The food here never changes been coming here for a while over 10 years. This pizza and the sandwiches are awesome today I picked up one chicken palm and one eggplant palm there were awesome sandwiches. I live in Spring Hill and we don't have a pizzeria that makes sandwiches or pizza like this place I wish people were here about you guys Services great the guys there it's all men is awesome. They cook good they're very nice friendly from New York and they know their stuff they have pictures of a couple of celebrities on the wall but other than that, this place is really placed really good place to go try you'll like it. I wish I would've took pictures of his place to show people out here in Spring Hill but my name is Frank and I definitely be back again. Cause this place is the number one spot to go. read more

Good food. Great service. Nice and friendly staff. Atmosphere is ok. I love the baked ziti and the pizzas.

This pizzeria has been my favorite for over 10 years. The last few times Ive been here there is always an issue. I will still go there but it wont be my only pizza spot. After a couple bad experiences I guess its time to branch out and try a new place. read more

Disappointing to walk in and be told it's going to be over an hour wait for any food because they had to make 40 pies. Drove over 30 mins to try this place. read more

Garlic Parm Pizza with sausage added is perhaps the best pizza I've ever had. Wonderful!

This is now my favorite place. The guy who answers the phone is extremely pleasant and makes it actually fun to order your food. The pizza is excellent. I am a pizza snob from Philly.... The food is like your Italian mom made it . Not fancy ,not spicy ... just right read more

This is by far a hidden gem! Went Sunday w my friend this was a request from my friend who is currently recovering from being sick. This made my heart happy to enjoy wonderful tasty NY style pizza!! I know I will be back for sure. The pizza extra cheese XL was amazing very flavorful. The meatballs were wonderful. I will definitely be back soon Pizza Suprema this was a great surprise driving from Tampa. This is a true family owned pizza place and they treat you like a friend read more

The best pizza in ALL OF FLORIDA!! I'm sorry I lied... it's the best EVERYTHING Italian in all of Florida!! Try anything on the menu and it will become your new favorite Italian spot in Land o Lakes, Lutz, Tampa... anywhere! The zeppoli's, ?fuuggheeddabbbooouuuutt it! Top notch! Service was outstanding and this tiny pizza shop should be on triple D !!! Come get you some! ( Sorry no pics.. we ate too fast to care!) read more

First of all, you have to understand, that you need to be from New York, preferably Bronx or Brooklyn, to understand why this place is so great. In New York it's always all about the food. The quality of the food needs to be the first consideration everything else is just convenience. Well, Pizza Suprema fits the bill perfectly. When you want a slice of pizza that's exactly like you expect from a good Italian, New York pizzeria, this is the place to go. End of story. Whether you're getting a slice of pizza or an entire pizza it's always hot and delicious. The crust is cooked through the cheese is great, the sauce that they use is just the right house made pizzeria sauce. And now to the crust, my father always said that the crust should be able to stand alone as good crispy on the outside soft in the middle Italian bread. Well, I will tell you, their crust is perfect. When you eat a piece of pizza and you're done with the toppings and cheese, don't forget the crust. The crust goes perfectly like a fresh made breadstick with a house salad with oil and vinegar. The crust is just something not to be missed. And it's the basis of all good pizzas. i've been coming to this place for almost 20 years now. As a matter of fact, it was one of the the deciding factors for us when looking for a home and realizing that Pizza Suprema was right around the corner within walking distance. If you want great New York style pizza, or dinner, dishes, like spaghetti, meatballs (Nonna Lena's original recipe!), veal Parmesan, meatball sub, or anything like that without all the fuss, this is the place for you. I guarantee you will love it! read more

amazing pizza!!! the best!! our new go to service was also very good. will be back, soon best in town read more

Pizza Suprema - PIZZA SUPREMA IS THE BEST.. OUT NEW GO TO - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

Pizza is always fantastic. So are the other items. Food is always fresh, even the non-Italian dishes. Fun to listen to the banter too

Our first time ordering Pizza Suprema and it did not disappoint! They were polite and friendly when I called to order and when I went by to pick it up. We got a large cheese pizza (and it's definitely LARGE!) and I got a Greek salad, that was also big enough that I have leftovers for lunch tomorrow. read more

See all

The food is delicious. They have a broad menu including dishes other than pizza, especially pasta. In particular, they have a seafood platter pasta dish that is excellent. It is a small business and not really suited for dining inside, although they do have a few tables. However, takeout is the better option. read more

When I called to order, I got a friendly voice that made sure my order was correct. This is great NY pizza too. Plenty of toppings and it did not disappoint. Another good thing is I live about a 1/2 mile from this location. It will be my new go-to place for pizza! read more

After relocating to Land O' Lakes a few years ago, we sampled numerous pizzerias in search of authentic New York-style pizza, but none met our expectations. Despite frequently passing by Pizza Suprema, the timing was never right to stop in. Today, we finally decided to give it a try, and we're delighted we did. The pizza not only embodied true New York style but was exceptional--possibly the best we've had in Florida. For those seeking the real deal, this is the place. We took home a menu and are eager to explore the diverse offerings( Huge menu). This pizzeria is a must-try. read more

Pizza is always good- fresh. I think their steak & cheese is better than anyone else's also. Worth checking out

Pizza is always delicious! Some times I come in for their two slices and a drink special and other times I order a whole pie to go. My mom loves their Italian dishes as well. Staff is super friendly and I always leave with a smile on my face. I often run in to people I know when I'm in there. In fact I was in there earlier today and ran in to my old gym coach from middle school! Place is a landmark in this town! read more

Drove here for beef patties with cheese and unfortunately, they were out of stock of defrosted ones due to a rush. They went above and beyond to make sure we got what we came for by offering to deep fry them and still tasted equally delicious. Great and friendly service. read more

The food is delicious I highly recommend the cheese pizza or the supreme. The staff is amazing as well all very easy going fellas, decent amount of seating. Prices were great and on of few shops that sell by the slice which is great. read more

Pizza Suprema - Pizza and drink 6.75$ - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

The food , service, and the ambiance is always wonderful. The pizza there it so good. I always buy my pizza pie there.... It taste and looks like a New York pizza. read more

I have been craving some really good pizza... so we placed an order at Pizza Suprema... a large cheese pizza, a large pepperoni pizza, a Greek salad, French fries and a buffalo chicken sub. Everything was delicious....their pizza is the real deal! Cheesy deliciousness! The sub was was toasted with crunchy bread and flavorful sauce. The fries were fine... I usually avoid ordering fries for delivery because they get steamed and soft on the way but they had good flavor. My only complaint was that we ordered a Greek salad but that isn't what we got. I think we got a chef type salad. It was good but we really wanted the Greek salad. This place really satisfied my pizza craving. I can't wait to satisfy it again! Lol. read more

See all

great big NY style pizza, crust is got a great chew, sauce is flavorful and not to sweet, and the cheese is top quality. My go to pizza in the Lutz area. read more

I've been here for four years and trying to get yourself some really good New York style pizza has been a challenge. I've tried many others. They were OK but nothing reminds me of New York City pizza then this place every time I order it's the same results I think I'm gonna quit going to all the other pizzas like 900 Pizza or Noble Crust or anything that advertises original New York Pizza I've tried many they all fell short. This is the place you want to try this New York City resident app approves this review. Lol read more

Pizza is amazing might be the best in pasco county, staff is kind aswell, highly recommend!

Best NY style pizza in Land O Lakes, FL. Owners are really great food is delicious! read more

They catered our baby shower and it was amazing ! We ordered 30+ pizzas and they were able to accommodate same day!

We always seek this spot out when we are in town... and the pizza is so good, I wish we were in town more often. We are well taken care of by the staff who always make sure our pizza is hot and the canolis are cold. Take the opportunity when you are nearby to get some fantastic food. You'll be glad you did. read more

Best NY style pizza around. They go out of their way to make mine lightly cooked because my husband can't eat it if baked normally.

Hands down, best Pizza south of the Mason Dixon. You will not be disappointed here. Been going since the early 2000s and moved farther away in 2019, so had some time away. This year I got pizzas for the Super Bowl, again a few weeks later, and today; father kept asking for me to pick some up for the last month. It's always as I remember, the Suprema of Tampa Bay and beyond. read more

Always quality pizza, been coming here since we moved down from New York, it's the closest you'll get outside of DT tampa

I would say the pizza is OK although their pricing seems to vary depending on the time of the day. The pizza is not horrible. I wouldn't say it's the best pizza I've ever had but it's not horrible. read more

Best pizza in the area. Solid crust and a good sauce. Service was great, and love the ambiance. This place reminds me of a hole in the wall spot back in Queens. Highly recommend!!!! read more

Pizza Suprema - Tossed salad with fresh mozz - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

LOVE this pizza shop. Friendly staff every visit, pizza is fantastic, calzones are awesome. Great spot to just grab a slice as well (hard to find). read more

There area lot of pizza places in the area! So if someone recommends a place as one of their top picks, that makes my list of points to try next. I ordered the Sicilian Suprema pan pizza tonight for the family. (They also have regular crust pizzas.) When I picked it up it was heavy! Literally, you get so much pizza for your money! The pizza was amazing, full of meats and veggies and very filling. Will definitely make our favorites list! read more

Pizza Suprema - The Sicilian Suprema (my husband grabbed his first piece before I could even get a pic!) Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

Our favorite pizza place every since early 2000. The food we order from pizza, subs, calzones, salads, etc. is always on time or earlier, friendly staff, and amazing quality food. There's no negative! read more

Pizza Suprema - Meat lovers & Cheese calzone- about the length of a large pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

Always amazing...never disappoints. Pizza lovers from New England; we know our pizza and this is the best Tampa Bay has to offer.

Wonderful people! Great service and superb pizza! I have been coming here since 99 and it never fails to supersede my expectations. Everything is fantastic thank you Frank for today and a wonderful experience. read more

Real NY style pizza, delicious!!! Fair price, clean and very friendly staff. Thank you!

THE BEST around the area. The white pizza, garlic knots, calzones...fantastic! Everyone who works here has always been the greatest. Couldn't recommend more! read more

My favorite pizza place in that area! You get such large slices and it's so delicious. Wonderful local pizza place that I highly recommend.