Cool looking spot, great pizza! Came here to start my night and was pleasantly surprised. read more

Pizza Secret - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Really enjoyed this Brooklyn pizza. True wood fire, thin crust. Lovely. read more

Pizza Secret - Polpettina & Ricotta, Montanara - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Love this place. I've gone back twice with my family and friends. They all agree the food and service I great! read more

See all

As a local and lover of brick oven pizza, I was a frequent visitor at the previous restaurant and was sad to see it one day with butcher paper in the windows - the telltale sign of a new business moving in. I was eagerly awaiting the opening of Pizza Secret once I looked up the owner/chef online, Rosario Granieri, and followed him on instagram @pizzasecret. The guy is a is a legit chef, and full on pizzaiolo!! We've been there three times now since they've opened and had amazing food each visit. We've tried the Chicken Malines, Spaghetti Bolognese, as well as the Margarita and Sausage Broccoli Rabe Pizza. The pizza dough and sauce are fantastic. The Chicken Malines is thicker than most you'll find at most restaurants, and doesn't suffer from the over frying you so often get with the dish. While they are clearly in the first few weeks of operation and still working through some minor kinks (liquor license apparently coming later this month), the food is amazing and every visit they've clearly tweaked and experimented with their service, decor, and vibe! Once these guys are up and running full steam this is going to be a neighborhood staple! read more

Came here on a Saturday afternoon, not too busy. Got the tartufo pizza and my husband got the americana, it was delicious! Great service, I would recommend. read more

Pizza Secret - Tartufo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We've had Pizza Secret on a few occasions pre- and during COVID. Happy to report each experience has been better than the last. Our go-to is the Americana. Jump on that hot-honey-on-pizza bandwagon here, it's pretty delicious. For 2 average-hunger people, I'd say one app and one pizza would be a good amount of food. We've enjoyed the arugula salad and bruschetta. Service can be a little slow but the pizza has always come out piping hot. Have never felt too close to other diners either. read more

Pizza Secret - Americana Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ordered delivery and was very disappointed. I had heard good things about their pizza but our pizza arrived just about folded in half with all the cheese and mushrooms off. They were very good about replacing it but the second delivery arrived with just about half the cheese off. The pizza itself seemed very doughy and lacked sauce. Don't think we will ever order from them again. Maybe their pizza is better straight from the oven. read more

Pizza Secret - Margherita Pizza with mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Stopped in on a Wednesday to this new spot in the neighborhood. They have only been open 3 days so everything wasn't perfect - but the food was delicious! We shared the eggplant Parmesan, Contadina salad, and burrata del pistachio pizza. The eggplant was layered and cheesy. The salad was plentiful and dressed nicely - hate when they put too much. The pizza was light and has just the right amount of seasoning. The servers were nice and very attentive, but you could tell they were new. The only complaint I have is that the pizza came out first when I would have preferred the salad and eggplant first. Overall - the food was super tasty and I would definitely return. PS- It's cash only and they are working on their liquor license read more

See all

Burrata pizza is good! The dough is chewy (incouding the crust). However the brocoli babe one was a bit bitter (also coz the crust was a but burnt). Service is good as they checked on us multiple times. Pretty homey vibe inside. read more

EXCELLENT! Over the top DELICIOUS. Service is PAR EXCELLENCE! QUALITY ingredients. They have so many menu options, not only pizza. One tasty course after another. We felt like we were in Italy and wanted to stay all evening. My nephew & bride to be had a family dinner there for over 60 people. The food kept coming out served hot and so good. The staff and owner were gracious and pleasant and the hospitality was superb. You have to go to Pizza Secret for pizza and other excellent menu selections. The owner was there that night, and wonderfully pleasant man, and he sent us off with a Lemoncello toast on the house. This is a MUST when you are in Brooklyn or Manhattan or vacinity. Great location. Definitely a must see and do! This is no secret.. PIZZA SECRET is FABULOUS! read more

We ordered the Salsiccia & Friarielli Pizza (Broccoli rabe puree, Italian sausage, chilly flakes, smoked fresh mozzarella, parmesan, basil) for takeout. Service (1/5): They forgot our order so needed to wait additional time for it to be made once arriving for pick up. Also had issues redeeming the free dessert offer that's on Yelp if you check in. We ended up paying -! Additional $20 for a dessert that we only ordered because it was supposed to be free. Food (3.5/5): it was soggy and falling apart but the flavor of the pizza and dough was great. Overall, disappointed with the experience but would potentially give this place another chance for dine in read more

Great food and service. Cesar's salad is very good and coleen was super nice even though she was by herself. read more

Pizza Secret - Great Cesar's salad and superb service. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Love this place! I've ordered here a couple times during COVID (take out/delivery only) and have never been disappointed. The pizza is always so flavorful, you really can't go wrong with any of them! I love the flavor combinations. I think my favorite is the Americana. It's semi-sweet because of a honey-olive oil, but also semi-spicy. Love this place - really can't recommend this place enough! read more

Best pizza in Brooklyn, the pizza chef is italian and the owner is from Napoli. Pastas are also great. Super friendly staff!! read more

Pizza Secret - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

So disappointed. First, it's super expensive. I thought I'd splurge a little because the reviews and the pictures looked great. Food was on time. Delivery person was very kind and very apologetically handed me a damaged box . He says he was in an accident and the box was slightly crushed. Pizza was minimally damaged so slightly annoyed by the cost and now damaged pizza, I still accepted and tipped the delivery person. We ordered the large Americana for $36. Aside from the pizza being damaged, it was also cold and mushy. It was sweet and spicy but Not impressed. Ordered the Panna Cotta for 9$ comes in a small plastic cup. I personally didn't like it, but my 1 year old enjoyed it. It's bland and has an odd after taste with a scoop of Nutella on top. Ordered the Tiramisu for $11 it comes in a plastic container. Tastes like it's been sitting in the fridge for a bit and the cream tastes off. This totaled $60 with taxes and with a 5$ off coupon and not including tip. I'm so disappointed because I had such high hopes! Such a waste of time and money. read more

See all

Ordered the Margherita, Americana and Cacio & Pepe with Tiramisu for pickup. The restaurant has been recently updated and is beautiful. The owner was extremely nice and helpful-um-and from Italy. Legit wood burning pizza oven. We arrived early for pickup and wished we had just eaten in. Attentive and hard working staff. The pizza was fab-u-lous. Wish we lived closer. read more

Pizza is very solid and staff is friendly. Will come back again! Came in here after struck out looking for a place to eat around the area. Good place to eat right before going to Barclays. read more

Very solid pizzas. The owner is from Naples (the birth place of pizza) so it's Neapolitan style pizzas here. Dough is tasty soft and airy. Crust is airy and fully on the crust and thin and soupy ish (not too much) it the middle. I love a good classic Margherita Pizza. They also add meatballs on top. I LOVE meat. I like their pastas here. The Pacherri is my favorite. It's nice and chewy. Just wish there were more meat though. This place is known for their pizza. Come here for that! read more

See all

Good Brooklyn pizza. If you're looking for a good place to get a personal pizza for delivery this isn't a bad option. The mushroom pizza I have taken a pic of was better than the prosciutto & arugula one, but both were great. 8/10 overall. read more

Pizza Secret - 4 Bruschetta - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We had been to Pizza Secret in person with some friends before the world ended and had a good experience, but at the time I thought the pizza was a bit overpriced and the pizza nothing to write home about. This second time experience completely changed my mind - the Americana pizza is wake-flocka-flame! The sweet heat from the sauce was a game changer, definitely going to have to order it again. The calamari's breading was great, but I wish that and the pizza arrived a bit warmer (not Pizza Secret's fault though). All in all, they've got a new repeat customer read more

Pizza Secret - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We did a take out with a margarita pie! It was delicious- the dough was doughy and soft. The sauce and cheese were high quality ingredients. For $15, that is the going rate for Neapolitan pie. Next time, we might dine in as the restaurant is spacious and kid friendly. read more

Pizza Secret - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Our go to in boerum hill/park slope. Great crust and fun toppings. They also do a good caesar and a good kale salad. Kind staff, too!

Espresso martini tasted like chocolate milk, asked for a plain cheese and pepperoni and was given a pizza with honey, asked for a coffee and got a large cup of espresso read more

This is THE BEST pizza I have ever had in my entire life, and I have had A LOT of pizza in my 25 years. I ordered the Americana by recommendation from my server. My food was prepared right next to me and cooked in a brick oven pizza put front. Music was great, employees were kind and attentive! I feel foolish for not taking a photo of my pizza before I ate it lol definitely recommend this beautiful and unique restaurant. Dec 2019 -- my love for this restaurant is unending. So happy to have the chance to be back in the Cory and made it a point to come back! Everything is always perfect! read more

See all

Great place , I really enjoyed the service and the taste of the pizza I would recommend Bufala DOP with spicy oil

Don't order the purple potato pizza. It doesn't come with pancetta literally comes with thrown on bacon. And very little purple potato purée. And bacon grease all over the place. And lukewarm. If you order for delivery. And the restaurant does nothing... read more

Pizza Secret - This is what they have on their website versus what I got. Obviously website photos have a lot of editing but this is very different. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Got the truffle mushroom and margarita pizza and oh my God-AMAZING! Definitely give this place a try!

The Americana pizza is my favorite pizza in New York. The other pizzas are solid and the pastas we've gotten have all been fine but nothing to write home about. It's usually not full so easy to grab a table even on the weekend. The delivery pasta portions were much smaller than what they served in the restaurant and didn't seem like great value. read more

This place has finally opened which is great, since I work in the area and I was looking for pizza or spaghetti. As soon as I walk in you are able to pick your choice of seating which we chose inside but the doors were open so we got a nice breeze. The waiter gave us all of their specials and what she thought was their best dish, it was nice since it was our first time but we got margarita brick oven pizza that was cooked perfectly. I love a crunchy crush and bottom and hot pizza. It was a 9inch pan enough for a personal pizza and very filling. I paid 15$ for a personal pan and it was well worth it. read more

Pizza Secret - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

My experience at this restaurant was not the best I will not be joining this place ever again , my pasta tased like it wasn't cooked all the way how tf you don't know how to make pasta its really that simple I felt like this place deserves better staff because they gave me and my friends a hard time, one of the workers charged my friend $141 after she told him to charge her $20 how slow could this man be... please don't come here for the pasta only the pizza for your moneys worth ... hope you hear me out. read more

Horrible staff and very expensive for no reason because the food isn't that good, the pasta is very hard and had no taste to it and the waitress don't even speak English, also the waitress charged me more money then I was supposed to pay for and when I asked if I can get the money back he said no and tried to say it was my fault so I got upset and i then asked another waitress for help and when I asked if I can get my money back she said yes and I finally got it back but in total the experience was horrible and would not go back again. I'm very disappointed. read more

Absolutely phenomenal pizza!! Cannot recommend enough. Can't wait to be back to try more pizzas. Rosario was incredibly nice and made some accommodations for us on 1 of the pizzas we ordered. HIGHLY HIGHLY RECOMMEND THE BRUNCH SPECIAL PIZZA. IT WAS AMAZING! read more

Pizza Secret - (Brunch Special) - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I love this place and food !!! And dessert was so amazing (try tiramisu) Italian Pizza read more

Pizza Secret - Tiramisu - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've been coming to this place for a very long time. their staff is very nice and their calzones are even better. I have had most of their food and I have to say that it's so good. If you want a really good first meal there I normally get a margarita pie or a meatless calzones (because I'm vegetarian) and a sprite. and if I'm very hungry I gat some penne or gnocchi (both are really good.) read more

Pizza secret is a great pizza place in downtown Brooklyn! One of the few Neapolitan pizza spots!

I gave it a three owing to the ambiance and the service. That being said, my mother's family is from Napoli. My fathers family is from the Italian Alps and my Godfather was from Palermo. I know pizza, upside down and sideways. This was, without a doubt, the absolute worst pizza I have ever encountered. Soggy crust. No flavor at all. But, as we Italians know, the crust is everything. Did the pizza chef die? Did the oven malfunction? Even frozen pizza from a supermarket is better than this. Sorry. Terrible place for pizza. read more

Rude staff. I called to ask a simple question about the menu (9/13 @ 7:30pm). The guy who answered wasn't communicating the answer, so I asked to speak to someone else or a manager, he then hung up. Bad customer service, they lost my business. read more

Great food great service and great atmosphere would rate it great for family friends and some alone time too

Amazing fresh light pizza with a thin crunchy crust . There is one with a little honey that I adore . I've been going with my family regularly but I asked for a donation to our block party and they totally came through . This place is a gem and we are lucky to have it close by. The owner Rosario is from Italy and the manager Coleen is super nice . read more

Amazing place amazing food services greed the truffle pies amazing really good and great but I like my pizza crispy but still is amazing it taste good read more