Great local pizzeria. Stopped by for a quick lunch, and had an amazing time. 8$ for table side fresh bread and butter (cinnamon butter like Texas road house), two large slices of 1-topping pizza and a fountain drink. It's a bellefonte staple! read more

The cheese in the mozzarella sticks was not fully melted, the boneless chicken wings were terrible, they looked like kids chicken nuggets with very processed chicken. However, the plain cheese pizza was good. read more

See all

After recently moving back to Bellefonte I've been trying my old spots to eat. Let's start with service, I was greeted an sat right away I knew what I wanted so I ordered on the spot. I ordered a cheesesteak and a slice of pizza by the time my slice of pizza came out my drink was gone he gave my slice of pizza with no warning about how hot it is and proceeded to leave without offering me another drink but to wait for him to return a few minutes later with my sub to ask if I wanted another (cooks should not be waiters!) pizza was delicious wants it was cooled down a little. Ok let's talk about the cheesesteak I ordered it as a 14 inch with only cheese extra mayo and lettuce first half was amazing but the second half had a lot of fatty pieces of meat witch I had removed I also believe there bread is to long for there sandwich's well at least the cheesesteak there is like a half inch of bread you could take off, also in my opinion they use to much lettuce probably filling the void that would be there if they did not, like I was saying smaller bread would most likely complement the portions. The space is little quiet and tucked in a little, away from a busy intersection overall decent experience. After receiving my bill I would more then likely predict that if they had lower prices they'd have more customers coming in to eat there food like the pizza mediums their subs for an example a slice of pepperoni pizza is $5 had a 4 star but now bring it down to a 2 hope to see future changes but more then likely not. read more

Pizza Mia! - Too much lettuce and the amount of extra bread that's wasted. - Pizza Near Me - Bellefonte, Pennsylvania

I order delivery from this place about once a month and I've done so for years now. I'm only giving 3 stars because of the inconsistency. I order the same thing almost every time, the Crispy Chicken Salad and I can say it's never been the same twice, even though I order from Slice and just reorder the previous order. I realize part of the problem may be that I'm ordering salad from a pizza place. You can order the chicken with a sauce, and they give you a choice. I always order the buffalo sauce. Sometimes the chicken is tossed in the sauce, other times you just get a cup of sauce on the side. Tonight several ingredients were missing, I received mostly a box of lettuce, very few onions, no mozzarella cheese, no croutons. Sometimes they do a great job, sometimes it's very disappointing, but it's never the same twice. read more

If you really know deep dish pizza, like a true Chicagoan, do not order this item at this restaurant. The bottom crust was covered in a thin layer of cheese and pepperoni, then ladled with sausage in sauce. It was gloppy and over sauced. What a disappointment! Bone up on deep dish.......bottom crust, cheese, pepperoni, sausage (what ever), then a top crust, cover with crushed tomato sauce. read more

Cheese steaks are top notch The bread is homemade and you can taste the difference one thing that makes this place is you can customize your cheesesteak without getting gouged on price. read more

Pizza Mía! is the real deal. Everyone who works here is awesome and the pies are the best I've had in the Happy Valley. I came here on the recommendation of some friends that I was in town to visit and it did not disappoint. read more

I accidentally left my camera on the bench outside when I was passing through town. The staff put it in the safe, and hung onto it for a week for me until I was able to come back. Their kindness and friendly faces are as supreme as their calzones. read more

Pizza Mia! - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Bellefonte, Pennsylvania

Pizza is great, love that they have daily specials. The staff is friendly. Our family usually goes in and gets the $6 pizza and drink combo and it's usually slow inside during the week which is definitely nice, the waitresses have always been super attentive and make sure you're taken care of. read more

Ordered on a Friday night. The pizza arrived fast and was delicious!! Best delivery option in Bellefonte!

Food was fantastic. My family and I got The Pizza Mia Chicago Style Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, and wings. Deep dish was swimming in cheezy gooey goodness, The other pizza had PLENTY of pepperoni, and the boneless wings were the perfect balance a juicy and crispy. And Nellie, our waitress was the absolute best. She pulled an extra table over for us and made us feel right at home. She made the experience even better. The atmosphere was relaxed and casual with a huge menu. Cannot believe there are reviews on here that say otherwise. Thank you!! We will return!! read more

The calzones are spectacular. I've always received excellent delivery service as well.

We called in for two wedges(dogeys) and five mozzarella sticks. He said $34. What? So we scratched one sandwich. Any way, when we got home and opened the box, we were disappointed. The doe in the dogey was super thin, like a pita, and under cooked to boot! Lol. Seriously, that was one of the most pathetic sandwiches I have ever saw in my life. Pale, tasteless, raw bread, about 1/4" thick, if that. Well, we ate it, because we were starving. But, with those high prices and that crappy food, we won't call them any time soon.... read more

Pizza Mia has one of the best Dill Pickle pizzas that I have ever tasted. The crust is soft on the inside and crunchy on the outside. The garlic sauce is fantastic and the pizza has just the right amount of dill and pickles. My friend ordered a breakfast pizza with eggs, bacon, sausage and ham and it looked fantastic as well. Great place for specialty pizzas. We ate in and the staff were very attentive and friendly. read more

We had to stop in for pizza, its been about 3 years since we moved from bellefonte to Pittsburgh and my boyfriend misses it so. He enjoyed the pizza but i was a little disappointed. The homemade greek dressing was mostly oil for my salad. It didn't have the flavor i expected. The pizza crust seemed thinner than i remembered. Otherwise service and the pizza was still great. I think the owners should consider having a more adult presence at the restaurant. The kids working werent the cleanest. I saw a lot of hands touching hair and not being washed. Inappropriate conversations that we could hear grim the dining room as well as discussing delivery customers. read more

I used to be employed by pizza Mia. I have to say that experience was sub par. Not impressed with the way the staff was treated and after my visit (a year and a half later) to the Bellefonte location. I was even more displeased. From a former employee stand point I can say the doagies were really good. That is however if they are made right. Per my request I asked for house dressing on the side, no tomatoes, and extra cheese. We received this item with barely any cheese, smothered in house dressing and many many tomatoes. It wasn't even cut correctly. I called the staff to explain my issues. I am allergic to tomatoes and I explained that at the restaurant. I was met with attitude and I was told that the food was made right. That I was just trying to get free food. I don't think they remember that I was a former employee, of course because I worked at the lock haven location. I remember how to make that doagie and again I was more than disappointed. Also they claim to use fresh ingredients, that is only partially true. They fabricate and make up stories to fit what they want you to believe. For a pizza place, that is supposed to be lighthearted and friendly. They are extremely shady, disrespectful, and rude. Please consider this when supporting such a lowdown, rotten, dishonest business. Thank you. read more

Very pleased with the service and food here. I'll start off by saying they were open on Labor Day, which was HUGELY helpful for showing my family around town and having somewhere to take them for lunch. We were the only ones in the restaurant, were seated very quickly, and had our drinks and order taken within 2 minutes. The pizza was fresh because they seemed to just be making to order today. We ordered the large California veggie pizza, which was loaded with vegetables in the description and on the pizza itself! I've known Pizza Mia's as an establishment that gets its ingredients locally, and you could taste it in the pizza. So fresh, all it needed was a little bit of oregano and garlic powder and it was perfect. Will absolutely be returning to try the studded eggplant and the cinnamon sticks! UPDATE 2/28/17: Portabella burger was amazing, very well prepared and seasoned. Great customer service, as always! read more

Pizza Mia! - California Veggie Pizza. I hope the picture speaks for itself. Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Bellefonte, Pennsylvania

We've enjoyed the pizza from here several times. Pizzas are pretty large and our whole family enjoys them. I've had several friends try it and they keep asking for us to take them back to Pizza Mia. I haven't tried other pizza joints in Bellefonte, partially because we've been happy with Pizza Mia and haven't felt the need to branch out. I'll update this once I've tried a few others. read more

Severly undercooked. Dough was gummy, vegetables raw. Called to tell them and got a manager who said "What do you want me to do about it." Claimed he couldn't do anything since I ordered thru Grubhub. Told him "Well I guess we'll just have to cook it all the way but heads up, your sending out undercooked food." To which the manager mumbled something then hung up. All in all this pretty much sums up Pizza Mia. So if you want a pizza thats undercooked and a business that doesn't give a flying fuck, Pizza Mia is perfect for you! read more

Subs are solid, pizza is good but not great, and over $18 dollars for wings that were bland and not fried was too much! We were so excited for these "hot and spicy" wings but they fell severely short on flavor and texture! Also definitely overpriced! Over $47 for two subs and 10 bland wings is definitely too much! Would not recommend! We were disappointed! read more

Was very hungry and happened to be in Bellefonte so stopped for 2 slices of pizza (1-pepperoni 1- garlic). Normally when your starving you can eat two week old roadkill and it would be great. These 2 slices were like eating gas station pizza, very poor! Stick with roadkill and you'll be better off. Oh by the way the price was $8.48. read more

First off, the pizza is delicious; I consider Pizza Mia to be among the top three in town in terms of flavor. That said, the service is HORRIBLE. 1. On one occasion they delivered the wrong pizza (wrong size and wrong toppings). 2. I ordered two slices on a cold evening when I was the only customer in the store. They said it would take 10 minutes to heat the slices, and that they'd bring them to me in the dining area. After 20 minutes I went to the counter to ask about the slices. They said they'd burned (!) the two slices and had to re-do them. Again, I was the ONLY customer in the store. 3. Pretty much anything I've ordered has taken a looooong time to get. read more

Don't waste your money. I recently moved to bellefonte and want to support locals. I ordered delivery at 5pm and was told 5:50 arrival, I live three/four blocks away. It arrived after 6:10. The pizza was cold and extremely greasy. It wasn't the worst slice I've ever had but it is pretty low on the list. The crispy chicken salad was fine, small amount of chicken but it tasted okay. It's hard to mess up lettuce, cherry tomatoes and cucumbers. Oh the croutons are kinda gross and really hard. I got an order of fries, which were soggy and cold and the mozzarella sticks weren't even cooked. Luckily I have an air-fryer to fix them but they still tasted gross. For the price, I would say go somewhere else. read more

To start off, I have always enjoyed the food I have eaten here. The biggest issue I have is with the rudeness of the people answering the phones & the insane amount of time it takes for delivery. On an random sunday night, I ordered a hoagie and chips. It took over an hour to arrive..which seems a bit ridiculous to me. There have been other times when similarly small orders took at least an hour to arrive. On the plus side, the drivers have always been friendly & most apologize about the time it took to get my food.. maybe they too realize how ridiculous the wait times are. Not sure if they need more staff or a quicker staff. read more

Really terrible service. Not sure what is going on there, but just saw someone else post a negative review for tonight so it's clear it wasn't just us. After a long day driving, this was one of the few options open near our hotel. We ordered from a group of guys who seemed stoned and more interested in singing songs and telling each other jokes than working. We were told it would be 10 minutes. We check in 10 minutes later and it's not ready. Then 20 minutes have passed and the guys realize when my husband inquires that they haven't even started the order. In all, it took more than half an hour (three times what we were quoted) to get our food, and for no apparent reason other than laziness. No offer to give a discount or any attempt to make amends for forgetting to place our order. read more

Just ordered from here and I was very disappointed. The marinara sauce on my spaghetti was not very good. It was thick, oily, and the overwhelming flavor of wine ruined it for me. I also ordered cinnamon sticks that were doused and sitting in a pool of butter (they forgot to give us icing too, which is advertised in the picture), our cinnamon bun was burned at the bottom, literally inedible. We had to pick at it to eat the good parts, and like the cinnamon sticks, it was sitting in a pool of melted butter. read more

Pizza Mia! - Pizza Near Me - Bellefonte, Pennsylvania

I've lived in 5 different states. While Pizza Mia isn't the best pizza place I've eaten at, it is certainly top 5. If you're a pizza place, I believe at a minimum you should be good at pizza and wings. Pizza Mia excels in this department. Their sides are good and their burgers are decent. I don't know how their salads are because if you get salad from a pizza place you're weird. If you're travelling through Bellefonte, Pizza Mia is worth a stop. read more

Pizza Mia was a disappointment. I have had many types and styles of pizza. New York, Chicago deep dish, Italian thin crust ,etc.. Not sure what it was I had. A running watery sauce on a piece of cardboard topped with low grade read more

Pizza Mia! - Proper u tensile - Pizza Near Me - Bellefonte, Pennsylvania

This place has some real potential, and the staff is wonderful. I wish I could remember my waitresses name, because she was honestly one the best waitresses I've had in years. The food is allright for Bellefonte, I love that they have a big selection for salads and wraps. read more

Pizza Mia is our favorite local pizza place. The food is consistently delicious and delivery times are always reasonable. We have ordered from them many times and never had a problem...until today. The young man who took the order struggled a great deal with understanding simply our phone number when my husband called in. The food arrived on time, but it was not the food we ordered in the slightest. Susan, the manager, was fast to start the food that would have been our correct order and send it on our way. Love family-operated businesses for their devotion to delivering to the customer! Our corrected order was delivered promptly, warm and wonderful. Sure, it would've been great to get the correct order on time, but it was truly wonderful to have the error dealt with so promptly and graciously. Even though it didn't work out perfectly in the beginning, I am still happy to give this restaurant five stars thanks to Susan's wonderful customer service. We will be back with no reservations. Thanks again, Susan and team! read more

The pizza is fine - not wonderful - just fine. I recommend never asking for delivery on a Tuesday. I placed an order online around 7 pm since I waited on hold on the phone for over 5 minutes. Received a confirmation that the pizza should arrive by 8 pm. Considering I only live a block or so away, I should have dined in or walked over and got it. It had been a bad day and I wanted delivery. At 8:15, I called to inquire about it and was told it was out the door. At 8:45, I called again and was told it was out the door - so I reminded the employee that I had been told that 30 minutes earlier. I told the person that it had better arrive within 5 minutes or they could keep it. The driver arrived within the 5 minutes and with 0 change. I asked him if this pizza was going to be hot and he said he just picked it up. Guess what - the pizza was cold. Stone cold. I called to complain, and was offered a new pizza but at 9 pm - I don't want a new pizza, I wanted my pizza hot and 45 minutes ago. I should have been offered a free pizza or a significant coupon towards a future pizza. It will be a long time before I order delivery from Pizza Mia again. I am very capable of holding a long grudge. read more

I had the pleasure of eating their holiday calzone for thing last night. It was so delicious I greatly had three servings. I'm planning on going there tonight! read more

Whomever's son needs to stop being so arrogant and control his staff. I never had to wait 20 minutes for fries at any other pizza joint. Never ask for extra cheese. It never turns out right read more

I ordered a cheesesteak tonight was the worst sub I ever had meat was cold cheese wasn't even melted with the meat .very poor service.they rushed our subs together. read more

I can't speak to the pizza, but the pasta was not good. The marinara sauce was terrible so I can't really imagine the pizza is good. The portions were very small and the prices were higher than I expected. We bought some cookies on impulse at the register and those were awful too. The only redeeming thing about this place was the bread, that was decent. read more

We ordered pizza and wings. By the time they were finally delivered, everything was cold. I would not recommend this place. The wings tasted like grease soaked in grease. Two thumbs down read more

I never know what to expect when I order from the Bellefonte locale. The associates answering the phone are either rude or condescending, and the online menu is a mess. But the constant price gouging is really the last straw. I'd ordered a 14 inch pizza and the price differentials for 2 inches of pizza more in the form of a 16 inch was almost $7!!! Are you kidding me, for extra cheese? Not to mention the shady delivery charge and the delivery drivers that cut you off in traffic then flip you the bird in front of your child. Also leaving me with an uneasy feeling was the fact that from Jan 1st till almost mid March there were NO PRICES listed in their online menu. This is Bellefonte- if you wanna last for the long mg haul get your prices, service and quality of your products on point. If I'm paying over $30 for a pizza and a side it better be flawless. I cannot in good conscience recommend this pizza place. Have ordered from them 7 times now. This will be the last read more

We are transplants from NY and have spent the last 10 months searching for a true NY style pizza (Brothers, Home Delivery, American Cafe and some other pizza place their name I can't remember) and Pizza Mia is our choice. Always delivered, always by when they promised, always hot and always, without fail delicious. Great staff, friendly and patient. Glad we found this place. Would be 5 stars but, must leave room improvement. read more

Every time I eat here the pizza taste better. Meal deals all the time just ask !! Garlic bread sticks are out of this world!!

We stopped by here for lunch passing through town and we're glad we did!! Great service, delicious food- exactly the kind of pizza we were looking for! read more