We have been here several times in the past month. The pizza is amazing. We did get a stuffed pizza one time and it was just too much cheese and grease. But their regular pizzas are outstanding. The service is good too. We pass up a lot of pizza places to drive here. read more

Glad to see that they are open again the food is great. Tried out their steak sandwiches Pizza Stromboli everything is great at a reasonable price too ! read more

Pizza Joe - Pizza Joe is open again April 16th, 2015 - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Great Pizza, period. I came from NJ so I know good pizza. No outdoor dining but fast. Friendly service. Place Is always packed on weekends so come early. read more

You just lost a 6-year regular customer tonight. We had suspected the quality had slipped recently, but this was the last straw. First, my takeout order was wrong. I ordered a cheesesteak but instead got eggplant parm. I took it back and got my cheesesteak, which was satisfactory. But the bigger problem was with my girlfriend's linguini with clam sauce. First, the packaging leaked so now my car smells like garlic butter. Since I drive for Uber and Lyft, this is unacceptable because it means I am losing several hours of productivity having to clean the seat and wait for it to dry. But while I was out getting my hoagie replaced, my girlfriend found a large piece of plastic in her entree. Fortunately she did not swallow it or that would have been a lawsuit. Sorry, but you hit a new low tonight. read more

I always get my Sicilian pizza at pizza joes but the one I got last night SUCKED. It was thin and no crunch, sloppy wet. YUCK. Next time Little Caesars bacon wrapped. at least its tasty, cheap, and lots of crunch read more

The pizza I got tonight taste like it was a day old. Crust was hard like it was reheated. The cheese came off in one bite like it was a day old. They had good pizza but tonight disappointed me read more

One of my go to pizza and cheesesteak restaurants!! Always good and reliable! Has been around forever and just continues on being one of the best in the area! read more

Has really gone down hill, pizza was greasy, not fully cooked and just gross. Save your time and dine elsewhere. Pizza in the Nazareth area has really seen better days. This was just terrible. read more

Food sucks. For the price i was blown away by the terrible quality. When i get a bill for 40-50 dollars for 2 pizzas i expect them to be edible. My dog wont even eat this poor excuse for food read more

The Best Garlic Knots around! Good pizza too but will be back for the Garlic knots! If you order pizza definitely get Sicilian it is Amazing! read more

This place is awesome! Wonderful homemade food, great service, and awesome family running it. Their dinners are awesome and the Sicilian is soo awesome and popular. Always crowded on Friday's and Saturdays... no wonder, the place is amazing! read more

The dark horse in the long standing battle for Nazareth pizza supremacy. Some people say Sicilys, some people say Mivajos, but a few of us who know better will always say Pizza Joe's. read more

Best pizza around. The staff is wonderful and friendly. Beverly is a sweetheart. The owner really appreciated the feedback. Just a pleasure each time. The food is worth the price and always perfect. Keep up the great work and thank you! read more

Not too busy tonight however staff constantly came to our table asking us if we needed our food boxed. We had to tell them three times that we were still eating. They need to wait till customers are in a relaxed position in the future. read more

Parking is tight but not a surprise with how great the pizza is. Our family loves it here! Best pizza we've found here in 2 years.

The absolute BEST Sicilian pizza I have ever had! It's about a half hour drive and since our first visit about a month ago, we've been back 3 times! It's THAT good! read more

No fancy words here, just the best sicilian pizza in the valley. That sauce does it every time.

Best pizza in the Nazareth area. A bit of a hassle to deal with sometimes so the rating is one star lower based on service.

Extremely casual.....and extremely good Sicilian pizza. The Neapolitan style is ok too (very thin crust if you enjoy that). Loved it ! Will be back for sure. Jim O described it best.....Mivajos and Sicily are both good in their own right......but there is something about Pizza Joe that I get a craving for. Maybe the Buffallo Chicken Pizza, maybe the sausage roll, maybe the Taco pizza. I haven't had one bad thing. read more

Totally hits the spot whenever I'm in town! I have been here many many times and they never disappoint! My food is always delicious. Sicilian pizza and Penne Vodka are definitely the best around! Atmosphere is very cozy and intimate and they have BYOB! Great family spot or date night! An absolute must try for anyone who has never been! read more

Very good pizza. They are famous for the tomato pie, I personally am not a fan of tomato pies, but if that's you thing, this is the place to go! read more

The best pizza around! I haven't ordered much else from here, but the sicilian and standard pies are awesome!

If you want a Sicilian pizza, this is the place to go. Out of all the pizza joints in Nazareth: Pizza Joe, Sicily's, Mijavo's, Pizza Hut, etc... this is the best restuarant to pick. read more

This is one of the most amazing establishments in Nazareth, Pa. The building was recently rebuilt and is beautiful. The pizza is amazing and tastes very flavorful. The service is fabulous and there are various types of pizza and other foods. read more

We traveled from Philly And after a tough day at the Martin Guitar museum we fired up Yelp and found Pizza Joe. It was late afternoon. They had a catastrophic fire and reopened in October 2015 after six months. The building is very nice, staff was pleasant, competent and professional. We had calamari, hug a plain pie awesome chicken florentine and absolutely the best 'thin' Sicilian pizza I have ever had. Little did we know our server was also the owner. A really pleasant experience and great food. Highly recommended!! read more

Good food, good service, very reasonable prices. Been here several times and always a great experience. Can get crowded on a weekend night.

My favorite place to have a quick lunch when I visit in PA! Their wedgies and pizza are great and everyone is so sweet. A little on the pricey side you can definitely rack up quite a bill. read more

Jerry and Janel, along with their crew catered my wedding for 225 people. The menu included lobster ravioli in a blush sauce, chicken francese, eggplant Parmesan, penne vodka, cavatelli with broccoli in a white wine sauce, and Caesar salad. They were very accommodating with my special requests- for example I wanted anchovies to be served on the side for the salad and fresh grated pecorino- Romano cheese available. They also made bread with seasonings fresh that morning and served it with dipping oil- it was a hit! The buffet food was served very hot and fresh! Our guests raved at the menu and I enjoyed my first meal as husband and wife very much! I would, without a doubt, highly recommend them for any catering needs! They exceeded my expectations and their friendliness, efficiency, and professionalism was greatly appreciated in a busy time in my life! read more

I am an avid pizza lover. I've had pizza all over the East coast. Pizza joe hands down has the best Sicilian pie ever. You will not regret the Sicilian from pizza joes ! read more

Jerry at Pizza Joe's is class act. Hard working family owned and operated business with great pizza. No delivery but they still do great business. Highly recommend. read more

Tried this place out last night. Ordered sicilian pizza. Absolutely disgusting! Barely any cheese. Was a big sloppy sauce covered mess. Would have given no stars if I could. read more

Good food, only problem is the take-out area is so small, you have to stand outside in the cold and wait sometimes. They always throw the food in the bag and it makes a mess. But the food is really good. read more

This is the best pizza restaurant in Nazareth(I know, what a resonating compliment...) in my opinion. Their prices are good, the pizza is quite delicious, their entrees are just as good. The only flaw is the wait staff in that they tend to either be aloof to your presence or busy(and I use that word loosely). Regardless of gripes, this is the place to go for Pizza and some italian food in Nazareth. read more

We love Pizza Joes buffalo, plain and Hawaiian pizza. Their antipasti's are the best around. I live in Nazareth and like to support all the pizza places. Depends on what I'm in the mood for. Mivajo's has the best italiand dinners, soup and cheesesteaks. Sicily has the best original sausage, chicken, eggplant rolls. The best service as well. My family likes their pizza. Goodfellows being one of the newest in Nazareth is definitely one of the best pizzas around. Their wings are to die for. The employees and owners can always be found there. I love their outgoing personalities they are very customer service oriented. Every customer is like family. read more

This is one of my go to pizza and pasta places. We love their salads and pretty much everything. We try to get there once a week. We go with a large group (usually 10 or more) and they are awesome! Hats off to Jerry and also our favorite waitress Heather. The Matase Family read more

One of the best pizza places in Nazareth and I don't even like pizza!! If you are like me and don't like pizza they have really good salads and calzones! read more

These guys were awesome! Always had the best pizza in town and recovered from the fire like a true champion?m! Highly recommend

New resident in the area and wanted to try a local pizzeria in the area instead of having Pizza Hut all the time. I ordered a Sicilian pizza and some cheese fries. I was surprised that the pizza was done the old fashion way. Cheese on the bottom and sauce on the top. The crust was good soft with a nice crunch. The bottom was hard to bite off. You could also taste the distinct herbs which was nice. The cheese fries was traditional. Cheese ontop which I think people should mix the cheese with the fries before heating so there's not just cheese ontop. Other than that the price was great, a 16 inch for 12.75. A regular large is only 9.95. It's a good place but will try the others to compare. There is like three within a couple streets of each other. So basically give it a chance and see if its for you. read more

Pizza Joe - A 16" Sicilian done old world style. - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

I ordered from the catering menu for a graduation party and the food was outstanding! Several guests came up to me to rave about the food was and ask where I ordered from. Between the quality and quantity of food, it was well worth it. For me it was a toss up between the chicken marsala and cavatelli with broccoli for my favorite, and my dad kept saying they were the best meatballs he's ever had. read more

We were going to a show at the Nazareth Center for the Arts & looking for a place to have dinner before the show. We picked Pizza Joe's based on all the positive reviews & we were not disappointed! Service was quick & all of he staff were friendly and pleasant. We are all picky eaters especially when it comes to Italian/pizza, and we found the food fantastic & the prices affordable. We will definitely be back the next time we travel to the Nazareth area! read more