We made a reservation here during our visit to Chatham, and we enjoyed sitting outside on their patio and people watching on the road. The inside looked very cute though - would have enjoyed seeing the ambiance in there as well! We started with wines and soup - the French onion was delightful, and the clam chowder was good as well. We each ordered cod - me the baked cod, and my friend the fish and chips. Both were good, filling meals, nothing extra special but definitely did the job. Next time I think we'd try the Chatham Squire, but this was a nice spot for a meal on a summer evening. read more

See all

Large indoor and outdoor spaces, happy faces on the patrons... Half dozen beers on tap, high hopes for a nice light lunch and we were not disappointed. Kind and efficient, hard working staff. Would definitely return when we are in the area. read more

The Wild Goose Tavern - Friendly bar area - New American Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

mixed feelings on the wild goose tavern... I took a chance with the reviews saying the food was good but service was lack luster.. I definitely agree. I got the French onion soup that was awesome, and the Brie and fig flatbread which was pretty good too I sat outside and there were some other tables sat there too. We all waited awhile for the waiter to stop by throughout our meals... nice gentleman but definitely was hard to catch. read more

The Wild Goose Tavern - half of the Brie and fig flatbread which - New American Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

EXTREMELY upset to be writing this review. I was overcharged $40 on my credit card and reached out to the establishment multiple times to get this straightened out. I left a $31 cash tip (20%) and was still charged $40 additional to my bill. When I called, I was put on hold each time, which is fine, but was told the manager (who I was informed is new, as if that matters in this situation) would call me back within 5 minutes. Never heard a peep. I do not live in the area, or else I would have just gone in person to figure things out since phone calls were clearly not working. I ended up having to call my bank to dispute the charge. Just a complete waste of my time and a very frustrating situation to be in overall. Truly a WILD GOOSE CHASE and I hope others do not have to go through this. read more

The place is spacious, beautiful and CLEAN. The restaurant is in an Inn, and on the super busy main street in Chatham - no matter the time of year. Our preferred places were booked and WGT was open for reservations, so why not? Solid bar and a decent wine list, nice staff. Bar staff is a hoot! The fish and chips were REALLY good... and here is where this place falls off a star for me a bit - the cost and quality of some items leaves a lot to the imagination = the lobster quesadilla. Not lacking in flavor. But for $20+ it was lacking lobster. Not cool folks. I understand its a tourist town. But if you are going to charge that, make sure the lobster has some "me time" in every bite. It is pricey. It's Chatham on the Cape after all. Pub meets bistro, it is an up scale grub place, with a tad of snootiness but down-to-earth people. Try the Goose fries - presented elegantly its one of those "kitchen-sinky" types of get dirty and enjoy dishes (they can fry well!) read more

A nice place to stop on Main Street, with outdoor seating as well as very spacious indoor seating. We happened to wander in at a good time and were able to get a table for 7. Decent selection of local and other beers, and the service was efficient and helpful. Lots of votes for the calamari and the coconut shrimp. The lobster roll was pricey (as they are everywhere on the island), but it was well received. Fish and chips were a little greasy, but tasty. The lobster quesadilla was more like stacked tostadas but the crema and the filling were excellent. Small-ish bar if you want to sit and have a drink. read more

See all

Waste of a Valentines Day evening. Made a reservation for 8PM a week in advance. Arrived at 7:50ish - check in , and was informed that things are running a bit behind and we would need to wait about 25 minutes to be seated but could sit at the bar while we waited and would receive a text message when our table is ready. No problem. 25 minutes comes and goes. Then 45. Then 1 hour. No tap on the shoulder "We are so sorry we are still running behind" , nothing. Zero communication. 9:30 PM as of this review and no text. Not that it matters - we are already home. So we miss out on Valentines dinner that we reserved a week ahead , we miss out on any other local spots being open. PLEASE BE TRANSPARENT ABOUT AN EXTENDED WSIT RIGHT AWAY!!! I know we were not the only couple that had this experience tonight. Several other frustrated couples were sat at the bar also wondering when their time would come. I absolutely DO NOT blame any of the hosts, hostesses , bartenders , or wait staff . BUT PLEASE , management ... DO NOT ACCEPT RESERVATIONS THAT YOU CANNOT HONOR!!! Edit : 10PM now and we are laughing at the lack of text. Were we EVER going to be seated ? read more

After walking into the Squire after a shop owner told us it was "cute" in there, we quickly left and came to this beautiful restaurant for lunch. The Squire was a total dump. Moving on, we sat at the bar here and the bartender was very nice. Amazing Bloody Mary. Excellent chicken sandwich. Came on toasted cranberry bread with Brie and arugula and cranberry mayo. Delicious. Excellent fries with Cajun seasoning. Just the right amount of crisp. Very nice place. Boyfriend got the fish tacos. He was happy with the amount of fish in his and loved the fries as well. read more

The Wild Goose Tavern - Bloody Mary - New American Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

The food and ambience are great. The staff are very friendly and helpful, very knowledgeable about the menu.

Last Thursday night my family and I went to the Wild Goose Tavern and had a wonderful experience. First, we were greeted by the kindest hostess Abby. While it was busy and chaotic, she welcomed us with the warmest smile and made us feel so welcome. Then our food was okay but the service was phenomenal. The food took a little longer than I normally would like in a fine dining restaurant but the entire staff was very accommodating and they offered us drinks and bread while we waited. Wouldn't return for the food but instead for the kind people. read more

Wonderful choice for a dinner inside or outside on the veranda! Fabulous food, creative drinks, great ambience. We have frequented The Wild Goose many times and always have a wonderful time , outstanding service and a great time! read more

The service is very good, the ambiance is lovely, and the food is excellent. I had the NY Strip with bacon bleu cheese compound butter, mashed potatoes, and asparagus. The steak was nicely charred and tender. My husband had the vegetable risotto with lobster. He is still talking about it! (If you have a Jeep, be sure to visit Ducks in the Window across the street!) read more

We are currently staying at the Inn attached to the restaurant. We arrived on time and we're greeted promptly and seated by the lovely hostess. Our waiter came over quickly and took our drink order. Juan Carlos was a very attentive and kind waiter. My husband got the fried clams and I got baked cod. Both were fantastic! My cod was cooked perfectly and the veggies on the side were well seasoned and delicious. We both got a cocktail (or two!) and the drinks were strong and tasty. One of the best French 75's I've ever had. The decor was old cape cod style, and the vibe was laid back and not too touristy. Everyone we encountered was friendly and helpful. The restaurant was clean and well maintained. We will definitely be back. read more

The Wild Goose Tavern - French 75 and traditional old fashioned - New American Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Very disappointed to see what has happened to a once solid dinner choice. To start off with the service it is extremely slow. The oysters are still a solid choice here and so are the clams on the half shell. The steak was cooked almost to my liking and had decent seasoning. However, the mashed potatoes that paired with that strip steak were pathetic. They tasted as if someone had boiled potatoes, mashed and threw them on the plate. There was no taste of cream, butter and let alone salt. I had to return with a salt lashing after another. Atleast 7 times I had to re salt the potato's after tasting. I also heard about 4 things drop to the floor in the restaurant by the end of the night read more

Service was horrible. Food never came out after 2.5 hours. We left. Manager did not handle the situation at all

Service was 5/5 Ambiance was 4/5 Food was a mixed bag Drinks were 5/5 Service was quick. Our waiter was friendly and professional. We had a larger party (9 people) which can be difficult to manage! We were seated instead in what seemed to be a large hallway/room that connected a larger banquet-type area and the bar/main restaurant. Drinks were stellar! Food as mention was mixed... the lobster bisque was the best we've ever had, and the lobster BLT was delicious! The calamari was cold, and the short rib was chunks of beef (we expected more of a pulled pork texture). We would return, likely for apps and drinks instead. read more

See all

Terrible service for our dinner tonight. Waitress barely greeted us and asked "what can I get you." Did not mention specials or take drink orders or app orders first. Did not bring us plates or utensils (we had to ask after apps out). Did not bring us bread (we had to ask after noticing many tables had bread and butter). Never filled our waters. Served me lobster with no claw cracker (I had to remind her that I needed this tool) to open claws, no butter, no hand wipes to clean up after eating. She told me that she didn't "load up the plate". She also said some people don't want bread so she didn't ask us. We waited a long time for the food ( no bread or even visit from our waitress to explain why the wait was so long). Lobster and fries - nice plate and delicious but served lukewarm. Hamburger - under seasoned. Lobster Mac and cheese great. Cioppino stew was mediocre. Loved the clam chowder and Brussels sprout appetizer. Overall food good, not great. Service really bad. read more

The food here was great, and atmosphere was special as well for a fun night in the cape. Staff was extremely friendly and helpful and everything was delicious. Would come back! read more

See all

Showed up at 4:40 with a party of 8. Was initially told by the hostess that our party of 8 could not sit outside (there was not one table seated). Asked if we could split into two parties of 4 and was told no but was then told we could sit in two parties of 4 if we had separate checks and we agreed. Then waited until 5 to sit because we were told the dinner menu didn't start until 5, even though other parties were sat before 5. Then waited until 5:15 for our server. Server was very nice. Entrees were inedible. Check came and (shockingly!), we were given one bill despite the orders from the (rude) hostess. One of the worst restaurant meals I have ever eaten for $550+ for four kids and four adults. Never again! read more

The service was really nice but our food took a long time to come out and the restaurant was not that busy. The restaurant itself is very nice and in a great area. For a $47 lobster roll i expected more, the flavor was fine but needed something. I was disappointed that the sides came in plastic and not a dish. I also had the clam chowder and it was just ok. just too expensive for what it's worth read more

The Wild Goose Tavern - Lobster roll - New American Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Do not come here! We made our 8:30 reservation for outdoors to watch people on Main Street, but upon arrival, they sat us indoors in the very back of the restaurant. The host brought no drink menu, no specials, and our waiter did not come over for ten minutes. We ordered drinks and food, but forty minutes later we had not even received our drinks. When we explained our frustration, neither the host nor our waiter apologized for the delay. The food was extremely mediocre. Soup came out cold, the burger they brought me had cheese even when I didn't order cheese, etc. It was not busy enough at all for this to be happening, in fact there were many empty tables. The long wait time, wrong seating, wrong order, and dismissive service left a bad taste and I would not go out of my way. So many other restaurants we've been to this trip (Del Mar) and (Buca's) knocked it out of the park. read more

The perfect people watching spot. Love everything about the recent renovations. Such a beautiful restaurant right on Chathams main drag. The food was delicious. The service was great for somewhat off season. Loved the lobster bisque with a heaping portion of lobster on top. Perfectly large shrimp cocktail. Wonderful rosè! Great drink options. I cannot wait to return! read more

See all

Horrible experience with the Thanksgiving buffet $95/person. We made a reservation but no tables available when we arrived. Never got one. Are at the bar. No turkey in the buffet line, oysters were green and sticky, food quality OK, but not nearly worth the $95 price. Staff was unapologetic and had no idea when or if a table would become available. Drinks way over priced. Dessert ok, overall, very dissatisfied and will never go back there. read more

The food here was actually pretty solid, but the service left a lot to be desired. We waited almost two hours for our entrees, and the restaurant wasn't that busy. The biggest issue was how they handled a food allergy in our group. We made it very clear to the waitress, but it was ignored, and someone ended up having an allergic reaction. That's a serious mistake that should not be happening. This was not worth the high cost of everything on the menu! read more

Our visit didn't meet the standards you'd expect from a place like this. Both our service and quality of food were lacking. Dinner started off good with the Fried Brussels Sprouts. They were cooked and seasoned perfectly. There was some miscommunication between our server and the kitchen afterwards that resulted in a very long wait between appetizers and dinner. The restaurant was fairly dead by the time we were sat around 7:20 on a Saturday, and still our party of 6 waited more than an hour between courses. When dinner finally arrived, it wasn't what you'd expect. The Goose Burger I ordered was flavorless and a ball of grease. Extremely rarely do I not take home leftovers, but I left most of the burger and fries here. Others in our party thought their meals were so-so, but not befitting the price charged. My wife was happy with her Caesar Salad, to which she added grilled chicken. The restaurant compensated for the long wait time with 3 free desserts for our party. We ordered the Flourless Chocolate Cake, which was decent, and 2 of the Crème Brulee. The brulee came out as sugar-topped scrambled eggs. With tip, our meal came to $300. We had much better meals on this trip for far less. If I happen to be in Chatham again, I'd skip this place. read more

The Wild Goose Tavern - Caesar Salad with chicken - New American Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

This restaurant in beautiful. It has a nice bar area, a spacious dining area, outdoor area and even live music. We started off with drinks at the bar which were promptly served with a decent amount of alcohol. Cocktails were fun and tasty. Wine was a decent pour. The food, unfortunately missed the mark: The clam chowder should have been called potato chowder. There were three small clam pieces in the cup. Wicked scam! The quahogs were not palatable. They had a weird sticky consistency and a starchy taste. Cheeseburger tasted odd. It had a watery texture consistent with being in the freezer for too long. They did have large salads that were much to big for one person and I am told a decent baked fish. Prices were high. Quality was low. We could be persuaded to come here for a drink but we would never eat here again. read more

Do not eat here! The resturant was empty and we waited an hour and a half for our food. The waitress's attitude was bad. She didn't return once to refill our drinks during the hour and half that we waited. When she eventually brought our food, l the order was wrong...When she brought the check, it was wrong. So we had to wait again for the correct bill. When we spoke with the manager about our experience, she barely said sorry and didn't offer to make anything right, not even a comped appetizer. (we weren't looking for anything free, however we are both in the service industry our concerns were not handled correctly) In summary: Our food was very expensive, the food tasted bad, and service was horrible. read more

When checking in with the hostess to get a table, the hostess and waitress were trying to figure out table numbers and seemed confused about who sits where and what table numbers are called what. Eventually seated and got a meal with a side of roasted potatoes which came with no toppings so I asked for butter to put on them. Waiter brought butter back 10+ minutes later so the potatoes were cold and just had them returned so I did not have any. The table I sat at rocked back-and-forth because not level. Disappointing because nice location and not bad ambience but would not recommend spending the money here. read more

Despite the poor Yelp reviews, we decided to give this place a chance. When we arrived at 1:09 PM, the restaurant was quite empty, and they quickly seated our party of 11. Unfortunately, the service was terrible. The waitress often forgot our drinks and drink refills, requiring us to get up several times to remind her. We waited an hour and 20 minutes for our food, and when it finally arrived, the server brought out extra dishes we hadn't ordered. Additionally, a cup of chowder we requested with our meals was missing. We noticed we were charged for the additional items when we received the bill. After asking to speak with the manager, she removed the extra charges. Still, she included a mandatory gratuity since our party had more than eight people, despite the poor service and unsatisfactory food. To make matters worse, the manager did not personally bring out the adjusted bill or apologize; she had the waitress deliver it instead. We left the restaurant after 3:15 PM, far later than intended. Due to this experience, we will avoid any restaurant with a three-star rating in the future! read more

The ambiance is up-scale, you'll likely need a reservation. The service was excellent! Our waiter was attentive, friendly, and accommodating. The food was good. I ordered the calamari and lobster macaroni and cheese. The calamari was okay, but the lobster mac was awesome! Definitely recommend the macaroni and cheese. Check it out if you're looking for something a little fancier. read more

The Wild Goose Tavern - Calamari - New American Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

Nice spot to grab a snack or a drink. They were pretty busy and they closed around 8 on Sunday night in the summer. We sat at the bar and got some cocktails which were very good. Highly recommend the spicy Margarita. Calamari was decent but not fantastic. I'd go back. read more

The Wild Goose Tavern - Calamari - New American Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

It's a good location if hungry while shopping. I would say go for early dinner for their better menu options. 5pm is when they have the dinner menu. Drinks overpriced for their pour. The food is good but nothing to get too excited about. Fish is fresh but a little spendy for what you get IMO. Our server was very friendly and always had everything we need. If you can get a table outside on the front porch you will have a good spot. read more

We ended up here for lunch after the Chatham Squire crapped the bed on service. The food was very good with some of the best clam chowder ever. Service was friendly, prompt, and sincere. Very nice and clean restaurant with great food. read more

The last few dinners we've had at Wild Goose have been disappointing, sadly. It's a great location and the bar has been redone nicely but the dinner entrees have been bland and unappetizing. We also had a few cocktails that were nothing like the actual cocktail. Lunch sandwiches and the chowder are good, but I'd avoid dinner. read more

Service was abominable. I asked the waiter for a package of sweetener, it never came. Ordered the chicken salad sandwich--the toast was cold, as if it had been toasted hours earlier. Chicken salad was good. Fries were outstanding. Salad is ok. Two and a half hours for lunch is far too long. The server was not friendly; he was not approachable or knowledgeable or personable. I'm in no hurry to go back. read more

the service was awful, food was okay. the place is HUGE but it seemed as if they were understaffed, letting too many people in that didn't have a reservation, and they WEREN'T BUSING THEIR TABLES. our waitress was a sweet girl but the kitchen was so backed up that everyone in the whole restaurant had this stressed/tired/exhausted look on their face because of how long the service was taking. quick list of things i took notice of: - hostesses were so stressed looking - bread was given to us about 30 mins after we sat - had to ask for refills on water - multiple families either leaving because service was taking so long or asking/getting frustrated with how long the service was taking - busing was not even occurring, it was just people assigned to kind of just put glasses on tables where people had left?? - atmosphere in the restaurant was very heavy feeling, only people at the bar looked happy lol i'm only giving this a 2 star review because the food was semi-good. overall, save your money, the food is very expensive. read more

Ate here on a Wednesday afternoon and was seated under a tent in the back of the restaurant. There were many empty tables inside and asked the hostess if we could sit inside. She said the tables were all reserved. When we finished with our lunch, the place was completely empty and the tables were saw previously were still empty. At least the food was good and waitress is good was well. Poor service by the hostess and will not come back. read more

Waited on the waitlist for 50 minutes for no reason. We did not get the notification that our table was ready because "sometimes the system does that" We were then put at a table and waited 10 minutes to be greeted by anybody. At that point we put drinks and food in on the spot bc we waited so long that we knew what we wanted. Took an hour and a half to even get sat and drinks took 20*. They close in 10 minutes in our food is so where close to be being out in the kitchen. read more

Not sure if this place is under new management, but it has gone downhill! I go to this restaurant every year while on vacation and have never had issues in the past. Waited 15-20 minutes with my toddler before notifying the hostess that no one has come over to greet us. Then waited another 10 minutes after that to put in an order. The restaurant was NOT busy and by the time we got our food my daughter was fussy from waiting so long, I had to take it to go! I remember this place being packed and used to have exceptional service. Given some of the reviews in the past month, they need to get their act together. As much as I used to love this place, I will not be returning.. food is too expensive for terrible service. read more

the food here was honestly amazing -- super fresh and packed with flavor. definitely the highlight of the whole experience. the wait was a bit longer than expected, and the service was fine but nothing special. still, the quality of the food made up for it. great atmosphere too. i'd definitely come bac read more