My fiance and I stopped here on a particularly rainy night on the cape and it was your typical sports bar vibes with jaws theme, it wasn't too loud and the service was great the bartenders were very fast and nailed every drink and order, which was amazing especially given how busy it was. We ordered the great white pizza add pepperoni, and in the words of my fiance this was a top 5 pizza he ever had, and I agree- it was delicious, thin crust, perfectly cooked, perfect fold, very very good pizza, will definitely recommend read more

Pizza Shark Chatham - The great white add pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Perfect for a rainy day takeout dinner on game night. We got the megalodon, nurse shark, thresher shark, and tiger shark.

Crust was too chewy for us, not crispy at all. It is very popular with great reviews. Pepperoni and a plain cheese. read more

Purchased pizza in 2025. Tastes great, tough crust. Purchased pizza in 2026, tastes great tougher crust. Getting worse. read more

Really cute little Jaws themed pizza spot in downtown Chatham. The entrance is on the back side of the building from the main street (in the parking lot). Many innovative topping options, gluten free crust available plus salad and sandwich options. We got chopped and wedge salad, both great. All the pizza was fantastic. They even have Jaws pinball. Perfect spot for a rainy day before or after a movie (theater is in the same building, just around the other side). read more

We noticed the sign outside and went to check out Pizza Shark. It's a pizza and sandwich place with a bar. We had a classic BLT, a small Texas , and a small Sand Shark which is a breakfast pizza. The small has 6 slices. Everything was delicious! Thin crust and good proportion of toppings. Lexie took care of us and was very friendly. She even checked for a medium white Tshirt for me for my son. There is also a movie theater in the building. It's got a good vibe there. read more

See all

Lunch at Pizza Shark with our Family, first time for my Wife and I, I will definitely be back, I got a Great White Pizza, it was delicious and so good, Wife got Cheese and she loved it, we had Leftovers. Definitely a great Pizza Joint.....10 out of 10 read more

See all

Another one that I'd rate 3.5 stars if available. Located inside of the movie theater. Pizza was okay. Service was kind of lacking. read more

See all

Pizza is our go to whenever we are in Chatham so the food is great the atmosphere is cool but the wait even when there is barely anyone in there is very long. Waiting at the door for 5 minutes before I was noticed and there was only 4 people seated at the counter and then waited another 5 min before someone came over to the table . But aside from that it's a great pizza shop!! read more

Pizza Shark Chatham - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Pie is first class and is delicious and has a very great finish. Better ingredients, better pizza. Period.

great pizza but the music was straight ah, my taste buds were happy but my ear drums werent. cool place overall but the aux was terrible.

The atmosphere is very relaxing and the food is really good especially their pizza. It is inside the Orpheum movie theater in Chatham.

We came here a lot this summer, frequenting the downstairs bar, Quint's. I recommend eating in over taking out, and the pizza is good, but we found it overall a bit inconsistent. Sometimes the garlic is under the cheese, sometimes it's on top, sometimes you get extra cheese when you order it, sometimes you do not. A little concerned overhearing from someone sitting at the bar that the bartenders don't get tips left on credit cards! We made sure to pay cash from then on. Wish we knew earlier, because service was always so great at the bar! It's definitely a great pizza option in town, and we always have a really great time at the bar, it's small, so everyone ends up very social, great way to meet people. The chicken parm sub and Cuban sandwiches were pretty good too, delicious bread. If you're picking up your pizza, go to the Orpheum lobby, you can't get it from downstairs unless you're ordering it there at the bar. The upstairs bar is small, but friendly service there, too! read more

See all

Went to PS in late August for some quick pizza as we walked through beautiful downtown Chatham. The pizza was great - we tried the Sand Shark which was fun because it was slightly before lunch time (it's a breakfast pizza). The service was great and the space was clean. The reason I'm writing this review is because my son lost his wallet while we were in PS (although he didn't know it at the time). We'd just been golfing and assumed he'd lost it out on the course - we spent hours re tracing our steps. The wallet itself was special to him because we'd bought it on a trip a few years ago. Yesterday a package arrived from Pizza Shark - his wallet fully intact - credit cards, cash, IDs and his lucky $2 bill --- along with a really nice note. Good pizza and good people are hard to find... Pizza Shark has both!!! Thank you. read more

I finally tried Pizza Shark for a quick lunch. One cheese slice. I am really into good pizza and found this just ok. Not hot enough. Not flavorful enough in terms of how I like pizza sauce. The cheese ratio was good however. Still convenient when enjoying a shopping trip in pretty downtown Chatham. Orpheum Theater overall adds a nice bit of culture here too. read more

Pizza Shark Chatham - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

$12 for a small cheese pizza for the little guy was a win. Pizza was delicious and the price was great. We also enjoyed a brownie from the corner. We will add this to our vacation takeout routine. read more

Visited during our summer vacation and was very impressed by what we assumed was a run of the mill pizza shop. The inside is amazing; connected to a theater with a beautiful cinema mural on the wall. It was so fun sitting with our family and trying to identify the characters and movies on the mural while we waited. They even gave us a cheat sheet at the end to help those we missed. Food was quick. Pizza was very good. The ricotta pizza was exquisite! My husband and I got chicken parm subs, which were fine. Good portion size for the price but sort of basic. Service was a little lackluster; you go up to the bar to order, so they don't really engage with you until you engage with them. However, it was a great experience overall for a quick bite. read more

Really great veggie pizza! The only thing that bums me out? Is no delivery within Chatham? Nice and clean inside. Has a great local feel!

Pizza Shark is a true gem of Chatham and delivers on pizza, friendliness, and a charming setting that doubles down on the shark theme. The pizza was true quality with generous helpings and fresh toppings - the Loan Shark was piled high with tasty meats and vegetables and we had leftovers - one slice. The owner and staff were great and accommodating. read more

Solid pizza place inside a movie theater! The hot chili oil is delicious and the dough is very chewy - love read more

Tried Pizza Shark on our trip to the Cape and we were very pleasantly surprised. We live in NYC so we are pizza snobs. We needed an easy pick up option so we decided to try it - and we loved it! read more

Solid place to grab a pie or slice! It is kind of hidden in the corner of a movie theater - Has a cool vibe to it! Service was easy and fast. I got the Megaladon (meat lovers). I'd recommend getting meatball, but not the whole meat lovers. read more

See all

Last night on the cape and we always struggle with getting a pizza order in Orleans. Saw Pizza Shark in Chatham and ordered a cheese pizza and wedge salad. Easy online order and ready on time for pick up. Wedge salad was amazing - I had with the Italian dressing and it was just the right amount of bacon, cheese and fresh lettuce to accompany my pizza. Pizza was thin crust and not greasy - not my usual NY style but still good! read more

Phenomenal pizza. Fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. We are very picky about our pizza and Pizza Shark goes above and beyond!

Food was awesome, we had a Deep Blue Pizza, Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, pulled pork, and Chicken Parmesan sandwiches. There was a fun atmosphere, and our waitress was great! read more

The lady working the cashier and taking orders was extremely rude. They definitely need someone with better customer service skills.

The food was amazing, best pizza on the cape. We stayed a week and got two pizzas. Cozy place! Only a star off because the bar tender was rude and seemed annoyed read more

As the busy season wind downs in Chatham we visited Pizza Shark for takeout on a rainy day when many restaurants have started to close. You pick up inside the Orpheum movie theater right on Main Street. We got an wedge salad and the Great White with chili oil. Inside was one of the cleanest restaurants i've seen with a couple tables and some bar seats. Couple employees working hard were very nice. We took it home and it was fantastic! Crust was thin but not too thin. Wasn't floppy and was crispy but also chewy just perfect. Ricotta was yummy with the chili oil. Fresh ingredients and these people clearly know ingredients it's not your typical cheapo cardboard cheese pizza. Inside the restaurant smelled great and they have wine and beer options for draft. You should visit because restaurants like this deserve business. Next time I wanna get takeout and take it to the beach Only note that I would give to the owner is more dressing for the wedge salad. It was a very small amount with chunks of cheese so we couldn't adequately cover our salad but they can totally improve that. I refuse to give a lower star value just over something small that can easily be improved. read more

Pizza Shark Chatham - Great White Shark pizza all their pizzas are named after sharks. - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

Friendly service and good hours. Pretty good pizza for something quick and inexpensive.

We grabbed two pies and a tuna sandwich to go. The great white pie was phenomenal and my tuna hit the spot. It's the perfect place to get something quick, especially with kids. read more

Possibly the best cheese pizza I've ever had! Ordered door dash after a long drive to our VRBO and it was well worth it!

Good pizza and an awesome location. For their small locale, they pump out a decent pie. If you need something easy like a pizza, there is no better in town. read more

Decent pizza relative to other pizza spots in the area. The pizza tastes good but was pretty oily. I think the best part is the ambiance - there's movie screenings and fresh popcorn being popped the whole time. Pretty cool place to watch a movie and get some decent pizza! read more

Grabbed dinner before seeing a movie at the theater it's connected to. Delicious pizza! There was only one person running the bar and tables, so it got pretty busy, but she managed it as best she could. Would definitely go back! read more

Pizza Shark Chatham - Great White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

YASSSSSS. Larry and I were walking down the main shopping drag in Chatham when we did a double take upon seeing a sign propped up on the sidewalk advertising "Pizza Shark" and "slices." I love pizza. I love sharks. So why not? We ordered a slice of the Great White to share and oh boy. We were stunned that this delicious pizza came from a little kiosk in the movie theater. It was also sitting in one of those warming-ovens for who knows how long before it was reheated and handed to us on a paper plate, and it was still really good! Try it if you haven't already! read more

Great service. Good pizza and drinks. Perfect spot for an afternoon snack while strolling in Chatham.

So, you are in downtown Chatham and looking for a quick, cheap meal or snack? This is a great option, rather than an overpriced sandwich elsewhere. The pizza is good. Setting is pretty nifty; the lobby of a small movie theater. Best past about it other than all that, was a welcoming dude behind the bar that really sold the pie. Great service! read more

See all

Pizza Shark has changed my life. Looking for something to eat after visiting the Chatham Shark Museum and randomly pulled into a public space and Pizza Shark was behind us, calling out to us. Pizza. Shark. Great branding and delicious pizza. Ordered several small pies from the lower take-out area and then went upstairs to its seated area/bar and movie theater combination. Pizza was handed over to us from the bar when ready and enjoy it we did. Pizza. Shark. Pizza Shark. read more

Pizza Shark Chatham - Souvenirs, sharks, and pizza!!! - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Very tasty pizza in a cute location. Ordered a great white (with chili oil) and a wedge salad to go. The man at the counter offered plates and silverware, which we were thankful for dining back in our hotel room. Pizza h it the spot! read more

Best pizza in Chatham, not really saying much but it is good and noticeably better than some of the others I've tried.