Pizza Pit

Nice facility, great staff that are friendly and efficient. We were disappointed in the cod fish…read morefry dinner itself as portions were small, but quickly delivered. Good selection of draft beers.

This can be hit or miss like any restaurant. Some nights its the best food around, other times it…read moreseems like they're possibly training new kitchen staff and one person has what they expected and the other person at the same table is left slightly wanting. The service is always welcoming and respectful, regardless of how the meal came out, the servers are always above and beyond 5 stars.

Front patio

French onion soup

See all

Enjoying the back patio!

Aztalan Inn Bar & Grill

4.0(50 reviews)

2.7 mi

What a great spot to stop for food and fun! Visited here in a Friday afternoon for lunch. We had…read morewings for an appetizer and oh my were the sauces AMAZING. The house made blue cheese is a must try. I had the fish fry and the cornmeal batter was very tasty! You get your choice of potato or veggies and beet salad or coleslaw. Highly recommend the fish fry! Our waitress was amazing and so attentive. She gave us great recommendations. Will definitely be back!

Aztalan Inn surprised us today with Sunday baskets (chicken, fish, chips) and the bloody mary bar…read morewas what I needed for this spring ahead Sunday morning!

Bar area

Fish fry

See all

Bloody Mary

Wingin' It Bar & Grill

3.0(8 reviews)

11.9 mi

We stopped in for the fish fry and thought it was great. Fish dinner, salad bar and soup. No one…read morecould go away hungry. The potato pancakes had the crunch I like and the cold slaw was creamy. Yum. The fried cod was perfect. I had the Polish pickle Zupa which was great and my partner loved the salad bar. This place had plenty of room, as we arrived early, and there were still tables available when we left. A little out of the way but worth it not to have to wait for a place at the table. We will be back.

Located in such a small town, but has great food! Chicken wings, made with a signature sauce, are…read moresold around the clock. Features a full menu as well -- homemade pizza, fish fry, burgers, etc. -- with food and drink specials throughout the week. Sit outside on the deck, in the dining area or at the bar. Volleyball courts and horseshoe pits too!!!

Right on highway 18 between Jefferson and Sullivan.

See all

Full bar and beer selection.

Chicken Licks

4.2(257 reviews)

15.5 mi

my favorite place so far, been here 3 weeks and keep wanting chicken licks! dive bar about 20 mins…read moreoutside of madison with good pricing! start with the cheese curds and add dry rub, order with blue cheese dip! the original (buffalo and dry rub mixed) and dry rub are both phenomenal, the HOMEMADE blue cheese paired with the original is by far my favorite! can not recommend highly enough, try to get there early bc everyone else knows how good it is and it fills up really fast (only complaint)!

If you're a wing person, this place deserves a spot on your radar…read more The setup is counter service -- think along the lines of Culver's. You walk up, place your order at the bar, grab a number, and find a table. Tables are first come, first served, so if you see one open, take it. Drinks are a cooler of options or beer and soda on tap. Cash is preferred -- there's a fee if you pay with a card. The vibe is Wisconsin dive bar, in the best way. I ordered the dry rub wings. The flavor was fantastic -- the kind where you don't need a sauce, but you reach for the ranch anyway because it's that good. Seriously, that ranch dressing could go on anything. My best friend got the original wings and said the heat level is comparable to BW3 medium -- noticeable but not overwhelming. If you like wings, Chicken Licks is worth the trip.

Tater tots

See all

Samijos Pizzeria

4.9(12 reviews)

7.9 mi

Wow! What a great pizza! Our 1st time here. The pizza has a fantastic thin crisp crust. We…read moreordered a chicken, breakfast bacon pizza with 1/2 red sauce and 1/2 white garlic sauce. Both were equally delicious. We will be regulars from now on. 5 stars!

Best pizza in Jefferson bar none the calzones are great too…read more Ordered one line went great ready in about 20 minutes

Chicken, bacon, half red sauce, half white sauce.

Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza

See all

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Kroghville Oasis

4.2(6 reviews)

5.3 mi

May all the rest of my birthday parties be at the Kroghville Oasis…read more The bartenders were nice as pie. The natives are refreshingly...native. The beer is cold. The bloody marys are unbelievable, and also provide your entire RDA of dietary fiber under US FDA guidelines. The well tequila is el Jimador, which outclasses Sauza any day of my life. And the dice game is sure to bring out the inner gambling addict in any normal human, 1-2 drinks in. Don't ever change.

This country bar is located about halfway between cottage Grove and lake mills off of highway bb…read more They have friendly bartenders,a long bar and 25 cent chicken wings on Sundays from ten till two. The bloody Mary had 15 different toppings,a three out of five for taste and a three out of five for value. It was good. I would stop in again.

Not fancy

See all

Brock's River Walk Tavern & Grill

3.4(49 reviews)

11.8 mi

Loved the location. Their homemade ranch dressing is very good. Food was plentiful and good.read more

I have been to this place 3 times. The food is always just fine. However, all 3 times service has…read morebeen horrible. We showed up yesterday around 1120 ahead of the lunch rush. We sat as a family of 4 for 35min and were not acknowledged. My other 2 experiences weren't quite this bad. But certainly excessive waiting for what I expected every time.

See all

Pettit's Lakeview Bar and grill

4.2(76 reviews)

18.5 mi

A great place for food and drinks. We stopped in on a…read moreSaturday afternoon. The patio is fantastic to enjoy live music and get some fun drinks and really delicious food. Service is definitely busy but attentive enough. Will definitely be back

Needed a place to eat lunch that was close to the marina where we were test driving a pontoon…read more This place had some great reviews and now we know why. I really want to come back on a nice summer day. They have some wonderful outdoor seating with a view of the lake. We ordered drinks. A Bloody Mary, and a hot Kahlua coffee were enjoyed while waiting for our food. My husband had the ahi tuna bowl which he said was amazing and I had the blackened grouper sandwich with fries, also worth trying. They have a lot of good looking dishes on the menu. Can't wait to come back and try more. Our waitress was very sweet. Food came out fast. The ambiance felt welcoming.

Bar decor

Blackened grouper sandwich and fries

See all

Delicious drinks

The Real MacCoys

4.3(19 reviews)

15.4 mi

The worst prime rib I have ever had no flavor and the onions and mushrooms tasted like dog food…read more How can these people serve humans this crap!!

Was tooling around on the Harley, and came across this place on a Sunday. Well, what a pleasant…read moresurprise! Wife and I both ordered a Bloody Mary. They had Shiner Bock on tap (that was my chaser) and the Bloody's were delish! Pickle, mushrooms, beef stick and all the rest hit the spot. Looked at the menu and decided on a mushroom swiss burger. We didn't order a split, but the server was nice enough to bring us both a plate, and it was all divided up already! The burger was hot and fresh and the swiss cheese pull was on point. Fries were sour cream and onion wedges, split on our two plates as well. It's a neat little place with good/friendly service. Check it out on a road trip! Bonus- There are some nice deer heads in this place as well. As a hunter and WIsconsinite, I appreciate that. :)

See all

OUTSIDE SEATING

The Barrel Inn

4.5(38 reviews)

11.7 mi

Over the railroad & through the woods to a great fish fry we go! Baked or fried cod, Blue Gills or…read moreWalleye & at reasonable prices! Clean, spacious, bright with lots of tables & plenty of bar space. Great service friendly & attentive. Delicious fried cod, baked sweet potato was wonderful & side salad was fresh & crunchy. Clam Chowder was spot on! Going to make it back soon!

Food came quickly and was decently priced. The homemade salsa was amazing. I didn't really taste…read moremuch sauce on my chicken Parmesan wrap, so I wished there was more of that. My husband said the burrito was good. The bartender was friendly. It was the middle of the day and was dead so we chatted and watched wheel of fortune together. Would definitely come again.

Clam chowder

Turkey bacon ranch wrap with fries ($10.00)

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Rob B.

0

11

3

6 years ago

Been a fan for a while now. Always great food, not just their pizza. My wife and I love the gyros and their hot subs even more. Keep it up read more

Pizza Pit - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Pizza Pit also viewed

PJ's Pizza

3.3

(17 reviews)

Amazing Buffalo chicken subzeeny. The spice on it has a perfect dose of spice…read more SUBZEENY - juicy, tasty sub -

They leave you on hold for 10+ minutes and ignore your call while they help customers in person…read more They won't give an estimated hold time just expect you to sit on the phone until whenever they feel like taking your order or not. I asked if they could call me back, no. Asked if they could give me an estimated wait time, no. They could have taken the order and just put it in when they were ready, no. Wasn't even in a hurry, just don't want to sit with a phone to my ear for thirty minutes while I hear them all chat in the background. She literally said "you can go back on hold or you can hang up" -Mrs Rude Honestly unbelievable. Do better.

Brickhouse Pizza Pub

3.9

(55 reviews)

It doesn't look like much from the outside, but inside was nicely decorated with Italian pizza…read moredecor with Italian crooner music for ambience. Friendly server took our orders and the drinks and food came out timely. Our loaded nachos were good, though the nacho cheese was a bit runny and pooled in the bottom. My grandsons loved their pepperoni calzone and Mac and cheese. My personal pan Meathead pizza was very good; tasty with a nice crisp crust. My wife enjoyed her chicken Tuscany pizza. Both personal pizzas were bigger than expected and very filling. Would definitely stop in again if in the area.

Had lunch today i had supreme personal pizza and wife had cream of mushroom soup. Both were very…read moregood and reasonably priced. Waitress did a nice job for our table of 6.

Samijos Pizzeria

4.9

(12 reviews)

Wow! What a great pizza! Our 1st time here. The pizza has a fantastic thin crisp crust. We…read moreordered a chicken, breakfast bacon pizza with 1/2 red sauce and 1/2 white garlic sauce. Both were equally delicious. We will be regulars from now on. 5 stars!

Best pizza in Jefferson bar none the calzones are great too…read more Ordered one line went great ready in about 20 minutes

Gordy's Pizza & Italian Food

4.5

(23 reviews)

Excellent Lasagna and pizza. I will definitely be back to try more. It's take out only. You can…read morestop in and pick up Lasagna and bake it whenever you're ready. Yummy stuff!!

Great thin crust pizza and friendly service. My family stopped in here months ago while visiting…read morerelatives and we still talk about it. Every time we get a pizza back home now we lament, "Well, it's not Gordy's." This will be our first stop when back in town again.

Sugar River Pizza

3.7

(143 reviews)

We went at 5 pm on a Friday and were able to get right in. This place is very large, but gets very…read morebusy. Parking extended into the adjacent businesses, but overall plenty of space Food 4/5: we got cheese curds and spinach dip for apps. The cheese curds were disappointing for being in Wisconsin. They were clearly the frozen kind and not freshly battered like many other places serve in the area. They were ok. The spinach dip is the star of the show. I love that they put tomatoes in it to give it extra veggies and the overall flavor is salty yet balanced. We got the Mau wowi, maple bacon, and Mac and cheese pizzas. Overall the Maui wowi and maple bacon had a salty sweet match up that brought the best umami. The Mac and cheese is just ok. Service 4/5: our waiter lacked personality but was overall great. Very attentive, continued to ask about drinks, and was prompt with the check when we asked. Ambiance 5/5: this place is huge. Overall adequate room between tables. Great space and wasn't too loud like some places can get. If you like a lot of options with your pizza between toppings and crust, this is a great place to try. They also have a large beer/wine/drink menu.

We quit going. Very stingy with the toppings. Actually started ordering double pepperoni to try…read moreto get it covered and they still put the same amout on. They only put 2 roni's on each slice. It's almost like they measure it out with a template.

Pizza Villa

3.2

(19 reviews)

Awesome pizza. Best pepperoni I have ever had…read more Has some quirky hours around the holidays, but that is to give employees time off to spend time with family. Very understandable. By far my favorite pizza in Jefferson county.

Pizza tastes like it did 30 years ago, amazing flavors and quality. And the owner Kim, is fantastic…read moretoo. Love this gem

Salvatore's Tomato Pies

4.2

(248 reviews)

I have heard great things about Salvatore's for years, but had never tried it before. We stopped in…read moreon Friday evening with a large group, and we had an incredible time! Our friends from Chicago were staying at an Airbnb in Sun Prairie, so we made the trek from the west side of Madison to meet up with them. They had called ahead of time, and even though they don't take reservations for groups that large, the staff said that they would make a note of it and have a spot ready to go for us. Between our 3 families, we had many young kids in tow, so I was apprehensive about a long wait. The minute we walked in, however, we told them our name, and they immediately led us to a large table in the back room where we were quickly set up! The vibe of the place is really fun, with exposed brick walls and fun art. One of the coolest things was for the kids - instead of crayons, the menu comes with Wikki Sticks. These kept the kids occupied the entire time! Absolutely genius. Despite our large table, our waitress had no trouble efficiently taking orders and getting us our drinks. I was shocked by how quickly our food came out - everyone was digging into their meals 25-30 minutes after we had arrived at the restaurant! The service was absolutely top notch, and the pizza was phenomenal. I ordered the tomato pie, and it was everything I was hoping for - gobs of delicious homemade red sauce, plenty of cheese, and fresh basil. I ordered a 10", and I'm not ashamed to say I only had one piece left to take home with me!

We've been here several times, and always enjoyed the food. We were disappointed tonight as they…read morehad changed the menu, which is cool, but the online menu from thier own website still showed the other menu, and our guest, the birthday boy, was looking forward to something specific so we chose to leave and go elsewhere. We'll be back though I'm sure.

Rolling Stone

4.1

(16 reviews)

Food was fantastic, many things made from scratch. Soup, sandwiches, sides, sauces and prime rib…read morewere all done very well with great flavors. The chef, Russ, came out and introduced himself, he was very pleasant and clearly passionate about what he does. Cocktails were tasty and service was great. Will definitely be back.

Food was not great. Brussels were burned. Chicken was over done. For the amount I paid I was…read moreextremely disappointed. No one in my house enjoyed it. unfortunately. Really was looking forward to good food in Juneau.

Famous Yeti's Pizza

4.3

(114 reviews)

We only have had the thin crust pizza, but it is some of the best we have ever had. Definitely will…read morebe going back!

Ordered a pizza and some cheesy bread for pick up and it was done on time. The ambiance and staff…read moreare fine. Very bummed though because I feel like this could be an excellent pizza place but the pizza was just about burned. It was very dark. The cheesy bread WAS burned... I threw away all the outside edge pieces and I had to peel the bottom off of the ones I ate. Next time I order I'm going to tell them to make it "light". If it's still burned, we won't be going back.

The Corner

3.2

(18 reviews)