add salty meats, its inconsiderate not to mention this to customers. Bf ordered a Cali steak sandwich...said it could have been purchased out of a truck stop. Salad that came with meal had iceberg lettuce. read more

Do not order from these rude people! We are new to the area and called to have food delivered. They said they delivered. The owner on the phone was rude and put us on hold twice before he took our order. We waited nearly an hour and the food arrived with part of the order missing, wrong items included and the food ice cold. We card the owner back not to complain but to simply ask for the rest of the order for our daughter and he yelled and screamed at us, told us he wouldn't deliver the missing food until after they closed because they were too busy, and had the audacity to tell us to call the Martinville location next time, which we tried to do first but they don't deliver. Not only did our daughter not get her dinner, but we got items we don't want ams the dood arrived ice cold and tasted terrible. Horribly rude owners, horrible service and horrible food. How target are in Haines is astounding! They should be closed down! read more

Pizza Brothers a year, year and a haf ago had a great pie, quality ingredients and they delivered. Now in the last 6 months, Their large pie is the size of a medium at a large price (compare Alfonsos) and instead of fresh mushrooms, they are canned and if you order more than one topping on a pie, they don't put as much on but charge a full topping price. Also their salads use to be great - now the come with brown wilted edges on the lettuce. I am moving to alfonosos. They use to be more expensive - not so much now - but their quality is amazing. I will miss the cluck u fro Pizza brothers though. read more

I would say it's very good "typical pizza". I particularly liked their sauce. I've been to too many pizza places with cardboard terrible pizza. This one will not disappoint unless you're looking for more quality ingredients. It's great typical; not artisanal. read more

Amazing pizza!!!! They are great with large orders, I use them all the time for big offices. The pizza is delicious and the service is superb! read more

We've ordered from here a few times. I love that they have online ordering but the delivery times are always almost double what they say, plus they charge a $2 delivery fee and a "convenience" fee. The last time we ordered online, the pizza was supposed to be white and it came all red. I'm not sure how they could screw it up when you order online - it's all clearly written out, so it's not like someone misunderstood me ordering over the phone. There's a lot of other places in the area. We probably won't be ordering from them again. read more

Greasy pizza. Taste great though. Pizza looks like it's been sitting out all day. Very spicy as well. Very flimsy pizza.

I get a baked ziti pizza from here every couple of weeks. It is GREAT!!!! This is a nice family owed and operated pizza joint. Yes there is room to improve, but overall the place is nice, the food is good, and the prices are reasonable. read more

Wanted to wait to review this place- lived in the area all my life and finally decided to never order from here again. One recent incident is I ordered delivery and fortunately my order was correct but they took an extra 15 minutes past delivery time. A bit annoying but it happens- then yesterday happened. I ordered to pick up after work- tortellini alfredo and mozzarella sticks. Picked it up- 2 bags. You would think that it would be the mozzarella sticks and pasta- so I didn't think to check. I get home and see that its my side salad and pasta packaged separately, no mozzarella sticks. I call and the counter girl apologizes and says its her fault and says "you can always drive back we have them". Why would you admit to it being your fault then CONTINUE to inconvenience the customer while trying to "help" them? Maybe thats just me. I would have had a driver drive it over or credited me back. But no. They could only put the credit on my "account" associated with my phone number. Granted, I rarely order from them. Which they can see when I call. So, I basically lost $7 for overpriced mozarella sticks and will most likely never end up using those $7- since this place can't show an ounce of customer service. I'm in college and this girl is in high school so its not a matter of age, its a matter of understanding and knowing proper customer service. Bedminster Pizza is and has always been better. Pizza Brothers has overpriced, overrated food, and disappointing customer service. Show some support to Bedminster Pizza, up the road and has never disappointed me. read more

Sicilian is the best ever, I true pizza place is only as good as the Sicilian. Cant beat the price either, plus they have the cluck u chicken. Delivery sometimes takes a while, lately it has been on point. Easy to order to, if you're a regular, they will even keep the number on file with the phone number. My husband loves their sub sandwiches too, soft bread and don't skimp on ingredients.... def reccomend read more

Got Pizza here day after New Year's as no other Pizza places were open. I was pleasantly surprised of the quality of the food and the flavor. I got a plain and buffalo chicken pie and both were fantastic. Would recommend! read more