DISCLAIMER: I'm writing this based on my experience with take-out via TGTG (Too Good To Go) for the 3.99$ bag. I came on a random day towards the end of December close to closing to pick up a Too Good To Go Bag. Everyone at my workplace likes to come here for their pizzas and pastries, and I can tell why. Whenever I pass by, everything looks impeccably presented and crafted; it looks more like an art gallery than a pizzeria. For this reason, I was excited to cross over the park and slowly make my way to Numero 28. Just be mindful that they are pretty strict about the hours, so please do go within the prescribed window. In my bag came two large rectangles of pizza (one a red sauce and sausage, and the other a sauceless vegetable medley) and one pistachio cream croissant. This was a really good deal for 4$ -- the slices were thin-crust and still tasty after being reheated on a skillet, and the pastry tasted fresh and decadent. I would not hesitate to come back again for a TGTG bag or just to have lunch/take out a pie for dinner. read more

The Pistachio Bombolone & Iced Nutella Latte were great! The guys at the counter were friendly. The ambiance was laid back. read more

See all

The Reginella and Sicilian slices are my fave. The penne vodka is also superb, perhaps my favorite in the neighborhood! read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Pasta Vodka - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Thin. Crispy. Perfect ratio of cheese to sauce. Fresh. Not dry. Exceeded my expectations during our pizza adventure in the neighborhood. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We ordered food to be delivered to work. We started with the potato croquettes. They were good, but cold. The side of red sauce was good but that too was also cold. We then had the pasta vodka with penne and the pasta alfredo with the homemade white fettuccine. The fettuccine alfredo was on the small size especially since we paid an extra two dollars for the homemade pasta. The penna vodka was also on the small size. We wanted a bowl of pasta and got short changed. The sauces were stellar, but we couldn't add chicken to the pasta and there was no bread. What a bummer! The side grated cheese was a surprise and was very sharp. It was on the pricy side, but the ingredients were definitely fresh. The place looked nice from the outside. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Fettuccine Pasta Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The pizza here is good!! The desserts are ok depending on what you get. I'm particular with my croissants so I would give a 3/5 for the croissants and other sweets like it. But the bombolini is really good! It's like a soft fluffy donut with the right amount of sweetness. Staff is super friendly :) read more

I didn't try the pizza but the donut.... Omg I had to go back for another one bc I live in queens. It was so good so was the croissant. 10/10. Soft and thick uhhhh so good! read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Almond Croissant and Pistachio Donut - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The pizza here was delicious! And those garlic knots!! Yumm. I was walking by this pizza shop while waiting on my food from another restaurant and couldn't help myself once I saw they had donuts on display in the window. What started as me getting desert ended with me ordering a second dinner. Honestly, worth it! The pizza was crispy & delicious. I love that they use a brick oven for their pies. They also had a good amount of freshly baked deserts available which was a really nice touch. The donut I got wasn't my favorite but luckily everything else was good! read more

My main exercise during covid is going on long walks around Brooklyn and every time I'm on 7th ave I stop and stare at the window at all the beautiful and tasty looking pastries but then talk myself out of it because the whole point is exercise! Today I finally made a concerted effort to come out here and get one. I got the Nutella bomboloni which is a light and airy pastry covered in sugar with a core of Nutella on the inside. It was definitely tasty. The person I'm assuming was the owner was super friendly, as was the second staff member. I definitely walked away with a good feeling and I'll be back to try the pizza and more pastries soon. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Nutella bomboloni - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Our family stopped in here and were blown away! Nothing fancy in terms of the room, and it looks like they do more takeout than dining room. We sat down in the back and the guy running the place took great care of us. Service was quick and friendly. We ordered two appetizers, two medium pizzas, and a spinach salad. Everything was fresh and delicious. The tomato sauce with fresh basil was completely outrageous! There are other Italian dishes on the menu, but this place is by far the best New York pizza I've ever had, and maybe some of the best pizza I've had anywhere. (And I'm a Chicago pizza guy!) We'll come back whenever we visit Brooklyn again. Really a great spot! I only remember to leave reviews for memorable places. This is definitely as good as it gets! read more

See all

I'm not sure how my favorite cookie is from a pizza shop. Or how a pizza shop manages to make amazing Napoli?style pies AND bake fresh, delicious desserts. But somehow, Numero 28 has it all figured out. I wandered in here about a year ago and have enjoyed it every time since. The dessert in the window drew me in and seeing the Roman slices made me stay. The desserts are light, not too sweet, buttery perfection. I tried the bombolini yesterday. The yellow crème made me think (and hope) it was a lemon custard filling but it's vanilla. It still looked too good to pass. It's soft and airy. Like an improved Boston Kreme, but less dense and not as sweet. It's basically perfect. I had to try another dessert--it wasn't optional at this point. So I went with the Linzer and it's another delicate, buttery dessert perfection. But since it's a pizza shop, it's only right I get out of dessert rambling and at least address the pizza. The pizza is my Roman-style squares. I got a mushroom slice and a ricotta slice and both had a crispy, lightly oiled crust, lots of flavor and weren't too heavy. There's also a mini setup for outdoor seating that accommodates 4 if you don't want to take your slice to go. read more

See all

We've had a small/baby margharirta pie to go. It is ok, a bit too salty for my liking. Husband said it was too soggy. Not sure if I want to try anything else from there. Though people there seem nice and the employees are highly efficient. And the inside is very nice and inviting. But I would not make my way out there just fir this place. Only if perhaps we were already in the area. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - a person holding a menu in a car - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

FOUND A LARGE INSECT IN MY SALAD I've been eating here for years, and usually get the same meal....The arugula salad with shaved Parmesan and two slices of their delicious artisan pizza. Never, EVER had a problem with the food... EXCEPT TONIGHT I noticed something dark in the salad, and was repulsed to find a large insect in the bowl. I'm not an entomologist, but it looked like a roach. It could have been something else, but that's not the point. I calmly brought the plate to the girl behind the register and brought it to her attention. She was genuinely apologetic, and gave me my cash back for the salad....15 bucks. I told her I would never eat there again..... And I mean it ABW Brooklyn read more

Flavorful and great quick bites! Excellent pastries- including a Nutella filled croissant. The turkey sandwich is another flavor dense quick bite. Pizza is flavorful. read more

Another sunny day and another bicycle ride thru Park Slope. I noticed two Pizzeria's on the same block. Numero 28 had outdoor seating, so I gave it a try. I ordered one Mushroom slice, and one Grandma's slice. The Mushroom slice was crispy and the mushroom's were perfectly cooked. The sauce on the Grandma's slice was delicious. My bill for two slices and a bottle of Poland Spring water was $11.70. The value was $11.00. I'll be back. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

A decent place for a quick bite but definitely not as good as some of the other pizza places around the area. They have some cool pizza toppings but at $4 a slice, you're better off getting a pie if you have a few people with you. We ordered a small cheese pie for 2 kids and shared a spinach salad and chicken parm. The pizza looked good but when I tried to pick up a slice, it was way too soggy. Ugh...soggy pizza is the worst! The spinach salad was good and seemed fresh but they are stingy with the other ingredients. I can literally count how many apple slices (4) and walnuts (6) in it. For $12, that's a hefty price for some greens and sprinkles of cheese. The chicken parm was good, thankfully not dry but again, they are stingy with the cheese. I've always eaten chicken parm where the cheese is oozing as you cut into it. This one was just some cheese on top. Overall, a solid 3 star pizza place. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - spinach salad with apples and walnuts - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The pizza here is incredibly good! I honestly can't say enough good things! If you are into the think NYC slice this place is for you. I'm so picky about sauce in general and this place really hits the spot. Definitely worth every penny! Super fresh and staff is abiding by all safety protocols ! read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Yummyyy and the best staff!!! Come in big or small group, pizzas come in all sizes .. perfect for your group! Love the wine as well.

They use great pizza dough, and the cheese-to-sauce ratio makes the pizza flavorful and light. I ate a slice of Margherita right outside, because you can tell a lot about a place based on their "cheese slice" -- and I am happy to say they passed my test, and I would love to go back. I strolled by here at 11am after going to the bookshop and I had to go in when I saw they were putting cannolis and fresh baked goods out (haven't tried but want to). I wasn't expecting the place to be as spacious as it was, but there is a large seating section in the back. It seemed a little dark and lonely, so I took my pizza slice outside in the sunshine. A pizza maker, Daniel, was super sweet, and the host/server Stephanie was extremely informative about how much pizza would feed a party of 8. Just for them I wanted to get delivery but they are a touch overpriced. A whole Margherita pie is $30 and the pepperoni or "Diavola" pie is $38. For context, 2 Boots is $26 for their meatiest pie. I included the menu below since you might be able to sling the "dough." Overall, I think their per slice is the better option and well worth it. read more

See all

I have never had this kind of pizza delivered to me before? As you can see in the photo, the pizza came sopping wet and parts of the pizza were completely uncooked. I tried calling the restaurant and they didn't pick up. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Reginella - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Delicious Neapolitan pizza. We love the margarita, caramelized onion, and the sausage pizzas. Big slices with big flavors. The dough is thin and chewy with nice char. Try the Italian donuts and the fresh cannolis. We see kids eating the spaghetti and meatballs - looks good and have it on our list. read more

Good pizza. Don't get it delivered. They don't speak English and can't help you if you get a pizza delivered poorly. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

exceptionally rude. since there were no prices on anynfo the cakes in the front window i had to ask the price. the man behind the counter was extremelynrude and couldnt be bothered to even tell me. they dont deserve any customers if they have so little respect. read more

So I have mixed feelings on Numero 28 Pizzeria. It is possibly my favorite pizza to have delivered. The Reginella pizza is worth every penny more than the margherita pizza. However, I live on the other side of the park. The restaurant will sometimes deliver to my home and sometimes not deliver to my home. I'd be happy to pay or tip more for their great pizza but usually can't learn if they're delivering to me until I attempt to order it. That being said, if you don't have the same logistical struggles as I do- give them a shot, it takes a lot to impress me for pizza and Numero 28 certainly did. :) read more

I usually only have pizza one way.....with red sauce. But this spot has changed me. I love the tortufo pizza - mushrooms and truffle oil, no red sauce! I have yet to try the other pizza flavors because I keep ordering the tortufo every time I go. It's my top thin crust pizza spot in NY. The bomboleni are a nice treat for something a bit sweet afterwards. read more

See all

Reviewing this place is pretty simple. The pizza is consistently well baked and is packed with loads of amazing flavors and spices. Their pizzas are long ovals cut into squares rather than your average round pie cut into triangle slices. The slices are average size when push comes to shove and cost between $3.50 & $4.00. Whenever I'm in there are at least 5-8 options for pizza styles. The inside has ample seating in the back if you'd like to stay. It is not full table service but that suits this place well. The garlic knots were also really great and were 3 for a buck and they are BIG and slathered in garlic. There is a fairly big bathroom and it was clean when I was there today. Generally I just like the style of this places. The service is always kind and quick, and most of all the pizza is so delicious. Great lunch option if you find yourself needing to grab a quick lunch while visiting someone at Methodist hospital. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Grandma "slice" - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've been wanting to try the bomboloni here for YEARS, but I always walked by at weird times of day. I finally tried them and I was absolutely not disappointed! The pistachio bomboloni tasted exactly like ones I had last time in Italy, and the heart shape was really cute. I also tried a heart-shakes mascarpone bomboloni and it was even better than the pistachio -- loved the little dollop of jam on top. I'll definitely be coming back to try more desserts, and the pizza too. It looked like legit Italian street slices rather than Brooklyn-style pizza, which is a nice way to switch things up. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Pistachio and Mascarpone Bomboloni IG: @sheneedsasnack - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Wow, what more can you ask for!? Food is amazing, especially for the reasonable price. I tried the margarita pizza and pasta ala Norma and loved both. I particularly love the sauce on the pizza. Seems like they use high quality ingredients. I don't live in park slope but would definitely come back whenever I am! read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Best pizza by far in Park Slope. Tastes like pizza from Rome. Plus delivery To Prospect Heights!

I was strolling around this neighborhood and I saw this pizza place and we really wanted pizza. We went in and from the start the lady over the counter was very nice and helped us decided what kind of pizza we wanted. I got a pesto sliced pizza and my partner got a pepperoni we both enjoyed the pesto slice more it was delicious and unique. Great service they let you eat outside during this time or you can do take out to eat at home. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Perfect crust great texture just the right amount of oil. So far the best pizza in Park Slope, maybe all of NYC read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

They have such a large variety of things and everything is so good. From their pastries to their coffee to their pizza, my favorite place! Also the workers are very nice and there is a great seating area outside and inside. read more

Their pizzas are okay but please don't get their chalkboard specials. Their chickpea soup ($8.50) is...half a can of chickpeas in hot water. It was disgusting. And their lasagna ($15) was mediocre at best. The layers peeled apart easily, and there was barely any cheese. A small portion as well. The only thing worth getting here is their pesto pizza, and even then it's pricey and sometimes not that fresh. There's better pizza in the area. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Just the rudest person I've ever dealt with over the phone that evidently makes the pizza. When I called explaining that they had made a mistake on our order--they had us paying for larger pizzas than delivered--whoever it was speaking in Italian to the poor girl on the phone with me thought I didn't understand what he was saying (too bad I'm also Italian!). He didn't care that it was wrong, he told her that we had to deal with it and would absolutely not offer in any way to rectify his "mistake", if it even was a mistake. So, since he wasn't even decent enough to talk to me directly on the phone, I asked the girl to kindly pass on the message in Italian AND in English that we will not be doing business again with them. read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - This is NOT a 14" pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Really quality ingredients shine through in Numero 28's pizzas. The dough, sauce, and cheese taste so fresh and so well proportioned that we rarely add toppings. At first the prices may seem a bit steep, especially if you order a small or medium pie (the large is very much worth the extra $2 more than the medium), but it's worth it. I haven't tried any of the pastries yet but they look pretty tempting. We're so glad to have great pizza in the neighborhood. read more

Discovered this hidden gem today! Everything here looks so good, it was so difficult to decide!!! We had delicious pastries and pizza. No pics because we were famished, but trust us...it was all delicious!!! Definitely recommend it!! read more

They do amazing pastries and pizza! I like this place. It's very nice and cozy. Good service and stuff. Thank you for your service.

Thank God I found this New Pizza shop in my neighborhood. The pizza is brick oven backed, they have have many options to choose from, all made with fresh ingredients. This is not your ordinary Brooklyn Pizza, it's more like Tuscany in Brooklyn. The best part about this pizza shop is that they sell brick oven pizza by the slice. They have fresh pasta available, which I have yet to try. The potato croquettes are a must try. Friendly staff. read more

See all

Finally real italian food in park slope! From the second I walked into this restaurant I knew I would be back ! The pizza is really sensational ! Like in Italy! Great thin crust that has taste and toppings that don't crush it! The pastas are also great! But try their delicious soups! The entire management deserves a hug ! They are friendly, polite and very kind. Which is rare these days. Real food. Real people! Fabulous addition for park slope that had crappy pizza ;) read more

Numero 28 Pizzeria - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Went here late in the evening on a Tuesday and sat in the back. I shared a small Margherita pizza, Parma salad, and montepulciano wine. The waitress brought us some toasted bread to go with our salad and that was a nice touch. Everything was made quickly and was so fresh and well plated. The salad had so many lovely flavors and textures. The bread was so light and fluffy, and the pizza was well cooked- although maybe a little too much as 1 corner was black, but I don't really mind that especially at the end of the day when the pizza ovens have been hot all day. It was such a pleasant experience for just picking the first pizzeria We saw on the block. We felt like we were transported back to Italy. read more